back to indexWhy Should I Invest in the Stock Market? | Portfolio Rescue 58
Chapters
0:0 Intro
9:20 Deflation vs Inflation.
12:55 Is the Stock Market a Ponzi Scheme?
18:23 Emergency funds.
22:43 Using banked PTO as an emergency fund.
26:26 Investing AFTER Retirement.
00:00:21.240 |
Duncan, I would wish you a happy New Year, but I'm not a happy New Year kind of guy. 00:00:25.520 |
I don't do it. Nothing against people who do it, it's just not my thing. I don't say it. 00:00:29.960 |
Maybe this is kind of like my Larry David thing, but I'm just not a happy New Year kind of guy. 00:00:35.040 |
No problem that people will say it, but that's just me. Kind of like investing. 00:00:37.520 |
It's just as important to define what you won't invest in as what you will invest in. 00:00:40.640 |
Today's show is sponsored by, yes, Liftoff Invest. 00:00:45.240 |
That's our automated platform that is run through Betterment's technology. 00:00:49.760 |
I have one account, but I have four goals under there. 00:00:52.080 |
One of them is for me and my wife, just a general investment account. 00:00:54.600 |
The other one, each one for three of our kids. 00:00:56.760 |
I was looking, and surprisingly, the investments were down this year, but my market values were up. 00:01:03.880 |
I think especially for young people, that's a really big thing these days. 00:01:07.960 |
Yes, it hurts to see the value of your portfolio go down, but if you bump up your savings rate, 00:01:12.480 |
especially when you're just starting out, that's where most of your gains are going to come from. 00:01:16.160 |
They're not technically gains, but if you want to see growth in your portfolio, 00:01:19.800 |
it's going to come from putting money to work. 00:01:21.680 |
Go check out LiftoffInvest.com to learn more. 00:01:25.520 |
Duncan, you told me that you finished my most recent book. 00:01:29.760 |
It's a pretty short one. How many pages is that, 140? 00:01:39.560 |
It's a short book, everything you need to know about saving for retirement. 00:01:41.560 |
I wrote it for people with 401(k)s or 403(b)s who are just getting started. 00:01:47.120 |
Maybe some of our clients' kids have read it, some people in our 401(k) plans. 00:01:51.320 |
You told me that you finished reading and had some questions or had some thoughts. 00:01:56.320 |
I was like, "I wish I did a podcast with Ben because then I could ask him these questions." 00:02:02.560 |
First of all, I just wanted to say, on behalf of a lot, 00:02:05.520 |
we had a lot of people writing in and commenting, 00:02:07.400 |
"We're all sorry for you getting so robbed of your take." 00:02:10.920 |
Michael took your Bezos take and just got famous off of it. 00:02:15.600 |
It was on TV yesterday, talking about it and stuff. 00:02:18.160 |
He's going to be the new Michael Burry because he leased one of my takes 00:02:21.320 |
about Jeff Bezos coming back to take over Amazon. 00:02:23.840 |
That's the kind of podcast co-host and friend that I am. 00:02:26.240 |
I'm willing to give my takes away to other people. 00:02:31.680 |
But yeah, so a couple of things I just thought of that I noted down 00:02:35.840 |
They're very basic probably, but I think people would be curious to hear, 00:02:46.760 |
What happens to them when they hit their date? 00:02:48.400 |
I mean, do they just go 100% bonds and stay that way forever? 00:02:55.640 |
Well, I looked at the Vanguard 2020 fund today. 00:02:58.520 |
So, someone would have set that 10, 15 years ago and said, 00:03:02.720 |
This is going to be my glide path to that point." 00:03:05.680 |
It's in roughly 45% stocks, 55% bonds right now. 00:03:09.760 |
So, your investing lifecycle doesn't stop just the moment you retire. 00:03:15.840 |
We actually have a question about this for today's show, 00:03:18.640 |
So, yeah, it just gets more conservative over time. 00:03:25.080 |
because you still need some growth in your portfolio. 00:03:26.760 |
Okay. So, they don't end or anything like that or go away? 00:03:30.120 |
No, it keeps going and it keeps going the glide path. 00:03:31.720 |
It'll probably get more and more conservative 00:03:41.680 |
you know, a huge part of the book is withstanding volatility, 00:03:44.200 |
withstanding downturns in the market and just sticking with it. 00:03:48.480 |
Have computers and algorithms and modern technology 00:03:51.520 |
and retail traders, all of the stuff that we think about 00:04:03.120 |
Overall volatility, like if you measured by standard deviation, 00:04:05.840 |
is probably pretty similar, like annualizing that number. 00:04:09.000 |
But the speed of the volatility has increased. 00:04:16.960 |
And he said back in like 1981, when a news event occurred, 00:04:20.640 |
you had time to actually sit and think about it. 00:04:23.240 |
it might not affect the US market until like the next day. 00:04:26.640 |
Like you don't have time to think through these things. 00:04:28.200 |
So I think the speed of volatility has certainly increased. 00:04:33.760 |
if there's a piece of news or economic data that hits, 00:04:39.280 |
You would have to get some of your news from the market 00:04:48.360 |
but the speed of the volatility and the speed of the moves 00:04:56.440 |
Yeah, I was wondering because the behavioral aspect 00:05:02.800 |
I wonder if that has made the market a little more stable. 00:05:11.040 |
'cause you're being force-fed everything in the short term 00:05:14.240 |
It's harder to think and act for the long-term 00:05:24.400 |
was nearly 29,000 companies traded on the US stock market 00:05:33.440 |
do you think that we'll lose 80% of companies 00:05:44.640 |
And so I think I got the stats from "Scale" by Jeffrey West, 00:05:52.040 |
Companies of old required way more upfront investment 00:05:59.200 |
He said like the first billion-dollar corporation ever 00:06:05.680 |
and like $3,300 in sales per employee, right? 00:06:10.720 |
And that's still like 90,000 in today's dollars. 00:06:12.800 |
But today they have over 500,000 per employee 00:06:19.560 |
Software makes it easier than ever to start businesses. 00:06:22.640 |
I just think, I look at this as a good thing too. 00:06:25.400 |
where the quicker these old companies are being pushed out 00:06:31.920 |
And the one great thing about owning a diverse set 00:06:43.920 |
it's possible it hasn't even been created yet. 00:06:47.360 |
to solve some big problem that we don't even know yet. 00:06:53.640 |
All right, so last but not least out of these, 00:06:58.880 |
for a young person to assess their risk tolerance? 00:07:02.440 |
and knowing your risk and different phases of life. 00:07:10.920 |
I know people say, "Oh, put together a paper portfolio. 00:07:13.120 |
"Pretend like you're trading, you've no money." 00:07:15.360 |
Unfortunately, it's difficult to say how you'll react 00:07:21.120 |
One of my favorite books of all time is this, 00:07:25.320 |
It's, I think it was written in the 1930s or 1940s. 00:07:28.760 |
He had this great quote that I use all the time. 00:07:30.120 |
He said, "Like all of life's rich emotional experiences, 00:07:36.260 |
"There are certain things that cannot be adequately explained 00:07:40.040 |
And so I think sometimes you have to just live through it 00:07:41.680 |
and see, I can keep 100% of my portfolio in stocks. 00:07:52.160 |
I think you have to kind of play it by ear and experience it. 00:07:55.620 |
And the good thing about if you're a young person investing 00:08:11.640 |
That a 50% loss when you have a couple thousand 00:08:22.800 |
'cause it's more dollars going out of your account 00:08:30.360 |
- Yeah, and I had one quote I wanted to share 00:08:41.080 |
have a larger say in your success or failure as an investor 00:08:52.840 |
Because if you give up and you just throw your arms up 00:08:58.760 |
that giving up on your plan is no plan at all 00:09:17.240 |
- Perfect, all right, let's get into a question. 00:09:20.600 |
So first up today, we have 2022 was all about inflation. 00:09:34.560 |
- All right, it does appear inflation is peaked 00:09:39.400 |
You can see if I'm performing technical analysis on this, 00:09:48.360 |
that we have had inflation before these past 20 months 00:09:51.800 |
Even before the current bout of high inflation, 00:09:54.680 |
They were doing so at a much more modest pace. 00:10:03.680 |
It was up like 21% in total, a little less than 2% a year. 00:10:07.600 |
No one just, people didn't really pay attention 00:10:19.560 |
It is a possibility if we get a nasty recession 00:10:24.520 |
To the point about inflation versus deflation, 00:10:33.560 |
My view is not necessarily that inflation is good. 00:10:46.320 |
that they'll be able to buy stuff cheaper in the future. 00:10:56.040 |
As unemployment rate rises, people's paychecks fall. 00:10:58.480 |
You know, it's like a death spiral of future price cuts. 00:11:04.440 |
And trust me, people seeing their prices falling 00:11:09.680 |
I think prices fell like 10% across the board 00:11:16.440 |
we're gonna have to accept some price inflation over time 00:11:23.600 |
a little bit of inflation over the long term, 00:11:27.000 |
So I look at rising prices as the lesser of two evils. 00:11:31.260 |
but if you wanna continue to see growth and progress 00:11:33.840 |
in our economy, you're gonna have to accept some inflation. 00:11:37.080 |
What we've seen this past year, year and a half 00:11:43.560 |
it's still gonna be, prices are still gonna be rising, 00:11:59.100 |
because that would probably mean a nasty recession. 00:12:01.920 |
And so I think if you gave me the choice of inflation, 00:12:06.840 |
but it's with economic growth and people's wages are rising 00:12:08.820 |
versus deflation and people are losing their jobs 00:12:10.580 |
and it's a recession, I'd probably take the lesser 00:12:23.960 |
- Well, people ask, he asked why is technology deflationary 00:12:28.080 |
and it's because it just makes us more efficient, right? 00:12:30.140 |
And back in the 1800s, 80% of us were farmers. 00:12:33.160 |
Now, I don't know, I think the percentage of people 00:12:36.760 |
It's 'cause we have technology that's available 00:12:38.560 |
to make it easier so people can do other jobs. 00:12:41.200 |
People have the ability to complain on the internet all day 00:12:43.720 |
because technology has made our lives easier. 00:12:58.020 |
"Do you think the stock market is a form of Ponzi scheme?" 00:13:01.180 |
And I gotta be honest, this question, I think, 00:13:07.880 |
"Do you think the stock market is a form of Ponzi scheme? 00:13:19.160 |
"So why are people investing in the stock market? 00:13:23.360 |
"from selling a piece of paper to someone else, 00:13:27.360 |
"If there's no one there to buy your piece of paper, 00:13:37.980 |
it wouldn't be used as a way to talk down on someone 00:13:44.520 |
I don't think the stock market is a form of Ponzi scheme. 00:13:50.820 |
because there's no business plan, there's no revenues. 00:13:52.780 |
Right, the stock market is made up of corporations, 00:14:03.840 |
but whatever's left over is used to pay down debt 00:14:06.300 |
or buy back shares or pay dividends out to stock investors, 00:14:16.900 |
And so as sales and dividends and earnings grow over time, 00:14:25.020 |
This is the dividend yield on the S&P 500 since 1950. 00:14:35.540 |
we're talking three to 6% dividend yields, pretty high. 00:14:49.540 |
there was a precipitous drop in the dividend yield. 00:14:51.740 |
You can say, "Well, that's 'cause stocks were going up." 00:14:56.580 |
for corporations to buy back their own stock. 00:15:02.220 |
This is going back to 1988 from Yardenia Research. 00:15:05.500 |
And I don't wanna go down the rabbit hole here, 00:15:07.660 |
but essentially, stock buybacks and dividends 00:15:17.180 |
So if you combine dividends and share buybacks, 00:15:19.460 |
the yield picture doesn't look quite so bleak. 00:15:20.900 |
It's closer to 5% now if you combine dividends and buybacks. 00:15:26.580 |
And so the shareholder yield is actually pretty good still. 00:15:38.920 |
So plus, you can't simply look at the yield itself 00:15:42.540 |
The S&P 500 has seen total dividends since that 1950 00:15:45.700 |
rise at an annual rate of nearly 6% per year. 00:15:48.320 |
Per year, that's above the 3% rate of inflation 00:15:50.620 |
where dividends are growing above and beyond that. 00:15:56.620 |
but the stock market is rising a little faster. 00:16:05.100 |
So if more people decide they want to own shares 00:16:09.340 |
the amount of investors willing to pay for them will rise. 00:16:15.460 |
But even if fewer people wanted to own stocks in the future, 00:16:21.020 |
buy back their own stock and whoever did own stock 00:16:22.780 |
would just see their share of earnings and dividends 00:16:28.860 |
we're taking all of our money out of the stock market, 00:16:32.700 |
I wouldn't recommend that, but if people did that, 00:16:35.360 |
the yields would be so low that the stock market 00:16:37.860 |
would have to look attractive on a relative basis. 00:16:41.220 |
So yes, there needs to be a buyer for every seller, 00:16:45.380 |
and cash flows rise, someone is going to buy. 00:16:48.060 |
So I think if you think the stock market is a Ponzi scheme 00:17:05.320 |
and then they'd be the ones accruing all the gains. 00:17:11.180 |
- Yeah, I think the buyback stuff is a little confusing. 00:17:13.180 |
Yeah, I find that math a little confusing, honestly. 00:17:22.180 |
And so I think that is the mentality sometimes. 00:17:37.460 |
There's four shareholders, still $100 in profit, right? 00:17:42.620 |
among only four shareholders instead of five. 00:17:50.440 |
- Yeah, no, I haven't heard it explained that simply before. 00:17:54.700 |
- So whether they paid out dividends to people 00:18:00.820 |
And so it's either people are gonna be paid back in cash 00:18:34.380 |
Currently VP of sales at a logistics company. 00:18:37.320 |
I've got about five months of household income saved, 00:18:39.540 |
and for a few years, it sat in a brokerage account 00:18:46.300 |
So where do you recommend people put their emergency funds? 00:18:50.940 |
So this is one of those common things we get asked about. 00:18:53.620 |
- Well, I mean, you talked about risk tolerance 00:18:56.460 |
We talk a lot about that in the investing world. 00:19:02.980 |
being laid off twice, changing jobs three other times, 00:19:11.020 |
People who are changing jobs are getting much higher wages 00:19:15.100 |
But if you're going to have some sort of career 00:19:17.780 |
where you're gonna have that much volatility, 00:19:19.220 |
I don't know what they do or what field they're in, 00:19:30.980 |
A lot of it depends on your tolerance for volatility 00:19:38.980 |
Like him, I had my money sitting in an online savings account 00:19:49.940 |
So you have places like Ally, Marcus, Capital One 360, SoFi, 00:19:58.220 |
I found anything in the range of 3.3% to 3.8% for these, 00:20:02.060 |
you know, and FDIC insured and fairly safe and liquid. 00:20:07.060 |
You could find a one to three month T-bill ETF these days, 00:20:13.900 |
I saw a money market account for a client this morning 00:20:20.700 |
Series I savings bonds, we've talked about them a lot here, 00:20:24.740 |
at which point I would expect that number to fall 00:20:39.660 |
If you're investing in short-term government bonds, 00:20:46.220 |
So savers are no longer being punished by the Fed, 00:20:50.100 |
This is one good thing the Fed is doing, I guess. 00:20:52.700 |
I think my only rule of thumb is don't put your money 00:20:56.340 |
Some of them will say you have to have a direct deposit, 00:21:06.620 |
And one of the reasons that these online banks 00:21:08.380 |
can offer higher yields is because the brick and mortar banks 00:21:13.460 |
and they just, I think I looked at the average today, 00:21:18.860 |
brick and mortar bank is like 24 basis points still. 00:21:23.420 |
So you can get like 3.3, 3.5% at an online bank. 00:21:26.500 |
I think my only advice is just don't try to go yield hunting 00:21:33.180 |
'cause you can get an extra 10 or 20 basis points. 00:21:36.660 |
Make sure they're not taking advantage of you. 00:21:38.020 |
But I'd say nothing less than at least three, 00:21:41.300 |
The fed funds rate is at four, four and a half percent. 00:21:43.940 |
So I would say anything lower than three and 3.25 00:21:48.860 |
is probably too low, especially in the liquid stuff. 00:21:55.420 |
There has to be a big enough gap for it to be worth 00:22:00.100 |
You can't just do it for like 25 basis points. 00:22:07.620 |
Go through the process of opening a new account 00:22:21.420 |
I know there's a lot of platforms these days. 00:22:25.460 |
- You had to go two decimal points out there, didn't you? 00:22:32.820 |
- Hey, well, 0.05 is what I was getting at my big bank, 00:22:40.220 |
Okay, so up next, we have a question from Hector. 00:22:47.860 |
That will never come close to fully collecting. 00:22:50.500 |
Those hours are equal to four and a half weeks of vacation 00:22:55.220 |
Do you think it's a viable option to use my unused PTO 00:23:00.940 |
I'm building up my liquid cash emergency fund 00:23:05.660 |
two months of cash savings is all I would need to save. 00:23:12.940 |
- Can we use two questions about emergency savings funds 00:23:19.700 |
- We definitely weren't getting these questions 00:23:26.460 |
This depends on how you define emergency, I think. 00:23:29.100 |
So I don't know, how easily could you cash in 00:23:32.020 |
on that vacation paying and get it in a pinch 00:23:35.100 |
Like, would it take some time for a company to pay it out? 00:23:43.380 |
was in my checking account or savings account 00:23:47.100 |
Maybe if you can cash it out every six months or 12 months, 00:23:58.500 |
So some people plan for car expenses and home maintenance 00:24:08.700 |
An actual emergency is when the apartment above you 00:24:11.780 |
leaves their windows open and turns their heat off 00:24:13.700 |
and the pipes freeze, and then it floods your apartment, 00:24:19.660 |
that you'd wanna have a fallback plan for, right? 00:24:31.500 |
like do you have a home equity line of credit 00:24:42.380 |
until you could get those four and a half weeks paid off. 00:24:47.220 |
- Yeah, no, I was gonna say basically the same thing. 00:24:50.460 |
in my situation with an apartment being flooded, 00:24:58.140 |
but we're having to pay out of pocket, right? 00:25:00.180 |
And so there are a bunch of huge expenses upfront, 00:25:06.540 |
ranges like I'm seeing 8,000, 10,000 plus for a month, 00:25:16.180 |
would be much more helpful than probably being like, 00:25:18.980 |
oh, I would have to quit my job to get my PTO 00:25:29.060 |
It's not like you can cash it out, I don't think. 00:25:39.260 |
an actual emergency savings, I want it to be liquid 00:25:47.860 |
You'll have the money if you put in for a transfer withdrawal 00:25:54.060 |
even if you have an ETF that you have it in short-term cash, 00:26:02.980 |
But maybe if your emergency you're planning for 00:26:09.880 |
if you live in an apartment, be a good neighbor 00:26:11.620 |
and don't leave your windows open and heat off 00:26:24.940 |
- Yeah, last but not least, we have a question from Tom. 00:26:27.740 |
I'm in my mid-60s with retirement coming very soon. 00:26:30.820 |
There's a lot of doom and gloom for people in my position 00:26:32.660 |
with the market dropping just as we're retiring. 00:26:34.820 |
However, I hope to be in the market 20 years from now 00:26:37.380 |
and still see myself as a long-term investor. 00:26:39.580 |
Even after retirement, we're still investors, right? 00:26:51.860 |
markets are dropping, but also you had 10 years 00:26:54.240 |
of fantastic returns to get your portfolio to a level 00:27:02.300 |
where you were doing pretty good up until this point, 00:27:05.100 |
and your portfolio would not have been as high 00:27:06.620 |
if we didn't have the gains that preceded this bear market. 00:27:09.420 |
And it's possible the only reason stocks are falling a lot 00:27:11.580 |
is because they went up a lot in the first place. 00:27:16.380 |
100 years ago, the average American died at 51. 00:27:20.460 |
According to the Social Security Administration, 00:27:22.180 |
they actually have this cool longevity thing. 00:27:32.080 |
at least one of them will live into their 90s. 00:27:34.380 |
So most people want a retirement where they can relax 00:27:39.380 |
and enjoy themselves, and most people probably retire 00:27:43.580 |
People think, oh, if I don't have enough money, 00:27:46.620 |
A lot of times, your health won't allow for it, 00:27:49.740 |
you're just, I'm done with it, I'm ready to be done. 00:27:56.940 |
So there is less human capital where you don't have 00:28:00.600 |
you don't have the ability to wait out bear markets 00:28:02.580 |
as much as you did in the past as a young person, 00:28:04.840 |
because your biggest asset should be financial assets 00:28:09.620 |
So you're not like someone who's accumulating 00:28:13.440 |
So there's more balance involved at this stage. 00:28:20.440 |
versus you need to keep up your standard of living 00:28:24.700 |
This is just a simple thing that we've shown over time. 00:28:27.320 |
How long it takes for different inflation rates 00:28:30.160 |
So 3% inflation rate is about the long-term average. 00:28:38.840 |
4%, it would be 17 years, 5%, 14 years, even 2%, 00:28:42.720 |
it's 35 years if we're using the handy rule of 72. 00:28:46.000 |
So unless you have more money than you know what to do with, 00:28:48.880 |
the stock market is likely gonna have to play a role 00:28:52.280 |
because it remains the best bet for beating inflation 00:28:56.220 |
inflation can ding stocks like it has recently. 00:28:58.960 |
So one of the ways I like to think about this 00:29:01.400 |
So let's say you land on 4% of your portfolio each year 00:29:04.560 |
you're gonna take out for spending purposes, right? 00:29:12.680 |
that would give you 10 years worth of spending, right? 00:29:15.000 |
A 40/60 portfolio would give you 15 years worth of spending 00:29:17.560 |
in fixed income or cash or something like that. 00:29:19.600 |
Now, this ignores inflation in your spending over time, 00:29:24.480 |
But I think this is a good way to look at things 00:29:26.200 |
in terms of getting comfortable with some balance 00:29:32.760 |
if you want to beat the rate of inflation over time. 00:29:35.600 |
So a lot of retirees are gonna wanna leave money 00:29:45.760 |
or your grandchildren's time horizon and risk profile. 00:29:52.760 |
once you're relying exclusively on financial assets 00:29:57.960 |
a little bit of volatility with part of your portfolio. 00:30:05.000 |
this 20, 30, 40, 50% is for the next 10 plus years. 00:30:09.360 |
This part is for the next one to three years. 00:30:11.640 |
This part is for the next three to seven years. 00:30:14.120 |
Whatever you have to do to get yourself comfortable there 00:30:17.360 |
because you're balancing out spending some now 00:30:23.780 |
It would be nice if you could just put your money 00:30:31.700 |
and you're just gonna have to live with some volatility 00:30:38.220 |
of thinking about, you know, yeah, still staying invested. 00:30:43.220 |
where you're cashing out all of your retirement plans 00:30:46.980 |
They make the point that your portfolio management 00:30:50.000 |
is never more important than when you are retired, right? 00:30:55.860 |
your asset allocation doesn't matter nearly as much 00:31:00.960 |
and all this stuff, there's so much more that goes into it, 00:31:02.800 |
which is why we have a lot of clients come to us 00:31:06.240 |
because there's a lot more complexities involved in that. 00:31:09.080 |
- And that's actually what I was about to ask, 00:31:22.660 |
All these things, it's definitely a mindset shift too, 00:31:26.580 |
psychologically, to go from being an accumulator of assets 00:31:31.140 |
That can be tough for people to turn on a dime 00:31:32.960 |
and then spend because they just want to hoard it all 00:31:36.480 |
And then to turn around and have to spend it, 00:31:37.780 |
it's tough when there's not anything else coming in. 00:31:49.160 |
everything else you need to know for the new year. 00:31:51.920 |
remember email us, askthecompoundshow@gmail.com. 00:31:58.580 |
Every week you can just talk about Duncan's hats, right? 00:32:09.640 |
You can also leave us a comment or a question. 00:32:13.360 |
I'm always in the comments battling it out with people. 00:32:22.300 |
Remember, email us, askthecompoundshow@gmail.com. 00:32:25.220 |
We're looking forward to an awesome year here.