back to indexThe Besties Take Napa | All-In Special
Chapters
0:0 Intro!
1:44 The podcast's impact on the besties
3:4 Future of AI, return potential
13:27 Why the besties play poker
16:37 Most impactful advice they've ever received
24:33 Happy Birthday Friedberg!
00:00:45.840 |
Everybody give it up for the dictator himself, 00:00:57.640 |
I love how it's freezing and there's one heat lamp. 00:01:04.600 |
I mean, these are literally like $80 for the night. 00:01:13.080 |
No, no, I mean, this is a super expensive place, 00:01:28.200 |
And they're like, he's been ordering wine on your tab. 00:01:32.920 |
So the event just flipped from being in the black 00:01:39.720 |
But I thought I would start with maybe asking the besties, 00:01:44.920 |
what has it been like, I think, having this podcast get 00:01:48.280 |
so big, and the scrutiny it's under, but the excitement, 00:01:57.540 |
I think I may have told the story on the pod, 00:01:59.320 |
but I'll tell it again because I do like the story. 00:02:08.200 |
I think it was either last summer or two years ago. 00:02:12.160 |
And we were literally just walking down the street 00:02:15.680 |
in Milan, and somebody comes up to Chamath and stops him. 00:02:33.480 |
And then that all happened, and then he moved on. 00:02:44.480 |
And there was some question about whether the pod would-- 00:02:53.320 |
In any event, so he comes up, takes a selfie, and then 00:03:08.040 |
about the current state of Gen AI and particular software 00:03:14.440 |
I'd love to hear about the lower cost of actually engineering 00:03:19.680 |
software and building companies versus actually Gen AI doing-- 00:03:24.280 |
replacing human judgment, replacing judgment, 00:03:28.400 |
And those two dimensions feel like they're not 00:03:31.120 |
exclusive to each other, but they are two different axes. 00:03:34.200 |
I'd love to hear current thoughts on the return 00:03:39.000 |
I think that the entire software stack is going to get rebuilt. 00:03:44.680 |
And I think it's going to be a bunch of 10- and 20- 00:03:50.040 |
And I think the core artifact of a new company today 00:04:05.120 |
And you measure them against the counterfactual, 00:04:07.880 |
where that counterfactual is what your productivity was 00:04:12.560 |
And you need to be 100% to 200% more productive. 00:04:16.720 |
So if an engineer is writing x amount of features 00:04:20.320 |
or x amount of code, they need to be at a 2x or 3x. 00:04:33.040 |
expect that they do that, which means that you also 00:04:35.600 |
have to deprive them of any help along the way-- 00:04:39.600 |
no administrative help, no HR help, no finance help. 00:04:43.400 |
All of that stuff needs to be a workflow or a bot 00:04:53.080 |
And I think the second is that the document that 00:04:57.040 |
matters more than ever is that PRD that defines 00:05:03.280 |
Because I don't think you should be writing much code. 00:05:08.120 |
is defining in excruciating detail what the feature 00:05:13.320 |
the guardrails of how features should behave in certain 00:05:16.680 |
boundary conditions, fed into an LLM that then spits out 00:05:28.720 |
It'll take a couple of years for us to get to that place. 00:05:31.720 |
But in that world, there is no room for $500 million 00:05:38.320 |
And the reason is the 10- and 20-person company 00:05:40.260 |
can price that thing at just a fraction of what 00:05:44.640 |
Because the incumbent has an OPEX load that's 00:05:49.780 |
It's correlated to the fact that you have 50,000 people 00:05:56.000 |
with all this ridiculous infrastructure that all 00:06:05.160 |
So like, Sachs and JCal both seed a lot of stuff, 00:06:08.460 |
get it off the ground, spin it up, and then raise money. 00:06:12.580 |
I'm going to build something, get it to a place 00:06:17.040 |
But the other version is much more distributed. 00:06:22.360 |
think it matters, it's like this web 3 model does actually 00:06:25.560 |
apply here, where there are some really interesting early 00:06:30.040 |
adventures in crowdsourcing technical completion. 00:06:35.880 |
that I'm starting to focus a little bit on called BitTensor. 00:06:41.560 |
And it's basically a thing where you go and solve 00:06:44.960 |
technical problems and produce features that people require-- 00:06:48.040 |
that need, and you get paid in this underlying currency. 00:06:51.780 |
That is actually a distributed form of venture 00:06:58.680 |
15 companies that need a replacement to Salesforce just 00:07:01.360 |
say, here's the bounty, and here's the feature set, 00:07:04.480 |
and it's a crowdsourced or a community-sourced PRD, 00:07:10.640 |
Like, that is this crazy new world that we're going through. 00:07:13.800 |
So it's all about speed of execution, I think. 00:07:17.580 |
and what you're seeing in the field right now? 00:07:20.120 |
Yeah, I mean, I think in having conversations 00:07:23.280 |
with enterprises and businesses, what they basically want 00:07:29.480 |
somehow into a LLM and be able to ask it questions. 00:07:36.680 |
want to be able to do that, but with their own enterprise data. 00:07:47.200 |
have that big what's called a context window, which 00:07:49.480 |
is kind of like, it's almost like active memory 00:07:55.960 |
like in the early days of computers where you had 00:08:00.440 |
It was like 8 megabytes, 16, then 32, then 64. 00:08:05.200 |
We had floppies and the 3 and 1/2 inch disks or whatever. 00:08:08.480 |
And eventually, just people stopped talking about RAM 00:08:14.320 |
have to be selective about what you feed into the model 00:08:17.520 |
because it just can only absorb so much information. 00:08:21.120 |
So if you give it all of your enterprise data, 00:08:24.520 |
And so you've got to figure out how to optimize it so 00:08:26.680 |
that you can give the AI model the right chunks of data 00:08:33.600 |
And that's actually-- it's a complicated problem right now. 00:08:42.600 |
called Raggy, which is basically RAG as a service. 00:08:45.240 |
It does retrieval augmented generation as a service. 00:08:54.720 |
And we're just dealing with some of the limitations 00:09:07.240 |
If you feed the exact right chunks into the model, 00:09:17.160 |
And again, the reason is because the model didn't really 00:09:21.000 |
So right now, it's like, again, glimpses of something amazing. 00:09:24.920 |
And we just have to kind of get to more predictability 00:09:30.120 |
going into solving some of these sorts of issues. 00:09:46.920 |
I mean, we had many challenges in podcast production 00:09:50.560 |
around things like transcripts or doing show notes 00:09:53.720 |
and learning, hey, about this person who's a guest. 00:10:02.000 |
who will take those three podcast interviews, 00:10:14.240 |
Or what are relevant topics this person is talking about? 00:10:19.240 |
So you can't say, well, what's David Sacks talking about, 00:10:21.840 |
if you're going to have him on your podcast, on Twitter? 00:10:24.160 |
Because there's no way to get that information. 00:10:34.320 |
And it's allowing people to do so much work so fast 00:10:37.000 |
and then unlocking things that were just not possible. 00:10:39.840 |
And that, to me, is very obvious inside the startups 00:10:45.660 |
we invest in, because when they're resource constrained, 00:10:48.240 |
they look for the fastest, cheapest way to do things. 00:10:52.640 |
the same ones who, when other people were racking servers, 00:11:00.540 |
And then they built businesses that you may have heard of, 00:11:07.200 |
who just fundamentally said, the paradigm of cloud computing 00:11:10.700 |
is going to work, even though it's not perfect right now, 00:11:13.040 |
even though it's slow, or expensive, or it breaks, 00:11:20.460 |
where they stood up their own data centers instead of-- 00:11:23.260 |
they were just scared to have their data at, I guess, 00:11:29.880 |
how many businesses become viable with just three, four, 00:11:35.800 |
Freeberg, you have any thoughts on AI right now? 00:11:47.560 |
I think that there's a chance that SaaS looks 00:11:52.400 |
occurred between the ubiquity of the internet 00:11:54.320 |
and the prevalence of AI for writing software. 00:12:04.320 |
they didn't grow up in software, and they're not software 00:12:10.640 |
And that's really been their primary function. 00:12:16.320 |
But they understand the needs of the business. 00:12:18.520 |
And I think that if they can have software written for them 00:12:22.720 |
at basically a cost of zero to improve their workplace 00:12:26.200 |
productivity, which was the original thing that 00:12:31.680 |
it starts to really change how folks are sourcing and using 00:12:36.040 |
software, that it can actually be written for them 00:12:41.600 |
And so I think that the tooling and the capabilities 00:12:44.400 |
to enable the enterprise to write their own custom 00:12:46.560 |
workplace productivity tools and their own custom workplace 00:12:50.840 |
or internal-facing, really becomes kind of the standard 00:12:56.040 |
And you see this, what I think Doug Leone called 00:12:59.240 |
the greatest business model in human history, 00:13:01.760 |
which is SaaS, getting kind of blown up in that new landscape. 00:13:05.440 |
So I think there's a chance that that happens, non-zero chance. 00:13:08.560 |
And I've just seen this in a bunch of settings 00:13:12.240 |
where folks are having software written for them 00:13:18.200 |
here's the layout, here's what I want it to do. 00:13:24.880 |
And they don't need to go pay some third-party per-seat 00:13:28.440 |
I have heard about your poker love through the podcast. 00:13:38.680 |
you think about your utility function personally? 00:13:44.940 |
Could you comment a little bit on how you all think about it? 00:13:49.560 |
But I think-- also, you made a good comment about it. 00:13:58.760 |
a poker player get old and lose their mental facilities, 00:14:03.600 |
No, Bobby Baldwin ran the city center in Aria for a long time. 00:14:17.080 |
because Doyle, when he died, was super sharp, sharp as a tack. 00:14:22.560 |
It's one of these unique games where you can really 00:14:33.360 |
Look, I like it for the same reason that you guys like it. 00:14:35.920 |
There was a phase early on where I would play in the World 00:14:43.040 |
I actually don't like sitting there for three days 00:14:50.000 |
And the thing that's fun is just playing with your friends. 00:14:55.640 |
I first started playing poker when I-- did I ever tell you 00:15:02.520 |
I got paid $4.25 an hour to work at this pool hall. 00:15:05.240 |
I cleaned toilets and scrubbed down the tables. 00:15:12.280 |
And he would take all of the bets on the payphone 00:15:15.640 |
And one day, after he got to know me for a couple of months, 00:15:17.880 |
he's like, come and play poker with us at our home game. 00:15:21.040 |
$1.00, $1.00, $1.00, $1.00, $1.00, $1.00, $1.00, $1.00, $1.00. 00:15:26.880 |
And I was 16, going to college, like fucking cold. 00:15:55.520 |
I made $10,000 that summer playing Limit Hold 'Em 00:15:58.160 |
at the Oaks Card Club, playing tournaments in 6-12. 00:16:01.680 |
And after that, I was-- and I learned so much 00:16:03.600 |
about investing and life and like perseverance 00:16:11.840 |
you know you made the right decision over time, 00:16:15.320 |
You don't need to like win every fucking hand. 00:16:19.880 |
was really influential to me in entrepreneurship 00:16:22.440 |
and investing and in decision making later on in life. 00:16:32.840 |
And for me, it was like a very kind of nostalgia. 00:16:34.920 |
Because I hadn't played really much since 2001, 2002. 00:16:38.660 |
What's the most impactful advice you've been given? 00:16:47.800 |
One was from Mike Savino, who's here somewhere, 00:16:51.920 |
And he said, the piece of advice his dad gave him 00:16:54.520 |
was look to the left and come in an hour before that guy. 00:16:57.080 |
And then look to the right and come in and stay an hour later 00:17:00.800 |
than that guy, just basically the hard work stuff. 00:17:04.400 |
who worked three or four jobs to put us through school. 00:17:13.600 |
Because I just decided, I'm just going to outwork everybody. 00:17:16.760 |
Because I was coming not from Harvard or Stanford, 00:17:19.360 |
but from Bayridge, Brooklyn, and going to night school 00:17:47.920 |
And I was like, OK, I'll stop fighting with everybody. 00:18:03.560 |
But it was actually because I had to fight for everything, 00:18:07.000 |
I think I just kept fighting to try to get the next level. 00:18:16.000 |
and just be helpful and elder statesman-like. 00:18:26.520 |
I am tireless in my ability with patience for them. 00:18:31.240 |
And I just-- and I try to do that with my friends as well. 00:18:33.320 |
It's just, what's the point of being successful 00:18:34.920 |
if you can't support the people around you who you love 00:18:39.240 |
You are like the most reliable wingman of all of us. 00:18:49.160 |
Because at the end of the day, all you have is your memories. 00:18:52.600 |
And you make them with your friends and your family. 00:18:54.720 |
And so I am on a mission to make great memories 00:18:57.720 |
with my friends and family, as many as possible. 00:19:01.040 |
And actually, this is part of it, you all being here. 00:19:03.560 |
And that's why I always tell you, make a couple of friends. 00:19:06.240 |
It's hard to make friends, especially as you get older. 00:19:10.400 |
Make a couple of new friends and go do things together. 00:19:20.120 |
The best career advice I got was from Peter Thiel, 00:19:29.600 |
But it ended up not mattering, because I ended up joining 00:19:36.040 |
The best career advice I've actually heard for Silicon 00:19:38.760 |
Valley was the advice that Eric Schmidt gave Sheryl Sandberg 00:19:45.200 |
when you get invited to take a seat on a rocket ship, 00:19:52.240 |
I actually think that is perennially great advice 00:19:57.320 |
There aren't that many of these rocket ships. 00:20:00.960 |
you should just take it and worry about the titles 00:20:12.600 |
every time I have, though, it's had profound impact on my life-- 00:20:22.880 |
You try and minimize beta, but you take all the alpha away 00:20:26.080 |
In 2009, I focused my company on the agriculture market, 00:20:29.800 |
We were in seven verticals and doing all sorts of stuff. 00:20:34.440 |
I went on a long hike in Iceland and I came up 00:20:37.600 |
with this crazy idea for the product for the app market 00:20:41.720 |
We launched it and we did like $30 million in sales that year. 00:20:48.040 |
And every time I focused and avoided distractions, 00:20:52.240 |
I think my decision to become a CEO again back in November 00:20:56.600 |
And I realized I was on lots of boards and doing 00:20:58.600 |
lots of investing and thinking about lots of things, 00:21:10.360 |
You're either going to catch one of the power law winners 00:21:14.040 |
Therefore, you've got to portfolio your way to a power 00:21:18.400 |
I don't give a shit about that because I think my job in life 00:21:21.280 |
is to make the power law and to make that outcome. 00:21:27.520 |
And it's really-- every time I've tried to act on it, 00:21:36.440 |
So the version of that that I tell founders all the time 00:21:42.440 |
Because founders, sometimes they have a whole bunch 00:21:48.360 |
but they're still hanging on to the old idea. 00:21:55.600 |
said you're going to do whatever two quarters ago 00:22:00.200 |
Whatever you think the best idea is right now, 00:22:06.440 |
I think that's just really important for founders. 00:22:10.440 |
It's just so hard to execute any idea that you 00:22:26.440 |
and you strike with full force and with all your energy 00:22:28.720 |
and everything you have, your whole character, everything. 00:22:33.120 |
You have to put one foot in front of the other every day. 00:22:47.680 |
to get better as I've gotten older-- is when I get 00:22:49.680 |
comparative and I compare myself to the other person, 00:22:58.160 |
to feel like you're less than something else. 00:23:01.560 |
And the reality is that has nothing to do with you. 00:23:07.760 |
And then if I don't take that medicine, I become insecure, 00:23:12.560 |
and then I make mistakes that are entirely avoidable. 00:23:16.160 |
So it's just tangible progress, the things that I can control. 00:23:20.160 |
That's probably the most useful piece of advice 00:23:29.200 |
One is I'll incubate companies from time to time 00:23:36.280 |
And the best piece of advice I got as an investor 00:23:51.280 |
And so you've got to commit, and you've got to go, 00:23:55.160 |
and you are going to have less than 100% hit rate, 00:24:02.000 |
And you just got to get to the surface and swim back out. 00:24:06.140 |
because I've had some huge wins, but I've also 00:24:08.480 |
had some huge losses and some total embarrassments 00:24:19.840 |
is more valuable because it's so easy to get distracted 00:24:24.960 |
and feel insecure because of what somebody else is doing. 00:24:33.800 |
And we're going to take a little walk over here 00:24:38.440 |
If I could have my four besties follow me over here. 00:24:46.800 |
a very special day or a special time of the year. 00:25:00.080 |
And we're all going to sing the Sultan happy birthday.