back to indexHow Should I Invest Cash on the Sidelines?
Chapters
0:0 Intro
3:15 Investing near all-time highs
10:40 How rate changes affect bond ETFs
13:15 How do economists make predictions?
21:5 Investing an inheritance as a couple
27:25 Purchasing big ticket items
33:40 Who is going to buy the Tesla Cybertruck?
00:00:14.520 |
where we had two weeks worth of questions building up. 00:00:16.460 |
Duncan and I today are thankful for the color purple. 00:00:19.860 |
Remember our email here, askthecompoundshow@gmail.com. 00:00:27.100 |
Duncan and I was in Detroit over the weekend, 00:00:41.480 |
I was walking around trying to be comfortable. 00:00:48.660 |
which is good for the summer, fall, spring time. 00:00:54.300 |
And in the past, I probably would have worn jeans, 00:01:02.660 |
they're still giving away the Bird Dog white tech dad hat. 00:01:14.740 |
- I gotta say, you look really fashionable in that photo. 00:01:30.780 |
financial questions at the Thanksgiving table? 00:01:33.540 |
- I did get a few finance questions from people at the table, 00:01:39.280 |
- Nothing as exciting as your Twitter exchanges? 00:01:48.780 |
People can get bad news from anywhere, right? 00:01:53.100 |
People on social media like to share bad news. 00:01:55.980 |
I like to give some optimistic takes into the world. 00:01:58.820 |
And if there's one thing people hate more than anything 00:02:03.380 |
it's good news and long-term stock market returns. 00:02:09.320 |
So I'm just trying to, listen, I'm not naive. 00:02:11.620 |
I know that there's bad things in the economy. 00:02:21.580 |
It's the stock market is almost back to all-time highs. 00:02:28.340 |
is to hate on people essentially and to fight. 00:02:33.340 |
they should at least have something original. 00:02:35.460 |
Half the time I'm looking, I'm like following the threads 00:02:39.000 |
that someone else already said and you refuted. 00:02:44.720 |
"Well, yeah, what about credit card debt levels?" 00:02:51.880 |
And then like five other people ask you the same thing. 00:02:54.200 |
What about credit card debt? - I'm used to it. 00:03:00.200 |
- I think people don't realize that you actually do enjoy it. 00:03:08.440 |
But right now I think the good outweighs the bad. 00:03:11.920 |
- Let's do a question. - Let's do a good news. 00:03:16.640 |
I'm finding it incredibly hard to invest my excess cash 00:03:22.640 |
I know I'm supposed to just grip my teeth and invest, 00:03:26.460 |
and take comfort in knowing that time in the market 00:03:29.800 |
is the biggest factor in my long-term investment success. 00:03:32.600 |
But it's so damn hard for me to do psychologically 00:03:42.160 |
and even invest a bit into my brokerage account. 00:03:45.100 |
But I have money building up on the sidelines. 00:03:47.000 |
There's cash on the sidelines, who you guys talk about. 00:03:56.660 |
because I know I'm not the only one suffering 00:04:06.080 |
I think for some investors, this will always be a problem. 00:04:08.920 |
The thing is, obviously, market timing is hard. 00:04:13.320 |
and the worst thing that can happen is you're right, 00:04:18.180 |
So when markets are falling, and you're sitting in cash, 00:04:20.840 |
you just say, well, they're gonna fall even further, 00:04:22.320 |
so I'm just gonna wait, so cash becomes a safety blanket. 00:04:29.000 |
and then cash becomes a safety blanket again. 00:04:36.320 |
I went to cash in 1999, timed it perfectly, right? 00:04:41.640 |
the most expensive the US stock market has ever been, 00:04:46.240 |
And then we came back after that bear market, 00:05:00.500 |
that you've been sitting in cash for so long? 00:05:02.220 |
He said, well, it's some combination of fear, arrogance, 00:05:05.000 |
and then he latched onto this macro doom and gloom 00:05:09.060 |
that just put him in the investment fetal position 00:05:13.220 |
And so it's like, obviously, market timing is hard, 00:05:19.120 |
But you also have to psychologically get over that hurdle 00:05:22.960 |
And so I think there's a few ways to get around this fear. 00:05:25.840 |
I'll start with the more spreadsheet strategies, 00:05:28.600 |
and then get to more of the behavioral side of things, 00:05:30.320 |
'cause the behavioral is obviously the biggest part here. 00:05:32.600 |
Like, I view diversification and asset allocation 00:05:36.600 |
If everyone knew what the future was going to be, 00:05:40.000 |
You would just put 100% of your portfolio into Oatly, 00:05:44.200 |
- Hey, Oatly's looking pretty good this week. 00:05:46.800 |
We joke a lot about my irresponsible position in Oatly, 00:05:53.200 |
- Someone in the live, someone wanted to know 00:05:59.120 |
- For the record, I'm still more than cut in half 00:06:05.160 |
is that you're balancing out your various time horizons 00:06:11.000 |
You don't have one asset allocation for a bull market, 00:06:16.200 |
and then deflation, and rising rates and falling rates. 00:06:18.480 |
You set an asset allocation that balances out 00:06:21.240 |
the different risks and needs in your portfolio, 00:06:23.440 |
and that's durable enough for any environment, 00:06:25.400 |
'cause you don't know what the environment's going to be. 00:06:27.000 |
So you have this mix of stocks, bonds, and cash, 00:06:32.160 |
So the first thing is, like, get an asset allocation, 00:06:34.840 |
and that should be true of both your current assets 00:06:38.800 |
and maybe cash is one of those buckets too, right? 00:06:40.800 |
Cash can be it, but I think you just have to, 00:06:43.240 |
have to think in that asset allocation framework. 00:06:47.200 |
for large cap stocks, like, we've talked about this. 00:06:49.920 |
We talked about this with Jeremy Schwartz a few weeks ago. 00:06:52.080 |
There's other asset classes you can invest in 00:07:05.200 |
You can diversify into other strategies and asset classes. 00:07:14.280 |
I used this one before from a couple weeks ago. 00:07:15.880 |
This is new all-time highs in the S&P by decade. 00:07:18.720 |
You can see there's some decades where it happens less, 00:07:27.480 |
So, you know, roughly one out of every 12 or 13 trading days. 00:07:38.400 |
The other big piece is obviously defining your goals 00:07:47.280 |
Like, I think most people look at their investments 00:07:54.800 |
or outperformance or a good sharp ratio or whatever. 00:07:59.200 |
or a second home or renovations or beach house 00:08:01.880 |
or whatever it is, healthcare needs, rainy day. 00:08:04.960 |
So I think you have to kind of attach a goal to this 00:08:08.200 |
and define what you're trying to get out of the future 00:08:12.280 |
And I think another way of thinking about this, 00:08:15.800 |
Remember we used the Dustin Hoffman example before. 00:08:18.680 |
I think you can, even though it's one big pile of money, 00:08:26.080 |
And then you can have an intermediate-term bucket 00:08:30.320 |
and then maybe a short-term bucket that includes cash. 00:08:34.660 |
you can have a percentage of cash over your portfolio, 00:08:37.640 |
And for me, my short-term savings, I have a level of cash. 00:08:52.180 |
but then anything over and above a certain level, 00:08:54.480 |
sweep into your investment accounts and put it to work. 00:08:57.760 |
So of course, that's like the spreadsheet part of it. 00:09:09.480 |
Automate your contributions, automate your asset allocation, 00:09:11.440 |
automate your rebalancing, put it on the schedule, 00:09:17.840 |
Like, have an asset allocation, make it automatic, 00:09:21.560 |
I think that's the best way to avoid mistakes 00:09:26.960 |
'Cause obviously, those psychological barriers, 00:09:34.800 |
- But this is something that I constantly hear from people. 00:09:40.800 |
and they just could not force themselves to get back in. 00:09:43.660 |
And you'd hear from 'em seven or eight years later 00:09:46.200 |
after there's a bull market, and then they go, 00:10:08.680 |
- But also, being optimistic long-term is good, 00:10:12.720 |
yes, there's gonna be short-term setbacks as well, 00:10:16.520 |
on waiting for those setbacks to happen all the time, 00:10:18.240 |
'cause that's really, really a tough stance to take. 00:10:21.560 |
I'm only going to invest when the market crashes, 00:10:24.080 |
because you constantly end up in a fetal position that way, 00:10:26.720 |
and waiting for things to get worse and worse, 00:10:36.280 |
- Okay, that question was from Josh, by the way. 00:10:44.000 |
"At a basic level, I understand the inverse relationship 00:11:00.520 |
because many bond funds have a relatively static maturity 00:11:07.140 |
is just a portfolio of individual bond securities. 00:11:13.420 |
There just might be some more buying and selling 00:11:14.940 |
as opposed to holding all the bonds to maturity. 00:11:17.180 |
So yes, as interest rates rise, prices go down, 00:11:27.280 |
So iShares was actually nice enough to provide us 00:11:29.540 |
with a historical look over the last 10 years 00:11:39.300 |
This is the average yield to maturity in the AG 00:11:43.320 |
You can see rates were pretty skippy there for a while, 00:11:49.980 |
and we got all the way down to 1% by the end of 2020, 00:11:53.120 |
which was just all risks, no reward, more or less. 00:12:00.380 |
the average yield of maturity on the AG is more than 5.6%, 00:12:04.840 |
But you've had to endure some losses to get there. 00:12:06.880 |
So John, show the next, throw the next one on. 00:12:08.800 |
This is the AG over the last three or four years 00:12:11.280 |
from the, we're in like a three-year bear market. 00:12:30.320 |
and your future expected returns are much better. 00:12:36.240 |
but bond investors are in a pretty good place these days 00:12:39.680 |
especially compared to the last 15 years or so. 00:12:41.880 |
- And now, I don't want to put words in your mouth, 00:12:45.240 |
but you did say on yesterday's Animal Spirits 00:12:48.360 |
that you think there's a 100% chance of a rate cut in 2024. 00:13:07.160 |
because I think you never go 0% or 100% for anything. 00:13:12.960 |
- Okay, up next we have a question from Dave who says, 00:13:23.260 |
"with their probabilities in the first place? 00:13:25.060 |
"It seems like they all just say 40% as a hedge 00:13:41.880 |
about the benefits of thinking in terms of probabilities, 00:13:51.400 |
you think of the future in terms of a range of outcomes 00:14:03.360 |
because then that's like an intellectual hedge 00:14:07.440 |
And I think the current setup is a good case in point. 00:14:12.680 |
Like people wanna know like what's the hard landing, 00:14:18.240 |
especially for something as complex as the economy, 00:14:21.360 |
placing probabilities on outcomes in an unknowable future? 00:14:33.420 |
in the Wall Street Journal, I think it was 2018, 00:14:38.560 |
'Cause if it doesn't happen, I was under half, 00:14:58.880 |
anything other than long-term asset class returns? 00:15:08.180 |
And if you have a long enough holding period, 00:15:15.280 |
well, you could reasonably expect those sort of returns. 00:15:22.400 |
some of them just extrapolate the current trends, 00:15:28.400 |
is like what just happened is gonna keep going, yeah. 00:15:31.780 |
- Right, employment is falling, it'll keep falling. 00:15:36.280 |
The other thing that I kinda feel lots of people forget 00:15:45.500 |
think about the institutional pressures on you 00:15:49.240 |
to try and stay somewhere in the middle of the pack, 00:16:01.300 |
even if you think the world is going to hell, 00:16:06.080 |
there's a lot of pressure on those sorts of jobs, 00:16:10.260 |
career risk, to go too far away from the herd. 00:16:21.880 |
where everybody puts out their year-end forecast, 00:16:25.980 |
and we talk about different people's forecasts. 00:16:29.020 |
I wanna ask the person who asked this question, 00:16:40.860 |
you should be thinking out decades, or certainly years. 00:16:45.640 |
The problem with 12 months is that it's way too short 00:16:55.460 |
- And your point about forecasting the markets 00:17:02.260 |
and knew what the data was gonna be in the economy, 00:17:10.780 |
that the Russians were gonna invade Ukraine next year, 00:17:16.000 |
and oil prices will be negative 12 months later. 00:17:18.860 |
Like that's the last thing people are gonna think about. 00:17:23.740 |
is gonna shut the whole economy next quarter. 00:17:27.420 |
Do you think the market's gonna finish up for that year? 00:17:30.860 |
It's so hard to do second and third steps removed. 00:17:38.020 |
it's not the first level thinking, it's the second level. 00:17:42.060 |
And then the repercussions in the third level, 00:17:44.860 |
it just becomes so difficult to try and figure out 00:17:53.820 |
by the time it reaches the other side of the lake. 00:17:55.820 |
- The one time that the economic model did say 00:17:58.520 |
there's 100% chance of recession in 2023, it was wrong. 00:18:03.020 |
And everyone assumed there would be a recession this year 00:18:06.380 |
So yeah, that's so true is that people forecasting 00:18:11.700 |
is not even like the data, it's the reaction to the data. 00:18:16.860 |
I can't guess what I'm gonna do tomorrow in some cases, 00:18:19.620 |
trying to guess what all these collective investors 00:18:21.540 |
are going to do in a month or a few months, it's impossible. 00:18:24.740 |
- That's why all this sentiment polling is so silly, 00:18:28.020 |
whether it's markets or inflation or elections. 00:18:31.540 |
When you ask somebody who you're gonna vote for, 00:18:38.200 |
Good chance that either of the presidential candidates 00:18:49.600 |
And then it's, are you gonna vote for who you're gonna say? 00:18:52.100 |
Say you are, are you even gonna get out of the house 00:18:54.900 |
We have such low levels of voter participation. 00:18:59.420 |
And it's the same as true when we talk to people 00:19:03.700 |
Nobody really knows what next year looks like. 00:19:06.100 |
Nobody knows the random events that are gonna come up. 00:19:11.640 |
Just look at the long-term returns for various asset classes 00:19:15.380 |
and that's how you should be thinking about your portfolio. 00:19:21.340 |
but we still can't guarantee with 100% accuracy 00:19:27.260 |
- Right, we can say 99% of all 20-year rolling averages 00:19:33.380 |
That's about as much, as close to a guarantee 00:19:38.540 |
Different countries don't have that same advantage. 00:19:42.080 |
- Is there anyone that like, ranks economist calls 00:19:50.580 |
- Institutional investor does these annual awards. 00:20:01.220 |
but it was never because he was making forecasts. 00:20:22.440 |
And his institutional clients have always loved him. 00:20:25.080 |
- I think that is the way if you're thinking of the economy 00:20:29.660 |
And then you have the outside stuff that happens 00:20:40.200 |
And they just put it close to whatever's happened. 00:20:52.200 |
- I like the idea of a choose your own adventure style, 00:20:54.000 |
though, where you have a couple of different-- 00:20:57.040 |
- And it's a smart way to think about an unknowable future. 00:21:11.840 |
My girlfriend recently received an inheritance 00:21:17.800 |
for a house purchase, but want to invest some as well. 00:21:26.960 |
that she was told were expected to outperform 00:21:30.760 |
I see they really went out there with their calls. 00:21:39.760 |
Do you have any advice on how I should convince her 00:21:42.160 |
that diversification could be the best option here? 00:21:44.720 |
It's a tricky situation since this is technically her money, 00:21:49.320 |
in the coming years, this decision will impact us both. 00:22:00.800 |
If you're a young person hearing this for the first time, 00:22:04.240 |
There's no way that anyone wants to hear that. 00:22:06.320 |
So I guess you could try to give the textbook stuff, 00:22:16.760 |
to know why diversification is important in the first place. 00:22:19.480 |
I don't know if you're gonna be able to convince her 00:22:21.280 |
unless she really listens to what you have to say. 00:22:23.840 |
- By the way, this was literally Thanksgiving conversation 00:22:34.320 |
single, living on her own, saving for an apartment, 00:22:37.920 |
saving to buy a house, and ended up getting a bunch 00:22:41.080 |
of individual stocks and said, "What do I do with these?" 00:22:47.460 |
You're young, you got a 40-year investment horizon. 00:22:50.280 |
You wanna live with the ups and downs of the volatility, 00:22:53.240 |
or do you wanna just put it on set and forget 00:23:01.200 |
What's gonna be worse if you stay with these stocks 00:23:05.480 |
and one of 'em crashes, or if you sell these stocks 00:23:08.600 |
for an index and they, you know, magnificent seven on you? 00:23:20.520 |
And I had to say, well, you know the answer then. 00:23:24.080 |
Roll it into VTI, roll it into Vanguard Total Market 00:23:27.040 |
or the S&P 500, or whatever your index of choice is, 00:23:35.200 |
and you say, "I wanna have a more tech-focused investment." 00:23:48.520 |
- Well, I always say the Black Monday crash happened 00:23:51.760 |
one time in the United States for the market. 00:23:57.360 |
- Tuesday, right, every Tuesday you get that. 00:23:59.520 |
The market could be up and your stock could be down 20%. 00:24:05.040 |
Maybe that's, I do like the regret minimization framework. 00:24:09.680 |
And just helping them understand the difference 00:24:11.520 |
between an individual stock and a basket of stocks. 00:24:23.360 |
- You know, this question really forces people 00:24:25.560 |
to think about who they are, what their risk tolerance is, 00:24:29.320 |
how, you have to kind of project yourself forward 00:24:39.320 |
who have investment portfolios and they're like, 00:24:41.560 |
I don't care about my, if the stock goes up and down, 00:24:58.440 |
But just be aware of the fact that sometimes, 00:25:06.200 |
in the early 2000s, Amazon crashed 80 something percent 00:25:42.000 |
- You know, indexers and active stock pickers can be married. 00:25:45.360 |
It's just a core and satellite sort of portfolio. 00:26:03.600 |
The data, by the way, is overwhelming on this. 00:26:11.560 |
You'll see 50 or 100 basis points of outperformance 00:26:22.400 |
how demoralizing it is to open up your brokerage account 00:26:29.000 |
And especially if it happens multiple times in a year, 00:26:33.640 |
- The time to have those experiences, as Ben says, 00:26:36.680 |
is when you're young and you could recover it. 00:26:42.920 |
to have terrible things happen to your portfolio 00:26:50.080 |
And as you get older and you hold bigger portfolios 00:26:53.880 |
and more and more of your wealth is in the stock market, 00:26:56.600 |
you kind of look at market crashes when it does matter. 00:27:16.320 |
This is actually one we haven't really gotten before. 00:27:18.200 |
And I wanted you particularly for this one, Barry. 00:27:27.360 |
regarding rare jewelry, collectibles, or art? 00:27:30.040 |
I want to buy a watch and I'm having trouble moving forward. 00:27:33.840 |
you'd have no problem approving the purchase. 00:27:35.800 |
I didn't grow up well off, so it's foreign to me 00:27:40.240 |
One thought I had was that a limited collection of art 00:27:44.680 |
I've studied watches for over a decade and know them well. 00:27:47.840 |
But I'm now thinking that if I was fine buying iBonds 00:27:51.640 |
why wouldn't I do the same for an investment watch? 00:28:00.160 |
- Yeah, I'm really not a big collectibles guy. 00:28:02.440 |
But Barry, you've dabbled in some of this stuff 00:28:05.720 |
How do you, do you ever approach this stuff differently 00:28:14.880 |
well, I think I'm gonna buy this because I like it, 00:28:16.840 |
but also because it's gonna appreciate in value potentially? 00:28:19.560 |
- So I love this question for so many reasons. 00:28:22.120 |
And you know, as I do, when we're dealing with clients 00:28:26.520 |
who are successful and have money in the bank 00:28:32.360 |
we kind of have to push them into spending money on things 00:28:41.600 |
Number two, and you've heard me say this so many times, 00:28:48.100 |
or this particular Ferrari was just sold for $51 million 00:28:52.120 |
or this watch, that is classic survivorship bias. 00:28:56.080 |
'Cause you're telling me what's done really well. 00:28:58.760 |
You're not telling me about all the other stuff 00:29:09.400 |
Or this, I give you a list of beautiful watches 00:29:13.600 |
from some of the finest watch companies in the world 00:29:18.540 |
- Yeah, the bad ones don't get reported probably, right? 00:29:26.020 |
first, if it's not one of the big three trilogy, 00:29:30.380 |
which is essentially AP, Patek Philippe, and Rolex, 00:29:36.940 |
well, first, if you want a watch, go buy a watch. 00:29:39.380 |
Second, if you're looking at an expensive watch, 00:29:44.820 |
You could go to places like Chrono24 or Hodinkee. 00:29:48.140 |
And there was a watch I was in love with for years 00:29:58.740 |
but it's owned by a company that has a lot of great brands. 00:30:08.960 |
So I happen to like, a Lange & Söhne is a watch I like. 00:30:17.140 |
I got right as I was finishing up Bailout Nation. 00:30:33.180 |
If you want to buy something that's collectible, 00:30:43.500 |
I love there's a couple of websites that do watch charts. 00:30:48.180 |
And not surprisingly, a lot of people had a lot of money 00:30:56.780 |
yeah, and a lot of these are now down 20, 30% 00:31:08.100 |
Unless you really want to spend a lot of time 00:31:11.260 |
thinking about the investment aspects of cars and watches. 00:31:24.060 |
it's not just a matter of paying $3,000 for a Ferrari 00:31:26.660 |
in 1965 and selling it for $50 million 50 years later. 00:31:34.580 |
you're putting insurance on it, you're doing maintenance. 00:31:37.500 |
They're breaking down on the side of the road. 00:31:39.820 |
It's, as opposed to cost you nothing to buy an index fund 00:31:48.900 |
- It sounds like he's also asking for permission, too, 00:31:50.580 |
'cause he said, "I grew up not very well off. 00:31:54.780 |
I'm sure he's looking at the price tag and going, 00:31:59.840 |
- Yeah, does a Rolex keep time better than, you know, 00:32:09.500 |
He said, "I got rid of my watch and I moved out here." 00:32:14.020 |
But yes, I think it's-- - But it's really true. 00:32:15.800 |
- Yeah, but if you're looking for the permission to do it, 00:32:22.700 |
What's the point of saving in the first place 00:32:24.260 |
if you're really well off if you're not gonna enjoy it? 00:32:45.940 |
Artwork, if you wanna tumble down that rabbit hole, 00:32:50.140 |
you can, but, you know, I go to different car events 00:33:06.880 |
You'll never be disappointed, and you know what? 00:33:27.020 |
then maybe you would consider selling something. 00:33:28.860 |
But otherwise, you're enjoying it in the meantime. 00:33:33.380 |
- Right, but if you're gonna put it on your wall, 00:33:35.460 |
don't assume that pretty painting is your retirement plan. 00:33:45.880 |
because I saw you wrote a post literally called clown car. 00:33:51.160 |
I'm quoting somebody who called it a clown car. 00:33:56.460 |
I don't know if you remember the game "Battlezone" 00:33:58.240 |
or "Tank Command" that you used to be able to play 00:34:12.020 |
where they're behind the rest of the industry 00:34:18.620 |
they've been so far ahead of everybody for so long. 00:34:32.340 |
So a bulletproof car to me isn't worth to exchange 00:34:40.520 |
I don't really think I need those sort of bowling proof, 00:34:49.680 |
That said, maybe Elon is not the greatest guy 00:34:53.980 |
in terms of figuring out humans and social networks, 00:34:57.580 |
but he's pretty good when it comes to companies 00:35:00.660 |
- Someone in the chat says it's the DeLorean of the 2020s, 00:35:07.540 |
That hardened steel is very hard to work with. 00:35:11.180 |
- As someone who has three kids and a lot of gear, 00:35:19.700 |
The Rivian, Doug DeMuro did a video on the R1T pickup, 00:35:28.660 |
Wild acceleration, incredible off-road capabilities, 00:35:32.660 |
passing Range Rovers, passing Jeeps up a hill, 00:35:38.460 |
- The soccer moms are not using these to go off-road, but-- 00:35:43.460 |
- The Hyundais are nice also, and they're half the price. 00:35:46.580 |
- I think some of it is gonna come down to capability, 00:35:50.180 |
If the Cybertruck can tow more than any other truck 00:35:59.020 |
If I tow a boat, I need it to move 8,000 pounds. 00:36:17.860 |
and you could plug in all of your electric appliances 00:36:38.780 |
We'll get the prices, the details, all the things. 00:36:44.260 |
and they have almost two million reservations. 00:36:47.260 |
- I'll wait 'til they start marking all these down 00:36:52.700 |
I mean, it's all gonna be based on price and specs, 00:36:58.900 |
with people who loved playing Halo back in the day. 00:37:01.820 |
one of those vehicles. - It looks like that, right? 00:37:05.940 |
- Okay, thanks to everyone who showed up live.