back to indexHow Do You Minimize Taxes in Retirement? | Portfolio Rescue
Chapters
0:0 Intro
4:28 Downgrading to one income.
9:8 Prepaying for college.
12:58 Save or invest inherited money.
20:49 Investing during retirement.
24:45 optimizing unrealized capital losses.
28:36 Setting aside IRA contributions.
00:00:00.000 |
Welcome to Portfolio Rescue, where we're always happy to hear your comments and questions. 00:00:20.160 |
Remember, our email here is AskTheCompoundShow@gmail.com. 00:00:24.480 |
Today's Portfolio Rescue is sponsored by Innovator ETFs. 00:00:26.740 |
This week's Wall Street Journal had a story about buffered ETFs, which anyone who's been 00:00:33.520 |
"A popular set of exchange-traded funds that claim to guard against investors' losses up 00:00:38.400 |
These buffer funds have attracted $6 billion of inflows this year, already doubling last 00:00:49.300 |
You can see people want some more defined outcomes. 00:00:53.320 |
They say, "The J.P. Morgan Hedged Equity Fund won, and the U.S. Equity Power Buffer ETF from 00:00:57.960 |
Innovator Capital, two of the biggest funds in the space, are easily beating the market 00:01:05.000 |
John, do a chart on of the performance here, which kind of shows. 00:01:08.440 |
You can see both of these hedged funds beating the equity market this year. 00:01:12.960 |
They said, "During the first half of the year, both of these funds were down about 11% compared 00:01:16.960 |
to a 23% drop from the S&P, but then after the market bottomed and rose a little bit, 00:01:21.280 |
they didn't quite catch up the same," so that's kind of the trade-off here, is that you get 00:01:24.680 |
a little downside protection, but you don't always go up as much when we have these bear 00:01:28.400 |
market rallies, at least that's what they seem. 00:01:31.800 |
Innovator tells me that they're closing in on $10 billion in asset center management, 00:01:38.320 |
They've brought in $3 billion this year alone, which is crazy. 00:01:44.400 |
Duncan, a couple weeks ago, I mentioned that I didn't necessarily want the stock market 00:01:52.280 |
I said, "I don't like this rally very much, because I want people to be able to invest 00:01:56.720 |
I wasn't making a prediction, per se, but maybe more of a request to the market gods. 00:02:05.080 |
I think sometimes an extended bear market is good. 00:02:08.480 |
It's September, the market peaked the very first day of the year. 00:02:12.360 |
I think it's pretty safe to say we're on an extended bear market. 00:02:15.880 |
This is every S&P 500 correction since 2008, when one got over. 00:02:19.960 |
So, you can see, this is the number of trading days that they've gone. 00:02:26.840 |
The only one that took longer to recover is 2011. 00:02:29.320 |
So, I guess if we recover in the next couple weeks, we could still beat that one, potentially. 00:02:33.080 |
But 2011 stocks were already going back up at this point. 00:02:39.640 |
You can see all these other corrections that we had in bear markets in the past had already 00:02:43.200 |
made their money back up and gone back to all-time highs. 00:02:46.480 |
You can see, even the 34% drop from 2020, at this point, at this length of time, had 00:02:51.840 |
already gone down that 34% and made money back to all-time highs. 00:02:58.300 |
On last week's Animal Spirits, Duncan, I know a lot of people don't go in the YouTube comments. 00:03:02.560 |
I put my hazmat suit on and I go into the comments, because I'm a man of the people. 00:03:06.640 |
I'm not one of these coastal elitists that won't check the comments. 00:03:10.880 |
And someone said, "You guys are way too bearish lately." 00:03:13.820 |
Now, this is the first time in my life I've ever been called bearish. 00:03:17.240 |
I've been labeled a permable before, but never bearish. 00:03:19.680 |
And I think what we're doing is, we're just kind of reporting what's going on around us. 00:03:22.560 |
Because the Fed has said, in the last two weeks, they're openly rooting for the stock 00:03:29.460 |
There's plenty to be negative about right now. 00:03:31.080 |
My whole thesis on life, though, is that we get through stuff, and this, too, shall pass. 00:03:36.720 |
And I wouldn't even consider myself being bearish, I'm just trying to be realistic. 00:03:40.400 |
But I think my whole thing on this is, it's okay to be bearish. 00:03:44.760 |
That's the problem for too many people, is they get bogged down in the negativity and 00:03:48.200 |
negative headlines, and it seems like there's a lot of negativity these days. 00:03:51.320 |
I think the problem is when you get stuck in that mindset and don't realize that we'll 00:03:57.600 |
But I think the longer-term bear market, it's good if you're saving money. 00:04:01.980 |
I mean, you're pointing out negatives in the market, and the market has a bunch of hurdles 00:04:07.840 |
It's not like you're shorting the S&P or anything. 00:04:14.200 |
Just kind of trying to point out what's going on. 00:04:17.200 |
This is probably the only time I've ever called bearish in my life, so I'm just going to take 00:04:20.280 |
Maybe I'm going to read Zero Hedge today at lunch. 00:04:25.960 |
Maybe we have you do the next show wearing a bear suit. 00:04:29.960 |
Up next, or up first today, we have a question from Will. 00:04:35.180 |
What do we need to think about in downgrading to one income? 00:04:37.440 |
My wife and I welcomed a pandemic baby, which I didn't know that's what people were calling 00:04:44.080 |
We welcomed a pandemic baby almost a year ago. 00:04:46.480 |
I work at home and have some childcare help from grandparents, but we are thinking of 00:04:50.000 |
having me go part-time or less in order to care for the kid. 00:04:53.240 |
Work from home with an energetic one-year-old is way different than work from home with 00:04:58.500 |
We also hope to be blessed with one more kid before we hit 40. 00:05:01.920 |
I worry that these are my prime earning years, but watching our child grow up is priceless 00:05:06.020 |
and childcare is fairly expensive in our area. 00:05:08.600 |
I can also support my wife's career, which she finds meaningful. 00:05:11.620 |
My career is in spreadsheets, and while it doesn't make me want to throw myself off the 00:05:19.200 |
We also started having kids late, age 37, so we are fortunate to have a nest egg, $150,000 00:05:25.280 |
income, $40,000 to $50,000 of spending a year, 2.5% mortgage. 00:05:32.080 |
That's $50,000 for retirement and a six-month emergency fund. 00:05:37.700 |
I had dreams of retiring early and this would slow it down. 00:05:41.900 |
My wife and I went through a similar decision-making process during the pandemic. 00:05:45.580 |
When we had our twins in 2017, that's when she decided to go part-time because we already 00:05:49.820 |
had another child, so twins was a lot on our plate. 00:05:53.140 |
She'd always kind of thought about retiring to take care of the kids from her job, and 00:05:56.340 |
the pandemic kind of forced her hand because it was so difficult going on and off and on 00:06:01.700 |
So she quit about nine months into the pandemic. 00:06:04.000 |
This person's at a different stage in life than we were, but I understand where they're 00:06:07.760 |
We've talked about the high cost of childcare on the show before. 00:06:11.640 |
This is actually the first year all three of my kids are in public school. 00:06:15.860 |
My birthday was a couple weeks ago, or last week, I guess, and two weeks ago, and someone 00:06:20.580 |
had said, "Happy birthday," and they said, "Are you celebrating?" 00:06:23.140 |
I said, "No, I'm celebrating the fact that my kids are not on daycare, I'm not paying 00:06:27.280 |
That was more important to me than my birthday. 00:06:31.140 |
Assuming the grandparents can't stay full-time with childcare, your decision basically boils 00:06:34.920 |
down to, are we a one-income family or daycare, right? 00:06:38.740 |
And you said it's fairly expensive where you are, so it's pretty easy to do the cost-benefit 00:06:43.380 |
And for a lot of people, childcare can be almost as expensive as one parent's income, 00:06:49.000 |
And you told us, again, it's expensive where you live, so I mean, this could obviously 00:06:52.220 |
tack on a few years to your early retirement, but I don't know, are you really going to 00:06:57.220 |
regret spending more time with your child if you do this? 00:07:02.020 |
Here's a few things to consider that we went through in this process. 00:07:06.780 |
My wife had really good benefits at her former employer. 00:07:09.660 |
She had a really solid 403(b) match, and we had to give that up, and so that's kind of 00:07:16.020 |
So you have to think through what are your benefits, what that change is going to be 00:07:18.900 |
Do you think you'll be able to get another full-time job when kids go full-time or maybe 00:07:23.900 |
Do you want to go back to the working world maybe when the kids go back to school? 00:07:27.580 |
Do you even want to go back to work, or is this going to be a full-time thing? 00:07:32.220 |
Have you tried living on your wife's income and being a one-income family for a couple 00:07:38.020 |
See if it works, and just bank your money for now as savings, because you're going to 00:07:43.300 |
And then the other thing is, psychologically, are you okay giving up on the working world? 00:07:48.660 |
Because you're going to be asked some insensitive questions, right? 00:07:52.540 |
You know, "Oh, you decided to stop working and your wife's working." 00:07:55.980 |
It shouldn't be that way, but it is that way. 00:07:57.580 |
And for any parent who does this, my wife gets asked all the time, "Well, what are you 00:08:00.380 |
going to do when the kids go back to school?" 00:08:02.580 |
And her answer is, "I'll do whatever I want, whatever I need to do to get done," right? 00:08:05.260 |
And so I think there's a lot of insensitive and sometimes inappropriate questions people 00:08:08.740 |
get asked on this, but my answer to that is screw them. 00:08:12.300 |
You do what works for you, what works for your family. 00:08:14.460 |
Don't worry about what other people think and if other people are going to judge you. 00:08:17.940 |
I think it helps that you already have your finances in order. 00:08:20.660 |
If you're spending $40,000 to $50,000 a year and you have $150,000 income, you're doing 00:08:25.580 |
pretty good in terms of your spending-to-income ratio. 00:08:27.820 |
So it sounds like you're as ready as anyone to pull this off if you can, if you want to, 00:08:33.860 |
Yeah, no, I mean, I think you hit the nail on the head there. 00:08:37.420 |
It sounds like they've thought it through really well and they're just kind of wanting 00:08:40.020 |
some encouragement to do what they want to do. 00:08:43.540 |
But yeah, like you're saying, this is bigger than just the... 00:08:46.300 |
This is bigger than the financial side of things. 00:08:48.460 |
Yeah, if you have the financial stuff taken care of, it's probably the emotional and psychological 00:08:52.100 |
impact is bigger than anything, but I don't think this is something that you're going 00:08:56.980 |
So if you have to rip the bandaid off, do it, but I just make sure you can live on one 00:09:00.340 |
income for a while and try it out and again, bank your money so you have some more savings. 00:09:06.900 |
Okay, up next we have a question from Martin. 00:09:10.380 |
My wife and I just had a baby and we live in one of the nine states that offer a prepaid 00:09:16.060 |
By making either a monthly contribution or a lump sum payment, we can walk in the current 00:09:20.460 |
cost of in-state tuition, which is about $30,000 in Florida. 00:09:23.980 |
If our son chooses not to go to college, the money can be refunded. 00:09:26.580 |
Do you have any thoughts on this type of investment? 00:09:28.980 |
How do you expect the cost of college to inflate in comparison to potential compounding growth 00:09:36.540 |
This one's triggering me a little bit, right, because we know the direction college tuition 00:09:43.460 |
This is the CPI of college tuition and fees versus the regular consumer price index. 00:09:50.340 |
You can see college has basically doubled it up on an annual basis, like 6.5% almost, 00:09:57.340 |
You can see in the early 2000s it just took off like a rocket ship and went even higher. 00:10:07.500 |
My dad said people said that 20 or 30 years ago, and it still did. 00:10:12.660 |
There's a lot of financial problems like this that you're trying to plan for that don't 00:10:19.420 |
What returns should I expect to earn in the market? 00:10:23.020 |
What should I set as a baseline for inflation expectations? 00:10:26.460 |
This past couple of years has told us that we don't know anything about that. 00:10:33.180 |
So, this is another one where how much will college cost when my child reaches that age? 00:10:41.540 |
College probably isn't going to be as expensive as you think, depending on your situation. 00:10:45.220 |
So, Ron Lieber wrote this book called "The Price You Pay for College." 00:10:47.380 |
He had a few stats that kind of blew me away. 00:10:49.620 |
The average first-year full-time student, this is in 2019 and 2020, got a discount of 00:10:55.380 |
So, we see these huge list prices in the sticker shock you get. 00:10:59.900 |
The average grant for public universities is more than $4,100 per student. 00:11:04.420 |
89% of students at private colleges get a needs-based or merit-based discount on tuition. 00:11:10.140 |
And so, the people who end up paying full freight are mostly international students, 00:11:13.660 |
very rich people, and then people who want to attend more selective schools. 00:11:17.220 |
So, the average price people pay for private colleges, including room and board, is like 00:11:22.300 |
For in-state public universities, it's around $15,000 a year, a couple years old for these 00:11:27.300 |
So, it's not nearly as bad as you might think. 00:11:29.180 |
So, I think a lot of this boils down to how much certainty do you want? 00:11:33.460 |
Like, how important is it to pay for your child's education? 00:11:35.700 |
I know for some people, this is a huge priority. 00:11:38.340 |
Other people say, "I'm going to do my oxygen mask first, and I'm going to save for retirement, 00:11:42.660 |
and then the kids can figure it out either through working in college, or getting a scholarship, 00:11:47.140 |
or going to a lower-paying college, or a community college, or whatever it is." 00:11:50.060 |
It sounds to me like this is probably a priority for these people, so, I mean, I don't know. 00:11:54.860 |
One of the worries people say, "Well, what if online education is much bigger in the 00:12:00.700 |
And what if your child doesn't want to attend that public university in Florida? 00:12:03.900 |
And what if the government actually does something about the cost of college?" 00:12:06.260 |
So, a lot of this depends on how much do you want to plan? 00:12:09.580 |
Because no one knows what it's going to be in the future, but if you can lock it in now, 00:12:12.540 |
and that certainty is more important to you than for your financial planning than anything, 00:12:16.060 |
and you can get that refunded, if that's a priority, I don't see a problem with it if 00:12:20.020 |
you're taking that uncertainty, if the uncertainty is a big problem. 00:12:22.180 |
Because I know a lot of people say, "Well, who knows what college is going to look like 00:12:27.460 |
So I'm just going to roll the dice and see what happens." 00:12:30.060 |
If you want to take that uncertainty off the table, I can see the appeal of that. 00:12:33.620 |
Well, I've never heard of this before, but I'm guessing it's not all or nothing, right? 00:12:37.660 |
You can put whatever amount you want in towards the college, right? 00:12:41.560 |
It's not like you have to pay the full tuition price right now, or do you know? 00:12:47.340 |
We don't have this in Michigan, for sure, so that's a good question. 00:12:48.940 |
Yeah, I've never heard of this, so yeah, kind of a cool idea. 00:12:51.580 |
Someone send us an email and let us know if they know us more on this. 00:12:57.300 |
Up next, we have, "Recently, my father passed away, leaving roughly $150,000 to me as an 00:13:05.620 |
I'm trying to figure out if I should save or invest it. 00:13:08.220 |
I'm 26 years old and served four years as an Army officer. 00:13:11.820 |
I will be separating honorably soon, where I will go back to school and may need to access 00:13:16.820 |
I also may need to use them to buy a future house or get married. 00:13:21.200 |
I'm afraid of investing the funds short-term, less than three years, due to market volatility. 00:13:26.140 |
CDs and some bonds seem like low returns when interest rates are rising. 00:13:29.860 |
Shouldn't I wait to purchase a CD if interest rates continue to rise? 00:13:33.340 |
I did purchase IBONS with a 9.62% interest rate, but I still don't like the idea of the 00:13:39.020 |
rest of my money sitting in a savings account yielding almost nothing. 00:13:42.600 |
Is sitting in cash the safest bet short-term? 00:13:44.700 |
Sorry for your loss, and also, thank you for your service." 00:13:50.820 |
Again, I said this was going to be coming, and we got another one this week. 00:13:55.520 |
This is obviously a follower of Portfolio Rescue, because they're in the IBONS. 00:14:01.920 |
The good news is, this person has their risk profile and time horizon figured out. 00:14:07.700 |
They want to earn a little bit of yield, but they don't want to risk. 00:14:09.860 |
And again, we talked about the emotional baggage behind this. 00:14:13.300 |
Because this is an inheritance, it could have a little more to it behind it. 00:14:16.060 |
So, this person sounds like they got the good first step. 00:14:18.580 |
The bad news is, for a lot of investors, the Fed is raising interest rates, and they're 00:14:24.140 |
But the good news is, for savers, those interest rates mean higher yields that you can earn. 00:14:28.340 |
So, John, do a chart on the Treasury yield curve here. 00:14:31.680 |
You can see, especially on the short end, interest rates have come up a lot. 00:14:34.780 |
So, at the beginning of the year, we're talking a handful of basis points for 3 months Treasuries, 00:14:38.380 |
which is basically the short-term T-bill rate. 00:14:43.940 |
A lot of short-term yields for Treasuries are now yielding more than long-term. 00:14:47.600 |
And that is the biggest bang for your buck right now, because the Fed is raising rates, 00:14:52.940 |
So, the reason this matters is because short-term bonds have much less interest rate risk than 00:14:58.220 |
In the past, investors were being forced out on the risk curve. 00:15:04.700 |
Rates are higher on short-term bonds than long-term bonds, and it's like you're being 00:15:08.980 |
This is a good thing if you're looking to save cash or cash equivalents, especially if 00:15:15.260 |
So, here's some simple options we've talked about before. 00:15:21.540 |
The average yield to maturity is 3.5% on that fund. 00:15:25.420 |
That's higher than the rate you get on TLT, which is a 20-plus year bond market, which 00:15:31.720 |
You could also look at muni bonds, like the iShares Short-Term Muni Bond Fund. 00:15:36.100 |
That shows an average yield to maturity of 2.4%. 00:15:38.380 |
So, depending on your tax rate, we could do a tax equivalent yield where we back it out 00:15:44.020 |
We're talking probably 3% to 3.5% on a tax equivalent yield, depending on your tax rate. 00:15:48.620 |
Marcus, the one that I use for an online savings account, now yields 1.7%. 00:15:52.220 |
I think Ally, I looked today, was more like 1.85%. 00:15:57.260 |
I think those will go up as the Fed continues to raise rates, assuming they do. 00:16:00.500 |
So, savers can finally earn some yield on their cash. 00:16:03.020 |
You can't exactly move to the beach and live off the interest on this anymore, but at least 00:16:07.700 |
it's something, compared to the past, where you're basically getting nothing. 00:16:10.340 |
So, you're right, you don't want to put it in a brick-and-mortar bank, where you're still 00:16:13.140 |
probably earning 10 to 20 basis points, which should, frankly, be criminal, if I'm being honest. 00:16:18.500 |
The fact that the banks still don't pay anything. 00:16:20.940 |
They're earning 6% on mortgage rates, and they're paying out 10 basis points on their 00:16:27.540 |
I mean, you do still have to deal with a high inflation rate, but compared to the 0% you're 00:16:31.740 |
earning years ago, I'd say don't accept anything below 2.5% to 3%, if we're talking short-term 00:16:37.940 |
And again, you could match up the duration of the bonds now with your actual maturity 00:16:43.460 |
So, like I said, there's a one-to-three year treasury. 00:16:47.020 |
So, anything below 2.5% or 3% today probably doesn't make sense if you're looking for a 00:16:53.740 |
My question for another day is, with stocks and bonds both down double digits in the last 00:16:56.740 |
year, will more investors now start allocating to cash or short-term bonds? 00:17:07.420 |
And so, why don't we bring in our favorite former armed service member, Bill Sweet? 00:17:11.740 |
Because there has to be something else going on here. 00:17:13.620 |
Bill, any other special considerations for someone who's leaving the military in terms 00:17:18.740 |
Because I have to imagine there's a lot of stuff that I don't even know about. 00:17:23.300 |
A lot of great, great things that could potentially help. 00:17:25.660 |
I want to start, though, saying I was decked out for this show, pre-show. 00:17:31.620 |
He told me I can't wear white before or after Labor Day anymore. 00:17:42.220 |
And again, Ben, I know you claim to be a man of the people, but maybe you've got something 00:17:48.620 |
I mean, just don't mess with him when he gets in your wardrobe. 00:17:52.620 |
Duncan, I'm not going to call you what Michael said yesterday. 00:18:06.260 |
And again, my brother, for taking on arms, especially the last couple of years. 00:18:09.820 |
But no, I think the number one thing that popped in my mind was post-9/11 GI Bill benefits. 00:18:14.100 |
And Ben, I don't need to get too much into details, but I did about six years active 00:18:18.500 |
And I'm qualified for like 40% of tuition to a public university, and they can subsidize 00:18:24.380 |
The really neat thing about the GI Bill is that you also qualify during your school time 00:18:28.020 |
for BAH, Basic Allowance for Housing, which is this tax-free benefit for military personnel. 00:18:34.620 |
So I definitely look there, but I do want to give the listener credit. 00:18:40.080 |
They're thinking about all the right questions. 00:18:43.140 |
If you're getting 5% for corporates and taking corporate risk and about 3% for munis, it's 00:18:49.300 |
And I would say for any taxpayer, if we're going back to school, I'm guessing there's 00:18:52.540 |
not going to be a lot of income in that year. 00:18:54.700 |
Standard deduction this year is almost $13,000, right? 00:18:57.620 |
And so if you're putting that 150K and you're earning 3%, that's about $4,500 a year. 00:19:03.060 |
And in theory, if your income is low enough, that comes all tax-free, right? 00:19:09.160 |
The only other thing I would mention is about IBONs. 00:19:11.200 |
I know that you guys did this in the past, but one of the things that's interesting about 00:19:14.160 |
them, the limit is $10,000 per person per year, right? 00:19:18.480 |
We're about four months today from the end of the year when you can refund that with 00:19:23.240 |
If you happen to be married, you can have one for your spouse. 00:19:26.480 |
If you have two kids, you can have a child's account too. 00:19:29.840 |
And the really interesting thing is for LLCs, trust, basically anything with their own EIN, 00:19:38.600 |
Is it going to cost more to put up an LLC just to invest in IBONs? 00:19:42.720 |
But there's nothing that we can tell that would prohibit you from doing so. 00:19:45.640 |
Obviously, consult with your legal and tax advisors. 00:19:48.000 |
But Ben, I think you pointed them in the right direction. 00:19:51.140 |
One other thing I want to add here that I can't believe you didn't do because it's a 00:20:02.920 |
So take 6,000 of that and max out your Roth IRA, right? 00:20:07.360 |
Because if you realize later you need all that money for the wedding, you can still 00:20:11.520 |
So I think you should probably, especially as a young person, max out that IRA for a 00:20:15.880 |
year and at least get that out of the way and help yourself there get that started on 00:20:21.840 |
And the other nice thing, so Roth IRAs didn't pop into my mind, Ben, because that's more 00:20:25.560 |
There's no qualified distributions until age 60. 00:20:28.440 |
But if you get a little bit over your skis, A, out of the total inheritance, that's a 00:20:34.800 |
And then you can take non-qualified Roth distributions, get your basis back tax-free. 00:20:39.420 |
So if you get over your skis, you find the perfect house, you can take that distribution 00:20:53.480 |
My mom is retired and receiving about $1,100 a month from Social Security. 00:20:58.200 |
She has about $50,000 saved and is interested in investing the money. 00:21:01.920 |
Unfortunately, she doesn't have an IRA, and I read that she can't open a Roth as a retiree 00:21:08.360 |
I was looking at opening a brokerage account for her, but I have some questions. 00:21:12.040 |
Will the investment income from this account be tax, dividend, and equity growth? 00:21:16.280 |
I read that if her Social Security benefits plus additional income don't exceed $25,000, 00:21:29.380 |
It was someone who has a low income and not a lot of assets. 00:21:33.020 |
She could potentially pay zero taxes in retirement. 00:21:38.240 |
And I think that they brought Social Security to the top of the question. 00:21:42.160 |
And the listener is correct-- Dave is correct-- that if your income is below a certain threshold, 00:21:47.040 |
I believe, for individuals around $30,000, $40,000, your Social Security benefit is 100% 00:21:52.800 |
And so that ends up being a pretty powerful thing. 00:21:54.400 |
Average Social Security benefit in the US is about $1,200, $1,300. 00:21:58.260 |
And so ultimately, if you can get $12,000, $13,000 tax-free, and then stack other income 00:22:03.300 |
on top of that to take advantage of that standard deduction, which is actually higher for seniors, 00:22:07.720 |
it's about $15,000, $16,000, you stack those benefits up, and ultimately, mom's in a great 00:22:14.700 |
So even if we're talking 5% to 8% on that $50,000, and she's getting that back in capital 00:22:20.080 |
gains when she sells, or in interest income or dividends, probably with that standard 00:22:25.340 |
deduction, still not going to be paying any taxes in retirement, right? 00:22:29.500 |
And the listener's specific question is, what should I do with mom's assets, right, because 00:22:31.700 |
I don't want to mess up this really perfect tax picture. 00:22:35.100 |
I think where they're going is the right thing to do. 00:22:37.180 |
You probably don't want to generate a ton of current income. 00:22:40.820 |
And so I think some sort of-- I mean, the IBON is perfect for this, because ultimately, 00:22:44.420 |
all that interest compounds until the year of distribution. 00:22:47.060 |
So therefore, you have a little bit of control over when that income gets realized. 00:22:50.780 |
But I think the absence of that, which is just-- it's this perfect sweet spot of Treasury-protected 00:22:55.460 |
high interest income, I think some sort of brokerage account where you can control when 00:22:59.420 |
the income gets realized makes a lot of sense for this listener. 00:23:02.820 |
And for $50,000, that $10,000 limit is going to be 20% of the account, right? 00:23:10.380 |
And going back to the prior question, that popped in my head too. 00:23:11.380 |
Like, so let's say the individual's going to school. 00:23:15.300 |
You cannot fund a retirement account if you don't have earned income in the present. 00:23:18.520 |
So I think the suite of options is kind of limited for this question, listener. 00:23:25.260 |
And then after that, look at a brokerage account. 00:23:27.760 |
This could be just the government does weird things. 00:23:38.700 |
Logic and reason need not apply when it comes to federal benefits. 00:23:44.780 |
I think the concern is that if you're below a certain income-- so it's this means-tested 00:23:52.740 |
The federal government in the last three years, I believe, has spent somewhere in the neighborhood 00:23:56.540 |
of $3 or $4 trillion more than it's taken in. 00:24:00.420 |
I think the other part of the answer is, like, why not police? 00:24:08.660 |
And I think the general answer is you probably don't want to create a lot of privileged classes 00:24:16.220 |
And ultimately, it is tax-free if you're below a certain income. 00:24:19.100 |
I don't really philosophically have a problem with the means test on tax. 00:24:24.220 |
Progressive taxes are a pretty good thing for society, I think. 00:24:30.340 |
Also, Bill just said the name of what his podcast would be if he was doing options trading. 00:24:54.180 |
I was listening to your episode on real estate being an inflation hedge, and I heard Bill 00:24:57.220 |
Sweet talk about the tax advantages of doing a 401(k) rollover into a Roth account during 00:25:03.500 |
If I were to do a rollover with my self-directed 401(k) and I currently have unrealized capital 00:25:08.220 |
losses, how would those losses be treated on my taxes? 00:25:11.700 |
Could I use that loss to offset any capital gains I might have from other investments? 00:25:15.920 |
If so, would offsetting be treated differently for short-term or long-term capital gains? 00:25:24.020 |
They want that succulent tax-free withdrawal from a Roth. 00:25:26.620 |
Now I assume people who have just started making contributions in the last couple of 00:25:30.500 |
years, those are the people who are going to have some losses, and they're the ones 00:25:35.860 |
Because it's all-- you think it's segmented, but it's all one pool. 00:25:38.940 |
So how does this work for offsets and other stuff here? 00:25:45.100 |
We're hitting some really uncharted territory when it comes to taxes. 00:25:51.500 |
When we're talking about tax accounts, there's really two different types in the world, right? 00:25:55.220 |
There's tax-qualified, and your Roths go in there, your 401(k)s, your traditional IRAs 00:26:00.660 |
The theory there is any income, any distributions, any capital gains, anything that's going on 00:26:04.780 |
in the account doesn't get taxed until you distribute the asset. 00:26:08.220 |
Meanwhile, you have a non-qualified account in your second bucket. 00:26:11.640 |
Non-qualified is what we were talking about a second ago. 00:26:14.820 |
If you sell or gain at a loss, you have capital gains, you have losses. 00:26:17.900 |
But the difference is everything happens in a current tax year versus before bucket one 00:26:23.700 |
So again, bucket one, deferral, bucket two, taxable. 00:26:26.660 |
I believe what Zach is asking about is 401(k), and a 401(k), there's no capital gain to be 00:26:35.800 |
He did not pay on any tax when he funded that 401(k), and so any distribution, including 00:26:41.180 |
unit conversion, is going to be taxable based on the value of the conversion, not based 00:26:46.860 |
That's a very important distinction to keep in mind here. 00:26:49.920 |
And then ultimately, what we get from that is tax-free growth in the Roth, right? 00:26:54.860 |
But the ability to-- Right, so the taxes are paid either way, whether 00:27:00.620 |
So I don't think capital losses in a 401(k) are a thing at all, because the benefit there, 00:27:04.140 |
the benefit of using these tax-deferred vehicles, including Roths, is you're not paying tax 00:27:10.580 |
Therefore, the capital gain is probably moot, and therefore, this question is not terribly 00:27:14.980 |
relevant, unless we're talking about funding a Roth IRA from non-qualified assets, which 00:27:20.580 |
So the point is, if you're going to do that rollover, you're just going to want to make 00:27:23.220 |
sure you're having the ability to pay the taxes that you already deferred in the first 00:27:28.460 |
And point of privilege, when you're doing this, if you are doing a conversion from a 00:27:32.980 |
401(k), from a traditional IRA to a Roth, you really want to make sure that you're paying 00:27:38.260 |
Because ultimately, if you're paying tax, if you're doing a tax withholding on the conversion, 00:27:42.500 |
that just means you're not converting the whole balance that you possibly can. 00:27:47.200 |
So if you're thinking about, "Okay, $10,000 is what I can afford, I'm going to pay out 00:27:52.100 |
Convert over $7,000, do the lower conversion, and then pay for that with non-qualified assets. 00:27:57.780 |
Do not tax withhold on a Roth conversion, if you can help it. 00:28:03.300 |
He asked, he said, "I think this person's thinking about it the wrong way when they're 00:28:17.300 |
What is that intro exam that you have to do for finance, the S-I-E or something? 00:28:35.420 |
So last but not least, we have a question from Kendall. 00:28:36.420 |
And this one is going to make a lot of us that live in very expensive places very jealous. 00:28:39.980 |
"I'm 22 and live in rural Missouri, one of the cheapest places to live in the United 00:28:45.780 |
Not to brag, but my rent for a studio apartment is $300 a month. 00:28:50.240 |
I max out my Roth IRA, which is my sole retirement account, and will fulfill my retirement goals. 00:28:58.580 |
While it is great to think of all my retirement money that will be tax-free in 45 years, should 00:29:02.980 |
I be setting aside part of my IRA contributions into a traditional IRA? 00:29:07.320 |
My thought behind that question is if I have no taxable income in retirement, my deductions/credits 00:29:13.460 |
would be going to waste every year after I retire. 00:29:16.020 |
Would setting aside, say, $500 on my max contribution for a traditional IRA be something to consider?" 00:29:23.660 |
The impressive thing here about them maxing out the Roth IRA is that their Roth IRA contribution 00:29:36.220 |
This is the second person that's looking to minimize taxes in retirement. 00:29:39.420 |
But what do you think about diversifying your tax base if this person wants to have some 00:29:47.820 |
However, let's talk about Kendall's situation. 00:29:50.140 |
So just like Ben, Kendall's looking down on us with his Midwestern bias and his low rent. 00:29:57.140 |
I would advocate for diversification in tax, diversification of portfolio. 00:30:01.920 |
But talking about tax, there are three types of accounts you can have. 00:30:05.180 |
And I would argue for you want all three of these. 00:30:07.100 |
When you hit your 60s, you want to have a traditional IRA bucket, right, or 401(k). 00:30:10.980 |
You want to have some taxable income that you can manage. 00:30:13.820 |
You want to have a Roth bucket that's tax-free. 00:30:15.420 |
And you also do want to have this non-qualified bucket that we just referenced a minute ago. 00:30:21.700 |
But Ben, man of the people, Ben, when you were 22 compared to where you are now around 00:30:27.500 |
So I'm guessing that was a full 18 years in the rear view mirror. 00:30:30.020 |
Are you earning less or more today than you were at age 22? 00:30:33.980 |
Not to brag, I'm earning more money now than I was at 22. 00:30:38.660 |
I would say on average, people's incomes tend to increase through over time, right? 00:30:42.100 |
Unless you're an NBA player, Kendall, unless you're a Jenner, more than likely what we're 00:30:46.500 |
talking about here is your career earnings are going to increase over time. 00:30:50.660 |
Therefore, Ben, are you paying more taxes or less compared to age 22 today? 00:30:58.300 |
I would advocate that your tax rate is exponentially higher. 00:31:01.380 |
And therefore, I would argue in your 20s, your income is the lowest, your tax rate is 00:31:07.280 |
Because you're paying tax on that income before you contribute it. 00:31:12.340 |
Kendall is no longer paying $300 a month rent. 00:31:14.620 |
He's paying $3,000 a month rent for like those of us. 00:31:17.380 |
And that's a bargain, by the way, in New York City right now. 00:31:19.660 |
And now at that point, when you're making 60, you're making 70, you're making $100,000 00:31:27.180 |
Maybe you move to New York, it's getting taxed at 40%. 00:31:29.580 |
That's the time when you want to do this traditional IRA because your tax rate's higher. 00:31:35.940 |
Max fund that puppy to the extent that you can. 00:31:38.380 |
Focus on traditional IRA contributions later in life when you can take that tax deduction, 00:31:44.580 |
And if you have some extra money, put it into a taxable brokerage account, maybe start building 00:31:51.380 |
Let's say it's something that's doing taxless harvesting for you, absolutely, Ben. 00:31:54.180 |
The buckets matter, but now's the time to do the Roth. 00:31:58.500 |
It fits in Brooklyn, but it also could fit in Missouri too. 00:32:04.540 |
Bill, we have one more question to you from one of us. 00:32:06.540 |
One of us on this show completely paid off their student loans. 00:32:11.540 |
No, one of us had some of their student loans forgiven. 00:32:15.420 |
That person wants to know, is this a taxable event for them? 00:32:21.500 |
Per the CARES Act law, which I'm going to detect in 2021, any student loan forgiveness 00:32:26.000 |
abatement at the federal level, and this is important at the federal level, is not taxable 00:32:34.220 |
Assuming this Biden program survives the courts and legal challenges, then no, it will be 00:32:40.700 |
However, and there's always a catch, there are a bunch of states that de-conformed with 00:32:45.300 |
the federal law, and so it's possible in up to 14 states right now per early analysis 00:32:50.160 |
that the state may apply tax unless the legislators change- 00:32:55.100 |
New York complies generally, and so I believe that New York will not be taxable as income, 00:33:15.960 |
Our question three, our army officer is Richard. 00:33:21.960 |
Sorry to hear about that, but Richard, thank you for keeping us safe. 00:33:25.960 |
We appreciate you guys following along, making comments. 00:33:31.580 |
Happy Labor Day to those who celebrate, too, and are bringing kids back to school. 00:33:43.660 |
If you're watching on YouTube, subscribe button, podcast, leave us a review. 00:33:48.820 |
New Compound and Friends should be out tomorrow, and we will see you next week.