back to indexWhat’s the Historical Return on Housing?
Chapters
0:0 Intro
2:30 Real Estate return expectations
11:19 Cut losses, or hope for a bounce in poorly performing stocks
18:13 Where to prioritize utilizing your money
26:31 401k Rollover
31:14 What is the point of a financial advisor?
00:00:22.000 |
A show where you, the audience, provide the questions, we try to provide the answers. 00:00:26.000 |
I gotta give the audience credit, I laughed at a few of the questions this week. 00:00:36.000 |
Today's show is sponsored by Fabric by Gerber Life. 00:00:39.000 |
Every time I get on a plane, Duncan, my wife, has a morbid conversation of, 00:00:43.000 |
"What if something happened to you? What would we do?" 00:00:46.000 |
Which is very morbid, but I guess she's planning, risk averse. 00:00:51.000 |
Life insurance is the first thing I did when I had my first child. 00:00:55.000 |
Fabric by Gerber Life was designed by parents for parents to help you get a high-quality, 00:00:58.000 |
surprisingly affordable term life insurance policy in less than 10 minutes. 00:01:05.000 |
You basically go from start to covered in less than 10 minutes. 00:01:09.000 |
It's all online, your schedule, no appointments, no piles of paperwork. 00:01:16.000 |
Join the thousands of parents who trust Fabric to protect their family, 00:01:22.000 |
That's meetfabric.com/atc, M-E-E-T-Fabric.com/atc. 00:01:27.000 |
Policies are issued by Western Southern Life Insurance Company. 00:01:32.000 |
Prices are subject to underwriting and health questions. 00:01:36.000 |
And it just gives you an estimate right away. 00:01:40.000 |
I especially like the point that they say you could be able to get it potentially 00:01:43.000 |
without having to do a health exam because I do not like going to a doctor. 00:01:54.000 |
I don't like needles, but I'm not scared of them. 00:02:01.000 |
Okay. I'm not afraid of needles unless they're, like, right here. 00:02:04.000 |
You know, once they're here, they're a problem. 00:02:12.000 |
I don't know how to take that, but sure. Okay. 00:02:17.000 |
Okay. Up first today we have a question from-- 00:02:20.000 |
That's why you drink oat milk because it keeps you healthier 00:02:23.000 |
I mean, it's probably not because of that necessarily, 00:02:26.000 |
but, yeah, I definitely try to stay out of the doctor. 00:02:29.000 |
Okay. So up first today we have a question from Pete. 00:02:34.000 |
Stocks, bonds, and cash are categories to compare, but it hit me. 00:02:38.000 |
As a retired boomer, what about home ownership as a comparison? 00:02:47.000 |
is that I've learned to appreciate the seasons more, though. 00:02:50.000 |
Every year around February or March when there's still snow in Michigan, 00:02:52.000 |
I complain, but we had our first big snowfall the past week or so, 00:03:11.000 |
All right. This question is in response to my recent piece 00:03:13.000 |
on historical returns for stocks, bonds, and cash. 00:03:16.000 |
Aswath Damodaran has this website for NYU where he updates every year 00:03:25.000 |
Average returns, best return, worst return for stocks, bonds, and cash. 00:03:30.000 |
There are typically a fair number of requests for other asset classes 00:03:32.000 |
whenever I post this kind of data, and as luck would have it, 00:03:36.000 |
Damodaran actually added housing and gold this year to the mix. 00:03:41.000 |
So I now have from 1928 to 1923 annual returns for stocks, bonds, 00:03:54.000 |
Real estate, which is the Case-Shiller Index. 00:04:02.000 |
Gold is 4.9%, and then inflation of 3% per year. 00:04:09.000 |
So real estate is kind of between a little bit less than gold and fixed income. 00:04:17.000 |
I broke this down by decade because I find this stuff interesting. 00:04:23.000 |
Stocks, bonds, cash, real estate, gold, and inflation. 00:04:28.000 |
the only down decade it's ever had was the 1930s during the Great Depression era. 00:04:35.000 |
while these other categories have all had negative. 00:04:41.000 |
So we've already had 10.2% annualized returns for housing. 00:04:45.000 |
We've never had an annualized return that high before. 00:04:47.000 |
The highest return we've ever had was the '70s when it was up 8.7% per year, 00:04:51.000 |
but there was also 7.5% inflation during that decade. 00:04:56.000 |
So the total return of close to 50% that we've seen in nationwide housing prices this decade 00:05:02.000 |
is already higher than what we saw for the whole decade of the '90s, the 2000s, and the 2010s. 00:05:10.000 |
So look at these historical returns and you think, well, wait a minute. 00:05:16.000 |
I thought housing was supposed to be the best investment. 00:05:18.000 |
Does this mean housing is a lousy investment? 00:05:22.000 |
The Case-Shiller Index does a good job of tracking housing prices on a national basis, 00:05:26.000 |
but I don't think that necessarily means it's realistic for most people 00:05:29.000 |
in terms of the proxy for their returns or housing in general. 00:05:34.000 |
Calculating returns on stocks, bonds, and cash is pretty straightforward. 00:05:37.000 |
You take the starting value, the ending value, add in any cash flows. 00:05:41.000 |
It's the starting value and the ending value, and that's your total return. 00:05:47.000 |
None of these historical returns include taxes and fees, of course, 00:05:50.000 |
but the frictions are so much lower these days because fees and bid-ask spreads, 00:05:54.000 |
and that stuff's all lower, tax-deferred retirement accounts, all that stuff. 00:06:00.000 |
Nicole just logged on to the compound chat handle. 00:06:04.000 |
It's confusing because multiple people from the same account. 00:06:10.000 |
Housing is the most unique of all financial assets in a lot of ways. 00:06:14.000 |
First of all, there's the leverage component. 00:06:16.000 |
Sure, some people may pay cash for their house, but most people borrow. 00:06:19.000 |
Let's say you put 20% down, dunk it on a $450,000 house. 00:06:26.000 |
You have a house that's worth $560,000, $2,000, and $500. 00:06:34.000 |
I was just thinking about what year I'd have to time travel back to 00:06:46.000 |
Technically, the money you put down is a 125% gain. 00:06:50.000 |
So maybe housing is even better than most people think. 00:06:53.000 |
In the life of your loan, you have to pay interest expense, insurance, 00:06:56.000 |
property taxes, maintenance, upkeep, people refinance, which costs money. 00:07:07.000 |
I thought you meant there was another mortgage insurance type thing, 00:07:12.000 |
Well, there's a lot of other bank fees you have to pay when you buy 00:07:17.000 |
Plus, like I said, the bid-ask spread for ETFs and index funds 00:07:22.000 |
For the housing market, the frictions are still really high. 00:07:24.000 |
So moving costs, closing costs, inspections, title insurance, 00:07:28.000 |
and all these other fees that banks more or less make up. 00:07:30.000 |
Selling your house requires these same fees along with realtor costs. 00:07:36.000 |
So even if you were the kind of person like me who would track all these 00:07:39.000 |
expenses in a spreadsheet -- I don't actually do this, 00:07:43.000 |
Even if you had all of these expenses to tell at your true cost 00:07:48.000 |
I know my outlays for my mortgage, for insurance, for all this stuff. 00:07:51.000 |
If you weren't paying your mortgage, you'd be renting somewhere, 00:07:56.000 |
So how do you calculate the difference between, well, 00:07:58.000 |
what I'm paying in my mortgage versus what I would be paying in rent, 00:08:02.000 |
So adding it all up -- and I don't think there's a single person in America 00:08:05.000 |
who knows what their actual return on their house is. 00:08:07.000 |
I think it's basically impossible to calculate. 00:08:09.000 |
So I don't think you'd have to make so many assumptions 00:08:16.000 |
but the Robert Shiller numbers are probably directionally right, 00:08:19.000 |
but that says nothing about the actual return most homeowners get 00:08:23.000 |
because of leverage and all these other costs and stuff. 00:08:26.000 |
If you're buying and selling rental properties, it's probably easier. 00:08:28.000 |
To track your expenses, you know what's coming in for rent, 00:08:33.000 |
I think you can calculate what the return is. 00:08:35.000 |
For some people, it's probably much higher than they assume, 00:08:38.000 |
because, again, if you're doing it out of that initial investment 00:08:40.000 |
and there's leverage involved, even a small, steady stream of returns, 00:08:44.000 |
when you have that leverage and you're only putting 20% down, 00:08:50.000 |
For a lot of people, it's probably worse than they think 00:08:52.000 |
because they don't realize the frictions for buying and selling. 00:08:57.000 |
They buy in the wrong location, all this stuff. 00:08:59.000 |
So I don't think we should be comparing the roof over your head 00:09:07.000 |
Vanguard does not provide mudrooms or open spaces to entertain 00:09:12.000 |
If I had to guess, it's probably closer to the stock market 00:09:15.000 |
than the bond market for true returns for most people, 00:09:19.000 |
but I think it's far too circumstantial to put an actual number on it. 00:09:22.000 |
So I'd like to look at my house as more of a home than a financial asset, 00:09:25.000 |
but it does provide a really nice hedge against inflation 00:09:28.000 |
because my mortgage is fixed, and then I can borrow against it if need be. 00:09:31.000 |
And for most people, it's just really a form of forced savings 00:09:33.000 |
because most of the middle class, that's their biggest financial asset by far. 00:09:36.000 |
But I don't think you compare it to stocks or bonds or crypto 00:09:39.000 |
I think housing is so much more of an emotional asset 00:09:41.000 |
that it's impossible to gauge what that actual return really is. 00:09:45.000 |
Do most people who seriously invest in real estate, 00:09:49.000 |
do they have some equation where it breaks down with square footage 00:09:52.000 |
and how much they expect to have to pay in general upkeep and maintenance? 00:09:56.000 |
Well, the biggest thing is they call it the cap rate. 00:09:59.000 |
But yeah, you could put a number on it like the fees are going to be 00:10:05.000 |
You could estimate that somehow depending on the location. 00:10:08.000 |
And yeah, someone who's doing rental properties, that's much easier. 00:10:11.000 |
They look for a cap rate on what they're getting and what they're netting out, 00:10:15.000 |
and then I guess you could add some equity in there somehow. 00:10:17.000 |
But yes, it's way more complicated than most people think. 00:10:22.000 |
I don't think you can just take the price you paid for it 00:10:25.000 |
and then the price you get when you sell, and that's your return. 00:10:27.000 |
There's so much more that goes into it than that. 00:10:34.000 |
I just corrected myself. I said "ruff," and then I said "roof." 00:10:48.000 |
I think part of what's happening just as a layman is I think a lot of people 00:10:53.000 |
are paying up for housing right now and are trying to justify it as being like, 00:10:58.000 |
I think that's why we're seeing more and more of these questions. 00:11:00.000 |
And again, I think it's more of a forced savings vehicle 00:11:03.000 |
than an investment for most people, but that can be a good thing too. 00:11:06.000 |
I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing, but you're right. 00:11:08.000 |
The fact that prices have been going up so much in the last couple of years, 00:11:13.000 |
And I think there's just a lot of stuff you have to take into consideration 00:11:19.000 |
All right. Up next we have a question from Mike. 00:11:29.000 |
"I've got a bunch of 2020 stocks"-- may give a couple examples-- 00:11:35.000 |
"with the losses representing maybe 8% of the value of my portfolio. 00:11:39.000 |
"Psychologically, they bother me, but I have no immediate need to sell. 00:11:45.000 |
"Is it best to hold and just see if they recover in some years 00:11:49.000 |
"or just cut bait, take the ordinary income deduction, 00:11:52.000 |
"prevent further losses, and reinvest the tax savings into an index fund? 00:11:56.000 |
"With the $3,000 win, I'd have carryover losses to claim 00:12:07.000 |
Mike here included some of the tickers, and I've got to be honest, 00:12:10.000 |
I've never heard of this one company, SKLZ, is skills with a Z. 00:12:14.000 |
I've heard of it, but I don't know anything about it. 00:12:17.000 |
My first point of advice would be never buy a company 00:12:26.000 |
In what world is a company with a Z in the end of it 00:12:36.000 |
Funny enough, the Russell 3000, which is essentially 00:12:42.000 |
so that's the S&P 500 plus the small and mid-caps, 00:12:46.000 |
there's nearly 2,700 stocks in it, which is kind of false advertising 00:12:49.000 |
because the Russell 3000 doesn't have 3,000 stocks. 00:12:51.000 |
On white charts yesterday, I ran a screen for historical drawdown 00:12:54.000 |
from all-time highs for these stocks, Duncan. 00:12:56.000 |
Out of 2,700 stocks that make up the U.S. stock market, 00:12:59.000 |
how many were down 70% or worse from all-time highs? 00:13:10.000 |
He mentioned a stock, he owns stocks down 99%. 00:13:13.000 |
Again, 25% of stocks, and we're right near the all-time highs, 00:13:17.000 |
a quarter of stocks in the index, in the market, 00:13:23.000 |
There are more than 40 stocks that are down 99% or worse. 00:13:26.000 |
That would put our guy Mike here in the bottom 1.5% of stock pickers, 00:13:29.000 |
I guess we want to look at it that way, for these stocks, which is nice. 00:13:36.000 |
One out of every 10 stocks is down 90% or worse from all-time highs. 00:13:43.000 |
Almost half of all stocks in the index are down 50% or more from their highs. 00:13:46.000 |
Tons of big losers, which is a feature, not a bug, of the stock market. 00:13:49.000 |
One of my favorite research pieces that I come back to all the time, 00:13:53.000 |
and I think it's worth repeating, is called "The Agony and the Ecstasy" 00:13:56.000 |
by Michael Semblis from J.P. Morgan, who's been on the Compounded Friends before. 00:14:00.000 |
John threw up the first chart. I love looking back at this data. 00:14:03.000 |
Semblis found that more than 40% of all companies that were ever in the Russell 3000 index 00:14:07.000 |
experienced a catastrophic stock price loss, which was defined as a 70% decline 00:14:11.000 |
from a price in peak levels, which is not recovered. 00:14:16.000 |
You can see he broke it down by sector as well. 00:14:21.000 |
Around 40% of the time, a single stock experienced negative absolute returns, 00:14:25.000 |
which would have underperformed a simple position in cash. 00:14:27.000 |
So holding T-bills, 40% of stocks underperformed cash. 00:14:30.000 |
2/3 of the time, those stocks underperformed the actual index itself. 00:14:34.000 |
So holding the index, you'd think, well, half of the stocks are going to do well 00:14:37.000 |
and half of them are going to underperform. That's not the case at all. 00:14:40.000 |
It's mostly mega-winners, which they define as these huge, huge winners, 00:14:43.000 |
and there's 10% of them since 1980 that are defined as mega-winners in the Russell 3000. 00:14:53.000 |
Wait, why don't we just focus on buying the mega-winners? 00:15:01.000 |
but the median stock ends up underperforming the index itself. 00:15:07.000 |
If you were the world's greatest stock pick, you'd say, 00:15:09.000 |
"I'll just hold the best stocks. Good luck with that." 00:15:12.000 |
The problem is, what if you own some of these stocks that end up being mega-winners? 00:15:15.000 |
Amazon was down 95% during the dot-com bubble and it recovered. 00:15:21.000 |
NVIDIA was down almost 70% at one point in 2022. 00:15:24.000 |
Facebook, not meta. I'm never going to call it meta. 00:15:28.000 |
Just like Google is not alphabet and Twitter is not X, 00:15:34.000 |
Facebook was down 70% in 2022 and recovered all its losses. 00:15:38.000 |
Netflix has experienced three separate 70%-plus drawdowns in its history. 00:15:48.000 |
It's still 30% away from the most recent highs in the new one. 00:15:51.000 |
But history says you're better off just cutting bait, right? 00:15:54.000 |
Do you actually believe in any of these companies? 00:15:56.000 |
I don't know. Maybe you could hold on to one of them as a lottery ticket or as a reminder. 00:16:00.000 |
I have one stock in my fund portfolio account in Robinhood that I picked. 00:16:04.000 |
I'm not going to name names, but someone at our company actually recommended it to me. 00:16:08.000 |
It immediately went up 100% and now it's down 75% from where I bought it. 00:16:16.000 |
It didn't kill me because it's such a small percent. 00:16:18.000 |
I kind of hold it there just as a reminder of just keep buying index funds, Ben, 00:16:21.000 |
because the big winners will be in there and the losers won't matter. 00:16:25.000 |
So I prefer index funds because it is extraordinarily difficult to pick stocks. 00:16:33.000 |
If one of these really turns around after falling 99%, it'll be a miracle. 00:16:37.000 |
Unless you think that it's literally going to be the drink of the future or something, 00:16:41.000 |
I see no reason to hold on to something when you're down big. 00:16:46.000 |
What was Oatly down from all-time highs at the worst point? 00:16:52.000 |
If I pull up the chart, basically, yes, you can't even see it. 00:16:57.000 |
If you get cut in half and cut in half, you're approaching zero, 00:17:00.000 |
but you can never actually hit zero, that's Oatly. 00:17:05.000 |
Something on this note that is kind of funny is back when I was in college, 00:17:08.000 |
in like 2008, I guess, 2008, the market wasn't doing so well. 00:17:13.000 |
And so I was like, "I should buy some stocks." 00:17:16.000 |
And so I took a little bit of money and bought a couple of things. 00:17:18.000 |
I bought Microsoft, which I still own, the same share. 00:17:24.000 |
And then I bought some shares of a company called Hemp 00:17:28.000 |
that was supposed to be like weed stock and, "Oh, this is the future," 00:17:34.000 |
No, no, no, it was supposed to be like cannabis, I guess. 00:17:37.000 |
Microsoft, that's a pretty good purchase, though. 00:17:42.000 |
And several others that I bought did not work out. 00:17:47.000 |
That data, though, for real, that's basically an argument for cap weighting 00:17:54.000 |
I mean, equal weighting, I guess, it's diversification. 00:17:57.000 |
The whole point about cap weighting is that the mega winners 00:18:04.000 |
Equal weighting is the kind of strategy, though, 00:18:06.000 |
that just has a little more turnover, probably. 00:18:20.000 |
I'm in my late 20s, married, and expecting our first child this year. 00:18:24.000 |
I have over $100,000 cash saved, but over $50,000 in student loans 00:18:30.000 |
I have a large bonus coming in Q1, greater than my student loan amount. 00:18:34.000 |
My bonus is nearly half of my total compensation, 00:18:38.000 |
I'm doing my best to max 401(k), IRA, HSA, and 529, 00:18:43.000 |
but I really want to put my family in a house that is more comfortable 00:18:46.000 |
and safe, even though it wouldn't be the end of days if we stay where we are. 00:18:50.000 |
I'm having difficulty balancing my desire to super save and pay off debt 00:18:55.000 |
with my desire to get a house I truly feel like my family needs. 00:18:59.000 |
On top of this, I would like to be charitable 00:19:03.000 |
How do I balance all these desires when I'm not quite at the level 00:19:06.000 |
where my total compensation is large enough to just do it all? 00:19:09.000 |
As a podcast host, I'm legally obligated here to say 00:19:14.000 |
Right, because that's what you say when you host a podcast. 00:19:17.000 |
There's a variable income component, student loans, buying a house, 00:19:20.000 |
tax-deferred retirement accounts, charitable giving. 00:19:23.000 |
This is certainly a financial planning question 00:19:25.000 |
with a little bit of everything, so let's bring in an expert 00:19:28.000 |
who's used to helping people make better financial decisions, 00:19:35.000 |
Kevin, I think there's this idea that once you have some money 00:19:37.000 |
or make a good income, your financial problems magically disappear, 00:19:40.000 |
but it's much like investing where you can never completely take risk away. 00:19:45.000 |
That's the same thing when it comes to finances. 00:19:54.000 |
I guess how do you help people rank order their financial goals 00:19:59.000 |
Because as with a lot of this stuff, there's no right or wrong answer here. 00:20:03.000 |
A lot of it just depends on what you want to focus on. 00:20:08.000 |
Yeah, I think for me the thing that popped out was what he mentioned 00:20:18.000 |
And the other thing to consider is where you are in your life, right? 00:20:23.000 |
Our colleague Nick Maggiuli, yeah, he talks about just keep buying, 00:20:31.000 |
He wrote a blog post, I think it was last year 00:20:33.000 |
or maybe the year before, talking about not maxing your 401(k) 00:20:37.000 |
and sort of how that kind of flies in the face of conventional 00:20:44.000 |
But for this person, if he's got other goals and he's in his late 20s, 00:20:49.000 |
you've got plenty of time to max out your 401(k). 00:20:53.000 |
So maybe it makes sense to not max out the 401(k) 00:20:56.000 |
and give yourself a little bit more flexibility by saying, 00:20:58.000 |
"Hey, instead of putting away $23,000 in the 401(k) this year, 00:21:02.000 |
maybe I'll put away $17,500, or maybe I'll put away $15,000, 00:21:09.000 |
I do think there's a big psychological hurdle for that 00:21:12.000 |
because if you max out your 401(k) and then you pull it back, 00:21:15.000 |
you feel like you're doing less or you're losing something. 00:21:18.000 |
So I think it's really hard for people to go backwards 00:21:24.000 |
And I always say that with the caveat that you've got to be purposeful 00:21:28.000 |
with the money that you're not contributing, right? 00:21:31.000 |
So if you are getting an extra couple hundred bucks in your paycheck, 00:21:34.000 |
are you just spending that or are you putting it into the account 00:21:37.000 |
that you're going to use to put the down payment on in your house? 00:21:40.000 |
Right. You're still getting ahead financially if you're using that money 00:21:44.000 |
As long as you're not blowing it on something, then you're still saving. 00:21:49.000 |
I was definitely not maxing out my 401(k) and an IRA when I was in my 20s. 00:21:54.000 |
So, I mean, frankly, I'm not even doing it now, but that's another story. 00:22:00.000 |
So there's all these different things, and that's actually part of it, right, 00:22:03.000 |
is that maxing out an HSA is great if you're starting a family. 00:22:09.000 |
So all these things that he wants to accomplish, I think-- 00:22:13.000 |
and, again, I just leaned towards the house because he mentioned it. 00:22:16.000 |
If the house is something that really will give you a lot of peace of mind 00:22:20.000 |
and you'll feel really good about that, then it's okay to say, 00:22:24.000 |
"Hey, I'm not going to put $23,000 away in my 401(k) 00:22:28.000 |
or $30,000 combined between the 401(k) and the IRA." 00:22:30.000 |
Especially with that first kid coming along, you know that the house 00:22:33.000 |
is such an important piece of the family and not just a financial plan. 00:22:37.000 |
And he talks about paying off the student loans. 00:22:41.000 |
To your point about flexibility, I don't see the need to pay those off, 00:22:44.000 |
especially if you have all these other goals. 00:22:46.000 |
I think that one in the hierarchy of the goals, 00:22:48.000 |
if you said the rates were 8%, maybe I would reconsider. 00:22:51.000 |
But at 4% rates, I think you push that one down, 00:22:53.000 |
and that's one of the last goals you have to worry about. 00:22:57.000 |
Yeah, I wonder if they refinanced to get that low. 00:23:09.000 |
But yeah, and then the other thing is the charitable giving. 00:23:12.000 |
I guess the thing is, yeah, give yourself a little bit of a break. 00:23:15.000 |
If you're in your 20s and you've got all this stuff figured out already 00:23:18.000 |
and you're maxing stuff out and you're trying to buy a house, 00:23:20.000 |
give yourself a break if you're not completely optimizing everything perfectly 00:23:24.000 |
and there's going to be some give and take and some course corrections along the way. 00:23:27.000 |
And sometimes if you have a huge goal like this, like buying a house, 00:23:31.000 |
the other goals have to take a back seat for a while. 00:23:34.000 |
And then the house is purchased and you're done saving for the down payment, 00:23:40.000 |
I know for people who are blinders on with the financial stuff, 00:23:46.000 |
But that's the whole point of a financial plan is that it's going to change. 00:23:52.000 |
And so we come across this a lot with people trying to optimize 00:23:58.000 |
And it can cause more stress than is good for you. 00:24:03.000 |
So I think your advice of just kind of taking the big goal first 00:24:09.000 |
and then trying to kind of waterfall it down from there. 00:24:13.000 |
Yeah. And my thing on the charitable giving side of things, 00:24:16.000 |
I treated it like it was a dollar cost average where I put it on automatic 00:24:20.000 |
every month I give to a couple organizations. 00:24:22.000 |
And then once a year, usually around Christmas time, 00:24:25.000 |
I'll look at that again and change it and increase it a little bit. 00:24:28.000 |
But I think that's the kind of thing too that you can put just like your 00:24:31.000 |
contributions where you can kind of put it on automatic 00:24:36.000 |
Yeah. And if there's some part of you that just feels like you should be doing 00:24:41.000 |
something from a charitable sense, maybe it's not writing a check. 00:24:47.000 |
Maybe it's writing a smaller check and volunteering. 00:24:49.000 |
There's a lot you can do that isn't necessarily writing a check 00:24:54.000 |
So that might be a good proxy for now while you're feeling like the dollar 00:25:02.000 |
is there anything else that they're not thinking of that they should consider 00:25:05.000 |
with a child on the way, financial tips or any planning they should do? 00:25:11.000 |
Just be ready to throw your financial plan out the window multiple times 00:25:14.000 |
with kids because Kevin's right, kids are expensive. 00:25:17.000 |
When I told my brother out we were having twins, 00:25:20.000 |
he had twins six months before us and he laughed and he said, 00:25:23.000 |
"Yeah, throw your financial plan out the window because kids are expensive." 00:25:27.000 |
So I think you have to be a little more – be willing to be more flexible. 00:25:31.000 |
The good thing about kids is that you spend way less money on yourself 00:25:34.000 |
because you have no time to spend on yourself anymore. 00:25:38.000 |
There's always another expense coming up that you didn't think about. 00:25:43.000 |
And at what age can you get them going with an IRA if they do something for you? 00:25:49.000 |
You can do that, right? You've talked about it before? 00:25:52.000 |
Yes, I think they technically have to have some type of income, right? 00:25:57.000 |
Ben had talked about how people have their kids – 00:26:00.000 |
I've heard people who work around – there was a blogger I knew 00:26:04.000 |
who would show pictures of his kids in his blog and pay them an income. 00:26:12.000 |
Yes. I don't know if my kids are cracked up for that yet. 00:26:17.000 |
Well, and remember, now the 529 rules, right? 00:26:20.000 |
You can eventually convert that to a Roth if it goes unused. 00:26:24.000 |
Yes, 529 is actually pretty – all right, let's do another one. 00:26:33.000 |
I was let go from my construction job in October, but I landed on my feet 00:26:41.000 |
It seems like you can roll it into another account or do a cash withdrawal. 00:26:47.000 |
If I do a rollover, should I open a new IRA or just move it to my existing Roth IRA? 00:26:52.000 |
We own our home, but this could be a good down payment for the lot behind our house, 00:26:58.000 |
We're young newlyweds and very financially secure. 00:27:01.000 |
I feel like you don't hear that phrase a lot. 00:27:03.000 |
I have a feeling the answer is to wait and roll half to my new 401(k) when it's open 00:27:08.000 |
and take the resting cash for an emergency or down payment. 00:27:13.000 |
You usually don't hear that from someone who's just let go from their job too, 00:27:15.000 |
so kudos for being – and this also shows how dynamic the U.S. economy is, right? 00:27:19.000 |
This person was let go from their job one month. 00:27:22.000 |
The next month found another one is already thinking. 00:27:24.000 |
I do think there's another psychological component to this where you leave a job 00:27:28.000 |
and you have some 401(k) money and you look at it and you say, 00:27:33.000 |
People treat it differently than they would otherwise. 00:27:35.000 |
If they would have stayed at this company and kept putting money into the 401(k), 00:27:41.000 |
But now that it's there and it's like, "Well, you know, it's just like $15,000. 00:27:45.000 |
What if I just pulled it out and used it to make a down payment or change it to this?" 00:27:50.000 |
I take a pretty hard line on retirement savings, like using for other purposes. 00:27:54.000 |
Unless there's an emergency or there are no other options, 00:27:57.000 |
if it's earmarked for retirement, keep it for retirement. 00:28:00.000 |
I think, Kevin, you can correct me if I'm wrong. 00:28:02.000 |
If he's taking it out for a down payment for something, there's going to be a penalty on it. 00:28:07.000 |
Yeah, you're going to get hit with taxes and penalties on that 00:28:11.000 |
unless it's a first-time home purchase and there's some rules around that. 00:28:13.000 |
It doesn't sound like that's the case here if you're just buying another lot. 00:28:17.000 |
Yeah, so you're going to pay ordinary income tax on that plus a 10% penalty. 00:28:23.000 |
And so it's definitely, unless you really need it, which sounds like you don't, 00:28:29.000 |
the options are, yeah, you're either going to roll it into your new company's 401(k). 00:28:33.000 |
If they have a decent plan, that's probably a perfectly fine option, 00:28:40.000 |
You can borrow against it if you really needed to access it. 00:28:44.000 |
Again, that wouldn't be the first place to go for liquidity. 00:28:49.000 |
Or you're right, you could roll it into an IRA, whether it's a Roth or a traditional, 00:28:58.000 |
I would really try to avoid cashing it out because you're going to pay quite a bit. 00:29:02.000 |
Yeah, you probably give yourself more options by just rolling it over into an IRA. 00:29:05.000 |
And I don't think you have to be in a rush, too. 00:29:07.000 |
A lot of companies will let you keep it there for a while. 00:29:09.000 |
And as long as the costs and fees are not egregious, 00:29:12.000 |
you can keep it there while you try to figure out what you're going to do with it. 00:29:15.000 |
Yeah, I mean, most 401(k)s are not going to boot you off the platform. 00:29:18.000 |
They're happy to have your assets and cliffhanger basis points. 00:29:21.000 |
Yeah, they don't want you to leave, probably. 00:29:23.000 |
I feel like I have heard there that sometimes they start charging you an additional fee 00:29:26.000 |
if you're no longer employed. I feel like I've heard that. 00:29:32.000 |
And, you know, I would just take a look at what the, you know, 00:29:35.000 |
some company 401(k) plans are not as good as others. 00:29:38.000 |
I mean, there might be the only options you have in the new company 401(k) 00:29:44.000 |
And in that case, you'd be better off just putting into a self-directed IRA 00:29:49.000 |
Or they might only have a couple options to invest in. 00:29:52.000 |
But again, you cannot take a loan against an IRA. 00:29:58.000 |
So there's one little piece that the 401(k) might make some more sense 00:30:02.000 |
if you ever think, you know, you might need to borrow against it. 00:30:05.000 |
Yeah, but Harry's saying that he's financially secure. 00:30:09.000 |
I would just roll it over. Don't overthink it. 00:30:12.000 |
Probably best to have the control than anything else. 00:30:15.000 |
Is there any reason to roll his traditional 401(k) into a Roth IRA? 00:30:19.000 |
Or is that not worth the taxes that they would end up paying on that? 00:30:27.000 |
Yeah, well, it sounds like you might have a Roth, given the question. 00:30:35.000 |
But just generally speaking, you could do a conversion. 00:30:41.000 |
But, you know, the gamble on that is that you are paying, you know, 00:30:45.000 |
if you're in a lower tax bracket now, it's less painful to do. 00:30:48.000 |
And that money is going to be tax-free in the future. 00:30:52.000 |
But, you know, if he is, you know, on the upwards trajectory in his career, 00:30:57.000 |
it could be a good time to take advantage of that. 00:30:59.000 |
But, you know, given that we obviously don't know what tax rates are going to be, 00:31:08.000 |
It's set aside for retirement for a reason. Keep it there. 00:31:14.000 |
Okay. Last but not least, we have a question from Nick. 00:31:18.000 |
I'm a 40-year-old investor with roughly $2 million in investable assets 00:31:22.000 |
split evenly between a typical assets under management wealth advisor 00:31:31.000 |
the AUM wealth advisor accounts averaged about 13% gains, 00:31:36.000 |
mostly in individual stocks and the taxable account, 00:31:39.000 |
whereas on my own, largely through low-cost broad market ETFs, 00:31:45.000 |
This pattern has held for the last few years. 00:31:51.000 |
So my question is what in the actual expletive is the point of using an AUM advisor? 00:31:58.000 |
What would be the actual valid reasons to use an AUM wealth advisor? 00:32:04.000 |
I'm looking for the actual point of using one. 00:32:07.000 |
I'm leaning towards just moving all into my own personal accounts. 00:32:13.000 |
and our first four-letter word that we had to bleep out-- 00:32:17.000 |
listen, if they're simply investing your money for you 00:32:22.000 |
they are not a financial advisor; they're an investment advisor. 00:32:25.000 |
Now, I'm not saying that there's anything wrong 00:32:27.000 |
with outsourcing your investments for some people. 00:32:30.000 |
But if you're just paying them to allocate or pick stocks, 00:32:32.000 |
that's a different thing than a financial advisor. 00:32:34.000 |
So I would--and this is obviously the thing you want to do up front, 00:32:38.000 |
so maybe they're realizing this after the fact. 00:32:41.000 |
Performance is not the only reason that you have this kind of change of heart, 00:32:50.000 |
So if they're doing something for you besides asset allocation, 00:32:55.000 |
I would have that conversation to help understand that. 00:32:58.000 |
So Kevin, when you're talking to prospects or clients, 00:33:00.000 |
how do you try to tell them the things that you're doing for them 00:33:06.000 |
Because we've had plenty of clients come to us who assume, 00:33:09.000 |
"Listen, you're managing my portfolio, you're managing my investments," 00:33:11.000 |
and that's a big part of what we do, but it's not the only thing. 00:33:14.000 |
I actually had a conversation with a client this week 00:33:19.000 |
"Listen, I thought the investments were the important thing, 00:33:21.000 |
but now I realize it's so much more than that. 00:33:23.000 |
It's taxes and insurance and estate planning and financial planning 00:33:26.000 |
and all these other things you do that I didn't even realize before." 00:33:29.000 |
So I think that--so how do you communicate that to people? 00:33:33.000 |
Yeah, so I tell potential clients all the time, 00:33:39.000 |
because as many times as you hear it on the TV ads or see it in print, 00:33:45.000 |
it does not mean you're going to have success in the future. 00:33:49.000 |
And also just think about--yeah, to your point, 00:33:52.000 |
what does this person think that they're doing for you? 00:33:56.000 |
If you hire them purely to manage their money and invest it for you 00:34:01.000 |
and try to get an outsized return, I could see why you have a gripe. 00:34:05.000 |
But please note that beating the index is really, really, really difficult, 00:34:11.000 |
which is why index investing has become so popular. 00:34:14.000 |
Because over time, I think it's something like 90% of professionals 00:34:20.000 |
So if they don't have a shot, why--if you can't beat them, join them. 00:34:25.000 |
And it's worth understanding what your allocation with them-- 00:34:28.000 |
if they have more cash or bonds or national stocks or alternatives, 00:34:33.000 |
But if they're investing your money in a way that you don't agree with, 00:34:40.000 |
And for your personal accounts to return 23% last year, 00:34:47.000 |
The advisor or the AUM person might have been investing in small caps 00:34:56.000 |
And maybe against their benchmark, they did perfectly fine. 00:35:04.000 |
It's easy to think it's simple when the markets are up. 00:35:10.000 |
And so to your point, Ben, you mentioned all those things earlier. 00:35:13.000 |
If you are looking for somebody purely to grow your portfolio 00:35:17.000 |
as fast as possible, risk management be damned, 00:35:23.000 |
then, yeah, maybe you want somebody who's going to just try to shoot the lights 00:35:28.000 |
But what we talk about a lot is that we're wealth managers. 00:35:35.000 |
You've become wealthy in some way, shape, or form. 00:35:40.000 |
And so focusing on the emotional components, right? 00:35:51.000 |
So getting a sense of that behavioral management, 00:35:55.000 |
understanding how to invest which dollars for what event in life. 00:36:00.000 |
And if this guy doesn't have a very complex situation, 00:36:04.000 |
We have plenty of people who, in our audience, 00:36:06.000 |
who are DIY investors and they do it all themselves. 00:36:10.000 |
But if he has a complicated enough financial life where he's dealing with 00:36:14.000 |
estate planning and insurance and taxes and needs someone to stand between him 00:36:18.000 |
and making a mistake, that's a financial advisor you're looking for. 00:36:21.000 |
So maybe you just have the wrong one or maybe you realize, 00:36:25.000 |
Yeah, I would actually bet that the vast majority of our clients were former 00:36:29.000 |
do-it-yourselfers and they found us by watching this show or listening to Josh 00:36:34.000 |
or Animal Spirits or whatever it is and said, 00:36:38.000 |
but now I'm getting ready to retire and there's so much about the 00:36:41.000 |
distribution aspect that I don't understand and taxes and all the other things." 00:36:49.000 |
I don't want to sit at a computer all day and watch my stock portfolio." 00:36:55.000 |
But if you're happy doing it yourself and you've got a good process and, 00:36:59.000 |
you know, Ben, you've written on this before, 00:37:01.000 |
like write down your investment policy statement and make sure that you stick 00:37:05.000 |
And there's a lot you can do in that area and save yourself the fee. 00:37:10.000 |
And the point of AUM is there's an incentive to grow the pot, right, 00:37:24.000 |
Thanks to Kevin for coming in and helping us. 00:37:29.000 |
you know that he knows what he's doing, okay? 00:37:33.000 |
Email us your questions, askthecompoundshow@gmail.com. 00:37:40.000 |
Leave us a comment on YouTube if you're watching there.