back to indexRPF0639-Friday_QA
00:00:00.000 |
- Big Boyz Comedy Kings is coming to Yamaha Resort and Casino 00:00:05.840 |
- That sweater so tight, it look like a snap between the legs. 00:00:09.540 |
- Once we stop running, I'll find out what it was we was running about. 00:00:15.980 |
They could be missing a leg, they still want to get into a fight. 00:00:18.480 |
- Hosted by my man Eric Blake and a special performance by Mario. 00:00:21.880 |
Big Boyz Comedy Kings, December 9th at Yamaha Resort and Casino. 00:00:30.900 |
- Today on Radical Personal Finance, it's live Q&A. 00:00:36.600 |
Welcome to Radical Personal Finance, a show dedicated to providing you with the 00:00:52.120 |
knowledge, skills, insight, and encouragement you need to live a rich 00:00:55.280 |
and meaningful life now while building a plan for financial freedom in 10 years 00:01:05.680 |
But I'm glad to have an open phone line today. 00:01:07.360 |
And so far, we've got one caller on the line. 00:01:15.200 |
Any Friday that I can arrange an internet connection and a quiet place to record 00:01:25.080 |
and all of the appropriate technical details, I open up the phone lines to do a 00:01:29.800 |
These shows are open to patrons of the show, people who sign up to support the 00:01:34.760 |
You can do that at patreon.com/radicalpersonalfinance. 00:01:38.720 |
That gives you access to the shows and you can call in and talk about anything you 00:01:43.920 |
Sometimes they're wide open, sometimes they're very full, but today they're wide 00:01:55.520 |
My question was about...it was kind of hoping to have you elaborate on a previous 00:02:05.920 |
And it was basically you were talking about the state of the United States and I 00:02:17.760 |
But anyway, I've been thinking about some of your suggestions as far as preparing for, 00:02:23.680 |
you know, a financial crisis and talking over with my wife. 00:02:27.720 |
And she actually thought of this question and it was about how you or what type of 00:02:34.480 |
solution you would use for medical insurance. 00:02:42.320 |
Not that I'm necessarily considering moving or, you know, doing, you know, 00:02:47.960 |
three months in, you know, one country and three months in another. 00:02:52.160 |
You know, whatever situation you find yourself in today, it's probably not going 00:02:56.680 |
But one of the issues that we thought about was, you know, we have great medical 00:03:01.640 |
And, you know, being able to find a good doctor in another country, 00:03:09.280 |
You know, I don't know anything about the health share ministries. 00:03:12.560 |
And so I thought maybe you could elaborate on that and the solution that you came up 00:03:19.840 |
Do you and/or any of your family members have any significant ongoing health 00:03:26.400 |
conditions, any major chronic diseases or acute illnesses that you're facing? 00:03:43.160 |
Nothing that we're concerned about right now. 00:03:46.040 |
I have some back issues that I've had for a while, but I don't intend to have surgery. 00:03:51.040 |
But it's in the back of my mind that someday that could be the case. 00:03:55.040 |
But no, to answer your question, there's no cancer, you know, heart issues, 00:04:02.160 |
- So the reason I want to begin with that question is because most of the time, 00:04:07.160 |
people who ask a question related to health insurance, especially on a show like mine, 00:04:12.840 |
are simply very thoughtful, careful people who like to be prepared for all situations. 00:04:23.760 |
But what I have observed over the years is, I don't know why, but there just seems to be 00:04:28.840 |
this almost obsession with being protected from any kind of medical issue that could 00:04:34.560 |
happen, and I have observed that sometimes it keeps people from doing things that could 00:04:41.360 |
For example, I have a friend of mine who, in his case, he does have significant medical 00:04:46.080 |
issues, but he has worked for 15 years at a job that he doesn't like, that he isn't well 00:04:51.400 |
suited for, and he works there exclusively for the medical insurance because it's a good 00:04:56.600 |
Meanwhile, he's miserable and he's going to die because he has no quality of life. 00:05:01.080 |
And I'm convinced, not being a medical professional, I'm convinced that if he would just simply 00:05:07.600 |
quit his job and pursue an alternative path, that he could improve his health so much that 00:05:15.000 |
he wouldn't need his extremely expensive ongoing health care stuff that he has. 00:05:21.760 |
Now, he isn't interested, and so he doesn't do it, and I think all of us should be free 00:05:28.520 |
But I've just observed so many people make life decisions that really don't make much 00:05:33.020 |
sense all around this idea of having medical coverage. 00:05:37.200 |
And I've especially observed this among healthy people, healthy young people who have an idea 00:05:41.600 |
for something they want to do, for that job they'd like to change, or a business they'd 00:05:46.120 |
like to start, and they can't figure out, "How do I afford the health insurance?" 00:05:49.800 |
And I have to concede, although I will never be advocating for governmental solutions, 00:05:56.720 |
I have to concede that one of the arguments that really I think is compelling in favor 00:06:01.480 |
of the government-provided health care options is simply that it can free people up from 00:06:08.120 |
worrying about chasing their, from worrying about trying to do something so that they 00:06:15.080 |
So statistically, if you are young and healthy, and statistically if you're in good shape 00:06:20.800 |
and you don't have any ongoing major health issues, you're probably not going to need 00:06:26.840 |
I mean, it's probably not, you're probably not going to have major health expenses. 00:06:32.200 |
Now that would be different if you were 75 years old and you had a whole bunch of risk 00:06:36.080 |
factors, but most young families don't have a lot of health expenses. 00:06:40.440 |
So that's a little wordy, but I want to put things into perspective that chances are you're 00:06:45.520 |
probably going to be fine even if you didn't have any kind of health coverage. 00:06:50.520 |
And even if you didn't have any health insurance, you didn't have a plan, you didn't have anything 00:06:57.920 |
Legally speaking, in today's world, in the United States, you're still going to be especially 00:07:01.760 |
fine because now that there's no pre-existing condition clauses for any official health 00:07:07.760 |
insurance policies, as long as you can make it to an open enrollment period, no matter 00:07:11.840 |
what happens with your health, you can always sign up. 00:07:14.760 |
And if you have a fullness of understanding of the law, of everything that I talk about 00:07:19.000 |
in this show, then going without health insurance is not that big of a risk. 00:07:23.600 |
Now, being a cautious person, being the kind of person who always wants to pay my bills, 00:07:30.760 |
being that kind of person and wanting to give that good kind of advice, I'm not advising 00:07:34.040 |
to just say, "Throw caution to the wind and dump the health insurance." 00:07:39.040 |
But I am trying to get people to think about it because for whatever reason, I've heard 00:07:43.760 |
so many people that live in fear of losing health insurance and it doesn't seem that 00:07:49.560 |
At least if somebody doesn't have an ongoing condition or some other major risk factor 00:07:57.280 |
Now, secondly, I would point out in what you're alluding to of a discussion around the subject 00:08:04.200 |
of having an economic crisis, I'm not advising people to leave the United States and go elsewhere 00:08:13.920 |
I can tell you how to do it if you want to do it. 00:08:15.840 |
It's what I've done, it's what I think is a good idea for many people, but that's not 00:08:22.000 |
My major focus in what I've talked about in the past is to be prepared to survive an economic 00:08:27.960 |
crisis and there could be many reasons why somebody would face an economic crisis. 00:08:35.360 |
Many people face personal economic crises because they get sick, they get hurt and they 00:08:42.600 |
So, I want you to be prepared for that and one way to be prepared for that is to have 00:08:45.960 |
good health insurance, which is why in the course that I have called How to Survive and 00:08:50.840 |
Thrive During the Coming Economic Crisis, we talk a lot about that and it's not all 00:08:55.440 |
It's not all about running away and going somewhere else. 00:08:58.160 |
So maintaining good coverage is important, but it's also important to have backup plans 00:09:04.560 |
The most likely economic crisis that many people are going to face is simply the loss 00:09:09.680 |
Economic goes up where you live, you lose your job, your industry goes into a slump, 00:09:13.760 |
your region goes into a slump, etc. and you've got to pick up and move somewhere else. 00:09:18.840 |
And so, if you face something like that, you're going to be facing it no matter whether you 00:09:23.000 |
go to the next state over, the next town over or the next country over. 00:09:27.200 |
So these are normal common problems and there are solutions to them along the way. 00:09:31.960 |
I would not recommend somebody that you just leave a disaster zone, you leave where you 00:09:38.760 |
So if you actually are facing a crisis, it's going to be apparent. 00:09:42.640 |
And one of the crises that many people are going to be facing is the loss of healthcare 00:09:51.840 |
That is a basic component of what I talked about in the shows that I did on the debt 00:09:59.240 |
The fact that no one wants to talk about the debt crisis. 00:10:03.960 |
There are three big entitlement programs that the United States government runs. 00:10:08.360 |
They are Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. 00:10:12.120 |
Social Security is currently the one that is making the news. 00:10:15.240 |
Various articles in the past months about the future insolvency of Social Security. 00:10:20.640 |
But Social Security is the most solvent of those three big entitlement programs and Social 00:10:28.880 |
Meaning that what they will do, in my opinion, this is not a guarantee, this is just my guess 00:10:33.840 |
on what they will do, is they will institute a number of different changes to try to bring 00:10:38.480 |
Social Security back towards actuarial solvency. 00:10:42.320 |
They will raise the retirement age, they'll do means testing if you have over a certain 00:10:46.760 |
amount of money you can't get it, they'll change the benefit structures. 00:10:52.560 |
What's not easily solved is Medicare and Medicaid. 00:10:56.280 |
Medicaid is kind of a different animal, let's just focus on Medicare. 00:10:59.160 |
The basic problem of Medicare is that retirees are given massive health benefits that are 00:11:06.640 |
not paid for by the retiree and there aren't enough current tax revenues to provide the 00:11:12.640 |
So you have people living extremely long lives but yet paying massive amounts of medical 00:11:20.240 |
And that can't continue, it can't be sustained. 00:11:23.560 |
And so even people who have a government paid system like Medicare, they're going to, in 00:11:29.240 |
my opinion, face the problem of decreasing coverage. 00:11:35.040 |
Maybe it looks like more stringent scrutiny of bills, maybe it looks like fewer things 00:11:40.160 |
covered, maybe it looks like just decrepit government run hospitals is the only place 00:11:45.340 |
you can get care and nobody goes to them because they don't function. 00:11:50.920 |
But the crisis could be caused by lack of health care. 00:11:54.240 |
Now that's a little far afield from your question. 00:11:57.280 |
So I'd bring it back and say today, the cool thing is in today's world there are enough 00:12:02.680 |
tools that nobody's life decisions should be frozen because of lack of access to health 00:12:13.200 |
I just, I can't comprehend why anybody should have their life choices frozen due to lack 00:12:21.600 |
There are so many different ways that we can exploit the system that we can figure out 00:12:25.560 |
a plan for you and me as individuals to do well. 00:12:28.640 |
Even if you were chronically sick, we could work on a plan to allow you to do almost anything 00:12:34.480 |
you need to do even if you're chronically sick by exploiting some of the things that 00:12:40.400 |
But for just an average person, there are really neat options available. 00:12:45.340 |
So first, since some of the liberalization that has happened in the last year or two, 00:12:50.760 |
once again you can purchase high deductible health plans that have very high deductibles. 00:13:02.940 |
So to back up for a little bit, prior to the passage of the Affordable Care Act, the health 00:13:07.240 |
insurance industry could offer different types of medical insurance plans. 00:13:12.200 |
You could purchase Cadillac policies and you could purchase stripped out lien policies. 00:13:16.540 |
For people who are healthy, what I always like people to do was just to get a high deductible 00:13:21.360 |
health plan that had a very high deductible but had a large coverage limit but that would 00:13:26.520 |
So a few hundred dollars a month, you would get something that had an unlimited or a million 00:13:31.040 |
dollar cap on the total benefits that the policy could get. 00:13:34.440 |
But then you had a 10,000 or sometimes hopefully you could get a 20 or 30,000 or higher deductible 00:13:42.460 |
That covers you from the really catastrophic risk of a catastrophic health condition. 00:13:47.200 |
A person who is healthy and who is financially prudent should be able to, in an emergency, 00:13:52.440 |
pay out of pocket 10 or 15 or 20,000 dollars for health expenses in an emergency. 00:13:57.960 |
What they can't pay out of pocket for usually is a million dollars of health expenses. 00:14:03.440 |
Then when the Affordable Care Act passed, it completely disrupted the individual health 00:14:07.320 |
insurance marketplace with all of the mandates that had to be paid for, all of the care, 00:14:14.600 |
Those policies basically got removed from the marketplace. 00:14:17.880 |
It was when those policies disappeared that I actually got out of the health insurance 00:14:24.360 |
I would sell some individual health insurance and I just got out of the business because 00:14:29.800 |
nobody was happy, the premiums were skyrocketing, etc. 00:14:35.520 |
Now I have not stayed super in touch with the marketplace, but a few months ago I started 00:14:43.400 |
I started talking to health insurance brokers to see if in the wake of some of the liberalizations 00:14:47.540 |
that happened when the Republicans took control of the Congress and President Trump was elected, 00:14:54.320 |
And yes, again, you're starting to see those kinds of policies available. 00:14:58.160 |
So I priced one out to see what they were and it wasn't unreasonable. 00:15:00.600 |
It wasn't as good as it was before, but you can today get a policy from some of the big 00:15:06.880 |
major insurers that gives you basically that catastrophic coverage. 00:15:11.040 |
And I think that's something that a lot of people could find useful. 00:15:13.800 |
Now what it'll be labeled as, I think they call it a short-term health plan. 00:15:17.880 |
It was previously kind of a stopgap plan and they did that to come around some of the rules 00:15:22.080 |
of the ACA and they're still marketing it, I think, as a short-term health plan. 00:15:26.640 |
But with policies like that, most people can afford to keep health insurance in place. 00:15:31.360 |
Now you alluded to the fact that I don't use health insurance myself. 00:15:36.240 |
I use a healthcare sharing ministry and I really, really love the concept of the healthcare 00:15:42.480 |
I really would like to promote them more in the future because I believe that they provide 00:15:46.520 |
a very useful alternative for people to look at. 00:15:53.480 |
I like them from an ideological perspective because first, they rightly align the incentives 00:16:09.680 |
I tell a doctor or someone, I don't have health insurance. 00:16:12.600 |
If I have health needs, I simply pay cash for them and then I take those expenses and 00:16:17.880 |
then some of those expenses may qualify for reimbursement under the terms of my healthcare 00:16:23.960 |
I also really want to support them because they give people the right of choice. 00:16:27.080 |
You get to choose the types of procedures that you're involved in. 00:16:30.280 |
You get to choose the type of people you do business with and that's extremely valuable. 00:16:34.120 |
It's a totally different experience working with a healthcare sharing ministry than any 00:16:45.520 |
This was our second baby that we've had using a healthcare sharing ministry and I actually 00:16:49.840 |
literally at this moment have sitting on my desk a big stack of cards from all the people 00:16:55.520 |
who sent us money for all of the medical expenses. 00:17:04.960 |
I've got this handful of cards here and I wasn't planning this. 00:17:08.120 |
I was just sorting through paperwork here but this is the kind of notes that we got. 00:17:11.800 |
We got Paul and Karen wrote us a note with a card with their check. 00:17:16.720 |
We pray for you that you're doing well and that God's precious gift to you will be such 00:17:24.200 |
Greg and Janet wrote us a note with congratulations saying they were praying for us with the arrival 00:17:29.400 |
One of our fellow healthcare people wrote us a whole long page long letter with all 00:17:35.880 |
kinds of resources that they'd found helpful and parenting tips and some books and things 00:17:40.080 |
that they'd really liked and they wanted to share some of those ideas with us. 00:17:45.840 |
It's so different than our first child I had on a health insurance policy and it was just 00:17:52.160 |
dealing with the billing department all the time. 00:17:58.440 |
One of the nice things about Samaritan Ministries that I use and I assume the other healthcare 00:18:03.840 |
sharing ministries is you can do some things. 00:18:07.000 |
They have a little more leeway sometimes than the health insurance companies seem to do. 00:18:13.800 |
We didn't have the baby in the United States. 00:18:16.320 |
With birth tourism there are various reasons why you can do birth tourism but one of the 00:18:20.200 |
things you can do with birth tourism is you can save massive amounts of money. 00:18:23.720 |
If I didn't have health insurance paying for bills in the United States, I don't know why 00:18:31.200 |
The medical system in the United States is so broken especially around childcare. 00:18:36.720 |
You can go to Mexico and you can have a baby for a hospital birth or even if you had a 00:18:40.840 |
cesarean in Mexico your total fee is under $3,000 versus $15,000 to $30,000 in the United 00:18:48.040 |
Well, under Samaritan Ministries all of my expenses are covered no matter where in the 00:18:57.960 |
There's some details there in terms of they don't cover – you have to work out the cost 00:19:02.760 |
comparisons and things like that but there's a lot more leeway with things like that. 00:19:06.920 |
So I can use Samaritan Ministries, I can submit my bills for reimbursement no matter where 00:19:12.240 |
And then I would finally point to just one more factor. 00:19:15.880 |
Don't forget that when traveling you have access to totally different medical systems. 00:19:25.320 |
Now we can argue as to why we think it's broken but I think most of us would agree that it's 00:19:30.680 |
I guess that the people who wouldn't say it's broken would say, "Well, you can get decent. 00:19:35.260 |
You can get really world-class medical care." 00:19:41.840 |
But in terms of the feasibility of that, the costs are so astronomical and it seems like 00:19:47.480 |
every time a new thing develops, a new opportunity where expenses can be saved, it seems like 00:19:51.900 |
another bureaucrat comes in with more regulation that messes up that part of the market as 00:19:59.560 |
There's a massive booming medical tourism business in Mexico. 00:20:02.560 |
There's a massive medical tourism business in Central America, in Asia. 00:20:08.680 |
You can save so much money by going abroad to have procedures done. 00:20:13.520 |
Now that doesn't work really well if you were just in a car accident and you got to be stitched 00:20:18.520 |
But it does work really well for any kind of elective procedure or any procedure where 00:20:24.180 |
So just because you leave the United States doesn't mean that you can't get good medical 00:20:28.160 |
care and in fact I'm more and more a proponent and an aficionado of people leaving the United 00:20:37.560 |
And if you're paying out of pocket for it or you're using some kind of useful interesting 00:20:41.480 |
arrangement that provides for medical tourism, you can get it cheaper, better, abroad than 00:20:50.560 |
There are doctors everywhere in the world and I think most of us who've traveled reasonably 00:20:54.840 |
extensively would say there are some places where we really don't want to get sick, where 00:21:02.400 |
But in many cases there are many times I think many of us would say if we're going to get 00:21:06.320 |
sick we'd rather get sick outside the United States than inside the United States because 00:21:10.520 |
for every place that's primitive and really really rough there are equally a number and 00:21:15.560 |
perhaps more places that you can get world-class care and not have your finances ruined by 00:21:32.680 |
So that's great and I actually do have a follow-up question if you have time to take it. 00:21:40.480 |
It's related to the Defon that you've talked about before. 00:21:45.560 |
I think we can pretty much all agree that something more than likely it's going to be 00:21:51.400 |
the tax man coming after you and I don't necessarily think it's going to be coming after your paycheck 00:21:55.640 |
but rather your overall wealth and so I think that retirement plans, pensions, everything, 00:22:03.720 |
anything that could be considered your wealth is probably going to be taxed in order to 00:22:07.560 |
pay for all of these liabilities that we can't afford. 00:22:10.720 |
And so my question is about avoiding some of that taxation not necessarily on your income 00:22:18.280 |
because on one of your previous podcasts, you talked about doing tourism or perpetual 00:22:24.760 |
tourism or whatever in countries that won't tax your income or tax your business or whatever 00:22:30.800 |
but what about taxing your assets or what about if you want to do perpetual tourism 00:22:37.200 |
and you just want to live on say a combination of your retirement accounts, your savings 00:22:43.000 |
account and a pension that you formerly had in the United States and then what countries 00:22:49.840 |
would be on the Joshua Proof list to consider for doing something like that? 00:22:56.480 |
Well so I think let me just clarify a couple of things because part of the problem that 00:23:04.120 |
I have is I taught through this stuff systematically in my course but I didn't do it on the show. 00:23:09.360 |
So first, perpetual tourism, the way that I define perpetual tourism is a strategy of 00:23:14.360 |
moving from country to country and not becoming a resident and specifically not becoming a 00:23:27.120 |
Now for some people that seems really exciting. 00:23:32.640 |
You know the phase of life that I'm in for example and that you're in Ryan it sounds 00:23:35.900 |
like when you've got two young children and you've got a third on the way, I would guess 00:23:41.000 |
that your wife is probably not too thrilled about the idea of hey let's pick up and get 00:23:45.680 |
on an airplane every three months and move from country to country. 00:23:50.120 |
Most of the time in our stage of life that's not usually a very conducive idea. 00:23:56.200 |
They go to spend a year with their kids traveling but just in terms of planning on that as a 00:23:59.880 |
long term plan it's usually not very exciting. 00:24:04.000 |
That's different than a lot of times single people they want to go out and live that kind 00:24:07.280 |
of strategy and I've interviewed people on the show who've done it and you can do it. 00:24:12.420 |
How I alluded to that in the context of economic crisis was probably simply to say that if 00:24:17.540 |
your home country is going through a massive global worldwide, sorry not global, countrywide 00:24:26.020 |
Like let's say that you were, Venezuela is a bad example because it's just so dire there 00:24:31.660 |
but let's, I don't know a better one right now so let's just go with that. 00:24:37.340 |
You're from Venezuela and a year and a half ago, two years ago before the government ran 00:24:42.460 |
out of passports, passport paper and stopped issuing passports you got your passports together 00:24:49.860 |
Well as a Venezuelan maybe you don't have easy access for a residency permit in another 00:24:55.100 |
country but if you just spent your time traveling among a group of countries that give you access 00:25:01.460 |
as a Venezuelan with a Venezuelan passport then you could just simply keep moving from 00:25:09.180 |
time to time and stay outside of Venezuela thus avoiding the starvation and the violence 00:25:14.060 |
and all of that while simultaneously being able to stay within the law of other countries 00:25:19.000 |
until you could ultimately get a residency permit in another country. 00:25:22.540 |
So I don't know all the Venezuela passport restrictions but if you put together a little 00:25:26.700 |
tour of Argentina, Paraguay, Uruguay, Brazil and you know that's enough and you just spent 00:25:33.660 |
three months in each of those four countries then you would not violate any visa agreements 00:25:40.100 |
So US Americans could have this as a good backup plan. 00:25:43.140 |
So hey if there's a problem in the United States of America I can get out and I can 00:25:47.540 |
go to Canada, I can go to England, I can go to New Zealand, I'm focusing on English speaking 00:25:54.420 |
countries here and I can just kind of bounce between those using just simply tourist visas. 00:25:59.340 |
So that's what I alluded to with perpetual tourism. 00:26:02.060 |
Now from a tax perspective let's come to taxes. 00:26:05.460 |
One of the advantages that US Americans do have with a US passport is you don't have 00:26:09.860 |
to become a tax resident of a certain country in order to qualify, in order to activate 00:26:18.480 |
the foreign earned income exclusion as we talked about for US taxes. 00:26:24.480 |
So if you're Canadian and you want to leave the Canadian tax system you have to go and 00:26:29.260 |
You can't just bounce around the globe but US Americans don't have to do that. 00:26:32.900 |
Americans are going to simply be out of the country and as long as you're out of the country 00:26:37.080 |
more than 330 days per year you can qualify for the foreign earned income exclusion and 00:26:41.740 |
you can avoid the US income taxation on about your first hundred thousand dollars of foreign 00:26:51.140 |
Now that doesn't solve the wealth problem because you're still going to pay capital 00:26:54.180 |
gains taxes, you'll still pay dividend taxes, etc. and if there are changes in the US tax 00:26:59.940 |
code then you would be subject to those and you cannot avoid those as a US citizen. 00:27:05.360 |
You cannot avoid those simply by changing your residency. 00:27:08.580 |
Even if you moved from Florida to the Bahamas which has no income taxes, which has no wealth 00:27:14.020 |
taxes, which has no inheritance taxes, even if you did that as long as you retain your 00:27:19.380 |
US citizenship you will still be subject to US income taxes, US wealth taxes if new ones 00:27:25.700 |
are instituted, inheritance taxes such as the estate taxes, etc. as a US citizen. 00:27:31.780 |
So your only pathway to avoid wealth taxes is, well let me say, your only legal pathway 00:27:39.140 |
you could always do tax evasion and play the game of they're not knowledgeable about my 00:27:44.540 |
assets that's a risky game but probably doable to some extent. 00:27:48.300 |
But the only legal way to do it is going to be to renounce US citizenship. 00:27:53.140 |
So what I would say is this, I don't think that the fear of going and I don't think that 00:27:59.620 |
the fear right now of moving abroad and the fear that in the future the United States 00:28:08.100 |
will impose wealth taxes and start taking more tax money from your IRA and from your 00:28:12.180 |
Roth IRA, I don't think that the fear of that should be sufficient for you to say well that's 00:28:18.860 |
But I do think the potential of it should have you working on a plan to make sure that 00:28:24.260 |
if you ever did want to renounce US citizenship you have that as an option. 00:28:29.580 |
And I would say that this is the only practical solution that I see for avoiding the taxes 00:28:36.260 |
Because at this point in time what do people say? 00:28:38.580 |
Nobody thinks that you and I are going to pay the bills of the United States, unless 00:28:43.700 |
But most 50 year olds say well it's obvious to us that the United States government is 00:28:48.100 |
deeply in debt, it's obvious to us that we're never going to pay this debt back. 00:28:51.620 |
But we're putting it onto our children and our children's children. 00:28:54.420 |
Well my solution Ryan, if you want your children and your children's children to have a choice 00:29:00.540 |
you've got to set them up so that they can move themselves out of from under the US tax 00:29:05.460 |
system in the future if taxes become onerous into another tax system. 00:29:11.780 |
And there are, if you study the tax systems to your question of jurisdictions, depending 00:29:16.360 |
on the makeup of your wealth there are many jurisdictions that you could choose that would 00:29:23.320 |
In the three part series that I talked about I alluded to choosing different jurisdictions 00:29:30.060 |
If somebody earns, I don't know, a modest amount of money I think they would be well 00:29:34.800 |
served, just a little bit of money, I think that they would be well served by staying 00:29:38.260 |
in the United States because everything is cheaper in the United States generally than 00:29:45.100 |
And so somebody earning $40,000 or $50,000 is going to probably be better off in my opinion 00:29:49.380 |
in the United States than moving to another country. 00:29:52.940 |
Unless they have an affinity for that and they can live cheap in the other country. 00:29:55.660 |
But most people, you can get things so much cheaper in the United States that quality 00:30:00.940 |
So but there's no reason not to move to a no state income tax jurisdiction if you can. 00:30:08.540 |
I said if you're earning, I don't know, a few hundred thousand dollars of taxable income 00:30:14.580 |
then going outside the United States is a really good solution to save you on taxes. 00:30:19.400 |
Then I went one step further with the Puerto Rico taxes and I said going to Puerto Rico 00:30:23.700 |
is not good if you make $100,000 a year but if you make a million dollars a year then 00:30:30.540 |
Now I didn't go on with the series and assume that it's for non-US citizens but if you go 00:30:34.640 |
on one more step and you start to look around the world then you can find other jurisdictions. 00:30:39.740 |
There are jurisdictions that tax income but don't tax capital gains or don't tax dividends. 00:30:44.360 |
So if your income is primarily capital gains income and not earned income you can do very 00:30:55.160 |
Or if your income is largely earned income but not capital gains income then you need 00:30:59.320 |
to go to a destination that doesn't tax earned income. 00:31:07.300 |
I think what you should do and you and your wife should talk about is let's say that our 00:31:11.820 |
children, our two young children and soon to be born third, if our children are in a 00:31:17.360 |
situation where their taxes are doubling and tripling and they're connected to it with 00:31:22.500 |
a country that has a military empire that can follow them to the ends of the earth then 00:31:27.300 |
how do we set them up so that they can move abroad, so that they can move to another citizenship 00:31:32.980 |
and so that they can renounce their US citizenship and eliminate the tax net. 00:31:37.020 |
Now that's not to say that taxes can't change right now. 00:31:41.060 |
If you haven't, there are a few different triggers but the big one is if you have a 00:31:44.500 |
net worth of more than two million dollars the US government will impose exit taxes on 00:31:50.620 |
But at the very least Ryan, go have a baby in Canada or go have a baby in Mexico and 00:31:59.020 |
Your baby has a second citizenship from birth. 00:32:01.820 |
Put your other family on track for a second citizenship. 00:32:06.980 |
Have you ever thought about this or researched this area of line of thinking Ryan? 00:32:10.180 |
Ryan Neuhofel I mean it's entertaining to me to think about 00:32:15.980 |
but honestly I couldn't see my wife signing up for having a baby in another country. 00:32:21.340 |
I mean just with our parents alone they'd probably, who knows. 00:32:28.780 |
It's a great thought experiment but I can't see it happening. 00:32:32.780 |
Well, I think a lot of people are in that situation and I don't do it if she doesn't 00:32:37.900 |
But let me just give you just a couple of thoughts on it. 00:32:44.520 |
People go and have babies all the time in other places and depending on the type of 00:32:50.500 |
birth experience that you and your wife like to have, that can put you in different jurisdictions. 00:32:59.100 |
If you, for example, like to have a hospital birth, hospitals all pretty much look the 00:33:05.460 |
It doesn't look, you know, a hospital in Florida looks about the same as a hospital in Toronto. 00:33:12.420 |
But the only difference is if you have your baby in Toronto, then that baby is a Canadian 00:33:18.620 |
That doesn't do anything for you immigration-wise to Canada for you but it does mean that your 00:33:22.820 |
child can have a Canadian passport or Mexico if you have your baby in Mexico. 00:33:28.780 |
Mexican hospitals, you might need to speak a little Spanish. 00:33:31.460 |
That's different than the Canadian hospital but if you have your baby in a Mexican hospital, 00:33:36.900 |
then your baby will automatically qualify to be a Mexican citizen by birth and you can 00:33:42.700 |
And the advantage of a Mexican, if you have a Mexican baby is if you're the parent of 00:33:46.820 |
a Mexican baby, then you can apply for Mexican residency and be issued a resident permit 00:33:53.300 |
for you and your wife and your other children as well without any other tests necessary 00:33:59.580 |
simply due to their reunification of family theory. 00:34:02.180 |
And there are other countries around the world that you can look at as well. 00:34:04.980 |
Now I will be the first to concede it's not easy. 00:34:07.600 |
So if you're in a town where everyone is there, you know, it's not easy. 00:34:11.940 |
But it is doable and it's something that I think I want to encourage more and more people 00:34:19.220 |
to pursue it and to research it and to think about it because I think it's really, it's 00:34:23.020 |
the only practical solution that I can see is to help your children develop secondary 00:34:28.180 |
citizenships so that if in the future they need to leave a confiscatory tax regime, then 00:34:34.060 |
they have already in place a second citizenship so they can renounce their primary citizenship. 00:34:39.060 |
And it's not anything against the US or any other country, it's just a reality. 00:34:43.820 |
In the United States, most US Americans don't think much about it, but much of the rest 00:34:46.660 |
of the world does because they've seen the value of it. 00:34:49.620 |
But it's really the only solution that I see. 00:34:52.660 |
The most famous big money example of it was Eduardo Saverin, one of the early employees 00:34:58.540 |
He was Brazilian, dual citizen by birth, born in Brazil, became a US citizen and then was 00:35:05.860 |
able to renounce his citizenship from the United States and in his case I think he became 00:35:13.740 |
Now he had to pay a lot of exit taxes on the way out. 00:35:17.100 |
He was taxed very heavily by the United States, but he still saved, I don't know if it was 00:35:21.820 |
tens of millions or hundreds of millions, but he still saved a massive amount of money 00:35:25.340 |
by renouncing his US citizenship prior to the IPO of Facebook. 00:35:31.900 |
If they have the choice, they may never need it, but they're not hurt by having it. 00:35:36.740 |
But you don't have to just do birth tourism, you can buy second citizenships, you can go 00:35:40.500 |
and establish residency abroad and work on a residency program and I think it's just 00:35:44.220 |
well worth having in the back of your mind because in my opinion the only answer to your 00:35:48.700 |
question of how do I avoid a wealth tax, if you live in a country that taxes you on your 00:35:53.740 |
worldwide income and your worldwide wealth like the United States does, the only solution 00:35:58.300 |
is to simply leave and get yourself out from under their taxing authority. 00:36:13.860 |
I don't think you're going to successfully convince your wife, but that's okay, you don't 00:36:18.140 |
But I'm sure there are other listeners who will be interested. 00:36:21.140 |
>>TED: Yeah, so it's not something that I'm thinking of imminently. 00:36:26.300 |
I mean you mentioned in your podcast you see the debt bomb exploding in your lifetime. 00:36:34.180 |
I don't feel like, I mean I think we can do QE four, five, six and seven before truly 00:36:41.020 |
no one's going to extend us any more credit and the debt bomb's going to explode and who 00:36:45.260 |
I just want to be thinking about these options as maybe I'll be in retirement by the time 00:36:52.980 |
I just want to be somewhat prepared, at least have some of the stuff before it comes due. 00:37:02.300 |
And so I don't see, and I think the fact that you are thinking about the solutions is probably 00:37:08.100 |
about all you need to do at this point in time. 00:37:10.900 |
And I think there are some basic things, as I talk about in the course that I made, there 00:37:16.540 |
are some basic steps that can be taken and should be taken. 00:37:19.680 |
But just simply thinking about it is more than most people. 00:37:25.980 |
So I'm not worried about anything in the near term. 00:37:30.940 |
Certainly I think we always face the potential for short-term economic problems. 00:37:35.460 |
But I think more likely is just kind of a slow malaise and a long, slow period of not 00:37:48.380 |
But I don't see any kind of short-term scenario. 00:37:51.660 |
So I would just say, as your wealth grows, just keep an eye on it. 00:37:54.940 |
If you have $100,000 of net worth, there's no point in doing much other than focusing 00:38:01.940 |
When you have a net worth of a million dollars, just start to look at it. 00:38:04.860 |
I think by the time you get to a net worth of a million dollars, a good portion of your 00:38:14.620 |
As you start to get to a couple of million dollars, I think you should be looking carefully 00:38:19.140 |
Even at a couple of million dollars, I wouldn't do anything. 00:38:21.020 |
But if you start to get much more than that, you should be paying attention. 00:38:23.980 |
And in my mind, the only thing that we can do at this point is just watch the news, watch 00:38:28.560 |
the tone in the country, and see what people start to do. 00:38:33.140 |
Now I don't have much optimism that things will change, because as best I can see, it 00:38:39.700 |
seems like in the United States we have developed a citizenry of people, or a voter base at 00:38:46.260 |
least, of people who believe that what belongs to other people belongs to them if they can 00:38:53.580 |
Now at the moment, it seems like it's just more talk than it is action. 00:38:59.740 |
You know, it's watch the 2020 presidential elections, watch the next few election cycles 00:39:05.900 |
But I do think that if you live in a citizenry of people who are greedy and jealous and think 00:39:10.140 |
that it's all your fault just because you're rich and all they have to do is get together 00:39:14.460 |
with a few million other neighbors and take from you, then that should be illustrative. 00:39:18.700 |
Now if we see somehow some kind of principled resurgence of a live and let live and, you 00:39:24.780 |
know, I'm not going to steal from my neighbor some kind of conservative political revival, 00:39:32.460 |
But if that happens, then I would be less worried. 00:39:34.900 |
But in your own personal decisions, there may come a time when you have a job option 00:39:38.420 |
and you're looking at taking a job in Jacksonville, but you're also thinking about taking a job 00:39:44.020 |
And you look at it and say, you know what, I'm going to pursue the job in Zurich. 00:39:48.500 |
Go to Zurich and start setting up a life there and just start the process little by little. 00:39:54.660 |
My hope is that just by exposing people to the ideas and the concept that they'll start 00:39:58.600 |
to look and then if the cost for you becomes significant, that's when you start acting. 00:40:05.180 |
I don't think it makes sense to take big decisions if you're not actually paying a personal price. 00:40:11.220 |
If you don't have a big tax bill or they're not coming after your wealth, then why go 00:40:19.360 |
But if you do start to develop significant assets, then keep in the back of your mind, 00:40:24.060 |
how would I get out if the climate becomes worse? 00:40:37.300 |
Did I clarify the stuff on the medical tourism thing? 00:40:48.500 |
My only comment is you're talking maybe with your wife and for anyone else that's in the 00:40:54.740 |
I have a lot of good things to say about the United States of America and I think we should 00:40:59.980 |
be cautious about thinking that it's just better other places. 00:41:04.780 |
It's easy to think that the grass is greener on the other side of the fence until you actually 00:41:07.580 |
go to the other side of the fence and check out the grass. 00:41:10.740 |
I would just say on some metrics, there's another place somewhere in the world that's 00:41:17.660 |
But if your wife is, let's say that you could probably as you talk with your wife, try to 00:41:23.380 |
figure out what the things are that would be important for her. 00:41:27.020 |
I would just say the first thing is that most Americans can do is most Americans should 00:41:34.500 |
Have you traveled a lot internationally, Ryan? 00:41:44.900 |
It counts a little bit, I guess, but not much. 00:41:58.260 |
Schedule a family vacation to Asia and take a little tour of Singapore and Hong Kong and 00:42:16.020 |
Go to Shanghai and start to see what's happening in the rest of the world. 00:42:21.100 |
The first time I went to Hong Kong, I had never been to... 00:42:25.580 |
As I can remember, I'd not really been to a big city outside the United States. 00:42:29.380 |
And I always thought that the United States was great. 00:42:33.860 |
And then I had been to England, I'd been to London, but it didn't do anything for me. 00:42:39.940 |
But I remember the first time I went to Hong Kong. 00:42:44.980 |
I can't remember what they call it, the subway system. 00:42:48.500 |
And I was just stunned at how incredible the subway system was. 00:42:53.340 |
And I walked around downtown Hong Kong on the island, and I could not believe what I 00:43:00.300 |
And it made New York look like the armpit of the earth. 00:43:05.120 |
Everything was bigger, everything was nicer, everything was fancier, everything was cleaner, 00:43:09.060 |
everything was faster, everything worked better. 00:43:13.060 |
I haven't been to Dubai yet, but it's on my list. 00:43:16.280 |
But I've seen the pictures of Dubai, and you look at what's happening in some of these 00:43:19.500 |
centers, and it's very hard to go back to the United States and make the argument that 00:43:25.100 |
Now I think that it would be false to do it just based upon the cities. 00:43:29.140 |
But if you are impressed by big cities and things, just get a plane ticket, schedule 00:43:35.380 |
Go to some place where you start to see, wait a second, the rest of the world hasn't been 00:43:50.660 |
But in Mexico City, there's so many wonderful places. 00:43:54.160 |
And I think that's the big thing that you can start to do, is just start to travel a 00:43:57.380 |
little internationally, pay the money, and it'll probably start to change your perspective 00:44:02.660 |
I think the United States is going to be in a long, slow decline over the coming decades. 00:44:08.260 |
I don't see any reason for kind of cultural optimism. 00:44:12.500 |
Basically we have developed a citizenry of people who are, in my opinion, fairly lazy, 00:44:18.180 |
fairly entitled, have this concept that basically everything, we're the best in everything. 00:44:25.580 |
And I don't see any foundational standpoint for a lot of optimism. 00:44:31.100 |
But that doesn't mean that the rest of the world is standing still. 00:44:33.660 |
So get out and travel, and see if you agree with me, see if you disagree with me. 00:44:38.620 |
Probably not the best time to start, but research, at least think about birth tourism, but at 00:44:43.660 |
least get out and travel, and see what you guys think about the rest of the world. 00:44:51.980 |
- I hope, it's always troubling to make broad sweeping statements like I've just made. 00:44:59.260 |
I hope I've given enough caveats and such to say, when I'm talking about this stuff, 00:45:03.460 |
I don't mean anything acute, I'm talking about long term. 00:45:05.860 |
I guess I just want to point out one more thing. 00:45:14.820 |
Because what I think is happening in the United States, you can succeed like crazy in the 00:45:20.700 |
There are so many opportunities for so many people to be successful in the United States. 00:45:28.620 |
That's different than the general population. 00:45:31.660 |
I think if you go back and you look at Charles Murray's book, Coming Apart, he traced this 00:45:38.220 |
out so perfectly, I don't know what other resource I could cite, where he clearly, and 00:45:44.140 |
in my opinion, overwhelmingly demonstrated the fact that the upper class elite in the 00:45:50.020 |
United States are doing better than ever before. 00:45:53.300 |
And frankly, that's probably who you and I are. 00:45:56.540 |
But that doesn't mean that the country is necessarily going to do better than ever before. 00:46:01.140 |
So you try to figure out where do you succeed. 00:46:04.860 |
Good chance for many of us, most of us, that's in the United States. 00:46:08.780 |
But you got to work within the system and recognize that just because you're doing well 00:46:15.340 |
And that could be dangerous in a population where you're doing well, but the people are 00:46:23.100 |
That could be very dangerous, could be dangerous to your health and wealth. 00:46:25.980 |
But you might not want to live in Dubai, you might not want to work in Singapore, you might 00:46:33.260 |
In which case, just enjoy the lifestyle benefits of where you are. 00:46:40.420 |
We watch over the coming years and see what happens. 00:46:43.300 |
But my only thing, I love the United States, I wish nothing but good things for the United 00:46:49.180 |
I just don't see the source of those good things on a large level. 00:46:53.540 |
I think that small groups of people who live very counter-culturally can do very well. 00:46:59.220 |
But on a broad basis, I don't see the reasons for optimism on the broad basis. 00:47:06.140 |
Hopefully that was enough backpedaling and whatnot to make it come through.