back to indexRPF0318-Casey_Fleming_Interview
00:00:05.000 |
California's top casino and entertainment destination 00:00:11.000 |
Play at Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel 00:00:14.000 |
to earn points, rewards, and complimentary experiences 00:00:17.000 |
for the iconic Palms Casino Resort in Las Vegas. 00:00:38.000 |
will be some of the biggest financial transactions 00:00:43.000 |
with those housing decisions will be dramatically affected 00:00:59.000 |
Conveniently enough, I'm speaking to Casey Fleming, 00:01:02.000 |
who's the author of a book called "The Loan Guide," 00:01:24.000 |
Welcome to the Radical Personal Finance Podcast, 00:01:29.000 |
to helping you figure out how to live a rich life today 00:02:12.000 |
and get a 30-year mortgage at a fixed rate interest, right? 00:02:24.000 |
I knew that you should only get a 15 or 30-year mortgage, 00:02:39.000 |
I don't think I knew nearly what I wish I had known, 00:02:43.000 |
and in hindsight, I wish I had done some more study 00:02:50.000 |
and mend the error of my ways with some additional study, 00:02:57.000 |
of "The Loan Guide," how to get the best possible mortgage, 00:03:02.000 |
If you're gonna buy a house, I recommend you probably. 00:03:05.000 |
And we're gonna try to chart the path for you a little bit 00:03:19.000 |
- Well, thank you very much, and thank you for having me. 00:03:28.000 |
and we had breakfast together, and I was so impressed 00:03:32.000 |
"Let's have you on the show, and let's talk about mortgages." 00:03:34.000 |
And what I'd like to do quickly before we get started 00:03:40.000 |
What's your background in the mortgage industry? 00:03:46.000 |
And founded a company and built it to one of the largest 00:03:50.000 |
appraisal and consulting firms in the San Francisco Bay Area 00:03:56.000 |
And then in the mid-'90s, I transitioned over into lending. 00:03:59.000 |
So I've been lending now for a little over 20 years. 00:04:14.000 |
- Well, some folks have asked me if it was a labor of love, 00:04:17.000 |
and actually I answered that no, it was a labor of being 00:04:22.000 |
And what I mean by that is everything that led up to the crash 00:04:31.000 |
on the part of players throughout the entire industry. 00:04:34.000 |
And it was very frustrating as someone who is very involved 00:04:39.000 |
in our professional organizations, and I know a lot of really good, 00:04:46.000 |
watching the bad apples ruin everything by essentially 00:04:53.000 |
taking advantage of the consumers was really maddening. 00:04:57.000 |
And obviously we all know how bad the results were. 00:05:04.000 |
So the purpose of the book was really to empower consumers 00:05:10.000 |
to educate themselves so that they can make wise choices 00:05:14.000 |
regardless of whether or not they're getting good advice 00:05:20.000 |
- I think it's a good job, and it's one of the best books 00:05:23.000 |
on mortgage--I mean, just the mortgage process that I have read. 00:05:30.000 |
to establish the context for our conversation. 00:05:33.000 |
You wrote this, "Nothing in this book is terribly exciting or sexy. 00:05:37.000 |
Reading about mortgages won't keep you up at night. 00:05:43.000 |
If I had my druthers, I'd rather be reading a tabloid. 00:05:45.000 |
Yet a mortgage is almost certainly the largest debt you will ever have. 00:05:49.000 |
There are some sobering implications to this. 00:05:51.000 |
You will probably spend more money on your mortgages over your lifetime 00:05:57.000 |
I repeat, you will spend more money on your mortgages over your lifetime 00:06:04.000 |
More of your working hours will be spent earning money 00:06:08.000 |
Families that manage their mortgage portfolio properly 00:06:11.000 |
can have tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, 00:06:14.000 |
more in assets when they retire than those who don't." 00:06:19.000 |
because it sets the context for how important the discussion is, 00:06:21.000 |
no, it's not exciting or sexy, but it is important. 00:06:25.000 |
Yet so many of us wander into getting a mortgage 00:06:29.000 |
and we know nothing about it, nothing about our options. 00:06:32.000 |
What are the biggest--let me say maybe the two or three biggest mistakes 00:06:36.000 |
that you see borrowers make when it comes to getting a mortgage? 00:06:41.000 |
Well, I think probably the first thing is not shopping hard enough. 00:06:49.000 |
They'll go off and they'll shop online and they'll end up being drawn in 00:06:55.000 |
by some great advertising, some great marketing. 00:07:00.000 |
And there's a lot of money in the mortgage industry, 00:07:03.000 |
so there's some pretty refined marketing that's very, very well done. 00:07:08.000 |
And it's pretty easy to draw someone into something 00:07:10.000 |
that isn't necessarily the best thing that they should do for themselves. 00:07:15.000 |
The other thing that folks do, I think, is they walk in 00:07:18.000 |
with a preconceived notion as to what they want. 00:07:21.000 |
And I hear these strange rules of thumb all the time. 00:07:26.000 |
You should never pay points or you should never pay any costs 00:07:29.000 |
or you should always get a 30-year fixed mortgage. 00:07:32.000 |
And the problem is, of course, is if you do that, 00:07:34.000 |
it really limits your ability to structure a mortgage in a way 00:07:38.000 |
that gives you the lowest possible lifetime cost 00:07:41.000 |
for your specific profile and goals and needs. 00:07:48.000 |
Can you give some examples of perhaps cases that you've worked on 00:07:56.000 |
and just considering the market at the time of purchase, 00:08:03.000 |
Oh, sure. I work with a lot of Silicon Valley engineers, 00:08:06.000 |
so they do tend to walk in with a lot of preconceived notions 00:08:14.000 |
So one of the most common is you should never pay any points. 00:08:17.000 |
And what I do is we earn the exact same amount, 00:08:22.000 |
no matter what you choose to do, whether you pay points or not pay points. 00:08:29.000 |
So we're going to earn the same amount no matter what you do. 00:08:33.000 |
So what I do is I give people options to pay points if they want to, 00:08:37.000 |
and then I show them how much the various options are going to cost over time. 00:08:43.000 |
And probably 75%, 80% of the time, engineers who walk in and say, 00:08:50.000 |
"I don't want to pay any points," will take a look at what it's really going to cost them 00:08:53.000 |
over whatever they believe their holding period is going to be, say, 7 years or so. 00:08:58.000 |
They'll look at the total cost over that holding period, 00:09:01.000 |
and they will decide to go ahead and pay money to buy down the interest rate by paying points. 00:09:07.000 |
So they walk in with one notion as to what they think is the best way to go, 00:09:11.000 |
and they walk out doing something totally different. 00:09:14.000 |
So why does that work? Why is that option available? 00:09:19.000 |
And why would the bank offer that to them to allow them--explain what buying points are 00:09:25.000 |
and why the bank allows that such that it reduces the costs? 00:09:32.000 |
The bank doesn't keep the loan. They sell the loan off. 00:09:37.000 |
And there's a price in the industry we call it par, where if a bank sells a loan off, 00:09:47.000 |
And on a typical loan, the lender is going to earn typically somewhere in the vicinity of about 3% 00:09:55.000 |
of the loan amount when they sell the loan off. 00:09:59.000 |
So what happens is that if the interest rate is higher than that, 00:10:06.000 |
then the buyer of the mortgage will pay more for that mortgage. 00:10:10.000 |
And if the interest rate is lower than that, the buyer will pay less for that mortgage. 00:10:14.000 |
So the bottom line of this is that if the lender has--if you accept a higher interest rate, 00:10:22.000 |
the lender's going to receive more profit on that. 00:10:25.000 |
And what they can do is they can use some of that profit to credit you for closing costs, 00:10:29.000 |
points, origination fee, even title and escrow fees. 00:10:33.000 |
If you want to earn--if you want to pay less in interest, 00:10:37.000 |
then the bank can simply earn their profit by charging you points 00:10:41.000 |
and then sell the loan off at--because it's a lower interest rate-- 00:10:46.000 |
at whatever price the buyer is willing to pay for that loan. 00:10:50.000 |
Describe a scenario where somebody made a choice other than a 30-year fixed 00:10:55.000 |
and perhaps it was a better financial choice for them and why. 00:11:00.000 |
So there's--on adjustable-rate mortgages, you have the option of different fixed periods initially. 00:11:09.000 |
So it could be a 5-year fixed or a 3-year fixed or a 7-year fixed, 00:11:13.000 |
where that initial period, it's fixed for that period of time. 00:11:17.000 |
So many folks, if they are pretty confident that they're only going to be in that home 00:11:21.000 |
for 5 years or 7 years, may choose to have a 7-year fixed. 00:11:27.000 |
And if they save, let's say, half a percent over the course of the first 7 years, 00:11:33.000 |
what they've done is they've saved thousands of money, 00:11:36.000 |
knowing--thousands of dollars of money--knowing that they're going to end up 00:11:42.000 |
selling the property before it turns into an adjustable-rate mortgage anyway. 00:11:47.000 |
It's quite common in Silicon Valley because most of the engineers and high-tech folks 00:11:54.000 |
that work here end up with fairly large occasional windfall income from RSUs 00:12:03.000 |
And I've had quite a few clients who came in and said, 00:12:06.000 |
"My intention is to actually pay this loan off in 7 years." 00:12:10.000 |
And because the adjustable-rate mortgage offers a lower interest rate, 00:12:14.000 |
they can pay it off faster and cheaper if they're fairly confident 00:12:18.000 |
they're going to be able to pay it off in only 7 years. 00:12:22.000 |
The fear with adjustable-rate mortgages is the potential for the mortgage 00:12:29.000 |
And this is the approach, say, "Well, wait a second. 00:12:32.000 |
If I get an adjustable-rate mortgage and interest rates go up by 3%, 00:12:35.000 |
all of a sudden my payment is going to be through the roof." 00:12:39.000 |
How do you actually analyze an adjustable-rate mortgage to figure out 00:12:43.000 |
if that's the case or if there is a margin of safety? 00:12:50.000 |
It's very important to understand the terms of your adjustable-rate mortgage 00:13:00.000 |
The most important terms to remember are the index, 00:13:05.000 |
and this is going to be defined in your actual contract. 00:13:08.000 |
An index is just simply a measurement of interest rates. 00:13:11.000 |
What they'll do is they'll say, "We're going to base-- 00:13:13.000 |
when we do adjust your interest rate, we're going to base it based on this index." 00:13:19.000 |
The most common index, and it's one probably most folks have heard of, 00:13:26.000 |
That's just simply a measure of where interest rates are at any given point in time, 00:13:30.000 |
just like the Dow Jones Industrial Average is a measure of where stocks might be 00:13:36.000 |
Then in your contract, they're also going to define the margin. 00:13:39.000 |
Now, a typical margin on a LIBOR loan is going to be between 2.25 to 2.75. 00:13:46.000 |
So you want to look at that margin, and what it says is when we adjust, 00:13:52.000 |
we're going to take whatever the current value of the index is, 00:13:56.000 |
So if the index, let's just say, is 1% and your margin is 2.25%, 00:14:06.000 |
The reason that this becomes important is today LIBOR is running under 1%. 00:14:14.000 |
So folks who have an adjustable-rate mortgage that is adjusting today 00:14:18.000 |
are finding that their loan is adjusting out to lower than where fixed-rate loans are, 00:14:29.000 |
The other elements that you really need to understand are your caps, 00:14:33.000 |
which is the cap on how high the interest rate can go, 00:14:37.000 |
and there's three caps that are really important. 00:14:42.000 |
So if you have, let's say, a 5-1 arm that's fixed for five years, 00:14:46.000 |
at the end of five years, then your loan can be adjusted a maximum of either 2% 00:14:56.000 |
Then you have an annual adjustment, and that's always 2%. 00:15:02.000 |
And then you have a lifetime cap, which is today in most cases 5% over the start rate. 00:15:10.000 |
So it's really important to understand those five terms whenever you're looking at 00:15:18.000 |
If you're comparing offers, for instance, you should be asking all five of those questions 00:15:24.000 |
and understand exactly how it's going to adjust. 00:15:27.000 |
I had a family member recently, as in the last few days, who's saying, 00:15:31.000 |
"Okay, I need to refinance my house, and where do I go? 00:15:36.000 |
How would you advise somebody who is looking at their house saying, 00:15:39.000 |
"I'd like to refinance," and trying to figure out how to approach finding somebody 00:15:46.000 |
How would you advise someone in that situation? 00:15:51.000 |
I think the best way to do it is to start online just so that you educate yourself 00:15:55.000 |
a little bit and understand where the various products are. 00:16:02.000 |
And then really write down, figure out what your real goal is in refinancing 00:16:07.000 |
because there's a lot of different reasons to refinance. 00:16:10.000 |
And when you actually go speak to someone--I'm a brick-and-mortar guy. 00:16:15.000 |
I prefer working with somebody that I can meet face-to-face and look them in the eye, 00:16:21.000 |
and that way I get a feel for whether or not they're being honest and ethical. 00:16:28.000 |
So I would educate--as a consumer, I would educate myself first, figure out why I want 00:16:35.000 |
to refinance, and then find somebody local, somebody who's referred by a family member 00:16:40.000 |
or a friend that you trust would be ideal, and ask them sharp questions. 00:16:47.000 |
You have the right to ask a lot of questions about why they're recommending 00:16:53.000 |
whatever they're recommending and about whether or not it's really going to be 00:17:03.000 |
Is there a way to know which is the cheaper option, working with a bank, 00:17:16.000 |
Generally, we all get our money from the same pool. 00:17:19.000 |
Ninety percent, roughly, of all loans made today are sold to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac. 00:17:25.000 |
At any given day and in any given moment of time, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae 00:17:33.000 |
actually advertise what they're willing to pay for loans that are going to be 00:17:38.000 |
So the differences between most lenders are fairly small. 00:17:43.000 |
The reason there are some differences is some lenders strategically go for the 00:17:51.000 |
Some lenders go for offering the best service. 00:17:54.000 |
And also, if a lender has been slow over the course of the month, then oftentimes 00:18:02.000 |
they will narrow their margin a little bit just to fill their pipeline a little bit. 00:18:08.000 |
In my experience, brokers have a lower overhead cost and can usually do a better 00:18:16.000 |
job, especially on conforming loans that are sold to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, 00:18:23.000 |
which would be loans under $417,000 to prime borrowers. 00:18:27.000 |
Usually, a broker can give you a better deal, but I still think it's worth 00:18:36.000 |
I know even here in my local market, when I took out a mortgage on the house that 00:18:39.000 |
I bought, looking back at it, the process went fine, but I never was confident 00:18:47.000 |
And what was the biggest frustration for me was I found out six months after I 00:18:52.000 |
bought the house about the Florida Mortgage Credit Certificate Program. 00:18:56.000 |
And I found out that the house that I purchased and the terms, I would have 00:19:01.000 |
qualified for the Mortgage Credit Certificate Program, which was a bonus tax 00:19:04.000 |
credit on top of all of the normal tax deductions that people are aware of. 00:19:09.000 |
And it was free money that if somebody had just told me about it, I could have 00:19:13.000 |
gotten and it would have been several thousand dollars a year, but except I had 00:19:19.000 |
And I just remember being so frustrated with the fact that the broker didn't 00:19:24.000 |
tell me about it, the real estate agent didn't tell me about it, the broker 00:19:28.000 |
I was just incredibly frustrated and I was like, "Do you guys not do your job?" 00:19:31.000 |
And even just in terms of the options, I never found a broker who was willing to 00:19:35.000 |
sit down and say, "Let me talk you through the options." 00:19:38.000 |
Rather, what happened was, "Well, here's a standard 30-rate fix and here are 00:19:43.000 |
And I was looking for more of someone to say, "Let's look through your situation 00:19:47.000 |
Nobody presented to me a few different adjustable-rate mortgage options and 00:19:51.000 |
explained to me, "Here are the risks and here are the advantages and here's the 00:19:56.000 |
I found it to be a very frustrating experience and I've not known how to 00:20:06.000 |
I think as a consumer, what you have to do is you have to be ready, willing, and 00:20:11.000 |
able to shop and talk to different people until you find somebody that you're 00:20:16.000 |
One of the tricks about going to the real estate agent, if you're purchasing a 00:20:22.000 |
home and your real estate agent is steering you towards a particular lender, 00:20:26.000 |
which is very, very common, we work as partners with real estate agents. 00:20:32.000 |
One of the challenges to that is that it's in everyone's interest except yours to 00:20:39.000 |
make the deal as smooth and effortless as possible because that gets us to 00:20:45.000 |
close faster so everybody gets paid sooner and more reliably because the longer 00:20:51.000 |
a deal is in escrow, the more chances there are for it to fall apart for any 00:20:58.000 |
So what you're going to find is complicated elements like the mortgage credit 00:21:05.000 |
certificate program are rarely brought up at that point in the process because, 00:21:13.000 |
quite frankly, it adds a lot of complexity and a lot of time to the process of 00:21:19.000 |
getting your loan approved and through the system. 00:21:22.000 |
So my advice is if you educate yourself and understand that you have the right to 00:21:29.000 |
understand a bunch of different options, then find somebody who's willing to 00:21:34.000 |
present you with at least three different options. 00:21:38.000 |
Yeah, as with anything, I can't blame other people for my lack of homework. 00:21:44.000 |
But it definitely – it just seems like in so many industries, I'm sure in the 00:21:48.000 |
service industry too, it should be pretty easy to stand out. 00:21:59.000 |
I'd like you to give just an overview, a few minutes of discussion of each of the 00:22:03.000 |
types of loans and thinking about what to do and how to approach it. 00:22:09.000 |
I want to start with the one that's abnormal but I get a lot of questions about 00:22:14.000 |
Explain what a reverse mortgage is and how to approach the decision of whether or 00:22:23.000 |
A reverse mortgage is simply a mortgage where you do not have to make the 00:22:30.000 |
The interest on the loan accrues and simply eats into your equity on the 00:22:37.000 |
So it's for older folks who do not have enough income to live. 00:22:44.000 |
And there's four different ways that a reverse mortgage can be structured. 00:22:50.000 |
And very briefly, one is just simply a lump sum payment. 00:22:54.000 |
And that's an ideal situation for someone who has a relatively large mortgage. 00:23:00.000 |
They're having difficulty making the payment. 00:23:02.000 |
They can get a one-time lump sum reverse mortgage which pays that off. 00:23:09.000 |
And then from then on, they simply have no mortgage payments at all. 00:23:13.000 |
There's also one where you get payments for your lifetime. 00:23:18.000 |
So you get monthly payments for as long as you live. 00:23:21.000 |
That's ideal for someone who has a little bit more equity in their property and 00:23:26.000 |
needs basically supplemental monthly income in order to be able to just live 00:23:41.000 |
And the equity line is perfect for folks that are okay on a monthly basis but 00:23:49.000 |
And a good example is a couple that I worked with where the husband had a 00:23:57.000 |
So all of a sudden, they had some large medical bills. 00:24:02.000 |
So they used an equity line but they ran it all the way up to the limit and 00:24:06.000 |
they were not qualified to increase that limit. 00:24:08.000 |
And they were looking at large medical bills that they simply couldn't pay 00:24:12.000 |
but a tremendous amount of equity in their home. 00:24:15.000 |
So we set up a reverse mortgage to pay off the equity line and then give them 00:24:19.000 |
-- to pay off the existing equity line and then give them another equity line 00:24:24.000 |
or let's just say it's all one loan but they had enough room to be able to draw 00:24:29.000 |
off money whenever they needed it for medical expenses. 00:24:33.000 |
And they would never have to make a payment for the rest of their life. 00:24:36.000 |
So it allowed them to stay in the home for as long as they wanted. 00:24:40.000 |
So the point here and I flipped it just in hopes of keeping the conversation 00:24:45.000 |
interesting but I may have made it more confusing. 00:24:47.000 |
The point of a reverse mortgage is to take equity that you own out of a house 00:24:51.000 |
and basically give it away to the bank in exchange for money now in one of those 00:24:56.000 |
So this is the exact opposite of a mainstream mortgage. 00:25:02.000 |
You see the value but you also see some dangers. 00:25:06.000 |
So what would be -- what are some reasons why people would choose not to get a 00:25:13.000 |
Well, it is the most expensive mortgage available and that's because virtually 00:25:21.000 |
all reverse mortgages today are FHA insured and that FHA insurance is fairly 00:25:30.000 |
So the rest of the costs are more or less the same as a forward mortgage or 00:25:39.000 |
But on the reverse mortgage, what we find is that you have -- it's a very, 00:25:47.000 |
The second thing is it does eat up your equity. 00:25:49.000 |
So if you have concerns about that, if you have children that you want to leave 00:25:52.000 |
your property to, you'll have less equity when you're ready to leave that to 00:25:59.000 |
your children than you would if you didn't do the reverse mortgage. 00:26:03.000 |
Reverse mortgages today are designed so that it would be virtually impossible to 00:26:09.000 |
eat up 100% of your equity but not completely impossible. 00:26:17.000 |
And then finally, the last bit is the -- the last thing that's important is that 00:26:23.000 |
the reverse mortgage is still the one product that the -- where the lender can 00:26:30.000 |
actually earn more money by selling you a higher interest rate. 00:26:35.000 |
On all other products, especially for brokers, we're unable to increase our 00:26:44.000 |
We have to make the exact same amount on everything. 00:26:47.000 |
That rule doesn't apply to banks and mortgage bankers, large mortgage 00:26:54.000 |
With reverse mortgages, you can actually earn huge incomes by selling a very 00:27:02.000 |
And because the consumer doesn't make any payments, often they don't actually 00:27:09.000 |
So it's sort of a little trap that's important to understand so that you can 00:27:14.000 |
avoid it if you're actually shopping for a reverse mortgage. 00:27:18.000 |
- Are the costs of mortgages declining, meaning as they've become more popular, 00:27:24.000 |
is the cost of insurance declining and is the cost of taking out the mortgage 00:27:34.000 |
The upfront cost of a reverse mortgage declined this year. 00:27:39.000 |
FHA sets the insurance premium and it declined this year. 00:27:43.000 |
And now it's down, your upfront premium is down to one-half of 1% of the value 00:27:56.000 |
So in virtually all cases, there's some exceptions, but in virtually all cases 00:28:01.000 |
today, the upfront insurance is actually considerably less than what it used to be. 00:28:08.000 |
- That's what has confused me about the reverse mortgage market, and I'm not in 00:28:12.000 |
it every day, but it just seems to me that it's a useful tool and you've got to 00:28:16.000 |
analyze it each time, but the prices shouldn't remain high forever. 00:28:20.000 |
Like there should be competition and there should be reasons why the prices 00:28:24.000 |
So yes, when it was a newer product, I could understand why the costs would be 00:28:28.000 |
high, but I'd like to see it coming down and being possible. 00:28:34.000 |
I want to describe a scenario and you can tell me what's available in the market 00:28:38.000 |
And this is the thing I've kind of puzzled over. 00:28:40.000 |
But in my ideal world, if I were a traditional retiree, say 65-ish, whatever, 00:28:48.000 |
I would, and assuming most people today, the concept of the family house that the 00:28:53.000 |
kids want to inherit is for most people dead and gone. 00:28:57.000 |
Maybe that was the case when you had the family farmstead and your kids were going 00:29:01.000 |
But today, most of us, the houses we live in are a commodity. 00:29:04.000 |
They're nice, but it's not like we're going to pass them on through the 00:29:08.000 |
So most of the time, if I die and leave behind a house to my 45-year-old kids, 00:29:14.000 |
they just got to go through the hassle of selling it and getting rid of it. 00:29:19.000 |
And they just got to deal with that and then they split up the money. 00:29:22.000 |
So in some ways, my ideal scenario if I were a retiree would be to have either a 00:29:28.000 |
rental house, which is less than normal because of the risks there. 00:29:34.000 |
Most retirees aren't willing to face the prospect of a landlord adjusting things 00:29:38.000 |
But I'd like to have either a maximum interest only mortgage or some way set up 00:29:43.000 |
with maybe a reverse mortgage where I don't own the property. 00:29:46.000 |
I just simply live in the property and I have a maximum mortgage on it possible so 00:29:53.000 |
that my assets are somewhere else that's a little bit easier to deal with than a 00:29:56.000 |
personal house, but minimum payments possible and to do that for the longest 00:30:03.000 |
If you get the scenario, what would be the best way to set that up if I were going 00:30:08.000 |
Would it be through using a reverse mortgage product? 00:30:10.000 |
Would it be through an interest only loan of some kind? 00:30:12.000 |
How would I set that up in today, 2015, 2016? 00:30:16.000 |
Just to clarify, so one of your goals is to not make payments or just you don't 00:30:22.000 |
really care whether you're leaving equity or not? 00:30:29.000 |
So $300,000 house, I want the maximum equity out of the house. 00:30:32.000 |
And I'm willing to make payments, but I don't want to make principal payments if 00:30:38.000 |
It's not a problem to make some payments, but I want to make either minimum 00:30:44.000 |
Well, an interest only loan would be significantly cheaper. 00:30:47.000 |
As a matter of fact, an equity line would actually be, by far and away, the least 00:30:54.000 |
And with an equity line, you can certainly get -- with a conventional equity line, 00:30:57.000 |
you can get significantly more money out of your property than you could with a 00:31:10.000 |
No, so then I would take the maximum equity line out and just pay the interest 00:31:18.000 |
And the only caveat to that would be that within 10 years, usually exactly 10 00:31:26.000 |
years, the equity line draw period will be over. 00:31:30.000 |
And so you'll have to change your strategy at that point. 00:31:34.000 |
And possibly you could refinance if you still qualify. 00:31:38.000 |
You could just roll it into a new equity line. 00:31:41.000 |
Or at that point, you could go out and get a reverse mortgage, too. 00:31:47.000 |
And could -- in an equity line, can they lower -- I guess it would depend on the 00:31:52.000 |
terms of the contract, but wouldn't it be normal that they could lower the amount 00:31:55.000 |
of the line and forced repayment of some kind? 00:32:00.000 |
But historically, the only time that's happened is when we saw large declines in 00:32:11.000 |
Because I know that's something that I did see happen with some clients. 00:32:14.000 |
I was just asking you because you're a creative thinker and it's a scenario 00:32:22.000 |
I used to think that the goal for a retiree would be to have a paid off home 00:32:27.000 |
mortgage, that this is the ideal scenario, have a paid off home mortgage and then 00:32:33.000 |
But what I've realized is when you're living off of the investment income from a 00:32:36.000 |
portfolio, you don't have the same risk that somebody who's living off of the 00:32:42.000 |
So for me, I'm 30 years old, it would be very valuable to have a paid for house. 00:32:46.000 |
And I'm not saying that if I had abundant other money that at 65, if I had a paid 00:32:51.000 |
off house from 30 to 65 that I'd go borrow money on it. 00:32:56.000 |
But I would consider it because if I'm living on a portfolio of income, then by 00:32:59.000 |
definition I have income and I no longer have -- the mortgage is just a cost of 00:33:05.000 |
And houses are really clumsy as far as passing along generationally. 00:33:08.000 |
And so I've looked for strategies to say, "What's the best way to cut the cost 00:33:21.000 |
So in your book, you talk about fixed rate mortgages, adjustable rate mortgages, 00:33:25.000 |
interest only loans, option arms, private money, second mortgages, and equity 00:33:32.000 |
And if you were approaching it, what are the pros and cons that an individual 00:33:35.000 |
borrower would need to understand when thinking through their decisions? 00:33:39.000 |
So what I like to do is I like to start off with finding out what a borrower's 00:33:49.000 |
Most borrowers will say their goal is to have the lowest interest rate possible. 00:33:56.000 |
What I need to know and what they need to know is, you know, are you looking for 00:34:01.000 |
the lowest monthly payment, the lowest upfront cost, the lowest lifetime cost, 00:34:05.000 |
or do you want to pay it off as fast as possible, or something else. 00:34:09.000 |
But it's usually one of those four things that becomes most important to them. 00:34:14.000 |
With a 30-year fixed mortgage, obviously the greatest advantage is the interest 00:34:20.000 |
rate's never going to change, your payment's never going to change. 00:34:24.000 |
But it is the most expensive mortgage out there, unless in the future interest 00:34:33.000 |
And given the fact that in the last 20 years they've been extremely low, 00:34:38.000 |
maybe the odds of them going through the roof are not that high. 00:34:43.000 |
The adjustable-rate mortgages we've kind of already touched on, 00:34:46.000 |
the greatest advantage to them is they're significantly less expensive, 00:34:53.000 |
And as it turns out, over the last 10 years they've been significantly 00:34:58.000 |
cheaper even after they begin adjusting, as long as it's not one of the 00:35:09.000 |
There was actually nothing wrong with the product. 00:35:11.000 |
Unfortunately, they were sold improperly to people that shouldn't have had them. 00:35:15.000 |
And so those are considered toxic loan products today, 00:35:19.000 |
and they're not available, so that's kind of off the table. 00:35:24.000 |
You would only use that if you can't qualify in any other way. 00:35:30.000 |
But I think for each person individually what they have to figure out is what 00:35:35.000 |
And then I do take a look at their income and spending profile. 00:35:40.000 |
If somebody has abundant disposable income, for instance, 00:35:47.000 |
some folks are really conservative and instead of spending 40% of their gross 00:35:52.000 |
income on housing debt, they only want to spend 30% or something. 00:35:59.000 |
Or if they have large bonuses or stock options, RSUs, 00:36:03.000 |
somebody with those kinds of income profiles usually have a higher risk 00:36:09.000 |
tolerance, so doing something like an interest-only adjustable-rate mortgage 00:36:18.000 |
If someone has really thin disposable income, 00:36:21.000 |
like they're really stretching out their qualifying and they're qualifying for 00:36:26.000 |
as much house as they can possibly buy, or if they have bad spending habits, 00:36:33.000 |
that tells me that they're likely to continue spending and they could get into 00:36:39.000 |
I mean, here in Silicon Valley we have a lot of layoffs, 00:36:41.000 |
and certain companies are more prone to it than others, for instance. 00:36:46.000 |
Well, if someone has those elements in their income and spending profile, 00:36:51.000 |
I would say they'd have a lower risk tolerance and I would be more inclined to 00:36:56.000 |
recommend a fixed-rate loan for someone like that. 00:36:59.000 |
You work in an interesting mortgage environment. 00:37:07.000 |
So you're not dealing with somebody in the Midwest who's taken out a $75,000 00:37:13.000 |
You're more likely to be working with a $750,000 mortgage. 00:37:16.000 |
How does that affect the mortgage decision process? 00:37:20.000 |
Well, the bigger the mortgage, the bigger the risk/reward equation becomes. 00:37:28.000 |
So it's a great point if someone's got a $75,000 mortgage in the Midwest, 00:37:34.000 |
their savings potential from getting an adjustable-rate mortgage is really 00:37:41.000 |
very small, as is the risk if it begins to adjust. 00:37:46.000 |
With a $750,000 loan, which isn't uncommon at all here, 00:37:51.000 |
you can save tens of thousands of dollars over the next seven years is a 00:37:58.000 |
typical period for what people kind of look at here because they figure they'll 00:38:02.000 |
be moving up within seven years or paying it off. 00:38:05.000 |
And you've got tens of thousands of dollars in potential savings and 00:38:12.000 |
significantly greater risk unless you manage it properly. 00:38:15.000 |
And the best way to manage risk on an adjustable-rate mortgage is to have a 00:38:18.000 |
plan to pay the balance down as fast as possible because, 00:38:22.000 |
just like with a Midwest person, the lower the principal balance when it 00:38:26.000 |
begins to adjust, the lower the impact is if interest rates happen to go way up. 00:38:35.000 |
I love my favorite chapter in your book is Chapter 19, 00:38:40.000 |
and I'd recommend listeners buy it if for no other reason than just to get 00:38:43.000 |
Chapter 19 where you talk through the money-saving strategies. 00:38:46.000 |
And you walk through these scenarios step by step. 00:38:50.000 |
So you talk about the holding period, just like you're doing just now. 00:38:54.000 |
If you're going to hold the house for longer, do this. 00:38:56.000 |
If you're going to hold the house for shorter, do this. 00:38:59.000 |
You walk through the life stage and the different products and price 00:39:03.000 |
recommendations for life stages, risk tolerance. 00:39:05.000 |
You even have a section on if you're going to have babies, having a baby. 00:39:10.000 |
If you're going to have a baby -- and here I'll read just -- this is the 00:39:14.000 |
But if you're going to have a baby and lose one income for a while, 00:39:17.000 |
get an adjustable-rate mortgage with an initial fixed period that is longer 00:39:22.000 |
If you think you want to stay at home indefinitely, get a fixed-rate 00:39:26.000 |
And if you decide you want to have lots of babies, you may want to consider 00:39:30.000 |
the possibility that you'll want to add on to your house in a few years. 00:39:33.000 |
If this is the case, then now might be a good time for an adjustable-rate 00:39:37.000 |
When the time comes to build on, you're very likely to refinance again to 00:39:42.000 |
And you go on and give these examples for each one. 00:39:48.000 |
This is a really important aspect of financial planning. 00:39:51.000 |
And listeners would be well-served to pick up your book and work through 00:39:56.000 |
Because as mortgage costs are going to be a big deal for you in the grand 00:40:03.000 |
scope of your life and in your life plan, it's important to get them right. 00:40:10.000 |
And all of the elements that I discussed in Chapter 19, every one of them 00:40:16.000 |
reflects a real-life client situation that I had. 00:40:21.000 |
And the more somebody talks to me about, "Here's what I'm thinking about 00:40:27.000 |
doing," the more we can sit down and talk about how the various options are 00:40:35.000 |
A good example is somebody that wants to start a business, because that's 00:40:40.000 |
And someone that wants to start a business, for God's sake, get a fixed-rate 00:40:44.000 |
mortgage and make sure you get it before you start your business. 00:40:47.000 |
Because once you start your business, you will not be financiable for at 00:40:54.000 |
Talk to your mortgage advisor about your plans and make sure that they are 00:40:59.000 |
part of the consideration in terms of your strategy. 00:41:02.000 |
Why get a fixed-rate mortgage in that context? 00:41:07.000 |
Well, because I guess it depends on the time frame. 00:41:11.000 |
But the main reason I would say get a fixed-rate mortgage if you're about to 00:41:15.000 |
start your own business is businesses, when you first start them, have a way 00:41:22.000 |
And sometimes it takes a long time before you're actually generating any 00:41:27.000 |
So your risk tolerance on a mortgage might be significantly lower if you're 00:41:39.000 |
It's amazing how no matter how hard you try to predict the future, 00:41:47.000 |
And my final question, and I'll give you a longer intro to it, 00:41:52.000 |
my final question is, do you have some strategies to create maximum 00:42:01.000 |
As we record this, we're recording this on December 1, 2015. 00:42:04.000 |
This will likely air either later in December or in January. 00:42:07.000 |
Hopefully, by the time we record this, I will have sold the house that I bought 00:42:12.000 |
But when I bought that house, I chose the house very, very carefully. 00:42:20.000 |
I didn't intend to do a -- it wasn't intended to be a starter house. 00:42:26.000 |
I didn't have any reason why I didn't expect to be in that house for 20, 00:42:34.000 |
I would be happy in it for a long time, nice enough and be happy, 00:42:38.000 |
Without going through the whole list, I chose the house really carefully. 00:42:42.000 |
And I intended to make a -- I made a 20% down payment. 00:42:59.000 |
deciding to close the business I'd been running for five or six years 00:43:02.000 |
and start Radical Personal Finance, which adjusted everything. 00:43:04.000 |
I had no need to live in the neighborhood where I wanted to live. 00:43:07.000 |
I wanted my money back out of the house, et cetera, 00:43:09.000 |
and I looked at different strategies and ultimately decided to just go ahead 00:43:13.000 |
And so what was funny is I've ended up owning the house, 00:43:15.000 |
and there were some timing strategies as well. 00:43:17.000 |
I had some -- it's a good time to sell as far as assuming the contract goes 00:43:23.000 |
I'll have made a healthy profit on the house and some kind of timing the 00:43:27.000 |
market a little bit to take some tax-free income as well. 00:43:29.000 |
But all of my plans -- I'm glad that I had some flexibility because even 00:43:35.000 |
though I had my plan set in one way, life changed. 00:43:42.000 |
So the question is do you have some suggestions and strategies that would 00:43:45.000 |
help listeners always keep flexibility so that no matter how much they're 00:43:49.000 |
planning, if their circumstances do indeed change -- they do what I did, 00:43:54.000 |
they start a business, they decide to move to another state to take a better 00:43:57.000 |
job, et cetera -- that they have more options? 00:44:05.000 |
One of the things that I like to do -- I work with financial planners a lot 00:44:09.000 |
where we kind of partner on strategy and we sit down and kind of think about 00:44:14.000 |
And financial planners that I work with tend to really like the idea of 00:44:18.000 |
having an equity line, which provides a tremendous amount of flexibility. 00:44:23.000 |
So it's not uncommon for us to use two different loans for financing a 00:44:29.000 |
property, whether it's a refinance or a purchase, especially if there's a 00:44:36.000 |
break at which your first mortgage becomes quite a bit cheaper because it's 00:44:42.000 |
in a certain category, in which case we could limit that and we use the rest 00:44:48.000 |
Or sometimes we just refinance your mortgage into the lowest rate possible. 00:44:57.000 |
Because the equity line, essentially if you're not using it, doesn't cost you 00:45:02.000 |
But provides you with a great deal of flexibility. 00:45:05.000 |
So I think the first thing I would say is in your situation is consider having 00:45:12.000 |
two loans, which means that you've got access to cash, especially if you're 00:45:16.000 |
starting a business, where you have quick access to cash. 00:45:20.000 |
Another probably very important consideration would be is if you end up 00:45:25.000 |
owning two homes, I'm not sure if you were going there or not, but if you end 00:45:29.000 |
up owning two homes, I like diversification in my debt portfolio as much as I do 00:45:37.000 |
So it might be a really good idea to have one fixed loan and one variable rate 00:45:42.000 |
loan so that if rates go up, you're protected on one. 00:45:45.000 |
If rates go down, you get the benefit on the other. 00:45:54.000 |
I was able to find a rental deal that worked. 00:45:56.000 |
But that's an interesting approach to consider to diversifying that. 00:46:03.000 |
Let's say that I were a real estate investor with a portfolio of loans. 00:46:06.000 |
Are there other approaches to intelligent diversification that you would consider 00:46:23.000 |
- I guess I'm just thinking my scenario of real estate investment is borrow a 00:46:30.000 |
million dollars and let your tenants pay it off. 00:46:32.000 |
So if you don't manage, however, your risks carefully on that million bucks, 00:46:38.000 |
And so as you're working into it, you've got to build safety for yourself. 00:46:44.000 |
And if you're starting without a ton of money, you're going to be borrowing a 00:46:48.000 |
And so you're going to be steadily managing your properties and kind of 00:46:55.000 |
And I just was curious if you had any big picture suggestions. 00:46:59.000 |
- Well, you hit the nail on the head with regards to risk. 00:47:02.000 |
I mean, you have no idea with a rental property how much it's going to throw off 00:47:09.000 |
In the long run, you can make some fairly accurate projections most of the time. 00:47:13.000 |
But on a month-by-month basis, you just never know. 00:47:15.000 |
So an excellent strategy there is to start off with an interest-only 00:47:23.000 |
For instance, a 711 arm that's adjustable for...or that's interest-only for 10 00:47:29.000 |
And the reason that that might work is that you have the option of making a 00:47:37.000 |
So you save a little bit of money because it's an adjustable-rate mortgage. 00:47:42.000 |
And what you do is when the property is performing well and throwing off a lot 00:47:47.000 |
of cash, you use that cash to buy down the principal as fast as you can in order 00:47:52.000 |
to mitigate any risk that you have once it begins to adjust. 00:47:58.000 |
But then if you have a bad month, you know, the property is vacant for a month 00:48:02.000 |
or requires a lot of repairs, you can make just the minimum payment, 00:48:06.000 |
which is going to be only whatever interest is due for that month. 00:48:11.000 |
So it's a way of reducing your cost and reducing your risk, 00:48:15.000 |
or at least your monthly risk, at the same time. 00:48:20.000 |
If that's your strategy, however, I certainly wouldn't finance all your 00:48:25.000 |
properties using the same thing only because at some point the loans begin 00:48:34.000 |
And once they do begin to adjust, if the rates have gone up, 00:48:37.000 |
all of a sudden what you've done is you've converted all of your debt 00:48:46.000 |
Well, Casey, thank you so much for sharing some of your insights and wisdom 00:48:53.000 |
If you're going to buy a house, I definitely recommend reading the book. 00:48:57.000 |
I'll link to it in the blog post for today's show and in the show notes 00:49:01.000 |
And then you also blog and have a site at LoanGuide.com. 00:49:06.000 |
Do you work with clients across -- you said you prefer to work locally. 00:49:10.000 |
Do you work with clients across the country or just primarily in California? 00:49:15.000 |
Licensing today is state by state, and I am only licensed in California. 00:49:21.000 |
Our company is licensed in several other states as well, 00:49:24.000 |
but I personally work only with California clients, 00:49:32.000 |
Well, any California listeners would definitely encourage them. 00:49:34.000 |
Check out LoanGuide.com, and if you're looking for a good broker, talk to Casey, 00:49:38.000 |
and you can provide the same kind of personalized advice that we all wish that we had. 00:49:44.000 |
Anywhere else that you want people to connect with you or any final words of advice, Casey? 00:49:48.000 |
No, as far as connecting, the best way to reach me is through LoanGuide.com, 00:49:53.000 |
and the final words of advice I think are don't be afraid to shop, 00:50:03.000 |
Many of the loan officers you talk to don't know any more than you do, 00:50:08.000 |
so do not be intimidated by them and hold their feet to the fire. 00:50:12.000 |
Sounds like the insurance industry, sounds like the investments industry. 00:50:20.000 |
Well, Casey, thanks for coming on the show today. 00:50:26.000 |
As we go today, I encourage you to check out Casey's book, 00:50:29.000 |
and I encourage you to think deeply and always look for a way of optimizing your scenario. 00:50:35.000 |
Every decision has pros and cons, and that's not just some random disclaimer. 00:50:43.000 |
It's your money, it's your life, and you are responsible. 00:50:47.000 |
You're the one who's going to sign on the dotted line, 00:50:51.000 |
and make sure that you have a little bit of a sense of what's going on. 00:50:57.000 |
Buying a book, let's see, on Amazon right now, this book is $25. 00:51:05.000 |
15 used from 1881, I wouldn't bother with those. 00:51:09.000 |
But $25 might be worth investing in for an education 00:51:14.000 |
that will impact the potential expenditure or savings of thousands, 00:51:18.000 |
tens of thousands, or hundreds of thousands of dollars 00:51:26.000 |
Become a person who researches things intensely. 00:51:28.000 |
You can't always be successful at always making the right decision. 00:51:35.000 |
But at least be somebody who does your best to do research. 00:51:39.000 |
Don't make big financial decisions without spending time 00:51:41.000 |
and spending a little bit of money on your education. 00:51:44.000 |
Definitely encourage you to get Jake Casey's book. 00:51:46.000 |
Books are going to be the best investment you're going to make. 00:51:49.000 |
$25 in, plus shipping if you don't have Amazon Prime 00:51:54.000 |
$25 in and thousands of dollars of potential savings out. 00:52:04.000 |
If you have enjoyed and appreciated our content, 00:52:06.000 |
please consider becoming a supporter and patron of Radical Personal Finance. 00:52:10.000 |
You can find all of those details at radicalpersonalfinance.com/patron, 00:52:18.000 |
Come on by and become a patron of the show so you can join our Facebook group. 00:52:21.000 |
Lots of interesting conversations there happening regarding real estate, 00:52:28.000 |
some interesting conversations regarding GDP growth. 00:52:31.000 |
So I'd encourage you to consider becoming a patron of the show