back to indexRPF-0036-Tax_Planning_-_Income_Timing_Strategies
00:00:03.000 |
Forget your cares in Fiji, white sand beaches and scuba diving are calling. 00:00:08.000 |
Your tropical paradise getaway is just one non-stop Fiji Airways Flight Away. 00:00:13.000 |
With round trip fares starting at $899 from LAX or SFO. 00:00:17.000 |
Or check out great fares to Australia and New Zealand with seamless connections via Fiji. 00:00:25.000 |
From here to happiness, flying direct with Fiji Airways. 00:00:34.000 |
Welcome to the Radical Personal Finance podcast. 00:00:58.000 |
And today's show is going to be all about tax planning. 00:01:01.000 |
We're going to continue our tax planning series. 00:01:04.000 |
And today we're going to mainly talk about the three strategies for tax planning. 00:01:14.000 |
I don't know whether it thrills you with excitement, 00:01:25.000 |
or blows your heart with excitement to think about doing a show on tax planning like it does mine. 00:01:31.000 |
We're going to dig into some meat and potatoes of financial planning. 00:01:35.000 |
And I don't want the show to go off the rails into all philosophy or all politics or all economics, things like that. 00:01:42.000 |
I want to balance this with a lot of meat and potatoes financial planning topics. 00:01:50.000 |
And I want to share just a couple minutes as far as why this topic, 00:01:54.000 |
why I hope this topic will be of interest and of value to you. 00:01:57.000 |
And then we're going to dig into some meat and potato stuff. 00:02:05.000 |
We're going to be working with the highly theoretical today. 00:02:09.000 |
We're going to be working with the highly theoretical. 00:02:11.000 |
But I believe this information is intensely practical once you understand it. 00:02:19.000 |
The last couple show topics have been, again, a variety. 00:02:28.000 |
I've talked about everything from welfare to philosophy to getting rid of your TV to dumpster diving. 00:02:33.000 |
And what I really want to do today is I don't want to stay in that world. 00:02:37.000 |
I think it's fun and it's important to go into that world. 00:02:40.000 |
But today I want to dive deep into meat and potatoes financial planning, 00:02:43.000 |
and I want to give you a framework that you can use to apply to your life, especially as regards tax planning. 00:02:51.000 |
Now, any time it comes to financial planning, I've never heard somebody give some of this framework in a book. 00:02:58.000 |
I've never read it in books as far as reading it in personal finance books. 00:03:05.000 |
Most of this information, the best I've been able to find it, comes from college accounting textbooks and things like that. 00:03:12.000 |
And so before you roll your eyes back and say, "I don't want to study a college planning textbook," let me explain why this is so valuable. 00:03:23.000 |
And the example that I thought of to try to convey this is the example of a car mechanic. 00:03:28.000 |
There's probably two ways to learn to be a car mechanic, and both of them I think are valid and important. 00:03:35.000 |
So the first way would be learn how to bolt and unbolt certain parts. 00:03:38.000 |
That's my level of expertise with car mechanics. 00:03:44.000 |
I don't understand how the various components work. 00:03:46.000 |
I do try from time to time to unbolt and bolt certain things on, and I have pictures, and I pull out a manual, and it gives me pictures, and I say, "Bolt this part here. 00:03:56.000 |
I know how to turn a wrench, and if the bolting and the unbolting works, then, okay, great, it worked. 00:04:04.000 |
I don't understand how the ignition system interplays with the fuel system. 00:04:10.000 |
So if I go to turn the key and the car clicks, I don't know what that might mean. 00:04:15.000 |
But someone who is an advanced car mechanic can understand what that means. 00:04:19.000 |
Now, how did they become an advanced car mechanic? 00:04:22.000 |
Well, they may have started with bolting and unbolting things, or they may also have started with learning the theory behind how the car works. 00:04:30.000 |
I think both are valid, and probably what is the most effective approach is to get in, roll your sleeves up, and start bolting and unbolting things. 00:04:39.000 |
And then also to learn a little bit about the theory. 00:04:42.000 |
So let's bring it over to financial planning. 00:04:44.000 |
Most financial planning radio shows or books that you read, frankly, in the personal finance space are very much, "Here's how you bolt and unbolt. 00:04:58.000 |
If somebody needs some instruction on you need to establish an IRA, and this will help you to establish an IRA, 00:05:05.000 |
and that may be the very basic that someone can start with, or here's where you need to study it, here's how a budget process may work, 00:05:12.000 |
and here's how you can use that budgeting process to enhance your life so that you have more money. 00:05:20.000 |
Now, if it's all practical, however, we quickly run into a problem, and we run into this problem. 00:05:26.000 |
Let's say that the book says establish an IRA, but you read another book, and this other book says you should establish a Roth IRA. 00:05:33.000 |
Now you have two books, both of whom are written by learned, caring people, and they have differing recommendations. 00:05:43.000 |
How do you decide which one of them is right? 00:05:46.000 |
Well, in order to do that, you need a little bit of theory. 00:05:48.000 |
You need a little bit of a framework, and so you need to understand what the advantages and disadvantages are of either of them, 00:05:57.000 |
They have different components, and so it's not smart just to say, "Well, I'll split the difference and do half and half 00:06:02.000 |
and hope that I'm half right and half wrong." 00:06:05.000 |
If you don't have the framework to understand what's going on, then you can't really make a rational decision between those two things, 00:06:13.000 |
and basically what you're then doing is you find yourself following the personality of the person that you like the most, 00:06:23.000 |
and then we get into a debate, and we say, "Well, my favorite personality says this, and my favorite personality says that, 00:06:31.000 |
and that personality may be right, or they may just be repeating something that they have heard, 00:06:37.000 |
but once you understand the theoretical framework behind what we're going to talk about today, 00:06:41.000 |
which is specifically the timing of taxes, the timing of shifting the timing of when you pay taxes, 00:06:49.000 |
a tax planning strategy, then you can quickly look at a personal situation. 00:06:54.000 |
I can quickly look, gather some facts, and I can say IRA, or I can look and I can say Roth IRA, 00:07:00.000 |
and I know why because I know the framework, so I'm going to share that framework to you. 00:07:03.000 |
It's not a secret, but that's why the framework is important. 00:07:07.000 |
We need framework, and we need technique, so the balance that I'm trying to drive at in this show, 00:07:13.000 |
and I don't know whether I'm doing it successfully or unsuccessfully, 00:07:16.000 |
but the balance that I'm trying to work at is to give you both of these things, 00:07:19.000 |
give you the framework and give you the technique, 00:07:22.000 |
and I believe that the integration, the synthesis between these two things is what will allow you, 00:07:27.000 |
if you're a do-it-yourselfer, to do a much better job of understanding your situation 00:07:32.000 |
and will allow you, if you're a financial planner of some sort, to do a much better job of helping your clients. 00:07:38.000 |
I looked for this information when I was younger. 00:07:41.000 |
I couldn't find the framework because I was lost in the world of personal finance, 00:07:46.000 |
and in the personal finance, what you have is technique. 00:07:49.000 |
You have technique, but you don't have the framework, the intellectual framework, 00:07:52.000 |
so I would read through books like I've referenced before on a tax planning book, 00:07:57.000 |
and it would have a list of techniques, but I didn't have any way to fit it in, 00:08:00.000 |
and so, again, where I ultimately found this information was through some of my tax planning books 00:08:06.000 |
for advanced financial planning designations and also through accounting courses, 00:08:10.000 |
and that's where I started to find the framework, and that helped me immensely 00:08:13.000 |
because then I could synthesize the technique and the framework because techniques come and go. 00:08:28.000 |
New taxes are added, so all of that changes as time goes on, 00:08:31.000 |
so if all you have is technique, your technique may soon be invalid. 00:08:37.000 |
What do you do with your planning technique if your entire financial planning technique 00:08:40.000 |
is built around the Roth IRA and Congress changes the tax laws about a Roth IRA? 00:08:45.000 |
People scream from the top of the house and say, "This is the worst thing that could ever happen, 00:08:49.000 |
so therefore don't trust the Roth IRA system." 00:08:51.000 |
I don't think there's--I don't have anything to worry about. 00:08:53.000 |
I'm not predicting anything, but I do know that Congress changes tax laws all the time, 00:09:00.000 |
If your whole plan was built upon Roth IRAs, your plan falls apart, 00:09:04.000 |
but if you were using the Roth IRA as a tool and you understood the theory, 00:09:10.000 |
I could accomplish exactly the same thing that the--I could accomplish 90% of the things 00:09:16.000 |
that the Roth IRA accomplishes with other strategies. 00:09:19.000 |
There are other ways to do tax planning depending on the situation. 00:09:25.000 |
Another thing that you need to understand before we get into this is you need to look at your personal situation. 00:09:30.000 |
All financial planning is and must be intensely personal. 00:09:35.000 |
If you are in a 30% tax bracket, that is very different-- 00:09:39.000 |
there are very different planning needs and planning priorities than if you're in a 0% tax bracket. 00:09:45.000 |
So you need to look to see where it is your bang for the buck-- 00:09:48.000 |
where are you going to get the most bang for the buck in your planning horizon? 00:09:56.000 |
If you are earning a relatively low income and you have a lot of deductions with children 00:10:02.000 |
and family members and things like that, chances are your biggest bang for the buck 00:10:06.000 |
is likely not going to come from doing sophisticated tax planning 00:10:12.000 |
because your tax rates and your tax base is fairly small-- 00:10:16.000 |
your tax base is small and your tax rate is low. 00:10:19.000 |
And if you don't know what those words mean, go back and listen to show number 15, 00:10:24.000 |
which was the introductory show to tax planning. 00:10:27.000 |
If you haven't heard that, stop now and go listen to show 15. 00:10:31.000 |
You'll find it at RadicalPersonalFinance.com/15. 00:10:34.000 |
That show was entitled "How to Eliminate Your Taxes-- 00:10:37.000 |
The Basic Foundation You Need to Understand to Do Good Tax Planning." 00:10:40.000 |
So you need to understand what is my tax base, what are my tax rates, 00:10:45.000 |
and what are the different taxes that I'm going to be looking at and planning for. 00:10:49.000 |
So that show will cover those details for you. 00:10:52.000 |
But it's likely that in terms of your personal finance, if you're at a low-- 00:10:57.000 |
again, if you're in a low-tax environment, your best bang for the buck 00:11:02.000 |
is probably going to be prioritizing something like yesterday's show, 00:11:08.000 |
So yesterday's show, episode 34--excuse me, 35-- 00:11:13.000 |
was about saving on communications expenses, and that built on show number 4. 00:11:17.000 |
Or it may come down to how can I dumpster dive or coupon my food 00:11:26.000 |
But you should still be preparing for this information. 00:11:31.000 |
I think every person who's broke should be planning to be a billionaire. 00:11:35.000 |
How are you going to become a billionaire if you don't plan to be there? 00:11:39.000 |
You've got to start with broke and then move on from there. 00:11:42.000 |
So look at your situation to see where your biggest bang for the buck 00:11:47.000 |
And this information is going to be just as valid for you 00:11:52.000 |
whether you're making $50,000 a year or $5 million a year. 00:11:55.000 |
This information is going to be every bit as valid 00:11:57.000 |
because today we're going to be talking about framework. 00:11:59.000 |
Now, in future shows with techniques, I'll give you an introduction to technique 00:12:05.000 |
and say here are some techniques that are going to be useful at $50,000 of income 00:12:08.000 |
and here are some techniques that are going to be useful at $5 million of income. 00:12:13.000 |
The next point I want to make is the difference between tax planning and non-tax planning. 00:12:17.000 |
This is where essentially you have to start all discussions. 00:12:24.000 |
Basically, effective tax planning is all about maximizing the after-tax wealth 00:12:31.000 |
while also achieving all of your non-tax goals. 00:12:36.000 |
Just maximizing after-tax wealth is not a rational goal. 00:12:41.000 |
If the goal were just simply to minimize taxes, 00:12:44.000 |
then the simplest way to do that is just simply earn no income. 00:12:52.000 |
If you can figure out how to live and earn no income, 00:12:54.000 |
and I'm going to profile people on the show who are doing that. 00:12:59.000 |
I can't remember the exact title of it, but it was like The Man Who Lived Without Money, 00:13:07.000 |
That's why I profiled on Friday's show last week. 00:13:10.000 |
I profiled a hobo, the guy that just refuses to work. 00:13:14.000 |
I think that's an amazing thing to learn, but it also comes with some disadvantages. 00:13:18.000 |
And so if that's the lifestyle you wish to pursue, go for it. 00:13:22.000 |
I would love to – I'll interview you on the show. 00:13:27.000 |
However, most of us are probably going to find some balance between minimizing the cost of taxes 00:13:36.000 |
So you may – if we were just focused on minimizing taxes, 00:13:40.000 |
the fastest and easiest way is just get rid of our income and just don't earn any income. 00:13:44.000 |
But if you're not willing to go through the resulting poverty that would ensue, 00:13:53.000 |
or if you're not willing to live that way, then that's not a practical way to approach life. 00:14:02.000 |
So good tax planning means that we need to factor in both the tax 00:14:06.000 |
and the non-tax advantages and costs in every situation. 00:14:12.000 |
Almost every financial transaction involves basically three people. 00:14:17.000 |
You have the taxpayer, the other person, the other transacting party, and then the government. 00:14:25.000 |
And you need to understand the roles between them 00:14:27.000 |
because that will allow you to structure win-win deals between you, the taxpayer – 00:14:33.000 |
I'm assuming that in this situation you're the taxpayer – and between the other party. 00:14:38.000 |
So by understanding these, you can structure more advantageous deals. 00:14:41.000 |
And when we get in the future – and I don't know whether this will be a couple years from now or what, 00:14:46.000 |
but when we get into shows talking about how to structure a business transaction, 00:14:50.000 |
how to do stock-for-stock transactions to avoid taxes and things like that, 00:14:54.000 |
and buying and selling corporations, then that's where it's going to be very, very valuable. 00:14:59.000 |
It's going to be important to understand those decisions 00:15:02.000 |
because large financial transactions don't happen with money, with cash. 00:15:06.000 |
They do happen with money and cash, but there may be other considerations. 00:15:11.000 |
So I want you to understand those three things. 00:15:13.000 |
So we always want to incorporate tax planning and non-tax planning considerations. 00:15:18.000 |
So although we're focusing today on tax planning, a good financial planner is always going to factor in – 00:15:23.000 |
and you, you being a good financial planner for yourself, 00:15:26.000 |
or if you're hiring a good financial planner is always going to factor in the non-tax considerations. 00:15:35.000 |
They're very, very important to understand those as we get into the meat here. 00:15:41.000 |
So as I mentioned at the end of the last show in this tax planning series, which was episode 15, 00:15:48.000 |
I mentioned that basically you can boil the major tax planning strategies down to three, 00:15:55.000 |
and those three are timing, shifting, and conversion. 00:16:03.000 |
Now these are theoretical but eminently practical mental constructs for you to use with tax planning. 00:16:12.000 |
As a tax planner, when I hear a technique, I'm quickly thinking, 00:16:16.000 |
"Is this a timing technique, a shifting technique, or a conversion technique?" 00:16:20.000 |
And that helps me to place it in my mind as far as to see where does this belong. 00:16:24.000 |
So timing is basically doing planning with a timing technique. 00:16:31.000 |
It's essentially all about are we taking income today and accelerating income, 00:16:40.000 |
So are we moving income up, or are we deferring it? 00:16:44.000 |
And then are we accelerating a tax deduction, or are we deferring a tax deduction? 00:16:52.000 |
Shifting is all about shifting income from high-rate taxpayers to low-rate taxpayers. 00:16:59.000 |
I won't be able to cover that today, but we'll do an entire show on that 00:17:02.000 |
because there's some very effective techniques that you can use in income shifting, 00:17:05.000 |
and that may be from a corporation to an individual, 00:17:10.000 |
or from a wealthy family member to a non-wealthy family member, 00:17:14.000 |
or from an individual to a trust, or from a trust to an individual, et cetera, et cetera. 00:17:22.000 |
And then conversion is all about converting income from high-rate activities 00:17:26.000 |
to low-rate activities, and that can be done in a variety of ways, 00:17:32.000 |
I wrote an article on corporate inversions on Monday's show. 00:17:35.000 |
So that article on corporate inversions, you should understand that. 00:17:40.000 |
The companies that are engaging in corporate inversions right now, 00:17:43.000 |
leaving the United States to go to a lower-taxed authority, 00:17:51.000 |
They're converting income from high-rate activities to low-rate activities, 00:17:53.000 |
but you can apply conversion strategies to your own individual situation. 00:17:59.000 |
When it comes to timing, it's all about when the income is taxed 00:18:09.000 |
So if you can--in essence, one of the major constructs that you want to have 00:18:13.000 |
is that any time you can have an expense, that's a deduction, 00:18:18.000 |
This, if you're an employee and if you've never run a business, 00:18:21.000 |
this may be a concept that you're not familiar to thinking about. 00:18:26.000 |
But in business, you're only taxed on profit. 00:18:28.000 |
So you don't pay--if you earn $10--let's use $100. 00:18:33.000 |
If you earn $100 on services provided, but in order to provide those services, 00:18:40.000 |
you incurred $50 of cost, you're not taxed on the $100 of income. 00:18:47.000 |
You're only taxed on the $50 of net income or profit. 00:18:51.000 |
So in the business world, one of the most important tax planning strategies 00:18:57.000 |
is to use the deductions that we have available, 00:19:00.000 |
and there are many more deductions available on the business side of accounting 00:19:05.000 |
but there are deductions available on the personal side as well. 00:19:08.000 |
So our timing strategy is all about when are we going to take this income, 00:19:12.000 |
when are we going to bring it in, or are we going to bring it in now, 00:19:15.000 |
or are we going to push it to later, and when are we going to take this deduction. 00:19:18.000 |
Are we going to push it out and take it in the future, 00:19:27.000 |
there are two important things that we've got to keep in mind. 00:19:32.000 |
We've got the three strategies now as part of timing. 00:19:37.000 |
and then we've got two important things that we need to keep in mind. 00:19:41.000 |
We need to focus on the present value or the future value of taxes paid or taxes saved, 00:19:51.000 |
and then we also need to focus on the tax rates and any changes in the tax rates. 00:19:58.000 |
And timing strategies are in one way the simplest, 00:20:06.000 |
I'm going to go over and cover in detail these variables 00:20:11.000 |
and then you can apply them to your situation. 00:20:13.000 |
So let's start with present value and future value. 00:20:16.000 |
One of the most fundamental concepts of financial planning 00:20:20.000 |
This would also be known as the time value of money, 00:20:23.000 |
and the basic idea here is that a dollar today 00:20:26.000 |
is always worth more than a dollar in the future. 00:20:32.000 |
It's true, and the assumption comes from the fact that if you have a dollar today, 00:20:38.000 |
you can invest that dollar and make a positive rate of return. 00:20:44.000 |
If that's true, then you should always, if given the option, 00:20:48.000 |
between having a dollar today and a dollar a year from now, 00:20:51.000 |
you should always choose to have the dollar today so that you can invest it. 00:20:55.000 |
Now, I'm going to cover a little bit of math, 00:20:59.000 |
If you're driving, don't worry, look at the formulas. 00:21:02.000 |
I think I can cover it in a way that is quick enough 00:21:06.000 |
and interesting enough to do in an audio podcast, 00:21:10.000 |
But I want to give you a mathematical formula. 00:21:12.000 |
I'm going to give you the future value formula 00:21:14.000 |
and the present value formula so that you can do the math. 00:21:19.000 |
We're going to be using it continually, but this math, 00:21:24.000 |
If you don't want to do this, I'll give you two ways to do it. 00:21:27.000 |
I'll give you the formula, and then I'll tell you how to run it on a financial calculator. 00:21:31.000 |
In the future, I hope to be able at some point when I get my production ability to do that, 00:21:35.000 |
and there's probably videos on YouTube already done, 00:21:37.000 |
but I want to teach you how to run a financial calculator 00:21:40.000 |
because just a simple financial calculator, which you can find online for free, 00:21:44.000 |
if you understand how to run it and how to run a financial calculator, 00:21:47.000 |
it will do far more than all of the web calculators that you find online for you. 00:21:55.000 |
There's a lot of value in the web calculators, 00:21:57.000 |
but the problem is those are all built on the underlying assumptions, 00:22:00.000 |
and it's easy to run a calculator and not understand what the assumptions are-- 00:22:04.000 |
the web calculator--not understand what the assumptions are. 00:22:07.000 |
But if you know how to run a financial calculator, 00:22:15.000 |
When I started as a financial advisor, I didn't know how to run a financial calculator. 00:22:22.000 |
Most financial advisors just simply don't know how to run it. 00:22:25.000 |
And I started it because I thought, "Well, I need to learn this," 00:22:30.000 |
So my dad actually, when I started working in the financial planning business, 00:22:34.000 |
he got me the same calculator he'd always use, which is a classic, an HP-12C, 00:22:40.000 |
which was the classic one that hasn't changed in, I don't know, 80 years, 60 years. 00:22:45.000 |
And so I thought it would be fun to learn--I thought it would look cool if I knew how to run it. 00:22:49.000 |
So I just started originally because I thought it looked cool, 00:22:51.000 |
and then I learned how to do it, and I just realized the power of the financial calculator. 00:22:55.000 |
And like I've said it before, if you can run a financial calculator, 00:22:58.000 |
you can give a pencil and a legal pad, and I can design a comprehensive financial plan. 00:23:04.000 |
So let's talk about the present value formulas. 00:23:07.000 |
So the first formula that I'm going to start with is the future value formula. 00:23:12.000 |
And please don't--I promise I won't go into too many details to make this boring. 00:23:17.000 |
But the future value formula is the present value times 1 plus r raised to the n. 00:23:26.000 |
This is the calculation that you need to figure out how much money is worth in the future. 00:23:29.000 |
So if we were going to use dollars, and in the 1 plus r, in the mathematical term, 00:23:37.000 |
So the present value--I mean, what's the money worth today? 00:23:41.000 |
And we're going to multiply that, but we've got to do this other function first, 00:23:44.000 |
times 1 plus r, r being the rate of return, expressed in a decimal. 00:23:50.000 |
So if you had a 10% rate of return, that would be .10. 00:24:00.000 |
And n is the number of years of the formula that we're investing for. 00:24:04.000 |
So 1 plus r raised to the n, and then multiply that times the number of dollars. 00:24:09.000 |
So if you--let's say that you were going to get a 10% rate of return, 00:24:12.000 |
how you would do this function is you would say a 10% rate of return is 1 plus 1.-- 00:24:31.000 |
You would take $100, and you would multiply that times 1.10, 00:24:38.000 |
So if you had $100 today, and you could invest it at a 10% rate of return for one year, 00:24:52.000 |
Well, in this situation, all you need to do--and here's where you probably need a calculator-- 00:24:55.000 |
you could do it by hand, but do it with a calculator would be a lot easier. 00:24:59.000 |
So now if you were going to do it for two years, you would do 1 plus .10 is 1.10, 00:25:10.000 |
And the answer there, if you were putting it out, the answer would be 1.210. 00:25:15.000 |
Then you would multiply that times your $100, 00:25:18.000 |
and multiply 1.210 times 100, and at the end of two years, you would have $121. 00:25:25.000 |
So there would be $10 of interest credited in the first year, 00:25:28.000 |
and then $11 of interest credited in the second year. 00:25:36.000 |
If you were going to do this for 10 years, you would do 1.10, raise that to the power of 10, 00:25:47.000 |
So the answer would be 2.59, multiply that times $100, and you would have $259.37. 00:25:55.000 |
So if you could invest $100 today, and you could invest it each year at 10% interest for 10 years, 00:26:02.000 |
at the end of 10 years, you would have $259.37. 00:26:08.000 |
Now, on a financial calculator, you basically have five buttons on your financial calculator that you can operate. 00:26:15.000 |
If you have a financial calculator, get it out, pull it out, or take a look. 00:26:18.000 |
I will put a link to an HP 12C, an online calculator I've often used, in the show notes that you can use. 00:26:28.000 |
So the way a financial calculator works is you have these five buttons, 00:26:31.000 |
and these buttons are N, which stands for the number of years, or rather the number of periods. 00:26:36.000 |
So you could use this in years, you could use this in months, you can use it in quarters, 00:26:42.000 |
And this is important to a financial planner because oftentimes you'll use an annual number, 00:26:48.000 |
Well, then you might compound something monthly, or if you were calculating bonds, 00:26:51.000 |
you would compound bonds, or generally the interest is paid twice per year. 00:26:54.000 |
So you would use six-month periods, you could use quarters, you can do whatever you want to do. 00:26:59.000 |
But N is the number of periods, I is the interest rate per period, PV is the present value, 00:27:06.000 |
PMT is the payment, so the cash flows in or the cash flows out, and FV is the future value. 00:27:13.000 |
So if we wanted to check our math on the $259.37, that our $10 would--excuse me, 00:27:21.000 |
our $100 would grow to over 10 years, I could do this. 00:27:23.000 |
I would do $100 for my present value, and when you're doing a present value calculation, 00:27:30.000 |
So I would change sign, put in $100 as a present value. 00:27:33.000 |
I would put in 10 as my interest rate for 10% annually, compounded annually. 00:27:40.000 |
I would put in zero for my payments because I'm not putting in any cash flows, 00:27:44.000 |
and I'm not taking cash flows out, and I would press the future value calculator--future value number, 00:27:49.000 |
and then the calculator will calculate, and my answer will be $259.37. 00:27:54.000 |
So I've proved that my formula works both ways, both by using the calculation function 00:28:02.000 |
If you are a financial planning student or if you are a financial--if you're preparing for something like the CFP exam, 00:28:08.000 |
learn how to do these things both ways, and what you'll find is just by running the financial calculator, 00:28:13.000 |
you can always check yourself, and once you understand the end, the payments, the future value, 00:28:17.000 |
and all of that, you can check yourself to make sure that you're getting your formulas correct. 00:28:21.000 |
So this future value formula is very important because we know that a dollar today 00:28:26.000 |
is much more valuable than a dollar in the future, 00:28:30.000 |
but this depends upon the rate at which we can grow our money. 00:28:35.000 |
So if I offered you $100 today or $100 in a year, which would you choose? 00:28:42.000 |
Well, to run this and calculate this actually, what you would need to do is you would need to run the calculation 00:28:50.000 |
and see what the present value of the $100 in a year would be today 00:28:55.000 |
or what the money is worth today and what the money is worth in a year. 00:29:00.000 |
So if we assume that you can grow your money at 10%, which is an assumption, 00:29:04.000 |
and I don't care what number you use, 3%, 8%, 10%, I'm going to use 10% to try to keep the math very simple 00:29:13.000 |
If we assume that you can grow your money at 10% each year, what I'm actually offering you is 00:29:20.000 |
would you like to receive, in terms of future value, would you like to receive $110 today or $100? 00:29:38.000 |
Now, the flip side of this calculation would be the present value. 00:29:42.000 |
So we did a future value calculation that the exact flip side of this is the present value. 00:29:46.000 |
And so from here, we want to always calculate what the present value is. 00:29:51.000 |
So the present value is basically--the formula for the present value is the future value divided by 1 plus r raised to the n. 00:30:04.000 |
So if we had--let's continue with our $100 and 10% number. 00:30:11.000 |
If we were going to use $1, we would use $1, 1 plus .10 and raise that to the number of periods. 00:30:18.000 |
And so if we raise that to 1 period, then the answer of what that would be is 1.10. 00:30:26.000 |
And then putting that into the formula, we would take $1 and divide it by 1.10, 00:30:37.000 |
The discount factor is essentially--it is a numerical factor that we can use to apply to figure out what is the present value of money today. 00:30:49.000 |
So I think that's as deep as I need to go into the math. 00:30:52.000 |
Look at the formulas and learn to work with these present value and future values. 00:30:58.000 |
What we always want to figure out is would we rather have the cash inflow or the cash outflow today 00:31:03.000 |
or would we rather have the cash inflow or the cash outflow in the future? 00:31:10.000 |
And I am--this is a good example that I read in one of my financial planning textbooks. 00:31:15.000 |
And so the example here is let's say that you go to a--let's say that you go to one of these furniture places where they say, 00:31:24.000 |
"We'll give you--we'll sell you furniture today with no money down and no payments for one year." 00:31:30.000 |
And so let's say that you buy $1,000 worth of furniture and you go--let's say two couches, $1,000 worth of furniture, 00:31:38.000 |
and you decide you're going to do no money down and no payments for one year. 00:31:41.000 |
So the question would be what is that worth to you? 00:31:44.000 |
Ignore all the personal finance nonsense of how the contracts work and fixing it and being in debt and all that stuff. 00:31:57.000 |
So let's say that you can annually grow your money every year at 10%. 00:32:01.000 |
You have an investment opportunity, whether that's an investment in yourself, whether it's an--let's say that you're going to invest that $1,000 into your own education in some way, 00:32:11.000 |
and you expect that to increase your income by 10%. 00:32:17.000 |
Well, the discount factor that we just calculated would be .909, would be the--.91 to .909 would be the discount factor. 00:32:28.000 |
So if you multiply $1,000 times that discount factor of .909, you wind up with the answer of $909. 00:32:36.000 |
So you saved $91 by taking that no money down and no payments for one year number because you either have to pay the $1,000 today or you have to pay the $1,000 one year from now. 00:32:48.000 |
But by pushing your $1,000 payment forward one year, you can now satisfy that payment for only $91 because you can take that $91, invest it at 10%, and that $91 will earn you $9 of interest. 00:33:02.000 |
Excuse me, your $909, and that'll earn you $91 of interest, and that'll grow to be the $1,000 that you need. 00:33:12.000 |
We would always--anytime that we are--anytime that we're going to spend money, the rule is this. 00:33:18.000 |
Anytime we're going to spend money, so we're going to have a cash outflow, we want to always take whatever is the lowest present value, the lowest cost. 00:33:27.000 |
And anytime we're going to earn money, we're going to take a cash inflow, we're always going to bring in the higher present value. 00:33:36.000 |
So let's apply this present value, future value, and let's look at tax rates and timing of income. 00:33:42.000 |
When it comes to tax rates, we need to understand are tax rates constant or are they changing? 00:33:52.000 |
Changing is a little bit more complicated, and this is why you get so much disagreement in the finance space about what you should do with your money. 00:34:00.000 |
So one economist thinks that tax rates are going down, another economist thinks that tax rates are going up. 00:34:05.000 |
One financial planner says you should--your personal tax rate is going to be lower in retirement. 00:34:11.000 |
Another financial planner says your personal tax rate is going to be higher in retirement. 00:34:16.000 |
And so the answers would be different depending on what assumptions you use. 00:34:20.000 |
So when tax rates are constant, we want to always accelerate our tax deductions, and we want to defer our income. 00:34:31.000 |
And the reason we want to do that is because of this present value calculation. 00:34:36.000 |
If we can accelerate our deduction, then we can invest that money that we save, and it'll have a higher present value than if we take that deduction a year from now. 00:34:48.000 |
And if we defer our income to the future and pay those taxes in the future, then we can pay those taxes with cheaper money, money that has a lower present value. 00:35:00.000 |
So when tax rates are constant, we always want to bring up the deductions, and we want to push off our taxable income. 00:35:09.000 |
And because we're maximizing the present value of the tax savings from bringing forward the deductions, 00:35:15.000 |
and we're minimizing the present value of the taxes that we're paying by pushing them off. 00:35:19.000 |
Now, I'm using the technical financial planner words for this, but this is intuitively true. 00:35:26.000 |
So if the words are confusing to you, just think about this. 00:35:29.000 |
If you have the--let's use IRAs as an example that most people are familiar with. 00:35:34.000 |
If you have the possibility, if you're going to pay the same $100 of tax on the income--so let's assume that you're going to earn the income now, 00:35:41.000 |
you're going to be at the same tax rate now, and you're going to be at a tax rate later. 00:35:44.000 |
If you're going to owe $100 of tax on--let's say it's at an effective--let's use 10%. 00:35:49.000 |
Let's say you're in a marginal bracket of 10%. 00:35:53.000 |
So you're going to earn $1,000. That means you're going to owe $100 of tax. 00:35:56.000 |
Would you rather pay that $100 of tax today, or would you rather pay that $100 of tax in the future? 00:36:02.000 |
So you want to accelerate your deduction and defer your income. 00:36:07.000 |
The key, however, is we need to be careful of when our cash flows are coming in or going out. 00:36:16.000 |
I'm not going to spend too much time on this, but it's not--it is as simple as saying, 00:36:21.000 |
"Bring forward the deductions and push off the recognizing the income." 00:36:25.000 |
But, by the way, recognizing income, that's another accounting word that means 00:36:30.000 |
that recognition of income means at the point--we now are showing the income at the point we have to pay tax on it. 00:36:36.000 |
So we're going to push off the recognition of the income. 00:36:39.000 |
We may earn it at an earlier period, but we're going to push the recognition back to the time when the taxes are triggered. 00:36:45.000 |
If there is a large cash outflow that we have to incur now in order to get a deduction, 00:36:52.000 |
then we need to run the math very carefully on that, and it's too complicated to do on the podcast, 00:36:59.000 |
So, essentially, any time you can accelerate a deduction without accelerating the cash outflow that you need to get the deduction, 00:37:14.000 |
First of all, any type of taxpayer who is a cash method taxpayer, you can often control when you're paying your expenses, 00:37:23.000 |
and so that's a key number is when you are paying your expenses. 00:37:28.000 |
So individuals may do this when it comes to your property taxes. 00:37:32.000 |
Let's say you're going to pay your property taxes, and you have the choice to go ahead and pay your property taxes 00:37:36.000 |
two years' worth in December versus one in December and one in January. 00:37:40.000 |
That would be an option that you have, and if those property taxes are deductible in some way, 00:37:51.000 |
So in an accrual method of accounting for a business, then here is where you are going to--you have a little bit more-- 00:37:59.000 |
you have a few more restrictions on you because in accrual, it's not just about when it's--in accrual accounting, 00:38:07.000 |
it's not just when the income is--when you actually get the cash. 00:38:13.000 |
But you may use an accelerated depreciation schedule for a depreciable asset. 00:38:21.000 |
Have you ever heard somebody say, "Buy a heavy car," or you may have heard somebody say, "Buy a heavy luxury car." 00:38:31.000 |
This would be a good example of accelerating deductions. 00:38:35.000 |
In this case, the deduction that we're accelerating is a depreciation deduction. 00:38:39.000 |
And let me just give you a little bit of background, and I think you'll understand how you can use these tax strategies 00:38:44.000 |
to measurably impact the quality of your life if you know what you're doing. 00:38:55.000 |
If you were running a business, there's a car that's probably involved, 00:38:58.000 |
and you are going to be using that car for business purposes. 00:39:01.000 |
There are tons and tons--by the way, quick disclaimer. 00:39:03.000 |
There are tons of details that I'm trying to avoid going deeply into 00:39:09.000 |
because it just can't be done in audio format in a compelling way. 00:39:15.000 |
Don't do anything with what I'm telling you without going and researching the current law. 00:39:19.000 |
But take what I'm doing as an idea, and then think about it if it may apply to your situation. 00:39:23.000 |
So businesses will often involve running a car. 00:39:26.000 |
So if you were a business owner, and you are in--let's assume you're in a high-tax bracket. 00:39:29.000 |
I'm going to assume you're in a 30% marginal bracket. 00:39:32.000 |
So you're in a relatively high bracket, and you're using a vehicle in your business. 00:39:39.000 |
You're not worrying about what you're actually spending every month. 00:39:44.000 |
Would you like to go ahead and have a nicer car? 00:39:47.000 |
And then because you basically--by running it in your business, 00:39:54.000 |
If you can buy a luxury automobile, then you can run that luxury automobile 00:39:58.000 |
and enjoy the 30% break that you get on the expenses that are associated with it. 00:40:02.000 |
So business owners would do that, and they would run a luxury automobile. 00:40:07.000 |
Well, that would be politically unpopular, so Congress decided, 00:40:10.000 |
"We're going to limit the deductions that you can take on a luxury car that's used for business." 00:40:14.000 |
So we understand that you're going to have expenses associated with a normal car, 00:40:18.000 |
but we don't want to allow you to deduct expenses associated with a luxury car. 00:40:21.000 |
We're not willing to let the tax code finance your luxury--your luxury--your luxury's expenses. 00:40:30.000 |
So in 1986, they passed a law that said you cannot take--you cannot--they limited the-- 00:40:39.000 |
excuse me--they limited the deductions that you can take on a luxury car that's used for business. 00:40:46.000 |
Now, at that time, basically, the problem was that they--their definition of a luxury car 00:40:51.000 |
was very different than what maybe your definition of a luxury car would be. 00:40:57.000 |
Basically, it would cover any car, even as little as $11,000 in 1986 dollars. 00:41:03.000 |
So they didn't want to impact real business vehicles, like trucks. 00:41:10.000 |
So they said that any car with an unloaded gross vehicle weight over 6,000 pounds, 00:41:21.000 |
So any car with a weight of over 6,000 pounds, then it would not be covered by those limitations. 00:41:27.000 |
So this opened up a--this opened up an opportunity that if your vehicle was heavy enough, 00:41:33.000 |
then you could go ahead and deduct the full amount of it. 00:41:37.000 |
And I'll get through some numbers in just a moment and show you how valuable this is. 00:41:41.000 |
So that could be something like a van. That could be something like a pickup truck. 00:41:50.000 |
You might have some big Rolls-Royce, and it's more than 6,000 pounds. 00:41:55.000 |
But it was written with--there was an exception because it's more than 6,000 pounds. 00:41:59.000 |
So maybe you're shopping for a Range Rover, and you say, "Well, this is not a luxury car. 00:42:05.000 |
So people started doing that, and the tax benefits of that were awesome, 00:42:12.000 |
And basically what happened is that there was--there is a section in the tax code 00:42:18.000 |
that if you don't have to depreciate property, you can expense it. 00:42:22.000 |
And in general, there's a difference in business taxes between depreciation and expenses. 00:42:28.000 |
So--or excuse me, yeah, between deducting depreciation and expenses. 00:42:32.000 |
If you have equipment that is large and valuable, then you have to depreciate that. 00:42:39.000 |
So what that means is that as the value of the equipment reduces, 00:42:47.000 |
you can't just write off $100,000 in the year that you buy it. 00:42:50.000 |
You have to write it off based upon a depreciation schedule. 00:42:53.000 |
For the simplicity of my show today, ignore the actual depreciation schedule 00:42:58.000 |
and assume that it means that it's 20% per year for 5 years. 00:43:02.000 |
So let's say that you can write off $20,000 this year, then $20,000 next year, 00:43:08.000 |
then $20,000 the third year, then $20,000, then $20,000. 00:43:12.000 |
So basically this applies generally to real equipment, real property. 00:43:16.000 |
Now, there's another thing, however, that allows you to expense certain costs. 00:43:22.000 |
So there's a section in the tax code called--in the U.S. tax code-- 00:43:29.000 |
If you can put something in under a Section 179 expense, 00:43:32.000 |
then that allows you to expense the full amount, the full cost of it, 00:43:38.000 |
And this can be helpful in something like computer equipment. 00:43:40.000 |
So if you can get your computer equipment in under a Section 179 expense 00:43:44.000 |
instead of in as depreciable equipment, it will save you on taxes now, 00:43:50.000 |
So what happened is that for a time, you could actually expense 00:43:53.000 |
up to $100,000 of business expenses, and that $100,000 could be-- 00:43:59.000 |
if your car were over a certain weight--then that $100,000 expense 00:44:06.000 |
So now, as a business owner, that allows you to purchase a $100,000 car 00:44:11.000 |
Because it's over a certain weight, though, it's not classified 00:44:15.000 |
And in excess of that--and you could expense the entire thing, 00:44:19.000 |
which means that you would save the $30,000 of taxes 00:44:22.000 |
that you otherwise would have incurred in buying the car 00:44:31.000 |
And in case you're wondering why I think that the tax-- 00:44:33.000 |
and why I and most economists think that the tax code 00:44:36.000 |
should be completely simplified, it's because rich people have the money 00:44:39.000 |
to sit around and pay people to--well, pay people to sit around 00:44:54.000 |
Hummer, Chevys, Suburbans--they should be over 6,000 pounds. 00:45:05.000 |
So then in 2004, Congress updated the tax code, 00:45:11.000 |
And instead of it being 6,000 pounds, then those limits became 14,000 pounds. 00:45:16.000 |
Well, now that disqualifies basically anything except an actual truck. 00:45:21.000 |
And there were still some limits for vehicles between 6,000 and 14,000 pounds, 00:45:26.000 |
but it's a much lower number, and there's a much lesser pool. 00:45:31.000 |
So now if you want to get your vehicle depreciation, 00:45:34.000 |
you're going to have to drive a big old truck every day, 00:45:39.000 |
This could still be applied to something like a heavy pickup truck, 00:45:42.000 |
and this would be valuable for you if you were running something like a construction company. 00:45:48.000 |
If you were deciding between a half-ton pickup truck and a one-ton pickup truck, 00:46:00.000 |
But here would be--and even with the limitations, though, the knowledge of this-- 00:46:04.000 |
I'll give you one example here, and I'll read from half of a paragraph from-- 00:46:10.000 |
This is Jeff Schnepper's "How to Pay Zero Taxes" book, 00:46:15.000 |
But from page 737--and this is last year's edition--it says, "In 2012-- 00:46:25.000 |
"If you buy a new $60,000 SUV with a loaded gross weight over 6,000 pounds, 00:46:35.000 |
So because it's over 6,000 pounds, you can expense the first $25,000, 00:46:39.000 |
but you can't expense the full amount like you used to be able to. 00:46:42.000 |
"Half the remaining $35,000 cost," which would be $17,500, 00:46:50.000 |
You also get 20% of the leftover basis," which would be $17,500, 00:46:58.000 |
Use the car 100% for business, and you get a $46,000 first-year deduction." 00:47:07.000 |
So the example here is if you are running a business, 00:47:12.000 |
and let's say that you're going to buy a $60,000 SUV-- 00:47:15.000 |
let me pause here and run the math real quick. 00:47:17.000 |
Okay, so I ran the math, and basically if you were to follow these rules, 00:47:21.000 |
it would allow you to buy a new $60,000 vehicle 00:47:24.000 |
for a cost of--out-of-pocket cost--of about $46,000 00:47:29.000 |
because of about $14,000 of savings due to a $46,000 first-year deduction 00:47:38.000 |
So this would be a good example of how, when someone's in a high bracket, 00:47:41.000 |
by accelerating the deduction by using this strategy, 00:47:45.000 |
and this would also be an example of a shifting strategy, of a conversion, 00:47:50.000 |
converting expenses if you could convert them over 00:47:53.000 |
from the personal checkbook over to the business checkbook, 00:47:57.000 |
this would be how you can make a major savings. 00:47:59.000 |
It allows you to buy a new $60,000 car for a cheaper price 00:48:03.000 |
than some other people might pay for a used car 00:48:05.000 |
because all those rules are only applicable to new cars. 00:48:08.000 |
So hopefully that's a good example to say that this stuff actually does matter. 00:48:12.000 |
I always get scared that I'm getting too deep, 00:48:14.000 |
and I don't know if I'm getting too deep or not. 00:48:17.000 |
You tell me if this was too deep or if this is good. 00:48:20.000 |
So you can accelerate deductions, and if you can accelerate deductions, 00:48:28.000 |
So if you can defer the recognition of income 00:48:33.000 |
that would be a really amazing thing as well. 00:48:38.000 |
because the IRA law is explicit about the fact 00:48:41.000 |
that you can defer recognizing the income for tax purposes 00:48:50.000 |
You have constructive receipt, which we'll talk about in just a minute. 00:48:53.000 |
It's on my notes to go over constructive receipt. 00:48:55.000 |
You have the receipt of the income so that you can go ahead and invest it. 00:49:00.000 |
So you can invest the money because you have received it. 00:49:02.000 |
It's in your 401(k) account, but it is not recognized for taxes. 00:49:07.000 |
And I'm going to go over constructive receipt in a minute 00:49:15.000 |
So that finishes up as far as the timing strategy 00:49:19.000 |
Well, what about if tax rates are going to change? 00:49:23.000 |
So this is why financial planning is in some ways a science 00:49:28.000 |
and why financial planning has to be integrated with economic analysis 00:49:35.000 |
When tax rates are constant, it's easy to do the math, 00:49:38.000 |
but we don't know what tax rates are going to do. 00:49:41.000 |
In the last 25 years, Congress has changed tax rates at least nine times. 00:49:49.000 |
So if you go back and look at it, you'll see what are the maximum tax rates 00:49:52.000 |
that are applied to ordinary income or capital gains. 00:49:59.000 |
So how do we know what Congress is going to do? 00:50:04.000 |
The marginal brackets changed just this last year, 00:50:07.000 |
and depending on what you think about the political climate of this country, 00:50:14.000 |
Which way is it going to change? I don't know. 00:50:16.000 |
Now, here's where you'd have to look at an individual situation 00:50:19.000 |
if you're talking about individual income taxes. 00:50:21.000 |
Are you in a very high bracket or are you in a moderate bracket? 00:50:24.000 |
The reality is that effective brackets haven't changed much for the majority of people, 00:50:32.000 |
So this is where you have to look at an individual. 00:50:35.000 |
So is the overall rate going to change, and what about your rate? 00:50:42.000 |
So is your rate going to change because you lowered your income, 00:50:47.000 |
because you raised your income, because you changed jobs, 00:50:49.000 |
because you retired, because you started a new business, 00:50:51.000 |
because you're pursuing a strategy of early financial independence? 00:50:55.000 |
Your own personal rates are going to be a major factor. 00:50:59.000 |
So we've got to figure out, are rates increasing or are rates decreasing? 00:51:04.000 |
And this is a big question, because depending on if rates are going up 00:51:07.000 |
or if rates are going down, then this is going to make a big difference 00:51:10.000 |
as far as should we bring income forward or should we defer income. 00:51:15.000 |
In general, the higher the rate, the higher the tax rate, 00:51:19.000 |
the higher the tax savings for a tax deduction. 00:51:22.000 |
The lower the tax rate, the lower the tax costs for taxable income. 00:51:27.000 |
So everything being equal, in general, you would want to recognize your deductions 00:51:33.000 |
during high tax rate years, and you would want to recognize income 00:51:39.000 |
So all things being equal for retirement, if you are going to be at a higher tax rate 00:51:43.000 |
while working than you are in retirement, which, by the way, most people will be, 00:51:46.000 |
you're going to want to recognize more of your deductions during your working years, 00:51:51.000 |
and you're going to want to defer your income towards your non-working years. 00:52:00.000 |
It's precise if you know what tax rates are going to be 00:52:02.000 |
and what your personal tax rate is going to be, 00:52:06.000 |
Now, you can do some calculations, some in general calculations, 00:52:13.000 |
and that's why you have to look at the personal numbers. 00:52:16.000 |
If tax rates are increasing--this is the really challenging one-- 00:52:20.000 |
because if tax rates are increasing, you have to do a complete calculation, 00:52:24.000 |
and you have to figure out what is the actual calculation. 00:52:30.000 |
There's no rule, because you would look and say, 00:52:35.000 |
Am I going from a 25% bracket to a 28% bracket?" 00:52:38.000 |
And then you would calculate the present value of a tax deduction 00:52:43.000 |
So you have to do the calculation, and I can't give you a rule for that. 00:52:49.000 |
then you're going to want to bring forward your deductions, 00:52:51.000 |
and you're going to want to push back and defer your income, 00:52:55.000 |
depending on whether rates are going up or rates are going down. 00:52:59.000 |
Are there some general strategies that you can pull from this? 00:53:02.000 |
I think there are, and that's why most financial planners 00:53:05.000 |
would rather you take deductions now rather than in retirement. 00:53:12.000 |
that you're going to be in a higher tax rate at retirement 00:53:19.000 |
if, indeed, tax rates stay similar to what they are now 00:53:25.000 |
However, is it possible that tax rates could change dramatically? 00:53:28.000 |
Sure they could. Brackets could change, absolutely. 00:53:31.000 |
And so is it likely that you're going to be? I don't know. It would depend. 00:53:34.000 |
Are you making $5 million a year or $50,000 a year? 00:53:37.000 |
There's no political will in this country for-- 00:53:42.000 |
to move the bulk of the tax burden onto people making $50,000 a year. 00:53:46.000 |
There is a tremendous, it seems, political will 00:53:49.000 |
to move the bulk of the tax burden onto people making $5 million a year. 00:53:53.000 |
So you would have to consider this for yourself. 00:53:57.000 |
So let's wrap up now with a couple of challenges 00:54:05.000 |
and then a couple of challenges and a couple of examples. 00:54:12.000 |
One of the limitations, for example, would be, in general, 00:54:15.000 |
if you're going-- let's say that you're going to invest in an asset. 00:54:24.000 |
You can defer recognizing the income on the stock 00:54:30.000 |
But you can't defer it any longer until you sell it, 00:54:33.000 |
assuming it's held in a taxable brokerage account. 00:54:41.000 |
you can't let the tail wag the dog, so to speak. 00:54:43.000 |
You can't let the tax strategy dictate your investment decisions. 00:54:49.000 |
and then figure out how to make them appropriate to the tax strategy. 00:54:55.000 |
you can see, then, how valuable some of the tools like tax-deferred accounts can be 00:55:00.000 |
because a tax-deferred account does allow you to-- 00:55:03.000 |
if you can do all of your trading in an account 00:55:05.000 |
that does allow you to defer the income completely, 00:55:11.000 |
Let's say you can do all of your trading inside of the Roth IRA. 00:55:14.000 |
Well, then now you can ignore the tax consequences of your trades, 00:55:17.000 |
and you can buy and sell, buy and sell, buy and sell, 00:55:20.000 |
because the tax consequences are already squared away. 00:55:24.000 |
But then again, you have to pay income taxes on that money. 00:55:29.000 |
It may be better for you to use--if you're using-- 00:55:31.000 |
you have limits as far as who can participate in those accounts. 00:55:34.000 |
So there's a lot of things interplaying here. 00:55:37.000 |
And in fact, I forgot--I was trying to stay away from using U.S.-centric examples. 00:55:43.000 |
today's show should be completely valid to your local tax environment 00:55:47.000 |
because the concepts are the same no matter what tax environment 00:55:50.000 |
and no matter what tax authority you're dealing with. 00:55:57.000 |
And then you get the whole question of can you afford to defer income. 00:56:00.000 |
If you are a single mom and you're raising--you're a single mom with three kids 00:56:05.000 |
and you're earning minimum wage, you probably can't afford to defer income. 00:56:09.000 |
So this whole idea of Joshua has this fancy tax strategy of, 00:56:12.000 |
"I'm going to defer my income," this is pointless. 00:56:15.000 |
This doesn't do any good for you because you need the money now. 00:56:18.000 |
But if you don't need the money, then there's a lot that you can do. 00:56:21.000 |
I was working on some tax strategies for an early retirement person, 00:56:29.000 |
and I was just struck by how if you are able to save a huge percentage of your income, 00:56:37.000 |
If you don't need the money that you're earning, 00:56:39.000 |
it's amazing how efficient you can be from a tax flow perspective. 00:56:43.000 |
So consider the non-tax scenarios and the tax scenarios. 00:56:48.000 |
You've got to always consider both of these things. 00:56:51.000 |
Are you going to defer income forward or are you going to pull it back? 00:56:53.000 |
And I want to finish with constructive receipt, 00:56:55.000 |
and this is both a limitation but an advantage. 00:56:58.000 |
So there is a doctrine in tax law that is called the constructive receipt doctrine. 00:57:04.000 |
And basically the idea is that if you receive money, if it is yours, 00:57:16.000 |
say you're an individual employee, then you would think, 00:57:18.000 |
"Well, if someone gives me money, then, yeah, I'm going to go ahead and get it." 00:57:24.000 |
So if I give you a check on December 1, 2014, 00:57:32.000 |
and I'm making a payment to you on December 1, 2014, 00:57:40.000 |
Do you receive the money on December 1, 2014? 00:57:43.000 |
Or if you just simply put the check in your drawer and don't cash it 00:57:48.000 |
until January 10, 2015, did you receive it on January 10, 2015? 00:58:02.000 |
Well, the answer is that you received it when I gave you the check 00:58:07.000 |
because you must report your income when the income is received, 00:58:12.000 |
whether it's received in the form of cash, received in the form of property, 00:58:17.000 |
You must recognize the income when it is actually or constructively received. 00:58:25.000 |
And so constructive receipt means that you are legally-- 00:58:33.000 |
if the income has been credited to your account 00:58:36.000 |
or if the income is unconditionally available to you 00:58:41.000 |
or if you are aware of the income's availability to you 00:58:45.000 |
and if there are no restrictions on the taxpayer's control over the income. 00:59:01.000 |
and there's no restrictions on your control over the income. 00:59:08.000 |
Let's say that you work for me as an employee 00:59:12.000 |
and you're going to receive a bonus check at the end of the year, 00:59:16.000 |
But you don't want--and it's a $100,000 bonus-- 00:59:19.000 |
but you don't want to get the $100,000 bonus, 00:59:23.000 |
"I'm going to go away and I'm going to take the last two weeks of the year off, 00:59:26.000 |
"and I'm not going to go into work and pick up the check, 00:59:28.000 |
"and I'm going to pretend I don't know that it's there." 00:59:38.000 |
You could go into your box at work or into your desk 00:59:43.000 |
So even though you said, "I'm not going to go in and get it," 00:59:51.000 |
does the IRS catch most people that do things like this 00:59:53.000 |
when they push things forward or push things back? 00:59:59.000 |
Does the IRS really care if you are going to screw around 01:00:08.000 |
Probably--I mean, they care if they're auditing you, 01:00:15.000 |
And that's where the IRS is going to get involved. 01:00:21.000 |
will actually influence just about all of our planning. 01:00:24.000 |
And when we get to talking through financial planning strategies 01:00:27.000 |
such as, let's say, non-qualified deferred compensation programs, 01:00:40.000 |
Has the employee received--constructively received the money, 01:00:47.000 |
And when you, as a business consultant or a benefits consultant-- 01:00:53.000 |
let's say I'm designing--let's say I'm working with a physician, okay? 01:00:56.000 |
And this physician has a small independent medical practice. 01:00:58.000 |
Let's ignore group practice because that's more complicated. 01:01:06.000 |
"Joshua, I need help with my tax planning strategies." 01:01:08.000 |
Well, frankly, if you're earning $500,000 a year, 01:01:14.000 |
A $17,500 that you can defer may be an additional $5,000, 01:01:18.000 |
so a total of $22,500 that you can defer out of your income 01:01:24.000 |
And a business--let's see what that number is. 01:01:32.000 |
"I can defer a total of 5% of my income into-- 01:01:45.000 |
I'm 55 years old, I'm a successful physician, 01:01:53.000 |
and I'm just sick and tired of this tax bill that I have. 01:01:58.000 |
So let's say then that I can go ahead and I can say, 01:02:01.000 |
"Well, let's design your 401(k) plan properly, 01:02:06.000 |
So let's design it where instead of the $22,500 limit, 01:02:12.000 |
and let's get you to the ability to defer $17,500 01:02:17.000 |
So you can contribute $50,000, and then on top of that, 01:02:22.000 |
So now we're at a point where we're doing $55,000 01:02:31.000 |
All we need is just simply to strike the documents appropriately. 01:02:36.000 |
Now he's deferring--you know, he's basically taking 10% of his income. 01:02:40.000 |
But he says, "Look, I'm 55 years old. I still can't afford it." 01:02:43.000 |
Well, now we move over into the world of non-qualified deferred comp. 01:02:48.000 |
"How can we set up a plan to allow you to defer-- 01:02:51.000 |
can we do a couple hundred thousand dollars a year?" 01:02:53.000 |
Well, the answer is yes, and we are not going to go into it today, 01:02:57.000 |
but we can set up a plan so he can defer $250,000 of income into this plan. 01:03:02.000 |
We've got to set it up with him and his employees. 01:03:05.000 |
We've got to make sure that we're very careful in how we do it. 01:03:08.000 |
But we need to make sure that he does not have constructive receipt of the money. 01:03:16.000 |
Because if he has constructive receipt of the money, 01:03:21.000 |
So we have to make sure that this is still an asset of the business 01:03:25.000 |
This is still--that we have to make sure that this is available to his creditors. 01:03:32.000 |
then we need to make sure that this retirement plan is available to his creditors. 01:03:35.000 |
And this brings in--if you're a financial planning student, 01:03:37.000 |
this would be why you can only do non-qualified deferred comp 01:03:44.000 |
So if you're taking a CFP exam, if you ever see S corp 01:03:47.000 |
and non-qualified deferred comp, you know that's wrong. 01:03:49.000 |
Non-qualified deferred comp must--is only useful in C corporations. 01:03:54.000 |
And the reason is because it has to remain an asset of the business 01:03:59.000 |
Or you could--we'd have to make--so then you would--so you say, 01:04:04.000 |
"Well, can we get some other protection in place?" 01:04:08.000 |
You know, "Could we set up a rabbi trust?" is what it's called. 01:04:10.000 |
If you're a financial planning student, you need to understand what a rabbi trust is. 01:04:18.000 |
I went too deep. I didn't mean to go into that. 01:04:23.000 |
In tax planning, you only need to understand the doctrine of constructive receipt. 01:04:27.000 |
And if you understand the doctrine of constructive receipt, 01:04:30.000 |
you now understand why it's important when you receive the income 01:04:35.000 |
and you can--and you receive the income when it is available to you as a person. 01:04:50.000 |
Again, I would crave your feedback on these shows. 01:04:56.000 |
And I don't promise to change anything because you let me know, 01:04:58.000 |
but I do want to know because what I want to do is I want to strike the balance. 01:05:02.000 |
I want to kind of provide something for everybody, 01:05:04.000 |
but I don't want you to listen to this and get my show and get the same old, same old-- 01:05:08.000 |
I want you to listen and have 18 tips for couponing every day 01:05:11.000 |
because the reality is there's more that you can do with that. 01:05:13.000 |
And hopefully you feel--hopefully you are smarter today. 01:05:16.000 |
Hopefully you are more educated about taxes and about income timing strategies. 01:05:22.000 |
Income timing, you can do some wizardry with income timing strategies 01:05:27.000 |
if you are off the mainstream, or even if--you could do some amazing stuff with income timing. 01:05:32.000 |
If you haven't checked out what the Madfientist is doing over on his site, 01:05:38.000 |
His site is madfientist, F-I-E-N-T-I-S-T dot com. 01:05:41.000 |
All of his strategies are--most of his strategies are income timing strategies. 01:05:47.000 |
And he interviewed--there's another blog you should check out. 01:05:51.000 |
Let me make a note to make sure I get it in the show notes called Go Curry Cracker, 01:05:56.000 |
a crazy blog name, but these guys are writing a lot about taxes 01:06:00.000 |
from an early retirement financial independence--Go Curry Cracker--and Madfientist. 01:06:09.000 |
But all that they're doing is income timing strategies. 01:06:12.000 |
So what I mean is that Brandon, for example, he is writing this-- 01:06:17.000 |
he has this awesome case study on his site which is really accessible to you, 01:06:20.000 |
and he goes through and shows how if you can earn a reasonable wage 01:06:24.000 |
and if you can live on a very small amount of it, 01:06:26.000 |
you can use some very straightforward 401(k) deductions, HSA deductions, IRA deductions. 01:06:33.000 |
You can use some very straightforward tax planning techniques 01:06:36.000 |
to push off the timing of the income to a future date. 01:06:42.000 |
You can use the transition from a 401(k) or from an IRA into a Roth IRA, 01:06:48.000 |
and you can basically get the income with zero taxes associated with it. 01:06:52.000 |
So he's doing a really great job of showing how this type of strategy can work in that scenario. 01:06:57.000 |
That's not going to work if you're earning $5 million a year 01:07:00.000 |
and you're listening to my show and saying, "How can I do this? 01:07:02.000 |
We need to use something else, but we're still going to be using an income timing strategy." 01:07:06.000 |
So hopefully by understanding this strategy a little bit more and having some good examples, 01:07:10.000 |
then you can start thinking to yourself, "Should I bring my income forward or should I defer it? 01:07:15.000 |
What's my rates going to be? Are my rates going to be constant? 01:07:18.000 |
And if my rates are constant, then I'm going to defer income 01:07:22.000 |
If my rates are increasing, then I'm going to do the math. 01:07:27.000 |
Excuse me, if my rates are decreasing, then I'm going to bring deductions forward 01:07:32.000 |
And hopefully you can start to think this way. 01:07:34.000 |
Hopefully that's a good place to end on today's show. 01:07:41.000 |
I want to know if you've heard this anywhere else in any of the podcasts, let me know. 01:07:47.000 |
If you've headed to luxury automobile depreciation, non-qualified deferred comp, 01:07:52.000 |
and Roth IRA early retirement strategies, I hope I didn't lose you. 01:07:58.000 |
I hope I didn't lose you. My disease is trying to pack too much. 01:08:01.000 |
I'm trying to make these shorter and make them more doable. 01:08:05.000 |
Hey, an hour and seven minutes right now for the recording. 01:08:07.000 |
That's pretty good. I'm pretty proud of that. 01:08:09.000 |
Going to have some more shows lined up for you this week, 01:08:12.000 |
and I'm going to continue these tax planning shows little by little as time goes on. 01:08:17.000 |
We're going to do some insurance stuff. We're going to do some investment stuff. 01:08:20.000 |
We're going to do some college stuff. I've got a bunch of these shows planned. 01:08:26.000 |
Two action steps for you, three action steps for you. 01:08:29.000 |
If you've enjoyed the show or if you hated the show, let me know. 01:08:32.000 |
RadicalPF is me on Twitter, so shoot me a tweet @radicalpf or shoot me an email at Joshua@radicalpersonalfinance.com. 01:08:44.000 |
Thing two, I would request, please go and rate the show on iTunes. 01:08:52.000 |
If you loved it, say, "I loved this show," and that rating would be so, so helpful to help people find the show. 01:08:57.000 |
One of the things that when people are looking at shows, they look a lot at the ratings, 01:09:01.000 |
and the ratings and the number of reviews makes a huge difference. 01:09:04.000 |
So please, I would just ask you, if you want to support the show, go and leave a rating on iTunes. 01:09:12.000 |
I'm going to be, as soon as I'm able to, little by little, I'm going to be adjusting the email list a little bit 01:09:18.000 |
to try to bring more content and make it look nicer as I'm able to. 01:09:21.000 |
But for now, go and sign up for the email list, and you'll get the full, complete show notes every day, 01:09:26.000 |
both for your files with the resources, recommendations, and also so you can hear about the show 01:09:31.000 |
and see if it's a subject that you're interested in that you want to listen to 01:09:34.000 |
or if it's a subject that you want to skip for the day. 01:09:39.000 |
Go kick some butt and figure out your own income timing strategy. 01:09:59.000 |
When you download the Ralphs app, you have easy access to savings every day. 01:10:04.000 |
Get the most out of weekly sales and receive personalized coupons to save on your favorite items, 01:10:08.000 |
all while earning one Fuel Point for every dollar spent. 01:10:11.000 |
Ralphs makes it easy to save while you shop, whether it's in-store or online, 01:10:16.000 |
so you get the most value out of every trip, every time. 01:10:19.000 |
Download the Ralphs app now to save big on your next purchase. 01:10:24.000 |
Must have a digital account to redeem offers? Restrictions may apply. See site for details.