back to indexWhen should your asset allocation change? | Portfolio Rescue 51
Chapters
0:0 Intro
4:47 How asset allocation strategy should change with net wortth.
11:50 Real returns for bonds.
14:50 I-bonds.
20:58 Retirement planning.
25:40 Monte Carlo analysis.
00:00:19.540 |
where we take questions straight from you, the viewers. 00:00:24.040 |
Thanks to the live viewers, as always, on YouTube. 00:00:28.840 |
We used to do it at, what, 11 in the morning? 00:00:33.520 |
The only reason we changed is 'cause Duncan is such a diva 00:00:39.000 |
It just worked out easier for everyone's schedule. 00:00:44.960 |
Duncan, one of the themes I've been writing about 00:00:48.140 |
I think 2014 was the first post I did in this. 00:00:52.680 |
I think I'm coming up with my 10-year anniversary here. 00:00:56.880 |
Is the fact that market cycles are getting faster. 00:01:00.240 |
The markets are more mature, they're more global in nature. 00:01:06.480 |
just makes things travel faster and move faster. 00:01:10.280 |
that just have their tentacles just into the market now 00:01:16.400 |
and 2020 made this a permanent feature, potentially. 00:01:19.420 |
I actually listened to Jay Powell's press conference 00:01:26.660 |
It's a little dry, but for people like me, I didn't mind. 00:01:29.700 |
And he basically took a soft landing off the table 00:01:35.700 |
"tighten financial conditions to the point of 00:01:37.540 |
"basically a recession, but if we go into a recession, 00:01:43.160 |
And I think this massaging of cycles at the extremes 00:01:47.980 |
to we're gonna provide tons of ammo when things are bad 00:01:55.620 |
on the other side and things get really good, 00:02:00.940 |
So we're gonna go from a recession in 2020 to a boom, 00:02:04.380 |
to a recession, to potentially another boom, who knows? 00:02:07.580 |
And I mean, it feels like we've had 11 cycles 00:02:11.320 |
We started out with like 1918 because of pandemic 00:02:13.740 |
and then we had like 1929 'cause we felt like 00:02:23.420 |
I guess the last year has been like the 70s kind of, 00:02:28.060 |
which is the last time the Fed threw us into recession. 00:02:30.740 |
And I think the fact that these faster cycles, 00:02:41.620 |
"I should be hedging, I should be making changes. 00:02:45.740 |
All these things where I think it makes it harder 00:02:47.460 |
for investors to just stick to a long-term plan 00:02:49.180 |
because these cycles feel like they're moving faster. 00:02:51.420 |
In the past, you had these cycles that would take 00:03:07.460 |
And I think people need to actually slow themselves down 00:03:12.540 |
But I think everything with the market structure 00:03:16.000 |
and I'm not trying to blame everything on the Fed here, 00:03:18.420 |
is just that I think it's harder for people to slow down 00:03:21.020 |
and pump the brakes on their own decision-making process 00:03:29.260 |
- Do you think, would it have a meaningful impact 00:03:34.580 |
"We're not gonna pay more than $12 for a Chipotle burrito"? 00:03:41.420 |
Because that's a big, maybe guac should just be free. 00:03:48.020 |
All right, I don't know if that's gonna happen. 00:03:55.640 |
But also, yeah, I mean, the serious part of that question 00:03:57.940 |
is like, yeah, it seems like people just aren't willing to, 00:04:16.540 |
there's gonna be good times, there's gonna be bad times. 00:04:18.000 |
I think that's the hard thing for people to do 00:04:21.700 |
to optimize your strategy for every single market cycle, 00:04:24.700 |
and I'm gonna have this kind of portfolio for this cycle, 00:04:29.740 |
that's durable enough to handle all these cycles, 00:04:31.480 |
as opposed to trying to make changes all the time, 00:04:36.420 |
and then when you have the pivot and you miss it, 00:04:38.300 |
then you think, oh, crap, my portfolio looks great 00:04:47.020 |
- Okay, up first we have a question from Ben. 00:04:57.300 |
with $10 million in net worth have the same allocation 00:05:09.040 |
- So the bulk of my career before coming to Ritholtz 00:05:12.600 |
That's like foundations, endowments, nonprofits, 00:05:17.080 |
like to call themselves sophisticated, right? 00:05:26.920 |
and some of the teams would focus on hedge funds 00:05:34.640 |
that the financial markets present a complex solution 00:05:42.600 |
sometimes assume that just has to be the case, right? 00:05:50.360 |
Like managing a pool of capital that's a billion dollars, 00:05:54.380 |
but I don't think just because you have more money 00:05:56.080 |
means you have to all of a sudden complicate things. 00:05:58.120 |
There's this old saying that you don't go to church 00:06:02.120 |
It's like you shouldn't try to reinvent the wheel 00:06:08.160 |
the things that matter most when creating an investment plan 00:06:10.900 |
So that's your willingness, need, and ability to take risk. 00:06:15.340 |
when are you actually gonna have to spend the money, 00:06:17.380 |
your current circumstances, where you are financially, 00:06:19.300 |
and then your goals, where you're going to be. 00:06:20.900 |
Those things are the only thing that's gonna matter. 00:06:24.380 |
that's hundreds of millions or billions of dollars, 00:06:34.100 |
And so I think that's the main building block, 00:06:47.100 |
it's kind of murky because let's say you're lucky enough 00:06:49.540 |
to have a high net worth and then millions of dollars, 00:07:02.340 |
But you don't have the need to take more risk 00:07:11.960 |
So then it comes down to your willingness to take risk. 00:07:19.380 |
How comfortable am I with keeping things the way they are? 00:07:37.820 |
and put it on private equity and venture capital 00:07:43.200 |
potentially high-reward funds and just invested it all 00:07:49.780 |
And the other guy took his billions of dollars 00:07:51.300 |
and invested it all in US government treasury bonds 00:08:06.480 |
The other part of the question here is basically 00:08:09.440 |
when should you actually change your asset allocation, right? 00:08:26.620 |
If something in your life happens that makes you change, 00:08:28.420 |
that's when you can kind of change your asset allocation. 00:08:30.740 |
I think when the market opportunity set changes, 00:08:34.100 |
that's time for it to potentially think about it. 00:08:35.620 |
So in years past, I mentioned we've had all these cycles. 00:08:50.880 |
because the market was kind of dictating that. 00:08:58.100 |
maybe people who were 70/30 or 80/20 could go, 00:09:05.740 |
or 50/50 portfolio because rates are so much higher. 00:09:08.460 |
And so I think when market opportunity set changes, 00:09:14.580 |
And I think when you pick the wrong portfolio 00:09:19.100 |
and you tell yourself, listen, I can do this. 00:09:22.220 |
that I can invest in three times levered NASDAQ funds. 00:09:28.280 |
That's easy to tell yourself when markets are going up. 00:09:42.420 |
- Yeah, I think out over skis is right there. 00:10:00.180 |
when you should change your asset allocation. 00:10:01.980 |
So should you automatically have a different portfolio 00:10:07.500 |
I still think that simple is always gonna beat complex 00:10:13.520 |
then it's a different line of decisions that you're making. 00:10:19.740 |
because the rest of your life is so much more complicated. 00:10:32.780 |
- Yeah, I think this bear market has taught me 00:10:35.940 |
that my risk tolerance isn't as high as I thought it was. 00:10:44.060 |
I think that sometimes you have to learn that. 00:10:49.300 |
you right-size your portfolio to not take on as much risk 00:10:54.140 |
Maybe next time you invest in almond milk, right? 00:10:57.940 |
Maybe not so much triple-levered stuff, you know? 00:11:12.700 |
you could have a 20% downturn in your portfolio. 00:11:19.960 |
But if you know you have $100,000 or a million dollars 00:11:24.140 |
and you say, "Oh my gosh, that's $200,000 now." 00:11:28.180 |
some people don't live their life in percentage, 00:11:31.240 |
So even that could change the way that you view risk. 00:11:33.420 |
So I think it's okay for your risk to change over time. 00:11:42.060 |
with the buy the dip thing working every time, you know? 00:11:53.460 |
"I get that nominal yields are significantly higher today 00:11:59.540 |
"that the real return of bonds is actually worse 00:12:01.400 |
"than it was before all of these rate hikes started?" 00:12:06.880 |
Also, do you notice that, I think in the social media age, 00:12:19.020 |
but they're still well below the level of inflation. 00:12:27.340 |
It's like an alligator mouth at the end opening up. 00:12:35.040 |
over the bond yields, going back to 1960 at least. 00:12:40.140 |
nowhere close to the inflation rate quite yet. 00:12:42.580 |
So yes, on a real basis, you're still losing. 00:12:50.660 |
As you can see, this is just subtracting inflation. 00:13:02.980 |
So back in the '70s, even though they had high nominal rates, 00:13:16.460 |
The thing is, I think people only really care 00:13:19.180 |
about inflation-adjusted returns when inflation is high. 00:13:22.660 |
No one talks about inflation-adjusted returns 00:13:39.100 |
is that if you're locking in these 5% yields on bonds, 00:13:45.740 |
We're gonna talk about IBONs in a minute here 00:13:52.860 |
for one, three, five years or whatever into the future, 00:13:59.340 |
to continue to be 8% per year going out that far. 00:14:05.380 |
then hopefully your real returns are gonna be better 00:14:09.500 |
And Jerome Powell, he said he's gonna throw us 00:14:24.500 |
where you were saying he's basically telling us 00:14:27.940 |
it's not like we have to read the tea leaves, 00:14:29.900 |
he's literally saying this is what I'm doing. 00:14:34.420 |
the Fed was very mysterious in what they would say, 00:14:37.620 |
and you'd try to, oh, they changed two words here. 00:14:41.340 |
hey, idiots, I'm sending us into a recession. 00:14:55.620 |
of working with Treasury Direct for IBON purchases, 00:14:58.060 |
and I think you might actually be underselling it. 00:15:06.420 |
I fear actually having to redeem my IBON someday. 00:15:16.900 |
with a terrible broker for these investments? 00:15:21.380 |
I would say there's no such thing as a free lunch, right? 00:15:33.900 |
And I love this question because there's plenty of talk 00:15:42.500 |
So there's a lot that goes into the portfolio 00:15:44.900 |
about asset allocation today, which is a biggie, 00:15:49.220 |
How much time and effort are you willing to dedicate 00:15:54.980 |
So one of the reasons that I wasn't a huge fan 00:15:57.500 |
of the more complex approach in the institutional world 00:16:00.100 |
is because it was so operational and efficient, right? 00:16:03.940 |
Anytime we had a private equity or hedge fund come in, 00:16:10.220 |
that was all just legalese speech from lawyers 00:16:19.740 |
There was tons of due diligence in the process. 00:16:21.580 |
There's all these different accounts you had to open. 00:16:23.020 |
You had to track some of these investment strategies 00:16:24.740 |
were hard to track, and the performance was hard to know. 00:16:34.260 |
that's really well-versed in this, it's not that easy. 00:16:36.420 |
And so, and then after you do all the heavy lifting, 00:16:38.940 |
the majority of these funds still end up underperforming. 00:16:42.740 |
like all that hard work, was it really worth it 00:16:47.520 |
So yes, that stuff is intellectually stimulating, 00:16:53.120 |
if you're not able to get in like those top decile of funds? 00:17:06.140 |
So they're getting there, but they're still way behind. 00:17:09.380 |
I opened up an account for my daughter when she was born, 00:17:14.980 |
"and I want you to open up a Savings Bond account for her 00:17:18.060 |
And so we did it for the first couple of years, 00:17:28.180 |
and I've done this a few times where I go in, 00:17:40.940 |
I called the 1-800 number, and it's like eight hour wait. 00:17:46.720 |
And so I do think you have to figure out also 00:17:54.120 |
because they based the rates on six months of inflation. 00:17:57.480 |
Right, so John, pull up the little CNBC article here. 00:18:07.760 |
but again, you have a $10,000 limit per individual. 00:18:10.360 |
So that's like $690 a year you're making on these, right? 00:18:14.080 |
You can get 30-day T-bills yielding almost 5% today, 00:18:18.400 |
You don't have to deal with this crappy Treasury Direct 00:18:27.440 |
For some people it is for the time and effort, 00:18:31.280 |
there's other people who do the constant switch 00:18:32.780 |
from online savings account to online savings account, right? 00:18:34.800 |
Because one of them yields 25 basis points more. 00:18:40.460 |
You have to change the accounts that are linked to it 00:18:44.060 |
It's like, is that really gonna matter in the long run? 00:18:50.400 |
talks about the difference between $3 questions 00:18:58.800 |
that material of difference to your finances? 00:19:02.860 |
But getting a raise or figuring out your housing situation 00:19:07.080 |
and making sure you're not overpaying on those things, 00:19:08.840 |
those can lead to huge outcomes over the long term. 00:19:10.940 |
I guess this one is more like a $300 question 00:19:15.760 |
For some people, that $10,000 is a lot of money 00:19:19.760 |
And in that instance, maybe $200 a year extra 00:19:29.080 |
with drawing your money and you need to get it, 00:19:30.640 |
'cause I know a lot of people are using these 00:19:32.480 |
as like a substitute for savings, like a savings account. 00:19:35.780 |
And there's the penalty if you pull it early. 00:19:38.080 |
And there's also like, what if you have a problem 00:19:39.840 |
and can't get someone on the phone and you need this money? 00:19:41.660 |
So, I'm still a big fan of the savings bonds, 00:19:47.840 |
and the fact that it's kind of a pain in the butt, 00:19:50.200 |
for some people, is just not worth the extra yield. 00:19:52.360 |
And it's just easier to take an online savings account 00:19:58.140 |
- Yeah, that's what I was actually thinking recently. 00:20:01.400 |
is why someone now would do short-term treasury ETF 00:20:06.760 |
as opposed to maybe getting 30 or 40 basis points less, 00:20:10.280 |
but it being a savings account, high yield savings account. 00:20:13.540 |
That's what I was trying to figure out recently. 00:20:16.100 |
- Right, which one is going to be easier for you? 00:20:19.100 |
I could be earning 1% more if I moved it over 00:20:21.740 |
to a brokerage account and put it in treasuries. 00:20:24.020 |
I've had the savings account for like five years 00:20:27.340 |
I know that seems dumb, but like, it's just, it's easier. 00:20:32.200 |
I can pull the money easy, it's there the next day. 00:20:36.420 |
And if I'm missing out on a few basis points of yield, 00:20:52.260 |
but yeah, I can't remember exactly what they went to. 00:21:02.820 |
She had a bunch of 401ks with small amounts in them, 00:21:05.340 |
so she rolled them over to an IRA to consolidate. 00:21:10.100 |
and only has about $40,000 saved for retirement. 00:21:17.520 |
She's a travel nurse, and while she makes good money, 00:21:21.920 |
so is seemingly maxed out at contributing $6,000 00:21:40.020 |
for having this conversation with his girlfriend. 00:21:42.980 |
It's not always a conversation people wanna have. 00:21:51.540 |
if your workplace employer doesn't have a 401k. 00:21:58.220 |
Let's make that one happen if someone's listening. 00:22:01.100 |
- So this is more of a financial planning question 00:22:03.980 |
'cause I think the savings piece is more important here. 00:22:06.460 |
So let's bring on financial advisor extraordinaire, 00:22:11.740 |
Blair, so we're trying to play catch up here. 00:22:25.820 |
What do you think, taking away the 401k and stuff, 00:22:38.580 |
and it sounds like the dating process has changed a lot 00:22:42.700 |
if we're having these kinds of conversations. 00:22:44.260 |
But kudos to you for helping your girlfriend out here. 00:22:47.660 |
- I'm not gonna lie, I had these conversations 00:23:18.420 |
- Yeah, solo 401k or a SEP IRA is even easier. 00:23:22.560 |
You can max out potentially up to $61,000 in 2022. 00:23:31.500 |
but it's essentially 25% of your net pay there 00:23:35.020 |
if you're self-employed to a SEP or a solo 401k. 00:23:41.580 |
You've already maxed out the savings bonds, which is great. 00:23:48.620 |
If she's eligible or has an HSA healthcare option, 00:23:53.300 |
that's another $36.50 a year that you can defer. 00:24:24.820 |
she won't be taxed to take money out of a brokerage account. 00:24:27.720 |
So it's not a bad idea to start building that bucket as well. 00:24:33.340 |
where you can automate it, automate the contributions, 00:24:35.540 |
get some tax loss harvesting if it's a robo-advisor. 00:24:45.780 |
The investment options are gonna matter eventually 00:24:57.280 |
any amount of investment returns you're gonna have. 00:25:02.120 |
And again, make sure you're putting that on autopilot 00:25:14.120 |
and invest that money immediately for the next 45 years 00:25:18.280 |
at 8.5%, then you might be saving a million dollars. 00:25:22.120 |
I honestly don't think that kind of decision is worth it. 00:25:25.500 |
If you cut back on something, no one ever does it. 00:25:29.480 |
- I'm not gonna pay for the Twitter blue check mark. 00:25:48.900 |
to see how my portfolio might look moving forward 00:25:53.300 |
What surprises me is that having a small bond position 00:25:55.820 |
has always been the highest returning asset mix. 00:25:58.220 |
I'm retired but live off of dividends and interest, 00:26:05.020 |
The only thing I can figure is that bonds protect 00:26:07.800 |
on equity declines more than they hurt on equity rises, 00:26:14.720 |
than rebalancing hurts when equities are high. 00:26:24.900 |
that has the highest remaining value after 40 years. 00:26:29.260 |
results in higher return when using Monte Carlo analysis? 00:26:33.840 |
- All right, Duncan's looking for an explanation 00:26:36.620 |
I don't know the exact reason an all-stock one 00:26:41.860 |
and if you're an all-stock and you happen to spend 00:26:45.420 |
at the beginning, it could lead to lower outcomes. 00:26:55.520 |
How do you explain this type of scenario analysis 00:27:00.140 |
should view when thinking through the scenarios here? 00:27:02.800 |
- Sure, so this is more of a complex planning tool, 00:27:08.140 |
in the Mediterranean here with Monte Carlo analysis, 00:27:10.860 |
but whenever you're building a financial planning 00:27:12.940 |
projection, you have to make some assumptions. 00:27:14.780 |
You make some assumptions on what asset class 00:27:21.060 |
and then you run what's called a straight line scenario, 00:27:26.980 |
that your portfolio is gonna earn 7% a year on average. 00:27:36.100 |
So then we throw in a calculator called the Monte Carlo. 00:27:42.620 |
1,000, I think, is the minimum you would need 00:27:52.820 |
and with bonds for their return and their volatility, 00:27:55.440 |
obviously, stocks are more volatile than bonds, 00:27:58.020 |
and the math changes when you start taking money 00:28:00.500 |
out of your portfolio versus when you're adding money 00:28:03.660 |
So if you think about the dispersion of returns, 00:28:06.360 |
even though taking more risk in an all-stock portfolio 00:28:11.700 |
it also widens the dispersion of potential outcomes, 00:28:29.540 |
There's something called sequence of return risk, 00:28:31.420 |
which is if the bear markets happen very early 00:28:33.660 |
when you start to draw money out of your portfolio. 00:28:35.940 |
Think about the market this year being down 20-plus percent 00:28:43.260 |
So what we're trying to do with the Monte Carlo 00:29:06.600 |
and I did put an example in the deck there, John, 00:29:16.040 |
but essentially it's running 1,000 different trials 00:29:23.720 |
for what my expenses are gonna be in the future, 00:29:27.200 |
But essentially, all those different squiggly lines 00:29:43.620 |
My kids are gonna get into some private college 00:29:45.520 |
that costs a million dollars a year, who knows. 00:29:52.320 |
because we don't know what the next 40 years will hold. 00:29:55.280 |
The best thing we can do is use history as a guide, 00:30:07.320 |
- And my way of thinking about using Money Carlo 00:30:15.700 |
I would rather be roughly right than precisely wrong. 00:30:21.360 |
but we don't know what the outcomes are gonna be. 00:30:22.540 |
So you have probabilities, and then you can use 00:30:30.780 |
because like you said, your life is gonna change 00:30:39.020 |
for future spending and your future outcomes? 00:30:44.560 |
this is how making this big change in your life 00:30:46.880 |
or your financial plan can potentially impact 00:30:55.420 |
And then you kind of update and go from there. 00:31:00.160 |
should never to be to end with the biggest pile of money 00:31:05.680 |
Really, what we're trying to do is save for the future 00:31:10.880 |
that there's enough there that if we live a long life 00:31:15.800 |
but at the end of the day, you should actually enjoy 00:31:18.240 |
the fruits of your labor and the goal shouldn't actually be 00:31:25.640 |
- Probably not even, yeah, it's a rough looking one. 00:31:30.280 |
Yeah, I was gonna say, do you think this is a use case 00:31:33.040 |
for augmented reality, like one day we'll have a headset 00:31:36.100 |
that just shows you the Monte Carlo simulation 00:31:41.360 |
- If visualization helps you achieve your goals, 00:31:46.520 |
- Sorry, Duncan, I'm out of the metaverse already. 00:31:53.680 |
Ben wearing a VR headset while we're doing Portfolio Rescue. 00:32:02.440 |
- I don't know, I don't know how many days this is for you. 00:32:05.160 |
- All right, if it happens, I gotta try to match Duncan. 00:32:17.240 |
As always, listen in to this in podcast form. 00:32:20.360 |
Leave us a review if you're watching on YouTube. 00:32:22.320 |
Leave us a comment, leave us a question if you want, 00:32:24.680 |
or you can email us askthecompoundshow@gmail.com. 00:32:30.840 |
I got mine in the mail, I gotta wear it at one of these. 00:32:33.880 |
This has been super popular. - That's killer, yeah. 00:32:35.440 |
- Okay, yeah, it's the Fed godfather one, very cool.