back to indexWhat if This Time Is Different?
Chapters
0:0 Intro
1:22 When to sell your winners
8:55 Is this time different?
16:7 Today's tech stocks vs dot com tech stocks
23:41 De-risking a portfolio
27:18 The optimal allowance for kids
00:00:15.800 |
Remember our email here is askthecompoundshow@gmail.com. 00:00:27.340 |
I just this week got a new pair of the bird dogs 00:00:34.200 |
dress up a little bit, but also be comfortable. 00:00:41.560 |
I actually, I like the, I have a pair without, 00:00:47.720 |
they're still giving away these dad tech hats. 00:00:57.540 |
I've been using the shorts lately just for working out 00:01:00.180 |
because it's too cold to wear 'em outside anymore. 00:01:07.140 |
- They're also our record sponsor here on Ask the Condown. 00:01:10.380 |
They have sponsored more shows than anyone else. 00:01:12.140 |
- Okay, so they've been on more than Bill Sweet even. 00:01:17.140 |
- They should make a pair of raw thigh raise for us. 00:01:22.580 |
Yeah, so up first today, we have a question from Chris. 00:01:35.740 |
our kids will be highly competitive to get into top schools 00:01:38.960 |
where it's estimated that four years will cost $250,000. 00:01:43.780 |
the money has been going into a couple of brokerage accounts, 00:01:46.800 |
$30,000 in Lyft off, which I never pay attention to, 00:01:54.000 |
because it has done pretty well over the years. 00:01:56.040 |
This is in large part due to early investments 00:02:20.900 |
so we will need to start tapping into the money 00:02:26.320 |
- So Chris actually sent us his statement here. 00:02:29.600 |
but he's got massive gains in both of these stocks, 00:02:33.720 |
Why don't we bring in a guy who's been talking about NVIDIA 00:02:35.600 |
for probably longer than Chris has been holding it. 00:02:43.440 |
- I wanted to say thank you guys for having me on the show. 00:02:52.320 |
John Carlo asks, "Is Josh a subway guy or an Uber guy?" 00:03:02.040 |
- Yeah, I mentioned you were coming straight from NYSE. 00:03:07.840 |
And it's not 'cause I think I'm too good for the subway. 00:03:10.960 |
It's literally just, it makes me so unhappy and depressed, 00:03:21.720 |
- You know what the worst part of the subway is for me 00:03:23.360 |
as being someone who doesn't take it very often? 00:03:27.600 |
and the pole is long from the person who held it before you. 00:03:29.760 |
- Yeah, I will absolutely not grab anything at all. 00:03:33.840 |
And what's funny is we have a dinner reservation 00:03:36.220 |
somewhere downtown 'cause we work in Midtown Manhattan 00:03:47.200 |
And it's not the length, it's the walking down 00:04:08.240 |
So I'm facing the same dilemma as, what's his name? 00:04:12.360 |
- Chris, so he's sitting on these huge gains. 00:04:16.420 |
I don't know if you have a goal to use this money for, 00:04:20.000 |
but he's saying, "I have this goal, I know how much I need. 00:04:28.600 |
My daughter just applied to 12 colleges last month. 00:04:39.440 |
So I didn't hear 529 anywhere in what he said. 00:04:44.040 |
And obviously he doesn't own Tesla stock in a 529. 00:04:47.440 |
- Right, yeah, he said he's using brokerage accounts. 00:05:06.960 |
the best possible vehicle you could have done it with. 00:05:10.640 |
because you could actually earn something in cash now 00:05:13.680 |
- Yes, I don't really care what happens to the market, 00:05:16.000 |
because this is now like, it doesn't make a difference. 00:05:18.880 |
This is, I know for a fact I need to use the money, 00:05:22.440 |
so I just mentally said, if I'm leaving money on the table 00:05:26.240 |
because there's a stock market rally, whatever. 00:05:39.800 |
And I missed some of it, but it doesn't matter. 00:05:47.040 |
just because if you can liquidate everything else, 00:05:52.040 |
literally put it into something high yielding 00:05:55.280 |
until you need it a year and a half from now, 00:06:03.800 |
- John, give me a try out of Tesla and Nvidia drawdowns. 00:06:11.280 |
I mean, Tesla was down 73% and Nvidia was down 66%. 00:06:17.280 |
that's the risk is that that money's not there when needed. 00:06:25.200 |
you could leg out of the other stuff if you wanted to, 00:06:29.360 |
- You would probably say the other way around though, right? 00:06:35.360 |
and try to hold onto the rest for another year? 00:06:38.160 |
- I would probably, if I know I'm gonna be spending 00:06:40.440 |
this money in the next couple years, I would lock it in. 00:06:44.980 |
I wouldn't even, I mean, maybe keep 20% in the stock market 00:06:49.480 |
But other than that, I'm all for cashing it out 00:06:53.160 |
and sitting and keep going chill or whatever. 00:06:59.200 |
It's like, all right, you're applying to private colleges 00:07:09.120 |
You're paying that out over the course of four years, 00:07:16.740 |
It's possible Nvidia and Tesla could double again 00:07:23.320 |
I didn't think they would in the first place. 00:07:27.400 |
So I don't know, but it seems to be like part of the, 00:07:31.160 |
it seems to be like to me that if you have some stock market 00:07:36.560 |
you don't have to take all of it off the table. 00:07:38.560 |
Also, if these are in taxable brokerage accounts, 00:07:41.440 |
these are huge embedded tax liabilities in the year 00:07:45.720 |
that you take these gains in those two stocks. 00:07:59.640 |
- Right, so maybe if he has other forms of liquidity, 00:08:09.640 |
would be too risky then for your risk tolerance? 00:08:15.360 |
- Well, if he wanted to, he could do a simple-- 00:08:25.380 |
Do 20% in one, two, three, four, five-year maturities. 00:08:29.940 |
- Yeah, and you match those assets with the liabilities 00:08:38.880 |
Don't they have the target maturity bond funds now? 00:08:45.360 |
- I thought you were gonna say chart options. 00:08:48.180 |
Well, I was gonna say, if you have a Lyft off account, 00:09:11.160 |
What are the stats when the Fed is actively offloading 00:09:22.240 |
I did just kind of a quick, over the last 70 plus years, 00:09:29.240 |
Just saying, like, this is, we're down 10% right now. 00:09:40.860 |
All-time highs happen like seven or 8% of the time 00:09:45.920 |
20% or worse, it's like one out of every six or seven years. 00:10:03.480 |
So a third of the time that you're investing, 00:10:07.600 |
you're investing in the midst of a correction. 00:10:10.520 |
- Yeah, and my point was, yeah, like, get used to it. 00:10:17.980 |
listen, throw all the historical evidence out the window 00:10:24.280 |
and the government is spending trillions of dollars 00:10:31.160 |
And I think the thing that we've come down on 00:10:56.360 |
- There's only one exception to what you're saying. 00:11:01.900 |
if there were YouTube or podcasts in the 1970s 00:11:51.680 |
Like, you had some superlatives where it's like, 00:11:54.220 |
well, maybe this time it's not gonna bounce back 00:12:01.020 |
We had net, I don't have the stats, I should ask Nick, 00:12:19.920 |
into my accounts with y'all, this would be the time. 00:12:34.080 |
that particular circumstance where this time, 00:12:43.160 |
And I think investors are more conditioned now. 00:12:47.640 |
you'd look back and you'd see, like, the Great Depression, 00:12:49.760 |
and then you'd see, like, this huge bull market in the '50s, 00:12:51.760 |
but you didn't have as much time to look back and say, 00:12:53.780 |
like, listen, every time the stock market goes down, 00:12:57.320 |
There's never been a time where the stock market has fallen 00:13:04.240 |
Nicole keeps backing my microphone away from me, 00:13:14.160 |
they look at the state of the world and the scary headlines 00:13:16.480 |
and think, like, it's never been this bad before. 00:13:22.400 |
"The only black swans of the history you haven't read yet." 00:13:24.720 |
Like, history has always been terrible, unfortunately. 00:13:27.320 |
It's just the scary headlines are just beamed 00:13:35.400 |
but also the news's profit motive has never been more, 00:13:41.760 |
so it's always, the profit motive of the news 00:13:45.080 |
has always been to impulse people into doing something, 00:13:48.680 |
you know, put down a nickel, buy a newspaper, 00:13:58.720 |
And so the incentive system for people writing market news 00:14:03.320 |
is to get you to read theirs and not someone else's. 00:14:16.640 |
Like, this is a much more challenging media environment 00:14:28.480 |
- Feels like mass media has become more and more like TMZ 00:14:31.720 |
instead of TMZ becoming more and more like mass media. 00:14:39.600 |
like where editors at major publications were like, 00:14:43.640 |
yeah, but how can we like, how can we make this more, 00:14:47.320 |
they'll say like, how can we make this more urgent? 00:14:56.120 |
- Like, we can't, we don't know how bad corrections 00:15:01.000 |
or when the stock market is gonna have a period 00:15:06.040 |
but I don't think, that doesn't mean you abandon risk assets 00:15:08.640 |
because they're gonna make you feel uncomfortable 00:15:10.800 |
Like, this is totally normal, the feeling of discomfort. 00:15:33.640 |
including, you know, a record-setting pace of rate hikes 00:15:37.040 |
and, you know, the Fed shrinking its balance sheet 00:15:42.640 |
This particular mix of circumstances does not show up 00:15:56.400 |
Like, you know, I'll show you some other stuff 00:16:07.520 |
- All right, up next, we have a question from Joe. 00:16:11.880 |
and would love to hear you guys discuss in detail 00:16:16.040 |
any different from Cisco, Intel, or Microsoft 00:16:20.840 |
Could these stocks end up going nowhere over the next decade? 00:16:23.600 |
Why are the tech stocks of today any different? 00:16:27.240 |
- It's funny that Microsoft is one of the big tech stocks 00:16:30.000 |
today, and it was, John, throw up the chart here. 00:16:33.840 |
going back from the 1999 peak, early 2000 peak. 00:16:37.760 |
Microsoft is actually the only one that's come back. 00:16:39.160 |
Cisco and Intel are still underwater from back then, 00:16:42.760 |
and Microsoft was underwater for 16 years, I think, 00:16:45.800 |
so it was 2016 on a price basis that it took to round trip. 00:16:52.240 |
The NASDAQ 100 was underwater from 2000 to 2016 as well 00:17:02.180 |
it went nowhere for over a decade and a half. 00:17:06.040 |
So from 2009, the NASDAQ 100 was up 19.2% per year, 00:17:10.400 |
which is just impossible for any professional investor 00:17:14.320 |
Since the start of 2000, it's only up 6.5% per year, 00:17:17.360 |
'cause from 2000 to 2008, the NASDAQ 100 was down 12% 00:17:25.520 |
So, I mean, that was the craziest the US stock market 00:17:29.820 |
has ever gotten, but I guess the way I look at it 00:17:33.140 |
is the biggest difference between now and then 00:17:35.300 |
is these companies are like conglomerates now, right? 00:17:37.620 |
Like Microsoft, how many different business lines 00:17:40.500 |
How many different business lines does Amazon have? 00:17:43.660 |
- Yeah, back then, I don't think these companies 00:17:48.120 |
Now, that doesn't mean these companies can't underperform, 00:17:49.720 |
but to have that sort of level of underperformance, 00:17:52.220 |
I think things got so silly in the dot-com bubble 00:17:55.860 |
- So, there's a few things what separates this from 2000, 00:18:03.540 |
first of all, the NASDAQ was like 86 times earnings 00:18:06.800 |
back then, and one of the things skewing that number higher, 00:18:10.800 |
the P/E ratio, is that a lot of the companies 00:18:18.780 |
not only were they not profitable, they had no revenue. 00:18:21.820 |
Like, we're talking about companies coming public-- 00:18:24.500 |
- Yeah, there were no fundamentals back then. 00:18:29.620 |
You look at the 100 companies that make up the queues 00:18:32.900 |
right now, compared to the dot-com bubble darlings, 00:18:37.340 |
there's no comparison on a fundamental basis. 00:18:40.300 |
Back then, these were companies doing experimental things 00:18:45.820 |
That is not what people are investing in right now. 00:18:50.700 |
Valuations are not cheap now, but they don't look like that. 00:18:53.900 |
So, like, Apple is now 24 times next year's earnings, 00:18:59.020 |
Next year, let's assume consensus is somewhat close. 00:19:04.020 |
but it's got features that investors are probably prizing 00:19:09.900 |
It's got more stability than most countries in the world. 00:19:32.600 |
to compare Cisco, which did one thing in the year 2000, 00:19:51.540 |
and I paid for my Whole Foods salad or something, 00:19:54.260 |
credit to me for eating healthy, with my palm. 00:19:59.280 |
'cause I like looking up people who are in movies. 00:20:00.700 |
That's owned by Amazon, they own MGM, Prime Video, 00:20:05.340 |
They buy up all their competitors these days, 00:20:06.900 |
so these companies are more than just one business line. 00:20:11.700 |
Again, that doesn't mean they can't underperform, 00:20:13.140 |
but not like that. >> Doesn't mean the stocks 00:20:15.460 |
Actually, one of the funny things about Microsoft, 00:20:29.100 |
who made his money as an employee, not a founder. 00:20:33.500 |
He didn't start, you know, he was employee number 30. 00:20:36.700 |
>> Right, he was like Bill Gates' assistant or something. 00:20:38.540 |
>> Microsoft hired him to follow Bill Gates around 00:20:40.620 |
and probably make sure he didn't put on two different shoes. 00:20:47.300 |
and when Gates was tired, Ballmer said, "Put me in, coach." 00:20:51.340 |
And over that next 10-year period, while he was the CEO, 00:21:16.140 |
but they're not getting credit for that earnings growth, 00:21:20.780 |
and Ballmer stepped into the seat at a very high valuation. 00:21:25.700 |
>> Yeah, you also had two 50% stock market crashes, 00:21:30.140 |
>> So it's very possible that NVIDIA grows its earnings 00:21:51.860 |
and that young people might have just experienced 00:21:56.780 |
you're comparing an acoustic guitar to an octopus on, 00:22:04.820 |
>> The dot-com bubble was like four or five years 00:22:07.260 |
of that behavior, not just like a six-month period. 00:22:30.020 |
and these were early delivery grocery internet sites. 00:22:53.420 |
oh, we're going to build a submarine with a screen door. 00:23:07.340 |
>> We're going to build a solar power flashlight company. 00:23:16.560 |
Yes, I want in, said the pension fund manager. 00:23:21.560 |
that are just uncomfortable investing in stocks, 00:23:24.500 |
this is the reason that stocks have the highest return 00:23:26.640 |
over the long term, because the future is unknown, 00:23:30.500 |
Like, the people that don't give it the benefit of the doubt 00:23:41.860 |
>> Okay, up next we have a question from Jim. 00:23:49.420 |
in my late 50s, doing well financially, not to brag, 00:23:57.300 |
finally have some yield after 15 years of 0% rates. 00:24:07.100 |
have probably 20 to 30 more years to grow our wealth 00:24:09.820 |
and keep up with inflation once we retire at 65. 00:24:18.700 |
since there's no handbook for this kind of thing. 00:24:22.740 |
This is the time when your financial plan matters most, 00:24:29.940 |
Middle age, investing probably takes over a little bit, 00:24:33.420 |
and make sure you're investing the right way. 00:24:42.000 |
what you're actually gonna do with this money 00:24:43.500 |
with how you invest it and what your goals are. 00:24:46.300 |
So I think that's probably the most important stage of life 00:24:51.780 |
'cause that's the thing people have been talking to us 00:24:58.380 |
over two, three, maybe four decades when I'm retired, 00:25:00.940 |
but I also have to have it be safe when I want to spend it. 00:25:07.800 |
- Yeah, I wish we could really answer this question 00:25:11.060 |
in this forum, but there are so many other variables 00:25:14.000 |
that a certified financial planner would have to know 00:25:28.200 |
in the early stages of talking to a prospective client 00:25:31.740 |
is trying to figure out, not what should I invest in, 00:25:38.980 |
And which money should be accessed at what time 00:25:48.460 |
all right, this bucket of money we know we need for blank, 00:25:58.520 |
and I think that that's a financial planning question, 00:26:05.460 |
You're like, this is how much I'm gonna spend, 00:26:12.900 |
don't have to think about when they're accumulating wealth. 00:26:36.140 |
maybe something complex happens in their life, 00:26:43.820 |
now I need some help and I have to talk to an advisor 00:26:47.140 |
- Yeah, I also think people like confirmation, 00:26:49.740 |
or they like having somebody to bounce things off of, 00:26:52.140 |
and most people don't have someone in their life 00:27:00.700 |
like long-term retirement and different account types, 00:27:07.020 |
- Yes, if you text most of your normal friends, 00:27:31.180 |
I shorten them and Duncan shortens them again. 00:27:34.500 |
I don't, no disrespect, they're great questions. 00:27:41.620 |
and we're starting to discuss giving the older one, 00:27:50.860 |
using the three jar method, saving, spending, giving. 00:27:58.980 |
one, money in the real world is tied to work, 00:28:11.580 |
out of a sense of familial, it's a hard word, 00:28:16.620 |
I was wondering if you give your kids an allowance 00:28:27.740 |
- So a couple months ago, my six-year-old daughter, Kate, 00:28:31.740 |
"Thank you for giving us such a nice house to live in." 00:28:33.780 |
And I was like, "Oh, that's very kind of you." 00:28:35.740 |
And she said, "It must be really expensive to buy a house." 00:28:37.620 |
I said, "Yes, how much do you think it costs?" 00:28:50.180 |
So they're obviously, they've done some research on this. 00:28:56.780 |
Some people say the allowance has to be tied to work 00:29:04.540 |
"No, no, no, the chores are part of being in a family. 00:29:11.380 |
- I don't think anything that you really teach your kids 00:29:18.300 |
I think you just give them stuff when they're, 00:29:22.040 |
They have their whole fucking lives to worry about, 00:29:37.780 |
So for my daughter, it's makeup and clothes and jewelry, 00:29:50.020 |
and then my wife will buy it and she'll be like, 00:29:53.000 |
"All right, I'm gonna contribute my babysitting money." 00:29:59.080 |
"Like your contribution is not really going that far yet." 00:30:07.580 |
It's good for her to feel like she's making a contribution, 00:30:14.900 |
It's good for her to give up, have skin in the game. 00:30:36.900 |
and he created a Caesars profile for himself. 00:30:40.740 |
while I'm downstairs in the kitchen making a sandwich. 00:30:47.540 |
and I don't even understand where he's getting it from. 00:31:02.420 |
He wants like to put money toward going to a Knicks game. 00:31:16.300 |
- My nine-year-old is a saver. - He's very good with money. 00:31:19.340 |
- My daughter, if she gets money for a birthday 00:31:23.620 |
she stocks it away in her thing and she's a saver. 00:31:26.720 |
That's kind of how I was when I was young too. 00:31:30.180 |
for the cleaning person that comes every two weeks-- 00:31:34.260 |
So, oh, so I forgot what I was trying to say. 00:31:40.220 |
I don't think I can tie chores to money for him. 00:31:53.100 |
It's like, all right, well, for the last two weeks in a row, 00:31:55.420 |
you got an invite to babysit and you said no. 00:32:01.380 |
they're paying like, I think they're paying like $20 an hour. 00:32:28.080 |
the same values and whatever, blah, blah, blah. 00:32:33.140 |
So I don't think you should torture your kids 00:32:35.800 |
with chores to teach them the value of a dollar. 00:32:40.900 |
- Also, you do run the risk of becoming the parents 00:32:51.420 |
- Hold on, it's Tom Whalen, delete that comment. 00:33:08.980 |
they're gonna learn about money the hard way. 00:33:11.780 |
Like they're gonna do stupid stuff with money 00:33:13.580 |
that either they get for their birthday or that they earn. 00:33:23.060 |
kind of trying to figure out what I do for a living. 00:33:26.060 |
She's most impressed with the fact that we're on YouTube. 00:33:35.900 |
Well, you have this money, then you make it grow bigger, 00:33:41.420 |
that it's just, their eyes gloss over and they're done. 00:33:55.300 |
when I see people doing like financial literacy 00:33:57.660 |
for 18-year-olds, like about retirement investing. 00:34:04.300 |
- Yeah, you have to wait till it actually matters. 00:34:06.780 |
- Nobody should be investing for retirement in their 20s. 00:34:08.020 |
- How about just exploring student loans first? 00:34:10.700 |
Right, yeah, you have to wait till it's actually applicable. 00:34:14.100 |
- How about just go be 24 years old and don't save anything? 00:34:18.140 |
It's like the only, Ben, I know that's anathema 00:34:21.980 |
but like just my personal opinion is the only time 00:34:27.420 |
- Yeah, you have no responsibilities, I agree. 00:34:29.340 |
- You could be dead next year, what are you doing, you know? 00:34:35.300 |
This theoretical retirement you're putting money away for, 00:34:39.100 |
like I gotta save money for my future children's college? 00:34:50.100 |
not like a Fintwit approved take, but that's the truth.