back to indexEveryday Educator - Mock Trial, Challenge B’s Capstone
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/81e44/81e4486ea129db21b53b4121e545e651b07396d8" alt=""
00:00:10.040 |
and I'm excited to spend some time with you today 00:00:19.720 |
that make homeschooling the adventure of a lifetime. 00:00:27.360 |
or deep into the daily delight of family learning, 00:00:31.640 |
I believe you'll enjoy thinking along with us. 00:00:39.600 |
you'll find even closer support in a local CC community. 00:00:52.840 |
Well listeners, I'm happy to be back with you 00:00:59.440 |
Mock trial is the capstone event of Challenge B. 00:01:09.560 |
I know nothing about trials, mock or otherwise, 00:01:22.920 |
I wasn't sure that I knew what I needed to know 00:01:30.480 |
So, we are gonna approach all of those questions 00:01:44.880 |
She helps directors and parents help their students 00:01:49.060 |
get the very most out of everything Challenge B related. 00:01:54.160 |
And Emily actually oversees Challenge A, B and 1. 00:01:59.160 |
So she knows where these B students are coming from, 00:02:24.600 |
that I think I just must be an eighth grader at heart 00:02:33.280 |
was one of my favorite parts about Challenge B. 00:02:39.280 |
but I think there's something for everybody to love. 00:02:44.760 |
that you also have tutored Challenge B for years. 00:02:56.460 |
when they first come in and they're wondering 00:02:58.880 |
what is it their students are gonna study this year? 00:03:01.040 |
What about Challenge B gets their radar pinging? 00:03:45.120 |
It does sound like it might be more fun than formal logic. 00:03:54.320 |
it sounds like something that they would like to explore 00:04:05.680 |
have you had many parents that have mock trial experience? 00:04:13.840 |
No, I think very few have any experience with it. 00:04:17.560 |
So I think most parents enjoy going through the process 00:04:29.480 |
Like I joined in 2004 and that was their third year. 00:04:34.360 |
So this community had been at it for a while. 00:04:48.920 |
who had been through it with a sibling before. 00:04:59.800 |
even if the current student was kind of green. 00:05:11.320 |
who maybe they don't have a child in Challenge B yet, 00:05:18.160 |
or what is this mock trial of which you speak? 00:05:23.680 |
'cause it is a semester long course or project really. 00:05:43.200 |
- So the first thing is the mock trial notebook. 00:05:46.240 |
Everybody has access to the mock trial notebook. 00:06:00.960 |
- Right, and then they'll read through the evidence, 00:06:03.800 |
they develop a strategy and then they tell the story. 00:06:19.600 |
with the same rules and regulations, if you will, 00:06:23.240 |
so that there are no surprises on the day of. 00:06:25.880 |
So that if we have really an even playing field 00:06:43.160 |
- Okay, so they don't make up stuff that goes into there. 00:06:57.520 |
- They don't add evidence or add parts to the story 00:07:09.640 |
and they really know all the ins and outs of a crane. 00:07:26.240 |
on the day of the event in question during the trial. 00:07:30.640 |
So they read all the background information about the case. 00:07:34.160 |
They learn the characters who was involved in the case. 00:07:38.520 |
From there, they'll read the witness statements. 00:07:41.240 |
They have, we have five witnesses and the students. 00:07:58.280 |
- They will spend weeks reading the witness statements 00:08:08.560 |
- And then they'll read through all the evidence 00:08:10.400 |
and they put the pieces together and they figure out, 00:08:25.680 |
- And then about a third of the way through the semester, 00:08:33.200 |
And depending on the size of the challenge B group 00:08:40.800 |
but each team will have two to four attorneys. 00:08:45.040 |
They'll have all their witnesses in the bailiff. 00:08:48.080 |
And at that point, it's up to the students as a group 00:08:52.240 |
to come up with how they'll question their witnesses, 00:09:05.360 |
And then that all leads up to the day of the mock trial 00:09:21.000 |
they are not allowed to speak to any other adults. 00:09:25.440 |
- So they're really on their own, but they've practiced. 00:09:31.640 |
And so the role of the director at this point or the tutor 00:09:35.320 |
is they oversee the discussion and the communication. 00:09:40.320 |
And that's also the role of the parent at home 00:09:52.920 |
They say, "Oh, well, hey, they have a weather report 00:10:02.960 |
- Yeah, there's this piece of garbage that they found 00:10:07.160 |
Why is that piece of trash important to the case? 00:10:12.360 |
So it's a lot of learning to ask your students 00:10:22.440 |
And they eventually, it starts off as a confusing process. 00:10:27.160 |
But over time, they sort out these puzzle pieces 00:10:31.040 |
and they create the bigger picture by the end. 00:10:37.080 |
and it's a really beautiful process to watch. 00:10:42.800 |
I'm gonna ask you this question that all of my parents, 00:10:56.160 |
It seems, even just listening to you describe it so clearly 00:11:01.160 |
and in such a simple way, I see why parents ask. 00:11:22.120 |
And I think many of them, what I saw in my students 00:11:25.480 |
was excitement and then fear in the headlights. 00:11:33.280 |
And then it all comes together and they learn, 00:12:03.320 |
The logic strand as they're working through their math 00:12:05.840 |
and their algebra, they're moving variables around 00:12:14.840 |
They're moving things around and laying it out. 00:12:24.600 |
- And their brain knows how to transfer that information. 00:12:28.640 |
And then the persuasive essays that they've been working on 00:12:33.720 |
They have learned how to formulate good arguments already. 00:12:43.000 |
- Yes, and also going on in the same semester, 00:12:49.520 |
So they have seen all the elements of a short story, 00:12:54.520 |
the rising action and the hook and the character development 00:13:14.520 |
Really it comes down to who tells the most compelling story. 00:13:26.520 |
I think this is just asking too much of them. 00:13:34.000 |
It does look like a bunch of buzzing bees at the beginning 00:13:40.800 |
But if they will listen to you as you lay out the process 00:13:46.480 |
and if they will work the process and wrestle together, 00:13:51.480 |
they create something that they and their parents 00:14:01.840 |
So what have you seen your students learn by participating? 00:14:13.720 |
and continuing to sharpen their skills of logical thinking 00:14:22.680 |
They are working on their persuasive speech skills. 00:14:43.880 |
to elicit the information you want to come out. 00:14:47.760 |
What did the students learn by participating in mock trial? 00:14:51.200 |
Well, I think one thing that they really learn how to do 00:14:57.080 |
but this is kind of in a different way is attend. 00:15:00.960 |
They have to attend to the information given to them. 00:15:11.840 |
another person may not find it to be important 00:15:32.600 |
Yeah, so they really have to learn to attend to the detail, 00:15:37.360 |
which is something they learned how to do way early on 00:15:42.240 |
when they're studying a flower, they're attending, 00:15:45.040 |
but this is a different way to attend to something. 00:15:49.080 |
They're saying, "Wow, okay, well, this witness, 00:15:51.320 |
he's saying this, but this witness is saying this. 00:15:59.400 |
Yeah, so they're really looking at that comparison 00:16:01.560 |
and the circumstances under which the event happened. 00:16:07.200 |
And considering what's possible and what's not possible. 00:16:12.600 |
Yeah, and like, "Well, wait, well, this character 00:16:14.440 |
is saying, well, something was happening here. 00:16:16.200 |
This one's saying this was going on elsewhere. 00:16:20.920 |
What's the relationship between this guy and that guy?" 00:16:36.120 |
You know, in the weeks leading up to the big event. 00:16:39.040 |
Right, what you do in class and what they do at home, right. 00:16:49.600 |
So they're saying, "Okay, what do I already know 00:16:53.920 |
Perhaps it's the attorney preparing their opening statement 00:17:05.760 |
Like, "Okay, maybe I should bring up this point first. 00:17:08.960 |
And then I'm gonna talk about this aspect of the case." 00:17:18.400 |
And all of them really go through those steps, 00:17:27.640 |
Like, "Okay, how am I gonna play this character? 00:17:29.720 |
What style, what attitude is this person gonna have? 00:17:42.720 |
which adds to the persuasion of your team's story. 00:18:05.200 |
I saw my students sharpen all of those skills, 00:18:31.920 |
You know, they have to learn to work as a team. 00:18:37.640 |
You know, a lot of the work that our students do, 00:18:45.760 |
but then they go home and what they do at home 00:18:48.240 |
is really what determines a good bit of their success. 00:18:57.840 |
The assessment at the end is very much dependent 00:19:02.320 |
on the team and how well people prepare and work together. 00:19:07.240 |
So one of the things that I always found students learned 00:19:12.080 |
was how to work together well, how to cooperate. 00:19:19.640 |
or even experiences that you've watched your students 00:19:28.000 |
Right, I think the working together as a team 00:19:34.360 |
this is the biggest task or project they've had to do. 00:19:41.840 |
Yeah, and they're learning how to do this with other people. 00:19:56.120 |
and they're learning those communication skills. 00:20:04.680 |
"It says it right here in the mock trial notebook." 00:20:08.800 |
- Yeah, they are having to set aside their own ideas 00:20:13.720 |
and admit that somebody else's idea was better. 00:20:17.120 |
They're learning how to lay out the groundwork 00:20:25.160 |
- They might be learning administration skills, 00:20:28.000 |
like organization, how to use a Google Docs sheet 00:20:35.680 |
- So they can share their information with one another 00:20:40.880 |
So because, again, we're talking about 13 year olds, 00:20:49.960 |
So sometimes those can't always be face-to-face meetings. 00:20:58.080 |
They'll share documents via email with one another 00:21:04.800 |
So they're learning so many other skills in doing this. 00:21:09.800 |
But I think some of the biggest ones were the communication 00:21:20.200 |
they're dealing with a lot of growing up at this point 00:21:25.080 |
And so learning how to do these things gracefully 00:21:43.320 |
And so our 13 year olds sometimes speak before they think 00:21:48.120 |
and they empty their gun before they really consider 00:22:00.800 |
and offer mercy both to your teammates and to yourself. 00:22:05.240 |
Another thing that I think is absolutely huge 00:22:31.160 |
and they would address the teams after the event was over 00:22:35.720 |
and they would just be kind of looking at these kids. 00:22:37.760 |
I've had judges say, "Now, who coached your team?" 00:22:50.320 |
And they would just shake their head in wonderment 00:22:55.160 |
who have never done a mock trial like this before. 00:22:58.640 |
They are in law school and they've not done this." 00:23:01.760 |
So the confidence that it inspires in our children 00:23:08.240 |
and with perseverance and teamwork do it well is huge. 00:23:31.520 |
And the students don't know either until it comes out 00:23:34.920 |
and then they know that they were able to do it. 00:23:56.120 |
And when she was working on her mock trial case, 00:24:00.040 |
he said, "This is more in depth than what we did 00:24:18.600 |
what have you seen as the most challenging thing 00:24:24.280 |
So what's the hardest thing for them as they come into this 00:24:32.840 |
- Yeah, so I think one of the biggest things, 00:24:36.160 |
well, of course, you know, we said working together, 00:24:37.880 |
so coaching them through the open communication 00:24:47.200 |
But a practical thing I think is their organization. 00:24:52.120 |
There are a lot of moving pieces to mock trial. 00:24:55.520 |
And so teaching your student how to organize their material 00:25:06.640 |
you are a grownup and you probably have more, 00:25:20.280 |
Because that will help your student be able to move 00:25:29.480 |
So whatever method you find works for your students, 00:25:34.520 |
Like, okay, every witness has their own color. 00:25:36.880 |
Or it's folders or index cards or a binder and it's tabs. 00:25:44.840 |
Because again, they're referencing this material 00:25:50.200 |
- So it might be, okay, I need to make five copies of this 00:26:13.760 |
I think sometimes scheduling is another thing. 00:26:25.200 |
that things take less time than they really do. 00:26:29.520 |
- Especially when they involve other people or cooperation. 00:26:40.480 |
that parents can easily step in and help with 00:27:07.320 |
- So the biggest thing is to step back and not help. 00:27:13.440 |
That is hard, especially if you get interested yourself. 00:27:27.880 |
or the thing that could be turned to our advantage, yeah. 00:27:40.360 |
Okay, so you have that piece of evidence in front of you. 00:27:58.400 |
- And also you mentioned it a little while ago. 00:28:00.360 |
The students have such a hard time seeing their schedule. 00:28:07.520 |
So making sure they're working on it every day. 00:28:15.480 |
because the mock trial notebook does not only discuss 00:28:27.840 |
that the students have to read over and over again 00:28:35.120 |
where the student was supposed to say something, 00:28:40.520 |
And we as a whole just did not read over that page. 00:29:02.040 |
And I, as a director, could not say in the middle of, 00:29:09.840 |
So it was a bit of a moment before he was like, 00:29:19.320 |
- Attend to the courtroom rules and regulations 00:29:22.440 |
Make sure your student reads those pages too, 00:29:33.680 |
your home, resources to help these students come together 00:29:50.880 |
especially if you're teaming up with another community 00:29:57.920 |
So it was a lot of Fridays that we spent coming together 00:30:02.640 |
as two individual communities to come together 00:30:20.600 |
At 13, they can eat a lot of snacks in two hours. 00:30:31.360 |
- You know, there are ways to involve your whole family 00:30:39.640 |
You could read the script of being the practice witness 00:30:45.320 |
or you could get your other students in your home 00:30:58.760 |
'Cause sometimes as the mock trial participant, 00:31:11.360 |
including the judge who will be at the trial, 00:31:15.120 |
haven't rehearsed this and they don't have all the context. 00:31:24.880 |
They have to provide enough context for the story 00:31:28.640 |
for it to make sense to somebody who's hearing it 00:31:32.160 |
- Right, and that's why those direct examination questions 00:31:38.120 |
it's the direct examination questions that tell the story. 00:31:54.880 |
- Yeah, so it's not a requirement to do it twice 00:32:05.760 |
and like how I wish I could have done this differently. 00:32:18.600 |
- They discover that you don't turn into a toad 00:32:23.640 |
you just take a deep breath and go on and you get better. 00:32:27.120 |
Yeah, I think it's incredibly valuable to Emily 00:32:31.740 |
'cause you get the nerves out the first time. 00:32:36.380 |
where there are multiple challenge B communities, 00:32:44.380 |
So you have three communities, they get a chance. 00:32:53.460 |
And I think the students appreciate that second time around 00:33:07.260 |
- And so it's like, yeah, practicing months and months 00:33:19.860 |
who come out of challenge B determined to be attorneys 00:33:36.860 |
that they gained and that they got to practice. 00:33:50.940 |
but I've become intimately familiar with challenge B 00:33:55.780 |
- And supporting it for several years as well, yeah, yeah. 00:34:00.780 |
So between us, we probably have 10 years of experience 00:34:05.220 |
For you, what has been the biggest revelation 00:34:11.980 |
as a tutor, as a parent, as an academic advisor, 00:34:27.980 |
- And I think the beauty of the entire challenge B year 00:34:32.980 |
is the theme of our young students can do the hard things. 00:34:41.340 |
we read so much literature about these children 00:34:51.140 |
So we read these books about 13, 14-year-old students 00:34:56.140 |
working for years to earn the money to do something 00:35:11.300 |
- Their family was poor and he had to actually earn money 00:35:24.420 |
we would never allow my child to do some of these things 00:35:30.180 |
And so I think we forget that in our modern society 00:35:33.940 |
that God built these young teenagers to do hard things, 00:35:42.340 |
they are so much more capable than what we think they are. 00:35:50.580 |
for us to keep in mind that meeting a hard spot, 00:35:54.580 |
meeting a difficult spot in life is a good thing. 00:36:10.740 |
But another revelation that I had was that our children, 00:36:22.660 |
our students learn to love their neighbors well. 00:36:27.140 |
- And particularly, I actually had both of my daughters 00:36:43.020 |
and two students that were born into my heart. 00:36:55.860 |
I saw students who would come alongside a classmate 00:37:00.860 |
who was utterly wigged out by public speaking 00:37:05.620 |
and did not, just really didn't know if they could do it. 00:37:08.660 |
And I saw teammates come alongside that person and say, 00:37:18.860 |
Or, "When you're nervous, you can look at me." 00:37:22.260 |
And I saw teammates push papers of notes of encouragement 00:37:43.940 |
"You know what, you're not doing the work at home. 00:37:48.180 |
You're not practicing, you're hurting our team. 00:37:57.860 |
and also to hold each other accountable for things. 00:38:06.940 |
that those students learn to love one another so well 00:38:14.780 |
- Yeah, we had, on the day of our mock trial, 00:38:22.820 |
And so we had one of our other students step up 00:38:26.620 |
and had to take over her role literally the last minute. 00:38:40.180 |
or shared her notes, it would have been done. 00:38:44.780 |
- And so at the end, she eventually showed up, 00:38:50.180 |
She was no longer able to participate by that point. 00:38:53.100 |
But the other student went up to her and said, 00:38:55.100 |
"Thank you so much because you prepared so much 00:39:11.220 |
We had one student, and this is also a tip for parents. 00:39:19.380 |
and just has a really difficult time reading lengthy passages 00:39:23.980 |
and the print in the mock trial notebook is kind of small. 00:39:28.500 |
- And so the mother read through all the witness statements 00:39:34.860 |
She read through the witness statement and recorded it 00:39:37.380 |
so he could listen to it over and over and over again. 00:39:42.500 |
- Yeah, and I think it was one of the other students 00:39:47.580 |
"Hey, have your mom read it so you can listen to it." 00:39:52.220 |
So I think it was one of the other students encouraged that. 00:40:10.060 |
And you just think, wow, this is a beautiful picture 00:40:29.980 |
How is it the perfect integration of all the skills 00:40:34.980 |
that our students practice during that Challenge B year? 00:40:57.900 |
What they learn in mock trial directly correlates 00:41:09.980 |
And so, and I asked my students in Challenge 1 this year, 00:41:22.220 |
They also read "Born Again" by Charles Olson. 00:41:45.420 |
in a way that they probably have never attended 00:41:47.620 |
to anything before, memorizing those details. 00:41:56.780 |
or the day of question of the accident in the mock trial. 00:42:00.140 |
- So they're learning the storytelling and expressing. 00:42:15.180 |
And so, yeah, they just, it all comes together 00:42:33.380 |
And they're learning the persuasive arguments, 00:42:42.140 |
And some of the things that they learned in Challenge A, 00:42:49.980 |
- They learn, they're putting these things together 00:42:52.540 |
that they may not realize that they are doing 00:42:58.260 |
Like, wow, remember when you were learning in Challenge A 00:43:02.460 |
and now let's twist those and put them to your advantage 00:43:08.940 |
Well, that's what makes it the capstone event 00:43:17.180 |
that our students have been massaging up to that time. 00:43:23.460 |
And thank you for answering so many questions 00:43:30.340 |
This has been really helpful and informative. 00:43:34.900 |
I mean, and I have said this to so many people, 00:43:41.020 |
but the amount of growth I think you see in a student 00:43:44.820 |
during the Challenge B year, it makes me cry. 00:43:49.020 |
They learn so much work ethic during this year 00:43:53.740 |
because they think so much of it goes back to 00:44:05.820 |
- I noticed a difference in my oldest when he went through. 00:44:10.100 |
I would say, "Hey, can you take out the trash?" 00:44:12.100 |
And a typical 12, 13 year old boy might complain about it. 00:44:25.580 |
hey, you know what, people really were working hard, 00:44:28.740 |
much harder than what I'm having to learn this year. 00:44:35.580 |
they just grow up so much in that Challenge B year. 00:44:41.340 |
- It is a beautiful picture of what God does in our lives 00:44:45.260 |
as he helps us to become who he wants us to be. 00:44:52.180 |
You've heard Emily talk a lot about the 15 skills 00:44:56.620 |
and the skill of attending and the skill of memorizing 00:44:59.900 |
and expression and invention and all of those skills. 00:45:03.980 |
If you are looking to become a better everyday educator, 00:45:18.780 |
It's hosted by a local CC leader every summer. 00:45:22.860 |
And this parent conference will give you an opportunity 00:45:32.860 |
or even just parents who are thinking about homeschooling. 00:46:07.780 |
the brand new math, classical math curriculum, 00:46:13.780 |
You're gonna be surprised at how approachable 00:46:27.980 |
and you can do that by visiting ccpracticum.com. 00:46:49.740 |
Thanks, Emily, I appreciate you being with us