back to indexRPF0642-Friday_QA-How_to_Contribute_to_an_IRA_When_Youre_Taking_the_Foreign_Earned_Income_Exclusion_How_Should_You_Think_About_FIREing_Yourself_From_A_Big-Money_Job
![](None)
00:00:00.000 |
With Kroger Brand products from Ralphs, you can make all your favorite things this holiday season. 00:00:05.240 |
Because Kroger Brand's proven quality products come at exceptionally low prices. 00:00:09.920 |
And with a money-back quality guarantee, every dish is sure to be a favorite. 00:00:18.180 |
Whether you shop delivery, pickup, or in-store, Kroger Brand has all your favorite things. 00:00:53.980 |
Welcome to Radical Personal Finance, a show dedicated to providing you with the knowledge, skills, insight, and encouragement you need to live a rich and meaningful life now, 00:01:03.760 |
while building a plan for financial freedom in 10 years or less. 00:01:07.200 |
My name is Joshua, I am your host, and today is Friday. 00:01:10.040 |
I don't have a live Q&A show, but I do have a lively Q&A show. 00:01:26.380 |
Happy Friday to you all. I was not able to get ahead enough, and to get the new little newborn squared away enough, 00:01:32.220 |
that he will be quiet to where I will be able to record a show as scheduled with live call, 00:01:38.020 |
and kind of got to sneak around and figure out when I can do these things at the moment. 00:01:41.560 |
Little boy's been sick the last couple of days, and so... 00:01:44.340 |
Not sick, just anyway, a little fussy and whatnot. 00:01:47.000 |
You might hear him in the background, but let's get to it. 00:01:48.740 |
I got a Friday Q&A show, and today I'm going to handle a handful of questions that listeners have written in. 00:01:56.640 |
First question comes in from a listener who's asking me about how to contribute to an IRA, though he be an expat. 00:02:06.120 |
Listener writes in and says, "Hi, Joshua. I'm a long-time listener. I really enjoy your perspective, 00:02:09.660 |
and it's been helpful in lifestyle choices and financial options. 00:02:13.500 |
Your episodes on expatriate life are of particular interest to me." 00:02:20.160 |
"I'm an American expat, and I have been living abroad for over five years. 00:02:24.380 |
I have been using the foreign income exclusion, and it's great for me in general. 00:02:28.740 |
However, one of the caveats is the inability to contribute to an IRA. 00:02:32.820 |
As I understand it, when utilizing the exclusion, you are unable to contribute to an IRA, 00:02:39.560 |
But with the foreign income tax credit, I believe you can contribute to an IRA. 00:02:46.300 |
So I've been unable to contribute since moving overseas. 00:02:51.340 |
Maybe on retirement investment options while abroad. 00:02:53.900 |
Would life insurance be an additional option? 00:02:55.740 |
Would setting up a USA-based LLC or some sort of entity be helpful? 00:03:00.040 |
Would that be advantageous in some sort of way if you're self-employed? 00:03:03.640 |
Thanks so much. Keep up the great and helpful work." 00:03:07.260 |
So this is a great question, and let me answer it directly. 00:03:12.460 |
I'll try to keep it to a few minutes of background information 00:03:15.860 |
to make sure that we are all on the same page. 00:03:20.760 |
US citizens, though they move abroad, continue to be required by the United States of America 00:03:26.060 |
to pay the United States of America income tax on their worldwide earnings, 00:03:31.660 |
even if they do not live in the United States of America. 00:03:35.560 |
This is unlike any other nation in the world save Eritrea, which has the same system. 00:03:40.960 |
So it's unlike anyone else in the world, but it is the fact for US citizens. 00:03:44.960 |
So though this listener is living outside of the United States, 00:03:48.960 |
he is still required to pay the United States income taxes on his worldwide income. 00:03:54.960 |
Now, the United States government offers three basic things 00:03:58.660 |
that are useful for people who don't live in the United States. 00:04:02.660 |
They are, number one, the foreign earned income exclusion, 00:04:06.460 |
which allows you to exclude up to about $105,000 of your foreign earned income 00:04:17.360 |
That's called the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:04:20.460 |
The second thing that is available is the foreign housing deduction 00:04:26.760 |
which allows you sometimes to additionally deduct some of your housing expenses 00:04:35.660 |
And then number three, you have what's called the foreign tax credit. 00:04:39.560 |
The foreign tax credit allows you to receive a credit against your US income taxes 00:04:45.860 |
for income taxes that you have already paid to a foreign government. 00:04:51.660 |
Now, the number one and number two, the foreign earned income exclusion 00:04:55.260 |
and the foreign housing deduction or exclusion function together, 00:04:59.360 |
whereas the foreign tax credit is a separate system. 00:05:03.260 |
Now, when you use the foreign earned income exclusion and you qualify for it, 00:05:07.460 |
what it does is it wipes out your income, basically. 00:05:11.560 |
The foreign earned income exclusion functions as a form of anti-income. 00:05:16.760 |
So if you earn $100,000, you can take the $100,000 exclusion 00:05:21.460 |
and you will effectively have, for the purposes of your federal income tax return, 00:05:29.260 |
You thus have no income, thus you owe no taxes. 00:05:33.660 |
This is a problem if you are trying to participate in something 00:05:37.060 |
that requires you to have earned income, for example, to make an IRA contribution. 00:05:43.260 |
In order for you to make an IRA contribution, 00:05:46.160 |
you have to have earned income at least equal to the amount of your IRA contribution. 00:05:53.460 |
And so the problem this listener is facing is their income is being wiped out 00:05:57.760 |
by the foreign earned income exclusion, leaving them with no tax liability, 00:06:02.860 |
but making it not possible for them to contribute to an IRA. 00:06:08.160 |
Now, is there a solution? Yes, there is a solution. 00:06:12.560 |
And I'm going to give you three solutions, one of which you have mentioned. 00:06:16.060 |
Let's start with that one, which is your worst solution. 00:06:18.860 |
What you are suggesting is that instead of claiming the foreign earned income exclusion, 00:06:27.160 |
Now, you are correct that if you claim a foreign tax credit, you will have income. 00:06:32.560 |
Let's say that you earn a hundred thousand dollars. 00:06:35.160 |
Let's say that you live in a country that is, I don't know where you live. 00:06:39.960 |
Let's just say you're paying an effective tax rate of 15% on your money. 00:06:44.560 |
So you've paid $15,000 of foreign taxes on your income to a foreign government, 00:06:50.360 |
not in the United States. Well, if you are in that situation, 00:06:54.760 |
then you can claim a credit, a tax credit for the $15,000 for the U.S. government. 00:07:01.160 |
Now, the way the foreign tax credit works, it doesn't actually save you any money. 00:07:10.160 |
So let me use an example. Let's say that you go to Canada, Canadian citizen. 00:07:15.560 |
Let's say that you're a dual citizen of Canada and the United States 00:07:19.260 |
and you have moved from the United States to Canada and you're earning a hundred thousand dollars. 00:07:24.160 |
Assume for the sake of argument that your effective tax rate in the United States on a hundred thousand dollars would be 20%, 00:07:30.760 |
but your effective tax rate in Canada on the same hundred thousand dollars is going to be 30%. 00:07:39.860 |
and then you can take that as a credit against your U.S. taxes, 00:07:44.760 |
but and you'll effectively wipe out your U.S. taxes, but you won't save any money. 00:07:48.060 |
You're going to pay the money out to either Canada or the United States. 00:07:52.560 |
Now, let's say that instead of working in Canada, you instead were working in the Cayman Islands. 00:07:56.860 |
So the Cayman Islands doesn't have an income tax. 00:07:59.560 |
They don't have any kind of income taxes imposed on people who live there, who work there. 00:08:04.760 |
So now you don't have any foreign taxes paid. 00:08:07.160 |
Well, now you can't take the foreign tax credit. 00:08:09.560 |
What that means though is you're going to pay $20,000 to the U.S. 00:08:12.560 |
government on your hundred thousand dollars of income, 00:08:14.560 |
assuming that you didn't qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:08:17.360 |
Remember, we're just talking about the foreign tax credit here. 00:08:19.660 |
So the tax credit really doesn't save you any money. 00:08:24.360 |
So if you pay taxes abroad, then you don't have to doubly pay those taxes in the U.S. 00:08:30.260 |
You will pay it whatever the total highest tax bill is. 00:08:33.860 |
If you're living and working in Canada, Canadian taxes are higher. 00:08:37.060 |
You'll pay the higher amount of taxes to Canada. 00:08:39.660 |
If you're living and working in the United States, in a place 00:08:41.560 |
where the taxes are lower than the United States, 00:08:43.460 |
you'll pay the lower taxes to the United States. 00:08:46.760 |
So the foreign tax credit can be useful if you're paying foreign taxes. 00:08:50.460 |
If you get the credit, you might as well use it. 00:08:52.460 |
But what I'd love to see most people do is use that for offsetting things 00:08:56.260 |
like their capital gains taxes, etc., and use it if you have it. 00:09:02.060 |
However, you are correct that even if you don't qualify 00:09:07.960 |
if you're paying foreign income taxes, you can still claim those foreign income taxes 00:09:11.960 |
and you will still have earned income allowing you to contribute to an IRA. 00:09:15.760 |
But that's the expensive way. Don't do it that way. 00:09:18.360 |
Take the foreign earned income exclusion, which let's go to number way number two. 00:09:21.860 |
The second way that you can contribute to an IRA is if you will simply make more money 00:09:27.160 |
than you can wipe out with the foreign earned income exclusion. Simple example. 00:09:31.560 |
Let's say that you can earn a hundred and fifteen thousand dollars, 00:09:36.060 |
but yet you can only wipe out a hundred and five thousand dollars 00:09:40.460 |
Now you have ten thousand dollars of earned income. 00:09:42.860 |
And the way it works is you will pay and owe US taxes on that ten thousand dollars of income. 00:09:47.860 |
It doesn't start at the bottom of the bracket. 00:09:49.860 |
It'll rather it will start at the top of the bracket, 00:09:52.460 |
but you will still be able to claim your deduction, 00:09:54.960 |
your standard deduction or your itemized deduction. 00:09:57.060 |
You will still be able to claim maybe a child tax credit or some of that 00:10:00.660 |
if you have it against that ten thousand dollars, 00:10:02.860 |
but you'll have ten thousand dollars of earned income, 00:10:05.160 |
which you can then use for an IRA contribution. 00:10:08.460 |
So that's another simple way is make your income higher so that you have more earned income. 00:10:13.460 |
However, easy for me to say maybe harder for you to do. 00:10:19.060 |
and you don't want to make a hundred and thirty thousand dollars 00:10:22.760 |
So let's go to way number three and that is based upon how you claim your foreign earned income exclusion. 00:10:31.960 |
There are two tests that can be used to qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:10:41.960 |
It's a test that simply goes based upon how many days you spend outside of the United States. 00:10:51.360 |
and thirty days out of a three hundred and sixty five day period outside of the United States in a foreign country, 00:10:58.160 |
then you will qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion regardless of any other factor. 00:11:08.060 |
Now this is one example wherein it's a little bit easier for U.S. 00:11:11.660 |
citizens to avoid the tax on their first hundred and five thousand dollars of income than it is for other citizens. 00:11:17.560 |
For example, you as a U.S. citizen can leave the United States 00:11:21.160 |
and as long as you are outside of the United States for three hundred 00:11:24.160 |
and thirty days out of the three hundred sixty five days. 00:11:26.660 |
And by the way, there are a few little rules there about international waters not counting and things like that, 00:11:30.460 |
but just keep it simple. Just just say you're outside of the United States 00:11:33.360 |
for at least three hundred thirty out of a three hundred sixty five day period. 00:11:36.460 |
Doesn't matter where you are. Doesn't matter if you pay taxes anywhere else in the world or not. 00:11:40.560 |
You can claim the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:11:46.160 |
or to do some of the things that we've discussed where you cannot pay any taxes to any other jurisdiction other than the United States. 00:11:52.860 |
That would not be the same if you were, say, Canadian. 00:11:55.960 |
If you were Canadian and you left Canada and just spent a year bouncing around the world, 00:12:00.260 |
you would still owe the country of Canada taxes because you're still considered to be a resident of Canada. 00:12:06.260 |
In order for you to end your relationship with the Canadian taxing authorities, 00:12:10.760 |
you have to become a resident somewhere else, pick up a residency and sever all your ties with Canada. 00:12:16.560 |
So for a hundred thousand dollars or less, the US system is probably a little easier to work with than the Canadian system. 00:12:22.460 |
Now, my hope is, of course, we all get to more than a hundred thousand dollars, 00:12:25.160 |
in which case I'd rather have the Canadian system. 00:12:26.960 |
But what what can we do? So that's the strict days test. 00:12:31.360 |
We'll come back to that in a moment because you have to use it for the trick that I'm going to tell you to work. 00:12:36.260 |
Now, the other way that you claim the foreign earned income exclusion is with what's called the bonafide residence exception. 00:12:42.360 |
So this is where you actually live somewhere else and you have a series of factors that demonstrate that, 00:12:50.560 |
If you can prove that you actually are a bonafide resident of another place, you actually live somewhere else. 00:12:56.660 |
You're not just bouncing around the world. You actually live somewhere else. 00:12:58.960 |
You have a residency visa or you're a citizen of another country. 00:13:02.460 |
You have stable house there. You work there. Your family's there, etc. 00:13:06.060 |
You're a resident and you plan to be a resident there forever. 00:13:08.860 |
Then you can qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion under the bonafide residency test. 00:13:14.360 |
And that will give you the ability, if you needed to or wanted to, 00:13:18.460 |
to spend more physical days in the United States than the strict days test. 00:13:24.160 |
Generally, you could probably spend up to about four months in the United States. 00:13:29.760 |
You can't spend more than four months in the United States every year 00:13:33.860 |
because that would cause you to fail the substantial presence test 00:13:37.360 |
if you were spending more than 120 days in the US every year 00:13:40.660 |
and thus automatically subject you to US taxation. 00:13:44.860 |
But if you spent, you know, a couple, three, four months in the US each year, 00:13:48.360 |
you could do that as long as you were a true bonafide resident abroad. 00:13:52.960 |
That won't work and allow you to contribute to an IRA 00:13:55.960 |
if you're claiming the foreign earned income exclusion under that test 00:14:01.860 |
It only works on calendar years, which is why generally when people expatriate, 00:14:06.860 |
the advice is claim using the strict days test first. 00:14:10.860 |
And then if you're going to set up a residence, move into the bonafide residence exclusion. 00:14:14.960 |
But here's the cool thing with the strict days test. 00:14:16.760 |
Let's talk about how it works. It doesn't have to be January 1 to December 31. 00:14:23.360 |
So you don't have to be gone from the United States from January 1 to December 31 00:14:28.460 |
in order to claim the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:14:31.660 |
You simply have to qualify for it during any rolling 365 day period that you choose, 00:14:38.960 |
which means that you could if you wanted to spend January, 00:14:43.360 |
February, March, April, and May in the United States, 00:14:46.960 |
you could leave the United States on June 1 and be gone until June 1 the following year 00:14:52.660 |
and then return to the United States for July, August, September, October, 00:14:58.460 |
and still claim the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:15:02.060 |
Now the way that would work is you claim that 12-month period, 00:15:05.860 |
but then it is prorated to your 12-month tax year. 00:15:10.160 |
So if you under that fact pattern I just described from June to June, 00:15:15.060 |
if you claim the exclusion during that period of time, 00:15:18.060 |
you would say, listen, I would have 50% of my earnings that are subject to tax 00:15:23.360 |
and I would have 50% that are able to claim the foreign earned income exclusion 00:15:29.860 |
So you would have access to say $52,500 of the exclusion. 00:15:36.960 |
Now let's assume for the case of simpler facts that you are outside of the United States all the time. 00:15:47.560 |
So that's automatically you're going to always qualify 00:15:49.660 |
for the foreign earned income exclusion under the days test. 00:15:52.860 |
Now what you've most likely been doing up till now is claiming your year 00:15:57.460 |
to go from January 1 to December 31 just for simple convenience. 00:16:11.560 |
So here's what you can do to create earned income 00:16:23.960 |
You're not representing to the IRS that you were in the United States for a different time period. 00:16:29.760 |
You're just saying I'm claiming a different time period. 00:16:40.660 |
Your daily wages in that situation are $274 if we go based upon seven days a week. 00:16:47.660 |
Now you're trying to generate some money, some earned income to contribute to an IRA, 00:16:53.360 |
but you also want to make sure that you qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:16:56.260 |
Well, you don't come back to the United States, 00:16:57.960 |
but 275 times say 30 days or January is 31, right? 00:17:08.060 |
So what you can simply do is when you fill out your tax return 00:17:12.860 |
and when you fill out the form, what is it, 2555? 00:17:16.060 |
Form 2555 for the foreign earned income exclusion on section, let me find it here, 00:17:22.760 |
section, sorry, very unprofessional, very unprofessional. 00:17:35.060 |
Section part three, taxpayers qualifying under the physical presence test. 00:17:39.560 |
Line 16 of part three says the physical presence test is based on the 12-month period 00:17:47.460 |
So when you are filling out form 2555, you simply write on that paper, 00:17:52.960 |
the physical presence test is based on the 12-month period from February 1, 00:18:02.360 |
Then you go on and you explain that you haven't traveled in the United States, 00:18:07.160 |
you were physically present in a foreign country 00:18:12.260 |
But because you wrote on that line February 1 to February 1, 00:18:16.060 |
you automatically still now have 31 days that are not subject to the foreign earned income exclusion, 00:18:22.060 |
which means that your income is going to be prorated 00:18:25.860 |
and you will pick up $8,494 of income from that 31-day period. 00:18:32.560 |
Thus, that $8,494 of income will flow through your tax return 00:18:38.760 |
and it's available for you to make an IRA contribution. 00:18:46.160 |
So if you want to create earned income, just claim a different set of dates on form 2555 00:18:56.860 |
And then when you do the following year's tax return, 00:18:59.060 |
you can claim February 1, 2019 to February 1, 2020. 00:19:03.060 |
All that you're claiming is the days that you're going to subject to that physical presence test. 00:19:07.660 |
And so you have now created 31 days that you're not going to claim the income for. 00:19:13.360 |
So that's up to you. Now, I would just say you're going to need to play with these numbers 00:19:17.560 |
because this is very much one of those things where you'll jigger the numbers as you're doing your tax return. 00:19:23.760 |
Although you could if you are very comfortable with this foreign earned income exclusion 00:19:27.660 |
and if you're trying to spend time in the United States or whatever, 00:19:30.360 |
you could just go ahead and spend the time there and change your dates every year. 00:19:35.960 |
Sorry, but we're just jiggering the numbers. The facts are what they are, 00:19:39.160 |
but you're jiggering the numbers here to see what's going to help you the best. 00:19:42.660 |
So I hope that helps you to be able to claim that 00:19:44.860 |
so that you can make an IRA contribution if you want to. 00:19:50.460 |
I don't see any reason for you to participate in a traditional IRA under this particular plan. 00:19:55.660 |
What's the point of deferring taxes to a later date when you can just go ahead 00:20:01.460 |
and pay zero taxes if you're not already maximizing your foreign earned income exclusion amount? 00:20:06.760 |
I can see why you would participate in a Roth IRA. 00:20:13.360 |
But just you judge appropriately. Now with regard to your other questions, 00:20:19.360 |
let me just hit those very quickly and not give you detailed answers, 00:20:22.460 |
but just hit you with a couple of quick questions. 00:20:26.260 |
First, talking about retirement investment options while abroad. 00:20:28.960 |
Of course, there are many options and just because you are abroad doesn't mean 00:20:32.960 |
that you can't participate in retirement plans in the United States. 00:20:38.060 |
And again, this is where in some ways we could argue that the US system is an advantage versus a Canadian system. 00:20:43.560 |
If you were Canadian, you need to leave and you're not going to participate in things back in Canada. 00:20:46.960 |
But for the United States, since your only way to ultimately leave is to formally renounce citizenship, 00:20:52.660 |
assuming you're not going to do that, you can still participate in everything in the United States. 00:20:57.260 |
You can have your entire financial infrastructure in the United States 00:21:00.660 |
because the only thing you're going to get by living abroad, 00:21:03.660 |
other than perhaps lower cost of living or better lifestyle or personal happiness, 00:21:09.760 |
the only financial benefit you're going to get is going to be foreign earned income exclusion, 00:21:13.960 |
foreign housing deduction, and the foreign tax credit. 00:21:18.460 |
And we'll talk in a moment about avoiding employment taxes. 00:21:21.160 |
But you can still participate in things in the United States. 00:21:24.260 |
So depending on your family setup and depending on the family situation and all of that, 00:21:29.260 |
you can still contribute to other retirement accounts. 00:21:34.660 |
There's lots of stuff that you can do and to go beyond that, 00:21:37.060 |
you would have to look at how you're actually running your business. 00:21:40.060 |
Now, would life insurance be an additional option? 00:21:41.860 |
Sure, it would be, but that's not going to matter whether where you are. 00:21:45.660 |
You can have the same life insurance investment options in the United States versus outside the United States. 00:21:51.260 |
The only thing wrinkle you will get into is when you go to take out a life insurance policy, 00:21:55.160 |
you'll have to work with a company that wants to work with somebody 00:21:57.860 |
who's not a physically present in the United States. 00:22:01.260 |
But you can be a US citizen and you can work with an offshore life insurance, 00:22:08.060 |
You can do that. You just set up a trust and have the LLC on the life insurance policy. 00:22:12.560 |
You can do all kinds of stuff. You can have a captive insurance company if you want to. 00:22:17.360 |
You can do all the fancy, fun, sexy stuff that's in the world of life insurance planning. 00:22:21.460 |
Or you can do everything in the United States, but that's immaterial. 00:22:24.160 |
It doesn't make any change based upon where you are in that situation. 00:22:28.760 |
Now you ask, would setting up a USA-based LLC or some sort of entity be helpful? 00:22:33.560 |
Most likely, yes, for the ease of doing your business. 00:22:38.160 |
But yet, depending on how you do this, more importantly, 00:22:41.960 |
what you probably want to do is set up an offshore company. 00:22:45.260 |
And you should be working and running your business, especially if it's a business. 00:22:49.060 |
A little different if you are doing services. 00:22:52.460 |
But if you're actually running an actual business, 00:22:54.860 |
you definitely want to set up an offshore company 00:22:56.660 |
and you want to structure it so that you are the employee of the offshore company. 00:22:59.960 |
Because that would allow you, and I'm gaining the idea that you're an entrepreneur of some kind 00:23:04.360 |
or working for yourself in some way, because that allows you to avoid the employment taxes. 00:23:09.160 |
And those employment taxes are your heaviest hit on your first $100,000 of income. 00:23:13.960 |
So with taxes, remember that there are two systems and they work differently. 00:23:18.160 |
You have federal income taxes, which are progressive, where they start off with $0. 00:23:23.760 |
And then the more and more money you make, the more you go up the tax bracket. 00:23:27.260 |
But I don't think that federal income taxes are that massive 00:23:32.560 |
when compared at $100,000 of income or $50,000 of income, 00:23:36.860 |
when compared to what they are at $500,000 of income or a million dollars of income. 00:23:41.260 |
I mean, depending on your family situation, all that, 00:23:43.360 |
you've got $100,000, you've got probably under $10,000 of federal income tax. 00:23:50.960 |
It goes a long way. We can supercharge your results. 00:23:54.060 |
But it may be less, depending on your deductions, etc. 00:23:56.960 |
Probably $7,000, $8,000, it just depends on your situation. 00:24:00.860 |
So that's very different than if you were earning a million dollars and paying, 00:24:04.260 |
you know, some taxpayers might be paying in excess of 50% on the top half million, 00:24:12.160 |
So your income taxes at $100,000 are not the bigger deal. 00:24:18.860 |
which is for self-employment, if you're paying both sides, $15,300 per year. 00:24:24.060 |
That's really tough. But the employment tax wage scale tops out around $120,000. 00:24:33.360 |
So below $120,000 is 15.3%, then it drops down to a couple percent. 00:24:39.560 |
Your big savings from being abroad will come from your getting a chance to work for an offshore company. 00:24:48.360 |
Because if you continue to work for a US company, 00:24:51.560 |
then you're going to continue to have to pay your US taxes. 00:24:54.860 |
For example, let's say that you're working for, you know, Big Corp USA, 00:24:59.160 |
but you happen to work remotely for Big Corp USA. 00:25:01.760 |
When I was out traveling around the United States, 00:25:02.960 |
I met a bunch of people who were working remotely for Big Corp USA. 00:25:06.860 |
So one guy's a technical service guy or whatever, you're an accountant, doesn't matter. 00:25:10.760 |
Well, if you just simply move from, say, Texas to Mexico, and you live in, 00:25:16.360 |
that's bad, because Mexican, you might subject yourself to Mexican taxes. 00:25:20.060 |
Let's say you move from Florida to the Bahamas, and you make that move, 00:25:25.060 |
you still have an internet connection, you can still work for Big Corp USA. 00:25:28.860 |
You will still have, your employer will still save 7.6%, take 7.65% as the employer contribution, 00:25:35.360 |
send that off, and then you'll have 7.65% of your pay deducted. 00:25:38.960 |
So you'll still be paying employment taxes in that situation, 00:25:41.860 |
but you won't be paying federal income taxes on the first $105,000 00:25:45.960 |
if you qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion. 00:25:49.060 |
But, if you, so you can travel the world, you can still work for Big Corp USA. 00:25:53.360 |
Now that's exactly the same if you continue to work for, you know, your own LLC. 00:25:57.760 |
If I start Joshua's LLC, and I work for Joshua's LLC in the United States, 00:26:02.360 |
then I'm going to still continue to pay my self-employment taxes, if that was what it was. 00:26:09.560 |
Or if I'm paying C Corp, or sorry, S Corp, if I've got an S Corp, 00:26:13.060 |
and I still work for that S Corp, then I'm going to pay employment taxes on my income. 00:26:18.960 |
But if I will simply start an offshore company, and I work for the offshore company, 00:26:24.160 |
and here you can do it where you have a US-based LLC that passes through to an offshore company, 00:26:29.460 |
so you can run your business from the US LLC, 00:26:31.760 |
but just simply the ownership is with the offshore company, 00:26:34.360 |
and the US LLC is disregarded for tax purposes. 00:26:39.360 |
then you are no longer subject to employment taxes or self-employment taxes 00:26:49.760 |
and if you work for a foreign company, you don't have to pay the $15,300. 00:26:54.760 |
And so in my example that I did when I talked about saving a lot of money moving outside of the United States, 00:27:02.660 |
that was how we got to $25,000 or maybe $30,000 of tax savings. 00:27:07.960 |
It was by combining federal income taxes and employment taxes. 00:27:12.460 |
So if you've got $100,000 income, instead of losing $25,000 to, again, employment taxes and federal income taxes, 00:27:21.060 |
then you can keep the—and only getting $75,000 after tax, 00:27:24.760 |
you can keep the full $100,000 if you will set it up with an offshore company. 00:27:28.860 |
So absolutely, yes, a USA-based LLC can be helpful. 00:27:34.060 |
It's probably easier for you to run things through that than through your foreign company, 00:27:37.660 |
but you need to have a foreign company at the top of the structure in order to save on those employment taxes. 00:27:42.460 |
Now, of course, remember—I guess it's probably obvious— 00:27:44.860 |
remember, you're not going to be getting Social Security credits if you're not paying Social Security taxes. 00:27:49.460 |
So you need to think about that. Maybe a problem for you. 00:27:52.860 |
It's certainly not a problem for me. I'm happy about it, but you should consider that 00:27:57.360 |
because you won't have much of a Social Security—you won't have any Social Security credits, 00:28:07.160 |
My opinion, take the $25,000 and run and invest that money like crazy. 00:28:11.560 |
I don't care whether you invest it in a retirement account or not. 00:28:14.860 |
Invest it like crazy, and then you'll have millions, potentially, 00:28:19.360 |
which instead of a measly couple thousand dollar check. 00:28:22.260 |
All right, next question. Whew, that took longer. Hope I didn't destroy you on a Friday. 00:28:26.160 |
Okay, that was technical question one. This is still a technical question, but less technical. 00:28:29.960 |
So if you got with me, less technical. Let's go. 00:28:34.460 |
Listener writes in and says, "Joshua, here's something I've been pondering for a while, 00:28:37.360 |
and I'd love to know your take on it. A lot of FIRE advice"— 00:28:40.460 |
FIRE, of course, for the uninitiated financial independence, retire early movement— 00:28:44.960 |
"A lot of FIRE advice is centered around 'your worst case scenario is everyone else's everyday scenario' premise, 00:28:51.160 |
meaning you can always come back to a job, at least some job. 00:28:54.960 |
While this is correct for many, it is totally misleading for most high-income earners or career professionals. 00:29:01.560 |
In my particular case, walking out from a high-paying job means starting almost all over again 00:29:07.660 |
if I want to get back into the industry. You jump off the ladder. 00:29:11.360 |
What framework would you use in a situation where making the wrong move 00:29:15.460 |
has very significant financial cost and is truly life-altering? 00:29:20.260 |
For a lot of people, getting to FIRE, getting to financial independence, is an easy part. 00:29:24.760 |
Pulling the trigger is the real challenge, as it is irreversible." 00:29:29.760 |
I think that's an excellent question, and I do think you are right to point out that there are problems, 00:29:36.260 |
especially if you are just a job wage earner, a corporate person, etc. 00:29:42.860 |
When you leave a job or a career, you will very quickly start to see your skills atrophy, 00:29:49.960 |
your connections will start to grow cold, unless you are very diligent about maintaining those skills, 00:29:55.860 |
maintaining those connections, maintaining that sense of connectedness. 00:29:59.160 |
And frankly, if you are going out to be financially independent, it will probably be hard for you to do that, 00:30:03.560 |
because you probably won't care as much as you once did about going to all the industry things 00:30:08.660 |
that you have been to for 15 years and you are just tired of the rubber chicken dinners and all that stuff. 00:30:14.260 |
Since I left the financial business professionally, my skills have atrophied. 00:30:17.760 |
I am not as good with a spreadsheet as I once was. I am not as good with a financial calculator as I once was. 00:30:23.460 |
I have lost many of my industry contacts. I am not as current on all the products in the industry. 00:30:29.660 |
I used to be I could tell you about all the products because I read the prospectuses. 00:30:33.460 |
All that stuff is gone. I don't do that anymore. 00:30:35.460 |
And so my skills have grown cold, and the same that all of us. 00:30:39.460 |
Now, I have built up other skills to compensate, and I think that that's what really most of us should do, 00:30:45.160 |
is build up other skills to compensate, but your skills will grow cold, 00:30:49.260 |
and you certainly won't be able to come back in at that same level that you once were. 00:30:56.060 |
It is a significant factor. You won't be able to pick up where you left off immediately. You just won't. 00:31:03.460 |
Now, I would point out, however, a few things here, and I'll give you my framework. 00:31:07.760 |
First, some comments on is this really a problem. 00:31:11.560 |
I don't think this is really a problem if you are truly financially independent. 00:31:15.560 |
I'm going to assume here for the sake of answering this question that we're defining that term using the 3% rule metric. 00:31:23.260 |
The idea being that you have a large enough portfolio that you can live on, say, 3% of the net worth of the portfolio balance. 00:31:31.960 |
And I think here, we need to make sure that we're dealing with some serious numbers. 00:31:36.160 |
So we're not doing some kind of silly thing where I'm 22 years old, and I have $130,000 in the bank, 00:31:41.160 |
and I'm going to consider myself five because I can live on $4,000 a year, and my life is never going to change. 00:31:44.860 |
That's silly. But let's say you've got $2 million in the bank, and you're saying, 00:31:48.960 |
"I could live on $60,000 as a safe withdrawal rate. I've got $2 million. I'm going to be doing well." 00:31:54.960 |
So here's the first thing I want to point out. 00:31:58.760 |
If the 3% rule doesn't work, we are in uncharted territories, and something is seriously wrong. 00:32:09.760 |
In a scenario where the 3% rule is not sufficient, we're not just in some kind of weird, you know, 00:32:17.860 |
"Hey, there was a temporary correction, a temporary bear market." 00:32:21.360 |
We are in end-of-the-world-as-we-know-it territory. We're in civilizational change. 00:32:27.160 |
If the 3% rule doesn't work, you better have 24-hour security on your homestead. 00:32:37.660 |
The 3% rule is a very, very robust rule of thumb to use, 00:32:44.060 |
and there is a lot riding on everything working as it has worked. 00:32:49.460 |
So just imagine you're in a situation where the market—I'm assuming you're mostly in stock market, 00:32:54.560 |
you're a wage earner, and you're mostly investing in stock market investments, 00:32:58.860 |
paper investments, mainstream mutual funds, etc. 00:33:02.460 |
If the 3% rule doesn't work, there's—again, we're in the end-of-the-world-as-we-know-it stuff. 00:33:09.260 |
We're in massive civilizational unrest. We're in Great Depression, but worse. 00:33:14.460 |
And I just want you to imagine what that would do in our economy, 00:33:17.360 |
what that would do when you look at the disruption from common bear markets, 00:33:22.560 |
and yet all the common bear markets are factored into the 3% rule. 00:33:26.060 |
So I would say if the 3% rule doesn't work, there's no guarantee you would have been able to maintain your job at all, 00:33:31.260 |
because many of us would very—be facing the loss of our jobs. 00:33:35.160 |
Now, you'd still be more employable if you were still working, 00:33:43.060 |
If the 3% rule breaks, it's because things are very, very deeply broken. 00:33:49.460 |
Now, is that possible? Of course it's possible. 00:33:52.960 |
Is it likely? I don't think it's likely, but I think it's possible. 00:33:57.160 |
And so I think you need to plan for that, and the best way I know how to do that 00:34:00.760 |
is with good disaster planning. You think about what would happen 00:34:04.460 |
if we were in an end-of-the-world-as-we-know-it scenario. 00:34:06.660 |
What would happen if we were in 40% unemployment territory? 00:34:10.560 |
And then you think, "How would I survive that?" And it doesn't cost much to be prepared for that. 00:34:14.860 |
It just costs a lot of mental energy to kind of convince yourself that it's worth it. 00:34:19.060 |
And you got to put on your catastrophist hat for a moment and say, 00:34:22.660 |
"All right, I think we're going to collapse. What does collapse look like?" 00:34:28.960 |
I would say an unlikely possibility, but a possibility. 00:34:34.660 |
So recognize that if the 3% rule isn't working, 00:34:38.060 |
there's no guarantee you would have been able to maintain your job at all. 00:34:42.860 |
Second, I would point out that unlike wage earners, 00:34:47.760 |
people who are living on an income portfolio actually do have a lot of warning. 00:34:53.060 |
When there's a wage earner, so the vast majority of people in the United States 00:34:56.960 |
have no money, save no money, work and spend, and it's paycheck to paycheck. 00:35:01.660 |
That's the normal experience for the majority of the people. 00:35:05.360 |
If people have net worth, it's usually tied up in their house, 00:35:08.760 |
and it's only a small percentage of the population that actually has savings and investments. 00:35:13.460 |
You're always going to have that. Seemingly in every society, 00:35:17.460 |
where 20% of the people are going to have 80% of the money. 00:35:20.860 |
But there is a distinct difference between living paycheck to paycheck, 00:35:24.960 |
earning $10,000 a month, spending $10,000 a month, 00:35:31.060 |
or for whatever the number is, $10,000 a month from your retirement portfolio. 00:35:35.260 |
Because if things start to turn south, you have warning. 00:35:38.960 |
If you're meeting with your financial advisor, 00:35:40.760 |
or you're sitting down and crunching the numbers on a quarterly basis, 00:35:43.860 |
you're starting to notice that your distribution rates are ticking up, 00:35:53.960 |
Now, I guess that's not true if you face something where your portfolio goes to zero, 00:36:01.960 |
but I can't conceive of how those circumstances are possible. 00:36:06.360 |
So let's just knock all that stuff out of the way. 00:36:08.660 |
I can't ever see how I could even design the chain of events that could cause that to happen, 00:36:18.660 |
So we're living in the United States of America, or in a much more stable place. 00:36:26.060 |
So if you start to overdraw your portfolio, you have time. 00:36:33.660 |
So you're much, much safer than even the average person is. 00:36:37.760 |
Now, here's the next thing I would point out. 00:36:40.460 |
You don't have to pick up your pre-retirement earnings 00:36:45.760 |
in order for you to be able to maintain your financial independence. 00:36:49.460 |
So let's assume that prior to your early retirement, you're earning $200,000 a year. 00:36:54.960 |
If you're earning less, if you're earning $80,000 or $100,000, 00:37:02.660 |
But if you're up $200,000, $300,000, $400,000, no, you're right. 00:37:05.960 |
You can't just jump into those without having the network. 00:37:14.160 |
No, you might not be able to go and get your $200,000 job back. 00:37:24.660 |
You see why? Because you're drawing from a portfolio. 00:37:27.360 |
You're not, you don't have to go to drawing from zero on a portfolio. 00:37:33.360 |
And here's what's more. If you're actually early retired, 00:37:35.960 |
if you're actually, you know, fi, then you make $200,000. 00:37:41.260 |
You only need $50,000 to live on because you were saving a huge amount of your money before. 00:37:45.260 |
So you don't actually need the job there anyway. 00:37:48.060 |
You just need $50,000. You don't need $200,000. You need $50,000. 00:37:54.060 |
Here's what's more. When you are actually financially independent, 00:38:05.260 |
that you can make choices with what to do with that. 00:38:10.860 |
Well, you've got tons of money that you can spend on creating more income. 00:38:15.060 |
So maybe you pursue a different investment strategy. 00:38:17.760 |
So you say, well, I can't go get my $200,000 job yet back. 00:38:21.760 |
Yeah, maybe that's true, but you still got a million dollars. 00:38:26.660 |
I can manufacture a $200,000 job in dozens of businesses. 00:38:31.060 |
I may not be able to manufacture $200,000 of investment, 00:38:35.160 |
of passive investment returns from a million dollar portfolio, 00:38:38.760 |
but give me a million dollars and I can… come on. 00:38:42.960 |
If you're willing to work and you're willing to take a job, you can do it. 00:38:46.760 |
Now my nervousness would be if you're used to being a corporate employer, 00:38:50.360 |
employee, and you don't know how to create a $200,000 job for yourself 00:38:54.160 |
when starting with a million dollars of capital. 00:38:56.060 |
So that might be something that might be hard for somebody 00:38:59.860 |
But you go to the average businessman who's earning a good income 00:39:04.460 |
and say, could you create this income if you had a million dollars to start with? 00:39:11.260 |
because most businessmen that start to make a $200,000 income started with nothing. 00:39:15.960 |
Now you give them a million dollars to start with, 00:39:20.860 |
Now notice I'm saying you create for yourself a $200,000 job. 00:39:25.260 |
I didn't say, again, passive investment returns. 00:39:27.860 |
But if you're willing to work, and by definition, that's what we're talking about. 00:39:32.160 |
You're saying I was working, then I retired, but now I've got to go back. 00:39:35.660 |
If you're willing to work, once you have capital, 00:39:38.260 |
you can print money all over the place as long as you're willing to work in it. 00:39:43.260 |
It might be harder to do with retirement, but you can do it with work. 00:39:47.660 |
You start a McDonald's, you open a gas station, 00:39:50.460 |
you buy an apartment building and manage it yourself. 00:39:53.260 |
I mean, the ideas are endless. They're endless. 00:39:58.560 |
So when you have that capital, you've got huge options available to you. 00:40:02.960 |
So those are kind of just some common sense answers to your question. 00:40:07.760 |
Again, by review, if 3% doesn't work, frankly, there's no choice. 00:40:13.360 |
You wouldn't necessarily have been able to have a job in any place. 00:40:18.260 |
You will have lots of warning, or at least some warning, 00:40:20.660 |
more than the average person is who loses their job. 00:40:23.560 |
And then all the other, you know, you won't need to pick up where you left off. 00:40:26.360 |
You don't need $200,000, you need $50,000 to get you through 00:40:28.560 |
until the markets come back or until you figure out a new plan. 00:40:33.560 |
and you can just deploy that capital more efficiently. 00:40:36.160 |
You might very well be totally happy putting your money in an index fund, 00:40:39.960 |
spending a little bit of it while you're traveling the world, 00:40:41.960 |
but when you start to run out of money, you come back and say, 00:40:45.160 |
Well, you can absolutely make more money than putting it in an index fund. 00:40:48.760 |
You're just going to have to put in more work. 00:40:50.160 |
So maybe you take on a more active approach to your investing. 00:40:52.860 |
Maybe you take on a more active approach to business management in some way. 00:40:56.160 |
But a more active approach will raise your rates of return 00:41:01.860 |
And then now you can fix your portfolio problem. 00:41:04.560 |
So I don't think it's a huge factor, a huge problem. 00:41:17.360 |
I really do. I think that it is bad to plan, to sit around and do nothing. 00:41:21.860 |
And I think it's bad to plan to just engage in— 00:41:31.460 |
I don't want to use the word "hedonistic" things, 00:41:35.660 |
Playing all the time is not a good way to live. 00:41:45.460 |
there are probably ways that you can do better. 00:41:48.360 |
You know, the guy who says, "I'm going to retire," 00:41:52.560 |
the dude gets cancer and he gets old and he dies, 00:41:59.960 |
So that's bad, but we're not talking about that. 00:42:02.860 |
But let's say you just say, "I'm just going to quit and play all the time." 00:42:14.460 |
And so why should you work and not make money? 00:42:17.660 |
It's the thing that I don't get about the whole FIRE movement. 00:42:21.460 |
because when I've been in jobs that weren't well-suited for me, 00:42:25.960 |
and I was like, "Man, I can't wait to get off of this." 00:42:31.860 |
Take three months, and about the end of three months, 00:42:35.260 |
At the end of a year, certainly, you don't want to sit on a beach anymore. 00:42:38.260 |
And so I think the key thing is not to go from work, 00:42:45.960 |
but to go from your big corporate job to your next job, 00:42:50.860 |
your next thing that you're going to dedicate yourself to. 00:43:04.660 |
I've never lived exclusively on earnings from my investment portfolio. 00:43:10.360 |
But I don't see very many examples of anybody who has done it, 00:43:15.860 |
and I don't see many examples of people who've done it and enjoyed it. 00:43:19.460 |
I think there might be a few people who do it, 00:43:28.360 |
But they're a very small percentage of people. 00:43:33.660 |
If that's you, then I think you should know it. 00:43:35.860 |
But the vast majority of people seem much better served to me by working, 00:43:44.260 |
because one of your most valuable contributions to society is the work that you do. 00:43:57.560 |
your rest, your relaxation far more if you can do it out of income. 00:44:21.260 |
Do whatever for a year, or however long you think is right. 00:44:24.860 |
But at the end of the year, you better have another thing to put your hand to. 00:44:28.260 |
And now you may put your hand to it with a different attitude. 00:44:31.260 |
You may not put 80 hours a week into the corporate grind. 00:44:36.560 |
You may work it into your life in a little bit better way. 00:44:41.060 |
Stay working, and then just spend out of that income, and set yourself goals. 00:44:44.760 |
And then when you multiply your income throughout your lifetime, 00:44:47.860 |
you don't get into this selfish perspective of just saying, 00:44:50.760 |
"Well, I'm just going to keep all the money for me, and it's got to just last it for me." 00:44:53.460 |
You maintain this sense of abundance, where you know there's so much money. 00:45:06.660 |
I don't ever want to be in a position where my income is going down. 00:45:09.960 |
You want your income to go up, and to have the confidence that it's going to go up more and more and more. 00:45:13.960 |
And I don't see any reason why that can't be fun and rewarding, 00:45:17.860 |
especially if you have time to do it right, etc. 00:45:26.760 |
but I still don't think you should plan on that, for the reasons stated. 00:45:32.060 |
I don't see really many examples of anybody who just does well by stopping and quitting. 00:45:38.160 |
So if you want to leave your corporate job, great. 00:45:40.460 |
But you don't need $2 million to leave your corporate job. 00:45:44.060 |
If you're earning $200, and you're living on $50, 00:45:47.060 |
you don't have to have a million-dollar portfolio to go and do something else. 00:45:53.460 |
and go take a $50,000-a-year job that you think will give you a better lifestyle. 00:45:58.960 |
That's basically, every time I go through fire, I come to this thing. 00:46:08.460 |
that work is good for the soul, that work is meaningful, 00:46:12.360 |
it's a meaningful part of your contribution in life, 00:46:16.660 |
and you recognize that the problem is usually that someone's doing work that's not well-suited to them, 00:46:21.560 |
where they don't feel competent or effective, 00:46:23.460 |
or they're in a bad environment that's something where they're not appreciated, 00:46:29.160 |
and/or if their work life is just not healthy, 00:46:34.260 |
100 hours a week, you know, massive pressure and stress. 00:46:37.160 |
If you just realize that those things can be changed, 00:46:39.460 |
you can find work that's well-suited for you, 00:46:41.860 |
and you can move into work that is in a very comfortable work life, 00:46:50.360 |
10,000 bucks will do it. 100,000 bucks will do it. 00:46:58.960 |
Escape the ordinary with Fiji Airways Global Beat the Rush Sale. 00:47:08.060 |
Fiji Airways has flights to Nadi starting at just $748 for light, 00:47:15.160 |
Discover your tropical dreams at FijiAirways.com. 00:47:20.660 |
From here to happy. Flying direct with Fiji Airways.