back to indexba1958ea-2c8d-0873-ef0c-633eb6347a1a
00:00:00.000 |
I am James Hong and welcome to the Surpassing Value Podcast. 00:00:15.620 |
The fuel and desire for this podcast was born out of a compulsion to flesh out what's 00:00:19.740 |
been going on in the midst of an ocean of megaphones that may not actually withstand 00:00:26.620 |
As a signpost theologian, I will do my best to filter out the impurities and point people 00:00:37.120 |
For this episode, I wanted to talk about the reliability of the New Testament documents. 00:00:46.460 |
For some people, when you hear this, you might think that such talk somehow becomes an impediment 00:00:52.780 |
to faith that a robust discussion into the empirical evidence surrounding the New Testament 00:00:59.340 |
documents shouldn't be a conversation to be had because it will somehow add on to faith 00:01:04.420 |
or perhaps take away from the faith we should have. 00:01:07.900 |
Although I agree faith shouldn't be subject to the whims of the intellectual priesthood 00:01:12.720 |
or external circumstances, that doesn't mean that truth doesn't withstand the test 00:01:20.420 |
Moreover, I flatly reject the claim that empirical evidence is somehow contrary to Christianity 00:01:29.860 |
I'll comment more on that at the closing of this episode. 00:01:34.020 |
With that said, let me begin by telling you that the New Testament documents have unparalleled 00:01:42.900 |
The New Testament documents have unparalleled textual reliability. 00:01:47.860 |
The three reasons the New Testament documents have unparalleled textual reliability are 00:01:55.240 |
due to the number of existing manuscripts, the span of time between the originals and 00:02:01.580 |
the copies, and the internal consistency among the existing copies. 00:02:08.900 |
When you study works of antiquity, for good reason and for reasons which I join in, we 00:02:14.500 |
rightly state that Homer wrote the Iliad, Sophocles wrote Oedipus Rex, and the various 00:02:20.740 |
works of Aristotle, commonly referred to as the Corpus Aristotelicum, were written by 00:02:28.060 |
The primary reason we do so is because of the reasons I just stated, namely, the number 00:02:33.740 |
of existing manuscripts, the span of time between the originals and the copies, and 00:02:39.140 |
the internal consistency among the existing copies. 00:02:44.100 |
The number of existing manuscripts for the New Testament stands at about 6,000, whereas 00:02:52.100 |
for the Iliad it is about 650, and for the various works of Sophocles it is about 200. 00:02:59.660 |
The New Testament manuscript stands completely alone in that category, which is a prong that 00:03:06.600 |
academicians use in corroborating the validity of the work itself. 00:03:13.100 |
The span of time between the originals and the copies is also well within two generations, 00:03:20.320 |
and this same fact cannot be said for any other work of antiquity if we are talking 00:03:25.460 |
about the magnitude of the same and the magnitude of the time. 00:03:32.180 |
Let me elaborate why it is so crucial that the New Testament documents are written within 00:03:40.100 |
Academies will tell you that in order for a myth to develop, you need at least two generations 00:03:51.020 |
Suppose you and I and a bunch of unsavory wicked fellows decide to start a cult. 00:03:57.740 |
In this cult, we decide to make you the ultimate demigod, and the lie has its roots in that 00:04:04.140 |
you are able to lift cars and fly like Superman. 00:04:12.200 |
If we decided to perpetrate this myth in the midst of the contemporary generation, what 00:04:17.880 |
do you think will be the logical reaction to people who are interested in our newly 00:04:28.500 |
People will want empirical proof of our claims. 00:04:32.740 |
They will want that because we are making extraordinary claims about our cult and if 00:04:38.740 |
true would lend credibility to an otherwise outlandish statement. 00:04:45.780 |
The problem is we are lying and you are not able to lift cars, you are not able to fly 00:04:50.980 |
like Superman, so the cult should not gather any esteem. 00:04:54.740 |
However, if the cult has its roots in making claims about irrefutable matters, then at 00:05:04.500 |
Notice I didn't say lies, I said irrefutable matters. 00:05:10.540 |
Instead of stating that a person alive is able to lift cars and fly like Superman, we 00:05:15.420 |
state that a person who was no longer alive was able to accomplish such miraculous feats. 00:05:21.980 |
If the handful of future adherents want to fact check the claims, they will not be able 00:05:31.820 |
The next step would then be to see if there is anyone alive who knew that dead person 00:05:37.280 |
who could lift cars and fly like Superman to see if they could corroborate the outlandish 00:05:46.940 |
The more people you have who are brought in to propagate the lie and perhaps have other 00:05:53.560 |
pieces of evidence to back up those claims, the greater the chance this lie will perpetuate. 00:05:58.820 |
Of course, if people alive who are not privy to the lie come in in droves stating that 00:06:05.220 |
they knew this person and they could accomplish no such feat, you're going to encounter resistance. 00:06:13.780 |
Which is why I stated earlier that historians will typically tell you it takes at least 00:06:22.540 |
How does this relate to the claims made in the New Testament and the New Testament itself? 00:06:28.420 |
The New Testament claims that its central figure, Jesus of Nazareth, came on the scene 00:06:33.980 |
and began publicly teaching about the kingdom of God and accomplishing miraculous works. 00:06:41.360 |
These miraculous works included, but are not limited to, making the mute speak, the deaf 00:06:47.020 |
to hear, the lame to walk, the blind to see, cleansing lepers instantaneously, healing 00:06:53.080 |
terminally ill people, and even raising the dead. 00:06:57.660 |
The relevant detail here is that much of the New Testament documents claim that Jesus of 00:07:03.100 |
Nazareth performed these acts and that people who witnessed these events were still alive. 00:07:09.860 |
There was a high likelihood that one saw these events themselves or heard from a living eyewitness. 00:07:17.980 |
The New Testament documents also claim that Jesus of Nazareth was executed but rose bodily 00:07:24.500 |
three days later and appeared not just to a fringe group of people, but to large chunks 00:07:34.640 |
After 40 days, the New Testament states that he ascended, or to put it in less religious 00:07:39.460 |
terms, he vanished and was never seen bodily again. 00:07:44.060 |
The New Testament claims that Christians began to multiply while suffering under heavy persecution 00:07:50.180 |
from the outside world because they could not deny these claims, while dealing with 00:07:56.180 |
those at times within the church taught an aberrant version of Christianity. 00:08:02.500 |
The renowned church historian, Philip Schafe, stated it like this, "The persecutions of 00:08:10.820 |
Christianity during the first three centuries appear like a long tragedy, first foreboding 00:08:17.860 |
signs, then a succession of bloody assaults of heathenism upon the religion of the cross. 00:08:24.820 |
Amidst the dark scenes of fiendish hatred and cruelty, the bright exhibitions of suffering 00:08:30.300 |
virtue, now and then a short pause, at least a fearful and desperate struggle of the old 00:08:37.060 |
pagan empire for life and death, ending in the abiding victory of the Christian religion. 00:08:42.900 |
Thus, this bloody baptism of the church resulted in the birth of a Christian world. 00:08:48.980 |
It was a repetition and prolongation of the crucifixion, but followed by a resurrection." 00:08:58.180 |
Schafe further remarks on the first four centuries of the church, under Roman rule, stating it 00:09:03.300 |
like this, "From the fifth century it has been customary to reckon ten great persecutions, 00:09:10.300 |
under Nero, Domitian, Trajan, Marcus Aurelius, Septimius Severus, Maximus, Decius Valerian, 00:09:21.380 |
This number was suggested by the ten plagues of Egypt, taken as types, which however befell 00:09:26.060 |
the enemies of Israel, and present a contrast rather than a parallel, and by the ten horns 00:09:31.740 |
of the Roman beast making war with the lamb, taken for so many emperors. 00:09:35.900 |
But the number is too great for the general persecutions, and too small for the provincial 00:09:41.260 |
Only two imperial persecutions, those of Decius and Diocletian, extended over the empire, 00:09:48.820 |
but Christianity was always an illegal religion from Trajan to Constantine, and subject to 00:09:59.700 |
Some persecuting members, Nero, Domitian, Galerius, were monstrous tyrants, but others, 00:10:05.540 |
Trajan, Marcus Aurelius, Decius, Diocletian, were among the best and most energetic emperors, 00:10:12.660 |
and were prompted not so much by hatred of Christianity, as by zeal for the maintenance 00:10:20.620 |
On the other hand, some of the most worthless emperors, Commodus, Caracalla, and Heliogabalus, 00:10:29.260 |
were rather favorable to Christians from sheer caprice. 00:10:33.460 |
All were equally ignorant of the true character of the new religion. 00:10:37.140 |
The long and bloody war of heathen Rome against the Church, which is built upon a rock, utterly 00:10:46.080 |
It ended near Rome at the Milvian Bridge under Constantine. 00:10:54.760 |
It called forth the virtues of Christian heroism, and resulted in the consolidation and triumph 00:11:03.500 |
The philosophy of persecution is best expressed by the terse word of Tertullian, who lived 00:11:10.540 |
in the midst of them, but did not see the end. 00:11:13.860 |
"The blood of the Christians is the seed of the church." 00:11:20.460 |
Let's begin to piece what we have together so far. 00:11:25.480 |
The claims made in the New Testament are that its central figure, performed and taught publicly 00:11:31.900 |
and the verification of who he was, lied in the miracles that he performed and the substance 00:11:40.900 |
Of high importance was that he claimed to be God. 00:11:45.820 |
To prove his claims, instead of exacting his power upon what the eye could see, he came 00:11:52.260 |
to offer his own life as a substitution for the required life of all who do not live perfectly, 00:12:01.500 |
Upon this, he stated that even death would not be able to hold him, and substantiated 00:12:12.200 |
His adherents would spread this message, but were met with great hostility. 00:12:18.120 |
If all of this is indeed true, it would stand to reason that there would be outside records 00:12:24.660 |
of all this taking place in some shape or form, and indeed there was. 00:12:31.420 |
Listen to what Josephus, a Jewish historian commissioned by Rome, wrote. 00:12:35.420 |
Mind you, Josephus was compelled to be objective and trustworthy since he was commissioned 00:12:42.740 |
Josephus states this, "Now some of the Jews thought the destruction of Herod's army came 00:12:48.900 |
from God, and that very justly, as punishment of what he did against John, that was called 00:12:55.580 |
For Herod slew him, who was a good man, and commanded the Jews to exercise virtue, both 00:13:01.060 |
as to righteousness towards one another and piety towards God, and so to come to baptism." 00:13:08.740 |
If you are unfamiliar with the New Testament, Josephus here is validating claims made in 00:13:17.620 |
This is an outside record validating what is contained within the New Testament. 00:13:26.340 |
Josephus elsewhere states, "Now there was about this time Jesus, a wise man, if it be 00:13:32.020 |
lawful to call him a man, for he was a doer of wonderful works, a teacher of such men 00:13:39.900 |
He drew over to him both many of the Jews and many of the Gentiles. 00:13:43.980 |
He was Christ, and when Pilate, at the suggestion of the principal men amongst us, had condemned 00:13:49.980 |
him to the cross, those that loved him at first did not forsake him, for he appeared 00:13:54.920 |
to them alive again the third day, and the tribe of Christians so named from him are 00:14:07.380 |
Here are some more outside records validating the claims of the New Testament from people 00:14:13.780 |
Tacitus writes this, again, no friend of Christians. 00:14:17.300 |
He writes, "Consequently, to get rid of the report, Nero fastened the guilt and inflicted 00:14:24.020 |
the most exquisite tortures on a class hated for their abomination, called Christians by 00:14:30.420 |
Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign 00:14:35.440 |
of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilate." 00:14:40.780 |
Lucian, a Greek writer, writes this, "The Christians, you know, worship a man to this 00:14:47.640 |
day, the distinguished personage who introduced their novel rites and was crucified on the 00:14:55.220 |
You see, these misguided creatures start with the general conviction that they are immortal 00:15:01.880 |
for all time, which explains the contempt of death and voluntary self-devotion which 00:15:08.600 |
are so common among them, and then it was impressed on them by their original lawgiver 00:15:14.040 |
that they are all brothers from the moment that they are converted and deny the gods 00:15:19.020 |
of Greece and worship the crucified sage and live after his laws. 00:15:23.920 |
All this they take quite on faith, with the result that they despise all worldly goods 00:15:30.300 |
alike, regarding them as merely common property." 00:15:37.360 |
Earlier I mentioned that the New Testament documents exhibited a remarkable consistency 00:15:50.480 |
The New Testament documents exhibited a remarkable consistency among existing copies. 00:15:56.960 |
The textual agreement between the existing copies stands at about 99.5% and the 0.5% 00:16:05.120 |
is merely Scrivener error that does not change anything of substance. 00:16:09.920 |
To put that into perspective, no other work of antiquity exhibits anything close to this. 00:16:17.560 |
Yet we still claim, with good reason, that Homer wrote the Iliad, Sophocles wrote Oedipus 00:16:26.840 |
But my point is, if we're going to be logically consistent, then we also have to claim that 00:16:33.120 |
the New Testament documents also should be taken for what they are stating not based 00:16:40.800 |
upon the documents themselves necessarily, but also based upon the corroborating evidence 00:16:54.360 |
There is also remarkable touchpoint corroboration of the times and places mentioned in the New 00:17:02.020 |
That's important because, again, it would stand to reason that if the claims made in 00:17:06.120 |
the New Testament of our actual times and places, those times and places should exist 00:17:12.360 |
outside the documents in the New Testament and indeed they do. 00:17:19.440 |
I'll be quoting from J. Warner Wallace who wrote a book called Cold Case Christianity. 00:17:30.520 |
He is a former homicide detective and lifelong atheist. 00:17:34.760 |
Before his conversion, he examined the empirical claims of Christianity at the age of 35, applying 00:17:40.600 |
his detective skills when undertaking his own personal investigation. 00:17:45.800 |
J. Warner Wallace writes, "Luke's narratives include detailed and specific descriptions 00:17:54.200 |
related to the locations, people, offices, and titles within the Roman Empire. 00:17:59.480 |
In fact, many of Luke's claims were eventually confirmed by archaeological discoveries. 00:18:05.340 |
Related to Quirinius, Luke wrote that Joseph and Mary returned to Bethlehem because a Syrian 00:18:12.520 |
governor named Quirinius was conducting a census. 00:18:19.120 |
Archaeological discoveries in the 19th century revealed Quirinius for someone with the same 00:18:24.440 |
name was also a pro-consul of Syria and Cilicia from 11 B.C. to the death of Herod. 00:18:31.200 |
Quirinius' name has been discovered on a coin from this period of time and on the base 00:18:40.000 |
Related to Erastus, in Romans 16.23, Paul wrote, "Erastus, the city treasurer, greets 00:18:46.480 |
A piece of pavement was discovered in Corinth in 1929 confirming his existence." 00:18:52.360 |
Related to Lysanias, Luke discovered a tetrarch named Lysanias and wrote that this man reigned 00:18:57.800 |
over Abilene when John the Baptist began his ministry (Luke 3.1). 00:19:02.640 |
Two inscriptions have been discovered that mention Lysanias by name. 00:19:06.960 |
One of these, dated from A.D. 1437, identifies Lysanias as a tetrarch in Abila near Damascus. 00:19:17.040 |
There were many other examples, but I thought a sample would suffice if this topic interests 00:19:23.000 |
Feel free to get his book, "Cold Case Christianity." 00:19:26.840 |
Another book I would recommend on this issue is "Jesus Under Fire" edited by Michael 00:19:32.800 |
That book is a collection of essays from multiple different academicians in response to the 00:19:38.200 |
Jesus Seminar, where another group of academicians came together in an attempt to reinvent the 00:19:46.440 |
The final book I would recommend is Craig Blomberg's "The Historical Reliability 00:20:00.080 |
In an essay he wrote, responding to questions regarding the reliability of the New Testament, 00:20:05.640 |
he makes two important points regarding the historicity of Acts and the questions of miracles. 00:20:14.840 |
This is Craig Blomberg regarding the historicity of Acts. 00:20:18.840 |
He writes, "The New Testament contains only one book with the genre or contents of Acts 00:20:27.640 |
This is a theologically rich and artistically refined work of history. 00:20:32.280 |
The number of characters and places in this selective account of key events in the first 00:20:36.800 |
generation of church history that have been confirmed is staggering. 00:20:41.260 |
From non-Christian works alone, we know of Annas, Claudius, Gamaliel, Caiaphas, James, 00:20:47.440 |
Galileo, Agrippa I and II, Sergius Paulus, Felix Drusilla, Festus, Bernas, and others. 00:20:56.540 |
Every city and location which has been excavated has been shown to be as Acts describes them, 00:21:02.960 |
complete with specific synagogues, theaters, ports, roads, rivers, and more, particularly 00:21:10.560 |
significant is how Luke gets right the names of the rulers in the various locations especially 00:21:17.480 |
since in some instances they varied quite a bit in a given region or from one period 00:21:25.780 |
These include the Sanhedrin, the Italian Regiment, Tetrarchs, Pro-Councils, Magistrates, Politarchs, 00:21:33.200 |
the Areopagus, City Clerk, and the Chief Man on the Island of Malta. 00:21:37.860 |
The very fact that one can mesh Acts with more fragmentary and sometimes called incidental 00:21:43.860 |
allusions to Paul's life in his letters sets Acts off from historical novels, modern 00:21:51.240 |
That one can generate a plausible detailed chronology of the events depicted in Acts, 00:21:57.240 |
again especially in comparison with Paul's letters, and chart his missionary journeys 00:22:02.400 |
as coherent and sensible travels further suggests Acts is historical." 00:22:13.960 |
The book of Acts in the New Testament contains all the hallmarks of reliability and trustworthiness. 00:22:27.280 |
Regarding the question of miracles, Blomberg writes "Can we believe in documents as filled 00:22:36.200 |
If one a priori postulates an anti-supernatural worldview then no, but then one is no longer 00:22:46.300 |
The claim that natural explanations are always more probable even if one does not rule out 00:22:51.760 |
supernatural explanations up front is itself a belief that cannot be demonstrated empirically 00:22:58.240 |
and that unduly denigrates the role of trustworthy testimony as the bedrock of historiography. 00:23:06.080 |
It also flies in the face of thousands of modern day experiences of ordinary people 00:23:11.800 |
all around the globe who have witnessed instantaneous healings and similar events after public concerted 00:23:20.400 |
Claims about miracles should neither be written off a priori nor uncritically accepted. 00:23:25.480 |
They should be tested like any other historical affirmations. 00:23:29.560 |
What sets the New Testament miracles off from accounts in many other kinds of literature 00:23:34.560 |
is their consistent link to the arrival or inauguration of God's reign in the person 00:23:44.080 |
Claims about similarities with other ancient miracle stories break down on careful inspection. 00:23:50.200 |
The closest parallels are all post-Christian, too late to have influenced the New Testament 00:23:56.160 |
Partially, similar pre-Christian parallels usually cluster around gods or goddesses or 00:24:02.400 |
heroes from some dim, mythical past and are not attached to recent people known to have 00:24:14.960 |
This is especially the case when one examines the resurrection of Jesus. 00:24:19.840 |
The most spectacular and significant of the foundational Christian miracles." 00:24:30.800 |
If you reject the New Testament claims prior to the investigation of the New Testament 00:24:39.160 |
claims, because the New Testament claims miracles, then what you've done is you've stated before 00:24:53.400 |
even looking into the claims that it must be false. 00:24:59.520 |
But wouldn't something as incredible, as uncommon, as outlandish as miracles be the 00:25:08.160 |
exact source of confirming something that is other-worldly true, that is supernatural? 00:25:19.920 |
Doesn't it stand to reason that if there is indeed a supernatural realm, the way to confirm 00:25:34.360 |
The question is whether or not miracles are actually the source of the confirmation of 00:25:46.400 |
The question is, did these miracles actually happen? 00:25:59.960 |
In conclusion, I want to comment on the nature of what I articulated in the beginning of 00:26:07.960 |
this episode as it relates to genuine faith, as if somehow they should be held in exclusion. 00:26:13.840 |
Remember, I'm not advocating that anything I said in this episode is salvific or necessary 00:26:22.800 |
for salvation, that's not what I'm advocating. 00:26:27.320 |
I'm advocating for something a lot more narrow. 00:26:31.040 |
What I'm advocating is that interest in the substance of what was articulated in this 00:26:36.080 |
episode or an investigation into these claims or even a desire to do that further research 00:26:45.040 |
somehow is contrary or is detrimental to faith. 00:26:53.480 |
In the last episode, we talked about John 10, 37-38, but let me read this passage again 00:27:03.040 |
"If I do not do the works of my Father, do not believe me. 00:27:07.880 |
But if I do do them, even though you do not believe me, believe the works, so that you 00:27:13.200 |
may know and understand that the Father is in me, and I in the Father." 00:27:24.400 |
Christ himself pointed at works as proof of who he was. 00:27:31.200 |
He didn't come on the scene, preach, and then state "believe or else." 00:27:35.920 |
He absolutely could have in one sentence, but my point is that even Christ used empirical 00:27:41.080 |
evidence as validation that he was indeed the promised Messiah and pointed towards that 00:27:47.680 |
evidence as proof of who he was, which was reflective of Isaiah 61 and Isaiah 35. 00:27:56.040 |
When God sent Moses to free Israel from Pharaoh, God used Moses to perform many miracles as 00:28:02.720 |
validation that God was the one true God of the universe and not the gods of Egypt. 00:28:09.120 |
You also see this same pattern with Elijah, that miracles accompanied his message as proof 00:28:16.080 |
of the substance of what Elijah was testifying to. 00:28:19.740 |
By God's grace, God has left a trail of breadcrumbs that corroborates the claims made in the New 00:28:28.880 |
Testament and also to the validity of the New Testament itself. 00:28:33.920 |
I want to make this point clear because this same point also applies to how you think about 00:28:43.340 |
I'm not saying that our reasoning, our minds, and our external evidence should be catapulted 00:29:01.240 |
I am in no way advocating for an elevated Rene Descartes line of reasoning here. 00:29:09.060 |
To advocate for that would then be advocating that anything we could prove physically is 00:29:14.240 |
what is true, or that the greatest form of validation is empirical, which would be essentially 00:29:22.740 |
What I am advocating, though, is that the scriptures themselves speak to a validity 00:29:34.300 |
This is usually coordinated with future prophecies, and they were also used to even shut the mouths 00:29:40.400 |
of people who state that, had there actually been a miracle, they wouldn't be entangled 00:29:48.200 |
God's not going to jump and dance for you every time you ask him to at the same time. 00:29:55.840 |
He has left a vast body of evidence that corroborates and eliminates excuses even for the most hardest 00:30:10.320 |
It is absolutely true that God saves those whom he foreknew, however, what is also true 00:30:20.640 |
is that the empirical evidence for the claims of the New Testament are at the very least 00:30:26.360 |
adequate and, in my humble opinion, compelling. 00:30:32.040 |
It's almost as if there is this mountain of evidence that demands a verdict, a la Josh 00:30:41.360 |
McDowell, and to look over it, you would have to forcefully ignore that and the evidence 00:30:56.480 |
Thanks for making it to the end, I'll continue to try to make the journey worth it. 00:31:03.280 |
To him be honor, glory, and eternal dominion, James Allnell.