back to indexPublic_Universities
00:00:00.000 |
Hello everybody, it's Sam from Financial Samurai and in this episode we want to talk about 00:00:04.840 |
why more public schools will eventually rank higher than private schools. 00:00:08.760 |
So if you have kids or if you went to college, I think this is a really interesting conversation 00:00:19.000 |
So you may not know, but Sydney and I, we met at the College of William & Mary when 00:00:26.760 |
We met in Japanese 101 class and we hit it off. 00:00:29.920 |
So William & Mary is a public school and when I went, the freshman and sophomore year was 00:00:35.160 |
about $2,800 a year in tuition, which I thought was a great deal. 00:00:40.720 |
And the main reason why I didn't want to go to a private school, I got into Babson College, 00:00:44.560 |
which is a small private college, but at the time it was like $25,000 a year. 00:00:48.840 |
So I thought back then going to William & Mary was good value. 00:00:52.420 |
What did you think about going to William & Mary? 00:00:54.760 |
I also wanted to go to a state school, not that far from home, not that big, that offered 00:01:05.000 |
Oh, speaking of liberal arts, it is a liberal arts school and so many people kind of bash 00:01:10.880 |
You know, they think you should go into STEM, you know, the sciences and so forth. 00:01:16.460 |
But I'm not sure that's correct because I know a lot of really awkward people who are 00:01:21.680 |
very one-dimensional after graduating from college and when you apply to jobs like at 00:01:27.200 |
Goldman Sachs, McKinsey, any of these firms that pay pretty well, I think they're looking 00:01:32.840 |
for more well-rounded people who can learn, adapt, work in teams, socialize, and communicate. 00:01:39.980 |
So as a hiring manager for over 10 years or about 10 years, what are your thoughts about 00:01:44.680 |
the argument that it's better to go to a liberal arts school rather than a school and focus 00:01:51.840 |
I definitely agree with what you're saying about finding well-rounded people. 00:01:56.120 |
I wouldn't necessarily exclude a candidate based on going to a technical school, but 00:02:04.480 |
having someone who is open-minded and able to communicate well with a lot of people and 00:02:14.200 |
has a bunch of skills that can be applied to many different types of roles is really 00:02:22.120 |
So yeah, and I guess technical is not the right word, you know, science, STEM stuff. 00:02:27.840 |
It just seems like when you graduate college and you join any kind of job, you learn on 00:02:34.040 |
So I think the most important ability is to be able to learn, try hard, and figure things 00:02:39.640 |
out and adapt rather than think, "Hey, you know these things from textbooks and these 00:02:46.160 |
things from projects, and you're going to hit the ground running." 00:02:49.880 |
I don't think it really is the case in most cases. 00:02:55.800 |
There's a lot of things that you're not going to be able to learn in college that's going 00:02:59.960 |
to be applicable to a specific role that you're getting hired for. 00:03:04.360 |
That was definitely the case for the company that I was working for. 00:03:08.640 |
All of our software was proprietary, so nobody could learn that software outside of our company. 00:03:16.600 |
But what we were really looking for were people who were detail-oriented, people who could 00:03:20.720 |
follow instructions, people who could communicate well. 00:03:24.680 |
Those are skills that you could pick up at any school or just in high school as well. 00:03:31.880 |
But I definitely agree with your point on finding well-rounded people. 00:03:39.120 |
So back to the topic about rankings, college rankings. 00:03:42.600 |
I think college rankings, a lot of students and parents are obsessed with them. 00:03:47.960 |
They're fun to look at, but they're frankly kind of boring in my mind. 00:03:52.400 |
US News and World Report always has their college rankings every year, and it's always 00:03:56.580 |
the same five, ten schools every single year. 00:04:01.440 |
It's like Harvard, Princeton, Yale, yada, yada, yada. 00:04:11.280 |
Why do you keep on pumping out these rankings with the same type of schools over and over 00:04:17.420 |
One of the things that came out of the college admissions bribery scandal, also called Operation 00:04:22.480 |
Varsity Blues in 2019, is that I was under the assumption and I was predicting that private 00:04:31.840 |
schools, elite private schools, would lose some of its luster, some of its prestige and 00:04:36.480 |
reputation because we found out that already wealthy families were bribing their kids' 00:04:43.960 |
way into these schools in the tune of it was like 10 grand, 50 grand to $6 million. 00:04:51.360 |
Schools such as Georgetown, Stanford, UCLA, which is a public school, University of San 00:04:55.400 |
Diego, USC, Wake Forest, and Yale, those were the schools all involved in the scandal. 00:05:01.480 |
I thought, "Well, I think the world is going to wake up to the fact that, huh, the system 00:05:08.440 |
You learned about the admissions criteria at Harvard where they have these really subjective 00:05:12.640 |
scales and they rate people by their personality and stuff like that, and it's very different 00:05:20.600 |
It just seemed like this whole scandal would wake the world up, parents and students, to 00:05:27.000 |
how rigged the college ranking system is and how it's kind of all BS in a way because you 00:05:34.680 |
can just bribe your way in through the back door or through the front door. 00:05:40.600 |
What are your thoughts on college rankings in general and spending big bucks on private 00:05:46.600 |
universities versus going to a more affordable state school? 00:05:50.120 |
I think that the rankings can be helpful when applying to college, but I don't think they 00:05:55.960 |
should be taken so seriously as some people do. 00:05:59.520 |
I think nobody really cares after a few years of working where you went to school. 00:06:06.040 |
The only people who care are students currently in college, the parents of students who are 00:06:12.520 |
currently in college, and maybe one year out. 00:06:15.880 |
The funny joke here in San Francisco Bay Area is how do you know if someone went to Stanford? 00:06:20.920 |
They'll tell you in the first one or two seconds. 00:06:24.600 |
I'm assuming that's the same joke in Boston with Harvard and Connecticut with Yale and 00:06:30.760 |
so forth because when you're a student, you're a cost center. 00:06:35.100 |
You just know stuff from the books and you kind of theorize how things are going to be. 00:06:40.000 |
As a cost center in your early 20s, you need to be diligent. 00:06:46.880 |
If you have to go to work on time, you got to ask how you can help and create more value 00:06:53.840 |
Eventually, you're going to start earning money for the company and so forth. 00:06:58.540 |
But in that crucial time period, hustling very hard at work, I think is very important. 00:07:04.440 |
In terms of the college rankings, I was very pleased to see that Forbes changed its college 00:07:10.840 |
You know, it took a break in 2020 due to the pandemic, but in 2021, it decided to increase 00:07:18.160 |
the weighting of the percentage of poor students who applied and got into school as a ranking 00:07:26.640 |
So, quote, it said, "It isn't enough to ask which schools give the best return on investment. 00:07:32.700 |
It's also important to evaluate what kind of students they educate and whether they 00:07:36.640 |
make themselves accessible to those who can't afford high sticker prices. 00:07:41.600 |
Even if like Harvard, they promise to pay full freight for the low-income applicants 00:07:45.120 |
they accept, do they take enough disadvantaged students to make that promise meaningful? 00:07:50.720 |
UC Berkeley does a much better job at this than Harvard. 00:07:55.320 |
At Berkeley, 27% of undergraduates receive federal Pell grants aimed at helping low and 00:08:03.240 |
At Harvard, by contrast, the share of Pell students is just 12%. 00:08:07.560 |
Meanwhile, the Harvard endowment is tens of billions of dollars. 00:08:12.360 |
And on average, 25% of students enrolled in our 600 top colleges received Pell grants. 00:08:18.200 |
So Harvard is way below the average, like 60% below the average. 00:08:22.660 |
So in other words, Forbes decided to look at the hard data and not just accept lip service 00:08:29.880 |
It's really easy for the marketers at private elite schools with massive, massive endowments 00:08:35.600 |
to say that they're doing their best to provide equal opportunities for all people. 00:08:42.320 |
A lot of schools, their goal is to try to educate people and to help people. 00:08:46.780 |
But if they really wanted to educate as many people as possible and help as many people 00:08:54.800 |
Why not accept more people and get that education, give them that education? 00:09:01.520 |
And further, they would also accept a higher percentage of students from low income households. 00:09:10.920 |
And the reason why is once you're rich, and once you're hanging around with other rich 00:09:14.720 |
people, you kind of just go with that inertia and you want to hang out with other rich people 00:09:20.520 |
and other connected people and other families who are going to donate money and do this 00:09:27.400 |
Yeah, this actually reminds me of our preschool application process where we were looking 00:09:32.760 |
at a bunch of different preschools across San Francisco. 00:09:36.140 |
And a lot of them will say in their marketing, "Our school values diversity and inclusion." 00:09:44.520 |
And then when you go and you go to an open house, for example, or you just learn more 00:09:51.780 |
about what's really going on at that school from people you know who have attended there 00:09:56.440 |
and whatnot, you find out that very few of these schools are actually doing what they 00:10:05.560 |
We went to, I think, five preschool open houses, and they talked about diversity and inclusion. 00:10:11.800 |
And I think most of the kids, like 90% of the kids were white. 00:10:19.120 |
Whereas the city of San Francisco is a minority-majority city. 00:10:27.040 |
And so to be so different in terms of reflecting the demographics of the city felt so jolting 00:10:35.320 |
to us that we decided we didn't want to send our kids to such a school. 00:10:40.780 |
No matter how much they say in their marketing material or the website that they're looking 00:10:46.400 |
I think it's clear, it's clear it's not true. 00:10:52.360 |
And I think if you talk to people from certain elite private universities, it's so amazing 00:11:01.360 |
what a high percentage of these families already come from wealth. 00:11:06.720 |
So if you're curious about the Forbes College Rankings for 2021 and 2022, they are from 00:11:12.840 |
top to bottom, Berkeley, Yale, Princeton, Stanford, Columbia, MIT, Harvard, UCLA, UPenn, 00:11:21.520 |
Number 10, Northwestern, Dartmouth, Duke, Cornell, Vanderbilt, Number 15, UC San Diego, 00:11:27.080 |
Amherst, USC, Williams, Pomona, UC Davis at number 20, Georgetown, Michigan, University 00:11:33.720 |
of Chicago, Rice, and University of Florida at number 25. 00:11:38.600 |
And I think obviously there's going to be some uproar, some pushback from the traditional 00:11:44.080 |
institutions that have always been in the top 10, especially if you're an alumni. 00:11:57.920 |
But if you understand the methodology, I think it is something that we need to be aware of 00:12:03.480 |
and how other ranking systems, whether it's from The Economist or any other magazine, 00:12:10.160 |
they are probably going to be changing their variable weightings going forward to reflect 00:12:16.960 |
changing society, changing demands of society. 00:12:19.400 |
And if they don't change, so if US News and World Report doesn't change, I think they're 00:12:30.600 |
Times are changing and the rankings should change with it. 00:12:34.600 |
I mean, I think everything is changing, so you got to change with the times. 00:12:38.800 |
You know, I think back to my high school days, my family didn't have the money to pay for 00:12:43.160 |
$2,000 Princeton review classes and $50 an hour after school tutors. 00:12:48.360 |
Instead, my parents told me to go to the library and borrow an SAT book. 00:12:52.160 |
And the SAT book was already all marked up and scratched. 00:12:54.760 |
And I would say 90% of the time, the answers are already filled in. 00:13:03.520 |
And so when I got a mediocre SAT score, they just told me to try again. 00:13:08.280 |
And when I could score no higher, that was it. 00:13:11.540 |
They weren't like in a panic, "Oh, you didn't get a 1200. 00:13:16.000 |
We're going to have to put money behind you raising your score." 00:13:20.720 |
They just said, "Yeah, that's the way it's going to be." 00:13:30.960 |
I did get my parents to get me a book from Barnes & Noble, which I don't even think exists 00:13:40.940 |
They didn't have the experience or the education to know what it was like to apply to colleges. 00:13:51.800 |
And I guess there's a definite benefit for figuring things out on your own. 00:13:58.440 |
It's this indelible memory that drives me to keep Financial Samurai always free. 00:14:03.120 |
I always think back to the kid sitting with me in the library, trying to study or try 00:14:11.160 |
And if I'm going to put up a paywall, it just feels like an anathema. 00:14:16.720 |
And so I hope more and more people can learn about personal finances, learn about other 00:14:22.840 |
things through this podcast or my writing for free. 00:14:25.920 |
So in conclusion, I guess I want to talk about the cost of private school versus public school 00:14:34.640 |
Let's say you send your kid to private school from kindergarten through the 12th grade. 00:14:45.560 |
And if you let it grow, let's say you invested it instead, it probably would double to, let's 00:14:54.280 |
And then if you go to private university, that's another right now it's like $70,000 00:15:01.400 |
So we're talking let's say a million dollars from kindergarten through college, a million 00:15:09.000 |
So if you could rewind back time and I told you as a 8-year-old or 10-year-old or 12-year-old, 00:15:17.320 |
you know, "Daddy will give you a big, big check if you decide to go to public school 00:15:23.560 |
and public university or you can go to private school and get no check." 00:15:29.880 |
First of all, at 8 or 12 years old, I don't think I would have any understanding of what 00:15:43.040 |
But I don't think a child is gonna understand that question. 00:15:50.880 |
We can convert it from money to toys, to free time, to whatever. 00:15:56.520 |
We can change that currency from money to something they really care about. 00:15:59.760 |
Or I mean if you tell any child, "Do you want more toys?" 00:16:03.360 |
They're gonna say yes, but they're not gonna really think about what they could possibly 00:16:10.080 |
Yeah, I just – the personal finance side of me just thinks, "Man, just give me the 00:16:22.320 |
Let's say 50,000 the first year, 60,000 next year, all that, you know, so that I don't 00:16:30.920 |
But it just seems like if we're going to school to get a purposeful and meaningful 00:16:35.800 |
job to be able to make money, to then have our own freedom, why don't we just give 00:16:43.120 |
the million-dollar check to our kids and therefore it would buy immediate freedom right away 00:16:49.120 |
or they could feel little pressure so they can really pursue their dreams. 00:16:56.280 |
However, I think everybody's circumstances are different. 00:17:00.200 |
Even if you have, let's say, the same net worth as another family but you live in a 00:17:06.240 |
different state or a different city, the circumstances could be totally different. 00:17:11.100 |
Public schools vary so much even from one neighboring zip code to the next. 00:17:18.000 |
And for me, it's just hard to break that down to something so simple because, I don't 00:17:25.040 |
know, I just think there's so many variables. 00:17:27.640 |
It's so simple to me because so long as you're not getting beaten up, abused, picked on at 00:17:34.920 |
a school, I think you are in a good enough setting where you can learn. 00:17:40.360 |
Now of course, right, if your child is just getting pummeled to a pulp every single week 00:17:46.600 |
because the kids are bad and the parents are totally neglecting their own children which 00:17:51.320 |
causes bullying, then yeah, you should change schools and protect your child at all cost. 00:17:57.640 |
But if a school is free and it's good enough, I don't see why that's so bad. 00:18:11.000 |
Well, I just think that yes, a school is there to teach children but you have to look at 00:18:20.000 |
not just necessarily if the school is public or private but also what kind of resources 00:18:27.640 |
How long have the teachers been at that school? 00:18:33.400 |
How involved is the community and the parents? 00:18:36.460 |
There's just so many different variables for each individual school whether or not they're 00:18:43.380 |
But I totally see where you're coming from, right, from a financial, you know, personal 00:18:51.080 |
Of course you want to help people gain financial independence sooner rather than later and 00:18:58.440 |
going to a public school versus private is a very good way to come out with more money. 00:19:14.940 |
Like if you attend private school, that money could be invested elsewhere. 00:19:20.140 |
However, but it's not just about the cost of the school. 00:19:23.940 |
It's also what happens after you graduate, right? 00:19:38.420 |
Yeah, I'm just going to say no to that because your view is that our decisions to go to public 00:19:45.580 |
school and public university were the wrong, were the suboptimal ones. 00:19:57.100 |
We were able to build a passive income portfolio so we can, we both were able to leave our 00:20:02.820 |
Now if I had gone to private school, I think my parents would be settled with a lot more 00:20:08.100 |
I think I would have felt a lot more pressure to be somebody, to make that money, to like 00:20:17.100 |
I knew that even if I was a failure, I couldn't get any job out of college. 00:20:21.180 |
I could just go back to my day job at McDonald's or my part-time job at McDonald's back then, 00:20:25.900 |
you know, at $4 an hour and pay my parents back the $2,800 in a relatively short period 00:20:31.780 |
I guess, I guess where I'm coming from is I'm focused more in my head on what happens 00:20:38.740 |
before you get to college, you know, grade school, private versus public. 00:20:43.860 |
I know we're talking about college rankings here, but I think when you think about public 00:20:49.820 |
versus private, you have to look at the whole picture of education that starts. 00:20:56.540 |
When you talk about whole picture, it's just like, how do you quantify whole picture? 00:21:01.380 |
All we can quantify is what we've experienced and we experienced public schools. 00:21:06.940 |
I guess you went to private school for high school. 00:21:11.820 |
But I also went to private international school when I was abroad and I just saw, okay, yeah, 00:21:17.260 |
the characters or my classmates and public school were a little bit rougher, just kind 00:21:20.620 |
of like my softball friends are a little bit, a little bit rougher on the edges. 00:21:26.220 |
But I think these situations, this is real world here. 00:21:31.380 |
It's not, you know, we got all the money and we can shelter our children from all of life's 00:21:36.420 |
I guess the other way, the other thing that I'm thinking about is when you're a student 00:21:42.180 |
going to college, you've learned so much more. 00:21:46.220 |
You're much more mature going into college as, you know, typically 18 year old student 00:21:59.060 |
So whether or not you go to a public or private college, I just think it's from a student 00:22:07.660 |
So you're saying you're saying you'd be more amenable to sending your child to a public 00:22:18.900 |
So four years out of 18 years of education, we can do the public school route. 00:22:24.220 |
So now I got to work on the high school, right? 00:22:26.980 |
I think, I mean, I think when you're 14, I don't know. 00:22:32.220 |
I don't know if you're mature or our kids will be mature enough to say, okay, going 00:22:42.060 |
Well, just speaking from my own experience, I was attending public school at age 14 and 00:22:52.060 |
There was so much violence in my school and there were gangs, there were fights in the 00:22:59.620 |
Literally, I remember walking down the hallway trying to figure out how am I going to get 00:23:03.540 |
to class when these girls are cat fighting, pulling each other's hair out, screaming, 00:23:15.060 |
I think you were traumatized by that experience. 00:23:17.260 |
I was traumatized by that and so many other experiences with bullying and whatnot. 00:23:23.900 |
And I wasn't, although our school, our public school had advanced classes that I was fortunate 00:23:32.420 |
to be in, I still feel like I wasn't being academically challenged as much as I could 00:23:38.780 |
have and I wasn't comfortable in so many ways. 00:23:42.540 |
And I ended up switching to private school in 11th grade because I begged my parents 00:23:51.980 |
I have a solution for our debate and our dilemma. 00:23:57.740 |
So in any good compromise, one person gives a little, the other person gives a little. 00:24:03.660 |
So since we have two children, what we should do is send one of our children to public school 00:24:10.340 |
and another one of our children to private school and then we can do a test and see how 00:24:23.180 |
In conclusion, I say to all of you, the school matters, but I don't think it matters as much 00:24:32.540 |
Over time, where we go to college, where we go to high school, middle school, elementary 00:24:36.660 |
school, I think it's going to matter less and less because everything is online for 00:24:42.580 |
And you just have to be aware of the changing times. 00:24:45.020 |
I think more public universities are going to dominate the rankings going forward because 00:24:51.060 |
society as a whole is looking to be more inclusive of the middle class, the lower income and 00:25:02.920 |
So for those of you looking to save money or who couldn't get into a lead private school, 00:25:11.160 |
And at the end of the day, I don't really even think it matters because we have so many 00:25:15.380 |
resources at hand to be able to live our lives better. 00:25:21.460 |
And if you enjoyed this episode, we'd love a positive review because it'll keep us going. 00:25:26.220 |
And if it's a negative review, we probably will just take a long break.