back to indexDuke_Baruch_or_Bust_v3
00:00:00.000 |
This Financial Samurai podcast episode is proudly sponsored by Danielson Legal, a boutique 00:00:05.940 |
law firm helping technology companies with their intellectual property, corporate matters, 00:00:11.840 |
technology law transactions, and litigation since 2008. 00:00:24.800 |
Hello everybody, it's Sam from the Financial Samurai podcast and I have with me a special 00:00:31.560 |
And in this episode, we're going to talk about the benefits of community college and whether 00:00:37.280 |
students should take it easy during their middle school and grade school years and not 00:00:43.420 |
stress so much about getting into one of these elite colleges. 00:00:48.600 |
So there's a great article out there called Duke, Baruch, or Bust? 00:00:54.240 |
Parents debate if pricey private schools are still worth it. 00:00:57.360 |
Let me just read a little bit from the article to give you an idea of what it's talking about. 00:01:02.520 |
Clara is a mother whose son is a rising senior at an elite private school in Miami. 00:01:08.320 |
For the past few years, as his peers have been beefing up on extracurriculars and thinking 00:01:13.460 |
about how to best translate their passions into projects that will stand out to college 00:01:18.620 |
admissions officers, Clara's son hasn't been doing any of those things, and Clara, the 00:01:26.880 |
Having watched acceptance rates plummet to the single digits as the cost of college has 00:01:31.000 |
skyrocketed, Clara's family is happily resigned to not gunning for the Ivy League and the 00:01:36.720 |
top 25 schools that most of her peer groups seize as the crowning achievement of a gilded 00:01:44.680 |
This means that her son is limiting the number of AP courses he takes to five throughout 00:01:53.000 |
And if he says he feels like he doesn't want to do soccer this term because there's too 00:02:00.160 |
We decided his health and wellness are much more important than getting a weighted 5.0 00:02:05.520 |
GPA, having no social life, being stressed, and doing homework until two in the morning. 00:02:12.960 |
So what are your thoughts about Clara's attitude and her son's attitude towards taking it more 00:02:21.960 |
The thing that jumped out to me the most was 12 AP classes? 00:02:32.400 |
Five itself is a lot, way, way above average, I would think. 00:02:44.040 |
I guess a lot has changed since we went to school. 00:02:49.480 |
Maybe I took three APs in high school, and that was tough. 00:02:53.520 |
Well, that's why you ended up at William & Mary with me, because we were just average. 00:03:00.440 |
So what are your thoughts about taking a more easy course load in high school and not worrying 00:03:07.720 |
about getting into one of these top 25 or top 50 colleges? 00:03:12.520 |
Well, I think it depends on how you define easy. 00:03:17.480 |
If you consider easy 5 AP classes, that to me sounds like her son is still trying very 00:03:27.160 |
I don't think, again, we don't have a high school student right now, so I don't know 00:03:31.560 |
if that's really the norm to take a minimum of 5 AP classes. 00:03:39.380 |
It sounds like what his peers are doing is just not feasible for her son's mental health. 00:03:49.380 |
I think that's great that they've found a healthy balance for him and their family. 00:03:55.960 |
If going to community college is better for balance, then that's the best way to go. 00:04:02.900 |
So imagine if you went to private school for 13 years, you spent $500,000 for private grade 00:04:12.100 |
I think there's nothing wrong with going to community college. 00:04:15.580 |
And even if you do, you can still have the option to transfer at some point during your 00:04:25.900 |
I think community college is the way to go for people like us. 00:04:32.140 |
We don't have really high academic achievements. 00:04:35.620 |
Just look at our SAT scores, they were quite mediocre. 00:04:38.980 |
We're Asian-American, so we have this Asian penalty for some reason to need to score even 00:04:43.660 |
higher to get the same chances for our kids to get into college. 00:04:48.500 |
So I feel like for us, there's really little to no hope to get into a top 25 or top 50 00:04:55.100 |
university, especially the private ones, because they have their standard criteria and they 00:05:04.780 |
And so I was thinking to myself, well, maybe community college is the way to go. 00:05:08.580 |
And I wrote a post about community college being a great option. 00:05:13.100 |
And I got so many great responses from the readership. 00:05:17.340 |
For example, Champ, a reader named Champ said, "Both of us went to community college and 00:05:21.580 |
earned six figures before we both retired in our 60s. 00:05:25.940 |
All our children went to community college and transferred to state universities. 00:05:30.860 |
Total college costs for five children, $180,000. 00:05:42.500 |
And one son and his wife earned seven figures. 00:05:46.260 |
Relocate and live responsibly instead of high rolling nonsense." 00:05:53.780 |
And after I wrote the post, I had another 40 plus commenters who went to community college 00:06:02.500 |
They're all living pretty healthy quality of lifestyles. 00:06:05.980 |
And I'm thinking to myself, this sounds like the way. 00:06:09.860 |
Maybe two years community college, it's probably going to be free by the time our kids go to 00:06:15.220 |
They can transfer to a four year state university if they want to save more money. 00:06:19.660 |
Or if they can get scholarships, they can transfer to a private four year university. 00:06:29.380 |
Because this is something that I'm really thinking about. 00:06:31.340 |
Because I don't want to go through having a stressed out son and daughter who thinks 00:06:36.900 |
they must take 10 AP courses and get a 5.0 weighted GPA and do all these extracurricular 00:06:51.300 |
And we're going to figure things out when the time comes. 00:06:57.980 |
And even, let's say they, for some reason, they got into one of the top colleges based 00:07:08.380 |
But we knew that they would not be able to keep up academically. 00:07:13.620 |
Even if they got into that top school, I'm not sure I would want them to go if I knew 00:07:17.460 |
that they would be struggling for four years. 00:07:21.220 |
I think there is a lot of value in balancing mental health and going to a school where 00:07:33.620 |
You'll be able to learn at a pace that you can keep up with. 00:07:37.560 |
So that when it comes time to graduate, you'll be in a good headspace and have a good foundation 00:07:44.580 |
and have built relationships with your professors and your peers and be ready to jump into the 00:07:54.180 |
I would also want to share a comment from Zen Master. 00:08:00.980 |
And he's so candid in his thoughts and the comments. 00:08:03.900 |
He was just saying, "I've got my twin daughters and they are just depending on me for everything. 00:08:14.300 |
Doesn't seem like they'll be able to get good jobs. 00:08:17.060 |
Whenever they have some kind of expense, they call me to ask for money." 00:08:22.060 |
And one of them is an adult who's graduated already. 00:08:25.380 |
And I asked him, "Why not just not give her the money?" 00:08:34.260 |
And so I asked him, "Why, if you could rewind time, why did you end up going this route 00:08:40.180 |
of super privileged lifestyle, private college and everything?" 00:08:45.020 |
And one of the reasons he talked about was peer pressure. 00:08:49.560 |
He was saying even though he realized that giving them all the privileges in the world 00:08:55.940 |
was maybe not a great way to harden them up, right? 00:08:59.620 |
Because if you are soft, you create soft kids. 00:09:02.420 |
If you are hard, maybe you create harder kids. 00:09:06.260 |
And he said peer pressure, in terms of peer pressure from other parents, from teachers, 00:09:12.300 |
from guidance counselors, from other friends, parents, right? 00:09:18.900 |
He said he just couldn't say no to that private college route due to peer pressure. 00:09:24.300 |
Do you think you will succumb to peer pressure, Sydney, from other moms and other dads out 00:09:31.260 |
I think I'm pretty chill in general in terms of my personality and lifestyle. 00:09:37.340 |
Because at the end of the day, we want our kids to be happy. 00:09:44.500 |
And even if they somehow manage to get into a top private university, if we knew that 00:09:49.420 |
that wouldn't help them succeed in life, then I don't think we would encourage that. 00:09:55.580 |
We would obviously have many discussions together to figure out what we felt would be the best 00:10:04.260 |
Ultimately, they would need to choose because it's their decision, their life. 00:10:09.180 |
But I don't think I would succumb to peer pressure. 00:10:13.100 |
Why would we want to make someone else happy if it's not going to benefit our children? 00:10:21.020 |
What do you think about sending our kids to public school and saving a lot of money over 00:10:26.520 |
the next 12, 13 years, given we don't succumb to peer pressure? 00:10:33.220 |
And the path to community college sounds like a good one. 00:10:38.020 |
It all depends on circumstances and there are a lot of challenges that we've witnessed 00:10:45.180 |
in the San Francisco public school system that we don't feel are the best fit for our 00:10:52.460 |
And for some families, it's great and I'm all for that. 00:10:57.320 |
We just have to look at what works best for our own family. 00:11:01.340 |
Yeah, because I know if I was six years old, let's say, and my parents said, "Would 00:11:08.820 |
you like to go to a private grade school and get no money upon graduating from high school? 00:11:15.180 |
Or would you rather go to a public school and get $500,000?" 00:11:22.640 |
And one of the reasons why is because I went to public school in high school and it was 00:11:29.300 |
Obviously, there were some ups and down moments, but I was like, "Give me the $500,000. 00:11:35.660 |
You're talking about asking a six-year-old this? 00:11:40.500 |
I know it's not realistic, but you can ask a 13-year-old before he or she goes to private 00:11:47.180 |
high school, "Would you rather have, let's say, $200,000 or $250,000 and go to public 00:11:54.620 |
school, public high school, or go to private high school?" 00:11:57.940 |
I think these are questions we need to ask as personal finance people. 00:12:04.260 |
Because let me continue in this article on Duke or Baruch and where this quote came from. 00:12:09.380 |
So this mother gave her son, who attends an elite Manhattan high school, an ultimatum. 00:12:17.580 |
I'm not paying $80,000 a year so you can go to Middlebury and learn to build a bonfire." 00:12:23.420 |
Although the family has means and can afford a school like Middlebury, one of the top liberal 00:12:27.700 |
arts colleges in the nation, with a 14% acceptance rate, the mother doesn't see the practicality 00:12:33.660 |
of paying for a so-called "select tier 2" college in today's world. 00:12:39.020 |
Her feeling is that an Ivy or Ivy-like school like Duke, Stanford, MIT, etc. degree offers 00:12:45.260 |
a level of prestige that will more readily translate into job opportunities, thus justifying 00:12:53.860 |
And I thought this quote was awesome because my Mandarin teacher in college decided to 00:12:59.420 |
leave the College of William & Mary and go to Middlebury. 00:13:02.180 |
And I remember Middlebury always being a wonderful liberal arts college with a wonderful, wonderful 00:13:09.380 |
And this is also a school that you and I probably would never be able to get into because of 00:13:17.460 |
And in retrospect, I'm thinking to myself, "Yay! 00:13:19.660 |
I'm glad we weren't able to go to these expensive schools because we were able to graduate without 00:13:27.700 |
So, I guess my hope is, it sounds great to me, so you think you're not going to succumb 00:13:36.420 |
I feel I'm a little bit more realistic when I see other people with a nice car or a nice 00:13:45.700 |
I feel a little bit like, "Oh, I want to have a nice house. 00:14:03.360 |
We go to a lot of events, playdates and whatnot. 00:14:07.860 |
And there's moms there who are always fashionable and looking great. 00:14:18.540 |
I would much rather buy a cheap outfit at Target or whatever because I know I'm going 00:14:33.500 |
I don't even know if you would consider that peer pressure in terms of looking your best. 00:14:39.820 |
I don't feel peer pressure to change myself in order to fit in. 00:14:45.220 |
I've never heard anybody say that they don't experience any peer pressure. 00:14:50.740 |
I remember when I met you in college, there was the grunge phase and you had baggy pants 00:15:01.220 |
So what I experienced as a student is different than what I experience now as an adult. 00:15:07.360 |
I think there was a lot of pressure to fit in at school. 00:15:12.620 |
You didn't want to be the odd one out and not have friends. 00:15:16.340 |
I have adult friends who I have similarities with and also who I have plenty of differences 00:15:21.740 |
with, but I'm confident with who I am now as an adult. 00:15:25.340 |
So I don't feel the same types of peer pressure that I did when I was younger. 00:15:31.460 |
Do I feel some pressure for our son and daughter to be well-behaved and to socialize? 00:15:41.380 |
So you're saying if one of your good mom friends, for example, son, ended up getting 00:15:47.180 |
into a top 20 university, you wouldn't feel a little bit envious or pressured or like 00:15:54.860 |
you noticed that he was doing really well academically freshman and sophomore year, 00:16:00.100 |
entering all these competitions, doing great on PSAT, doing all this extracurricular. 00:16:04.700 |
You wouldn't feel like, "Oh, maybe our son should do the same?" 00:16:08.700 |
I might feel some jealousy in terms of achievements, but again, we've talked about this before 00:16:18.340 |
There's a lot of parents out there who are sending their kids to three to four different 00:16:33.500 |
So why would we want to put him through that if he's going to be miserable and it costs 00:16:38.780 |
We find other activities that he's interested in. 00:16:41.660 |
Swimming, for example, you guys worked on that. 00:16:44.140 |
That's something that was a sports activity that you guys focused on and he loved it. 00:16:49.580 |
So we're going to focus on things that our kids are interested in and be happy with that. 00:17:00.980 |
When the rubber meets the road, when it's time, when he's in high school to apply to 00:17:06.340 |
college and get a job or whatever, I think you're going to feel a little bit different. 00:17:12.820 |
I think it's important for parents to actually pull or push, whatever the phrase may be, 00:17:18.500 |
a little bit more than kids will do on their own so they can self-discover and they can 00:17:27.020 |
One story for me is I liked tennis growing up, but I wasn't pushed hard enough to train. 00:17:35.580 |
As a result, I wasn't as good as I could have been. 00:17:42.820 |
I always wonder, wow, what if my parents pushed me harder to train more on the tennis side, 00:17:48.540 |
gave me a better framework, more consistency? 00:17:51.180 |
I think I would have been better and I definitely think I could have played for college. 00:17:56.940 |
I think that's why you and I are so involved with our kids. 00:18:01.220 |
That's something that we really care about and we want to be able to support them in 00:18:07.460 |
I think what will affect me way more emotionally is if, let's say, our kids have their hearts 00:18:14.060 |
set on a specific school and we've talked about it and we think that school is within 00:18:19.140 |
reason, they apply to it and they get rejected. 00:18:22.140 |
That's going to hurt me way more than their classmates getting into a school. 00:18:27.900 |
If it was the same school that our kids wanted to get into, then yeah, that's going to hurt. 00:18:42.380 |
I think the reason why I'm more sensitive to rejection is because I've been rejected 00:18:48.780 |
I'm always putting myself out there, whether it's trying to get business when I was working. 00:18:53.660 |
Nobody would pick up the phone, respond to my emails. 00:18:55.700 |
They'd say, "No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no." 00:19:00.180 |
I compete in USTA tennis at the 4.5 and 5.0 level. 00:19:04.860 |
I lost so many times, but I kept on competing. 00:19:09.180 |
Many times when I lost, I felt crushed for a day. 00:19:11.740 |
I was like, "Man, I trained so hard and I still lost. 00:19:18.660 |
I remember trying to join these blog networks, which were popular at the time. 00:19:33.420 |
Over time, I've become more hardened, but I still feel that sting, that pain of rejection, 00:19:40.460 |
which as a father, I know our kids will get rejected so many times. 00:19:45.620 |
Whereas I think for you, you had a different type of job when you were working and you 00:19:50.580 |
don't put yourself out there as much as I do, which means you don't feel that sting 00:19:58.700 |
In terms of the type of job that you had, yeah, for sure. 00:20:04.020 |
When I had in college, I had this very, very minimum, low minimum wage job where I had 00:20:17.540 |
And yes, I was rejected probably 99.9% of the time on all those calls. 00:20:26.860 |
I was like, "I cannot be in sales when I graduate from college." 00:20:33.660 |
So yes, in the type of role that you had at work and all of your athletics, yeah, you 00:20:41.820 |
definitely had to face way more rejections and failures than I did. 00:20:48.660 |
Well, so maybe what we should do is to kind of equalize how we feel about rejection and 00:20:53.580 |
failure and the sting is to get you to put yourself out there more. 00:20:58.420 |
Maybe try to send a manuscript to a publisher, for example, or try to do competitive orchestra 00:21:12.300 |
I've done stuff like that and not gotten the results that I've wanted. 00:21:17.780 |
I've had plenty of rejection in my life as well. 00:21:20.900 |
So how about we just continue to do that because it's been years since you did that. 00:21:27.980 |
Yes, because if you feel the pressure and you get rejected at this age, then we'll always 00:21:33.380 |
know what it's like to try really hard and fail, which would make us, I think, a little 00:21:42.500 |
I'll get rejected before I even get my audition taken. 00:21:50.180 |
Promise me you're going to do some audition and try. 00:21:54.420 |
But I feel that a lot of people don't try to put themselves out there, try to do something 00:21:57.420 |
entrepreneurial or new is because they're afraid of rejection and then it just hurts 00:22:03.380 |
For some reason, I have this defiant attitude. 00:22:10.220 |
But I think that's a personality trait, but it's also honed over years and years of experience. 00:22:16.060 |
Yeah, there's this common thing that people are too afraid to try because they're afraid 00:22:22.580 |
I think that's a common fear that a lot of people face. 00:22:28.820 |
Well, we don't want our kids to get rejected, but I think rejection is good because it makes 00:22:34.940 |
But I think we can't set their expectations if you agree to have them go to community 00:22:43.100 |
It doesn't require you getting straight A's in high school to go to community college. 00:22:47.860 |
And if they do well in community college, they can always transfer to a four-year state 00:22:53.380 |
What do you think about going forward this plan as they enter middle school and high 00:23:01.140 |
I think it's something that we're going to keep open and we will apply to – I think 00:23:07.300 |
we're going to have to apply to a lot of schools. 00:23:08.980 |
I feel so many people – it's just like a numbers game. 00:23:13.580 |
You have to apply to a bunch in hopes that you'll get into one or two. 00:23:19.300 |
And just for people curious about what the average income is for people who graduate 00:23:23.180 |
from community college, it's about $33,000 to $34,000. 00:23:27.540 |
And the average income for people who graduate from a four-year state school is closer to 00:23:34.260 |
And I think the average income for Ivy League graduates is about $5,000 to $8,000 higher 00:23:42.460 |
But it's still not that impressive if you graduate from an Ivy League university. 00:23:50.780 |
That's all you make five years out of college from an Ivy League or 10 years out?" 00:23:54.620 |
I was thinking to myself, "Why stress over for five to eight years of your life during 00:24:00.300 |
grade school to achieve that when the chances are 95% to 99% chance you're going to get 00:24:10.220 |
Well, I'm really pleased by that because one of my stresses is are children doing well 00:24:16.300 |
enough in school to get into a decent college, to get a job and be financially independent 00:24:26.380 |
Well, there are other things greater, but it feels wonderful to be independent and not 00:24:32.540 |
have to rely on your parents once you're an adult. 00:24:36.420 |
Especially as, I don't know, I think as a male, because as a male, not only do we – I 00:24:43.780 |
We have this growing up aspect where we're thinking, "Oh, we've got to provide enough 00:24:49.140 |
And I know things have changed over time, but that's how I felt. 00:24:52.420 |
Any last words before we let the audience go? 00:24:55.220 |
I just wish the best of luck to all the parents out there who are going through the application 00:25:04.780 |
This episode of Financial Samurai is proudly sponsored by Danielson Legal. 00:25:09.540 |
Danielson Legal is a boutique law firm that has been helping tech companies since 2008. 00:25:15.060 |
They pride themselves on prompt attention to their clients' day-to-day legal needs, 00:25:19.660 |
including intellectual property, corporate matters, technology law and transactions, 00:25:24.820 |
and litigation, with pricing designed to provide value to their clients. 00:25:29.660 |
You can find them on the web at www.danielsonlegal.com. 00:25:39.340 |
If you would like to subscribe to Financial Samurai, go to financialsamurai.com/news. 00:25:45.020 |
You'd also love a share, a review and a rating of this podcast.