2022-05-31_Intelligence_and_College
00:00:00.000 | Are you ready to make your next pro basketball, football, hockey, concert or live event unforgettable?
00:00:05.440 | Let Sweet Hop take your game to the next level.
00:00:08.080 | Sweet Hop is an online marketplace curating the best premium tickets at stadiums, arenas and amphitheaters nationwide.
00:00:14.840 | Sweet Hop's online marketplace makes it easy to browse and book the best seats.
00:00:19.400 | With no hidden fees and a 100% purchase guarantee, you can feel confident when you book your premium LA tickets with Sweet Hop.
00:00:26.480 | Visit suitehop.com today.
00:00:30.760 | Imagine a high school senior who is trying to decide whether to go to college.
00:00:35.400 | He walks into the office of his school's counselor and asks for help in making up his mind.
00:00:40.360 | The counselor knows that this student's grades are B's and C's, and that his motivation and industriousness are fine, but nothing special.
00:00:51.040 | He's considering some college majors that sound interesting to him, but he does not have a passion for any of them.
00:00:57.440 | In fact, as the counselor talks to the student, she discovers that what he really enjoys is working with his hands.
00:01:04.240 | The idea of sitting in an office does not appeal to him, but his parents have their hearts set on their son's getting a college degree,
00:01:11.840 | and most of his friends will be going to college next fall.
00:01:15.240 | What information should the counselor give to the student to help him decide?
00:01:19.080 | We know what she is likely to say.
00:01:21.440 | A survey of high school students revealed that more than 90% of them were encouraged by their high school counselors to go to college.
00:01:28.880 | But what does this student really need to know?
00:01:31.760 | Above all, he needs to know whether he can expect to do well in college if he puts in a serious good faith effort.
00:01:38.000 | And to know that, the student needs to understand the relationship between his level of intellectual ability and the demands of college courses in the majors he wants to declare.
00:01:50.200 | The counselor is not likely to give that information to him.
00:01:53.560 | She is unlikely even to possess it.
00:01:55.960 | Hardly any high school counselor has such information, because publicizing blunt facts about the relationship of intelligence to success in college has been out of bounds for decades.
00:02:07.840 | In an age when everyone from parents to presidents urges every child to go to college, a simple truth is almost universally ignored.
00:02:17.280 | Only a small minority of high school graduates have the intelligence to succeed in college.
00:02:23.240 | The refusal to confront the relationship between intelligence and success in college has produced a cascade of harms to many students who try to go to college, to those who do not, to the system of higher education, and to the nation as a whole.
00:02:39.840 | Academic Ability and Academic Success.
00:02:43.160 | For 40 years, American leaders have been unwilling to discuss the underlying differences in academic ability that children bring to the classroom.
00:02:51.400 | Over the same period, federal policy, backed by billions of taxpayer dollars in loans and grants, has aggressively encouraged more and more students to try to obtain a college education.
00:03:03.600 | As a result, about half of all high school graduates now enroll in four-year colleges, despite the ample evidence that just a small minority of American students—about 10 to 15 percent—have the academic ability to do well in college.
00:03:18.960 | At first, that proposition seems false on its face.
00:03:22.160 | After all, more than a quarter of American adults have successfully obtained a bachelor's degree—hereafter, B.A.
00:03:29.080 | But the point is not that only a small minority of young people can survive for four years and get a degree in today's colleges.
00:03:36.320 | Rather, that only a small minority of them can do well.
00:03:42.000 | For everyone else, there ought to be better options than spending four years scraping by.
00:03:48.160 | At best.
00:03:50.400 | To make that case, it helps to put aside that inflammatory word "intelligence" and substitute
00:03:56.900 | the term "academic ability."
00:03:59.200 | It's mostly a matter of changing labels, not meaning.
00:04:04.080 | Academic ability refers primarily to two of Howard Gardner's famous multiple intelligences—linguistic
00:04:11.960 | intelligence and logical mathematical intelligence.
00:04:15.680 | These two, along with some aspects of what Gardner calls "spatial intelligence," are
00:04:20.800 | what IQ tests measure as part of their larger effort to determine "G," the general mental
00:04:27.760 | factor.
00:04:29.100 | Academic ability is also well measured by the SAT, ACT, and other tests that bill themselves
00:04:35.400 | as indicators of academic preparation for college.
00:04:39.120 | But labels can make a difference.
00:04:41.280 | Using "academic ability" instead of "intelligence" emphasizes that the argument does not depend
00:04:47.280 | on the heritability of cognitive ability, the relationship of test scores to socioeconomic
00:04:52.920 | status, the malleability of mental capacity in toddlers, or the reality of "G."
00:04:59.960 | Instead I work from the simple and easily demonstrable proposition that what you see
00:05:04.760 | in the academic ability of high school seniors is what you get.
00:05:09.760 | Things can still change at that age, and so can motivation.
00:05:13.920 | Such changes can have dramatic effects on academic performance.
00:05:18.400 | But the underlying level of academic ability is fixed long before the end of high school.
00:05:24.000 | So how much academic ability is required to do well in college?
00:05:28.240 | We can begin by looking at what it takes to graduate from college.
00:05:31.760 | In 1972, the standard textbook for the Weschler Adult Intelligence Scale concluded that "a
00:05:38.440 | good working rule of thumb for the mean IQ of college graduates was about 115, which
00:05:44.680 | cuts off the 84th percentile."
00:05:47.680 | This was just an estimate based on the author's clinical experience and consistent with the
00:05:52.160 | research literature on college students of the 1950s and 1960s.
00:05:57.200 | But we have two excellent sources for checking that estimate more precisely, members of the
00:06:02.520 | 1979 and 1997 cohorts of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, NLSY, who were given a psychometrically
00:06:11.720 | sound measure of academic ability, the Armed Forces Qualification Test, AFQT, at baseline.
00:06:19.440 | I have limited the samples to those who took the test in their high school years so that
00:06:23.240 | the measure of academic ability is uncontaminated by any college-level instruction, or lack
00:06:29.200 | of it.
00:06:30.200 | I also limit the sample to non-Latino whites, hereafter just whites, to sidestep complex
00:06:37.280 | issues about differential treatment of whites in minorities in colleges, issues that are
00:06:43.000 | extraneous to my argument.
00:06:46.240 | The members of the 1979 cohort who qualified for the analysis were in their college years
00:06:52.480 | from 1980 to 1986.
00:06:55.960 | Expressed in the IQ metric, the white youths who eventually got a bachelor's degree during
00:07:01.520 | that era had mean AFQT scores of 115.0.
00:07:07.720 | The members of the 1997 cohort were in their college years from 1998 to 2006, and the mean
00:07:14.400 | AFQT of the white youths who had gotten a BA as of 2006 was 114.1.
00:07:22.360 | That "good working rule of thumb" offered in 1972 still seems to be very good indeed.
00:07:29.600 | About half of the white college graduates had scores lower than 115.
00:07:34.280 | In the 1997 cohort of the NLSY, for example, a quarter of the BAs were acquired by white
00:07:40.360 | youths with AFQT scores under 107, and 10% went to youths with scores under 100.
00:07:49.480 | So if getting a degree constitutes our definition of "doing well," then the proportion of
00:07:56.080 | whites who can "do well" is much larger than 10-15%.
00:08:00.840 | On the other hand, anyone who has taught a college class (unless he has spent his career
00:08:05.200 | at a highly selective school) knows that large numbers of students who manage to get a BA
00:08:11.760 | do not do well in the classroom.
00:08:14.400 | They get by, showing in their classroom participation that they do not understand much of the material
00:08:19.400 | – writing barely literate term papers and turning in essays on the final exam that aren't
00:08:25.440 | quite bad enough to flunk.
00:08:27.600 | These students aren't necessarily "lazy," they just aren't very good at the kinds
00:08:31.640 | of things that constitute competence in college courses.
00:08:35.600 | Just getting a BA is far too loose a standard for "doing well."
00:08:40.600 | A better definition may be drawn from Jennifer Cobran's 2007 analysis of college readiness.
00:08:46.900 | In line with others' definitions, Cobran, a researcher for the College Board, defined
00:08:51.900 | college readiness as a 65% chance of getting a 2.7 grade point average in the freshman
00:08:57.840 | year of college.
00:08:59.400 | She used a sample of 165,781 freshmen of all ethnicities with SAT scores and freshman grade
00:09:07.720 | point averages who had attended 41 different colleges, ranging from unselective state universities
00:09:14.700 | to elite schools.
00:09:16.780 | The question she put to her data was this – what is the minimum SAT score, the benchmark
00:09:22.480 | score, that is statistically associated with that 65% probability of at least a 2.7 grade
00:09:29.380 | point average?
00:09:30.380 | It doesn't sound like a demanding standard – a B-minus average in an age of grade inflation
00:09:37.260 | with no limitations on the courses that qualify.
00:09:40.220 | But demanding or not, the benchmark score for reaching that standard was 1180 for the
00:09:46.300 | combined SAT Verbal and SAT Math.
00:09:50.300 | Was the benchmark inflated by tougher grading in the most selective colleges?
00:09:54.740 | No.
00:09:55.740 | The difference between the benchmarks of the unselective institutions and highly selective
00:10:01.060 | ones was only 23 points.
00:10:03.580 | Was it inflated because many small private colleges were part of the sample?
00:10:07.820 | No.
00:10:08.820 | The benchmark was lower for small private colleges than for large state universities.
00:10:14.480 | How many of America's 18-year-olds could get a combined SAT score of 1180 or higher
00:10:21.300 | if everybody took the SAT?
00:10:23.740 | In my 2008 book Real Education, I used three independent methods of calculating the answer
00:10:29.100 | to that question – estimating the distribution of scores of the 18-year-olds who do not take
00:10:34.000 | the SAT, using the College Board's norm studies that employed nationally representative
00:10:39.620 | samples and using the work of Meredith Fry and Douglas Detterman, who compared SAT scores
00:10:45.460 | and AFQT scores in the 1979 cohort of the NLSY.
00:10:50.900 | The three methods each produced a narrow range of plausible answers.
00:10:55.260 | Somewhere between 9 and 12 percent of the 18-year-old American population could get
00:11:00.540 | a score of 1180 or higher, with a realistic best guess of about 10 percent.
00:11:07.860 | There is no inconsistency between Cobren's results and a 115 mean IQ among white college
00:11:14.820 | graduates.
00:11:16.100 | The students who make salient points in classroom discussions, who write well-researched term
00:11:21.220 | papers and whose final exams demonstrate that they understood the material, are usually
00:11:26.620 | well into the upper half of the distribution of academic ability among those who go to
00:11:30.740 | college.
00:11:31.940 | In other words, they are somewhere in the top 15 percent of the population, and usually
00:11:36.460 | in the top 10 percent.
00:11:38.540 | This conclusion is easy to accept when it comes to majors in mathematics and the hard
00:11:43.420 | sciences.
00:11:44.660 | No one can do well in those majors unless he can handle the math, and handling the math
00:11:49.260 | usually means being able to pass courses in advanced calculus and statistics.
00:11:54.220 | Most people are willing to concede from their own experience with mathematics that only
00:11:57.700 | a small percentage of people are competent in advanced math, and 10 percent does not
00:12:02.980 | sound out of line.
00:12:05.420 | Yet courses in the humanities and non-quantitative social science would appear to have no equivalently
00:12:11.220 | obvious intellectual barrier to entry.
00:12:14.040 | All you have to be able to do is read and comprehend.
00:12:17.500 | But in college, what you have to read is often not easy.
00:12:22.140 | In Real Education, I used quotations drawn from page 400 (a randomizing choice) of several
00:12:28.860 | college textbooks to remind my readers what college-level reading is like.
00:12:34.140 | Here is one from page 400 of The Western Heritage (1983) by Donald Kagan, Stephen Osment, and
00:12:41.260 | Frank Turner.
00:12:44.100 | The Protestant Reformation could not have occurred without the monumental crises of
00:12:47.820 | the medieval church during the Exile in Avignon, the Great Schism, the Conciliar Period, and
00:12:54.540 | the Renaissance Papacy.
00:12:56.280 | For increasing numbers of people, the medieval church had ceased also to provide a viable
00:13:00.460 | religious piety.
00:13:02.100 | There was a crisis in the traditional teaching and spiritual practice of the church among
00:13:05.620 | its many intellectuals and laity.
00:13:08.580 | Between the secular pretensions of the papacy and the dry teaching of scholastic theologians,
00:13:13.380 | laity and clerics alike began to seek a more heartfelt, idealistic, and, often in the eyes
00:13:19.940 | of the pope, increasingly heretical religious piety.
00:13:25.520 | If you think that more than 10 percent of American 18-year-olds could follow the thread
00:13:29.700 | of that paragraph, even if you explained what Reformation, Great Schism, and Renaissance
00:13:36.220 | meant, you should go to the National Center for Education Statistics website.
00:13:41.080 | It posts sample questions from the 12th grade reading tests of the National Assessment of
00:13:45.860 | Educational Progress along with the percentages of students getting them right.
00:13:50.940 | The numbers are sobering, as are the overall results.
00:13:56.080 | Just 5 percent of 12th graders reached the "advanced" level on the National Assessment's
00:14:01.100 | reading test, and "advanced" is what that passage from the Western Heritage requires.
00:14:07.940 | Succeeding in social science and humanities courses taught at a genuine college level
00:14:13.100 | demands a lot more than just basic literacy and motivation.
00:14:18.180 | Add in the rigors of courses in the hard sciences, and that estimate of 10 to 15 percent who
00:14:23.420 | can do well in college seems not just plausible, but generous.
00:14:30.100 | The Costs of Failure If trying for a college degree were cost-free,
00:14:36.260 | and if students were unaffected by failure, these numbers would still justify some version
00:14:41.220 | of an "everybody should go to college" position.
00:14:45.060 | If people with average academic ability can sometimes get a BA, why not encourage everyone
00:14:50.700 | to attempt it?
00:14:52.140 | But trying for a BA exacts high costs in both time and money, often burdening students with
00:14:58.980 | large loans as they start out in life.
00:15:01.900 | And teenagers bleed if they are pricked.
00:15:04.780 | Encouraging young people who can succeed if they try hard to strive for college is one
00:15:08.540 | thing, but setting young people up for failure is another.
00:15:13.420 | The advocates of college, for everyone, seldom mention those who try and fail.
00:15:18.660 | But in fact, the college dropout rate is extremely high.
00:15:23.380 | In a longitudinal study sponsored by the Department of Education, 42% of those who entered college
00:15:29.420 | in 1995 had not obtained a degree within 6 years.
00:15:34.280 | That is almost exactly the same as the 41% of white youths in the 1979 NLSY cohort who
00:15:41.160 | dropped out of 4-year colleges and never got a BA.
00:15:45.500 | For whites in the 1997 cohort who were at least 24 years old in the 2006 survey, 39%
00:15:53.420 | of those who had entered a 4-year college had not yet obtained a degree.
00:15:58.580 | The mean AFQT scores of the dropouts in the 1979 and 1997 cohorts were 104 and 103, respectively,
00:16:08.700 | compared to the 115 and 114 of those who graduated.
00:16:13.880 | Lower academic ability in high school was strongly associated with increased likelihood
00:16:18.780 | of failure.
00:16:20.420 | A statistical analysis lets us be more precise.
00:16:23.740 | The figure on the following page shows the probability that a person with a given AFQT
00:16:28.980 | score who enrolled in a 4-year college dropped out before getting a degree.
00:16:33.060 | The results from the two cohorts, born 20 years apart, are remarkably similar.
00:16:38.660 | They will become virtually identical as those in the 1997 cohort who were still enrolled
00:16:43.220 | in college as of 2006 either give up (disproportionately those at the low end of ability) or get their
00:16:49.740 | degrees (disproportionately those at the high end of academic ability).
00:16:54.700 | Note that the analysis is based only on those who had the motivation to enter a 4-year college
00:16:59.740 | in the first place.
00:17:01.300 | If the graph were based on everybody, the probability of failing to get a degree would
00:17:05.900 | be far higher for those at the lower levels of academic ability.
00:17:10.280 | But even when restricted to the self-selected group who try for college, the crossover point
00:17:14.940 | at which a student had a 50/50 chance of getting a BA was an AFQT score of about 105 in both
00:17:22.100 | cohorts.
00:17:23.780 | Now put the information in that graph together with these facts about who tries to go to
00:17:28.220 | college.
00:17:29.660 | About 17 out of every 20 white high school seniors of the 90th percentile of academic
00:17:34.500 | ability enter a 4-year college hoping to get a BA.
00:17:38.060 | 20% of them can be expected to fail.
00:17:41.020 | About 2 out of 3 white high school seniors at the 75th percentile of academic ability
00:17:45.700 | enter a 4-year college hoping to get a BA.
00:17:48.740 | 40% of them can be expected to fail.
00:17:52.180 | About half of white high school seniors at the 60th percentile of academic ability enter
00:17:56.900 | a 4-year college hoping to get a BA.
00:17:59.620 | 52% of them can be expected to fail.
00:18:02.900 | About 2 out of 5 white high school seniors at the 50th percentile of academic ability
00:18:07.260 | enter a 4-year college hoping to get a BA.
00:18:10.260 | 60% of them can be expected to fail.
00:18:13.860 | The reality behind these numbers is even more depressing.
00:18:17.500 | Those among the academically talented who do not get a degree are likely to be voluntary
00:18:21.500 | "failures" – students who easily could have gotten the BA but behaved in ways that
00:18:25.980 | prevented them from doing so – spending too much time partying, or running the student
00:18:30.380 | newspaper, or as in the case of Bill Gates and Steve Jobs, deciding they wanted to do
00:18:34.740 | something else.
00:18:36.380 | The lower we go down the ladder of academic ability, the higher the probability that the
00:18:40.060 | failure was genuine – an inability to cope with college-level material, combined with
00:18:45.820 | the discouragement and loss of self-confidence that accompany any endeavor in which we try
00:18:50.700 | hard and just can't do it.
00:18:54.780 | Counselor's Conundrum Let us return to the guidance counselor as
00:18:58.060 | she considers what to tell the uncertain high school senior.
00:19:01.420 | Leafing through his folder, she finds a record of his score on an IQ test the school administered
00:19:06.100 | when he was in 8th grade.
00:19:07.980 | It is 105, a number consistent with his performance in high school.
00:19:12.780 | So now she has something specific she can tell him.
00:19:15.400 | For the last 30 years, white students with AFQT scores of 105 (roughly equivalent to
00:19:21.100 | IQs of 105) who have gone to college have had only a 50/50 chance of getting a BA.
00:19:27.500 | If the student takes an undemanding major, he can improve his odds.
00:19:31.340 | And if he works really hard – much harder than most students do – he can improve his
00:19:35.740 | odds.
00:19:36.980 | But if he is interested in a difficult major, the odds go down.
00:19:41.200 | Taking any major that requires serious mathematics drives the odds close to zero.
00:19:46.980 | Another reality is that, on average, dropouts spend about two years in college, incurring
00:19:52.500 | the high costs that involves before they leave.
00:19:55.940 | The fact that they dropped out probably meant that they were not getting much out of their
00:19:59.140 | courses and had not enjoyed their classroom experiences.
00:20:03.340 | The high school student should know these things too before he decides to take the plunge.
00:20:08.740 | But the counselor must also talk to the student about two other realities.
00:20:13.020 | First, having a BA will probably increase the student's future income substantially.
00:20:18.780 | Judging from the 1979 NLSY cohort, someone with this student's academic ability will,
00:20:25.700 | in his early 40s, be making about $29,000 more per year if he gets a BA than if he doesn't.
00:20:33.100 | That is an extremely large incentive to get the degree.
00:20:36.940 | Second, less concretely but just as real, the BA has become a social gatekeeper.
00:20:43.700 | Having a BA does not confer much prestige anymore unless it comes from an elite school.
00:20:49.020 | But not having a BA is a badge of second-class social status, unless one is in the Bill Gates/Steve
00:20:55.380 | Jobs category.
00:20:56.700 | To be just a high school graduate sounds very bad these days, and it doesn't sound much
00:21:02.340 | better to say you have an associate's degree from a community college.
00:21:06.820 | After the counselor has given all this information to the student, the young man says to her,
00:21:10.700 | "What do you think I should do?"
00:21:14.220 | It is a daunting question.
00:21:16.340 | What is, in fact, in his best long-term interests, both for maximizing his chances of financial
00:21:23.540 | success and for finding him a satisfying vocation?
00:21:27.620 | The counselor has no good answer, because the options available to her are inadequate.
00:21:32.980 | The student should certainly get more education after high school.
00:21:36.260 | There are courses taught on college campuses that could benefit him.
00:21:39.660 | But four years?
00:21:41.260 | A BA?
00:21:42.780 | Why should he have to commit to the BA to get what he needs?
00:21:45.980 | The purpose of college has evolved, but the measure of success in college, the bachelor's
00:21:50.380 | degree, has not.
00:21:52.620 | Therein lies the source of the counselor's conundrum.
00:21:55.900 | Enormous economic and social value comes from a nearly meaningless piece of paper.
00:22:00.460 | It is nearly meaningless because, except for a handful of majors in the hard sciences,
00:22:05.260 | a BA tells an employer next to nothing about what the degree holder has learned.
00:22:10.860 | The requirements for majors are usually so loose, and the availability of soft courses
00:22:15.380 | so great, that an employer has to scrutinize the transcript course by course to have any
00:22:20.860 | idea of what an applicant knows.
00:22:23.900 | Nor does the BA signify rigorous training in argumentation, decision-making, and writing.
00:22:30.060 | Some newly minted graduates have taken courses that inculcated those abilities.
00:22:34.860 | Many have not.
00:22:36.340 | Nor does the BA signify that the graduate has obtained a liberal education.
00:22:40.260 | The core curricula that once ensured a solid grounding in history, philosophy, the natural
00:22:44.940 | sciences, great literature, and the arts have all but disappeared from American colleges.
00:22:50.580 | And yet, the BA has become a prerequisite for getting an interview in vast stretches
00:22:55.260 | of the job market.
00:22:57.000 | Not because a BA is necessary for the entry-level tasks that employers need performed, but because
00:23:02.500 | it represents a course screen for a certain degree of intelligence and a certain degree
00:23:07.040 | of perseverance.
00:23:08.780 | We are so accustomed to this use of the BA, and let's face it, it fits so comfortably
00:23:13.740 | with the interests of upper-middle class parents with smart children, that we need to find
00:23:17.780 | ways to step back and see how bizarre the situation has become.
00:23:22.060 | Try this thought experiment, which I propose in Real Education.
00:23:26.540 | You have been made a member of a task force to design America's post-secondary education
00:23:31.260 | system from scratch.
00:23:33.100 | One of your colleagues submits this proposal.
00:23:36.220 | "First, we will set up a single goal to represent educational success, which will
00:23:40.660 | take four years to achieve no matter what is being taught.
00:23:43.500 | We will attach a large economic reward to it that usually has nothing to do with what
00:23:47.220 | has been learned.
00:23:48.460 | We will urge large numbers of people who do not possess adequate ability to try to achieve
00:23:52.380 | the goal, wait until they have spent a lot of time and money, and then deny it to them.
00:23:57.500 | We will stigmatize everyone who doesn't meet the goal.
00:24:00.440 | We will call the goal a BA."
00:24:05.220 | You would conclude that your colleague was cruel, not to say insane, but that's the
00:24:10.300 | system we have.
00:24:13.060 | An alternative.
00:24:15.220 | Many young people who cannot do well in the four-year residential college program leading
00:24:19.380 | to a BA could do well in other educational configurations, if such alternatives were
00:24:25.940 | available, and if society accorded them more legitimacy.
00:24:30.500 | In some cases, better configurations could be achieved simply by shortening the amount
00:24:34.020 | of time spent in school.
00:24:36.220 | Get rid of the four-year requirement, and many young people who are eager for careers
00:24:40.000 | in business, say, would do just fine in the eight or ten courses in marketing, management,
00:24:44.660 | and finance that they are highly motivated to take.
00:24:47.900 | Other alternatives might require adaptation to different learning styles.
00:24:52.120 | If the traditional BA is the goal, there is no getting around severe demands on verbal
00:24:56.260 | ability in the humanities and mathematical ability in the sciences.
00:25:00.420 | But the skills necessary for many vocations that now require the BA for a job interview
00:25:05.260 | could be taught better than they are in the traditional college course.
00:25:09.540 | If these skills were taught in a more hands-on, apprentice-like manner, they, and the vocations
00:25:15.180 | opened by them, would become more accessible to people whose strengths are not linguistic
00:25:20.060 | and logical mathematical.
00:25:22.720 | Some improvements might just be a matter of eliminating the residential requirement.
00:25:26.980 | Going to live at that idyllic four-year college is just not feasible for many young people.
00:25:31.900 | They need alternatives that don't require a residence and a full-time commitment.
00:25:36.460 | Community colleges and distance learning through the internet provide an abundance of those
00:25:40.260 | alternatives.
00:25:41.540 | But they are always going to be second best as long as the BA is the goal.
00:25:45.740 | The solution, then, is not a better BA, but no BA.
00:25:51.880 | In lieu of degrees, substitute certifications.
00:25:56.060 | The CPA exam for accountants is the model for occupations that lend themselves to paper
00:26:00.180 | and pencil tests.
00:26:01.620 | Journeyman examinations in the crafts are the model for occupations in which work samples
00:26:06.780 | are important.
00:26:08.220 | The goal is simple.
00:26:09.640 | Give young people a way to show prospective employers what they know and what they can
00:26:13.300 | do, not where they studied and for how long.
00:26:17.260 | Certifications will work just as well for graduate and professional schools seeking
00:26:20.360 | to evaluate prospective students.
00:26:22.820 | What do law schools, medical schools, and graduate schools in the arts and sciences
00:26:27.020 | really want their applicants to bring to the graduate experience?
00:26:30.820 | Presumably a liberal education, along with credentials specific to the discipline.
00:26:36.060 | So let the schools define what that means in terms of content areas and specify accordingly
00:26:41.460 | the evidence they want to see.
00:26:43.780 | There are no technical obstacles to such reforms.
00:26:47.220 | Certification tests already exist for dozens of occupations, and the model for employing
00:26:51.340 | them is easy to follow.
00:26:53.300 | What is needed is a change in mindset—recognition by employers, parents, students, and educators
00:26:58.940 | that it is wrong and punishing to use the BA as the prerequisite for a job interview.
00:27:04.940 | Employers looking for productive employees, and graduate schools looking for well-prepared
00:27:09.260 | students, need information, and the piece of paper called a BA does not provide it.
00:27:14.840 | Nothing in this proposal forces students to treat college as vocational training or as
00:27:18.660 | a way station to graduate school.
00:27:21.040 | On the contrary, I can imagine the development of a certification demonstrating that someone
00:27:24.660 | has acquired a liberal education—a real certification of what the BA now falsely purports
00:27:29.940 | to show.
00:27:31.260 | It is even possible that the popularity of rigorous liberal education will grow, because
00:27:35.460 | many types of employers will want real evidence of a real liberal education.
00:27:40.580 | Nothing in this proposal conflicts with the intangible benefits of the college experience.
00:27:44.900 | The maturation, development of skills and critical thinking, and the broadening of horizons
00:27:49.500 | that are virtues of that experience today do not depend on forcing everyone into the
00:27:53.900 | BA mold.
00:27:55.420 | On the contrary, insofar as students are taking courses that they want and are motivated to
00:28:00.500 | take, the chances that they will benefit from their college experiences are increased.
00:28:05.540 | Nothing in this proposal suggests that we should follow the German model, sorting students
00:28:09.580 | into vocational and academic bins at an early age and limiting their educational opportunities.
00:28:15.380 | On the contrary, the reason to substitute certifications for the BA is not to reduce
00:28:19.880 | options for some, but to create new options for everyone.
00:28:24.100 | It is worth adding, however, that to avoid the German model, the government must stay
00:28:28.140 | out of the process.
00:28:30.380 | Certifications must evolve based on the evidence of learning that employers and graduate schools
00:28:34.780 | want, not the evidence that bureaucrats think they should want.
00:28:39.020 | If certifications come to replace the BA, colleges around the country will still be
00:28:43.100 | filled with students—even more students than today.
00:28:46.820 | The difference will be that far more of them will be there to learn, not to wait out four
00:28:51.380 | years.
00:28:52.620 | And one other difference.
00:28:54.200 | Today we live in a world with first-class and second-class paths from adolescence to
00:28:59.420 | adulthood.
00:29:00.960 | College is first-class, and everything else is second-class.
00:29:04.980 | When the BA is no longer the universal goal of post-secondary education, it will be easier
00:29:10.100 | for everyone to recognize that all students who seek more education after high school
00:29:14.020 | are engaged in the same activity—discovering what they love to do, and learning how to
00:29:18.900 | do it well.
00:29:20.380 | For some, the things they love to do will involve the stuff of a classic liberal education.
00:29:26.820 | Others will pursue practical tools for making a living.
00:29:29.420 | But the quest is the same for all.
00:29:32.580 | Ridding ourselves of the BA is a good way to help everyone recognize that common bond.
00:29:41.020 | The article I have just read you is called "Intelligence in College," written by
00:29:47.940 | Charles Murray, published in 2009 in National Affairs Magazine.
00:29:54.420 | The bad news is, there hasn't been a ton of progress since 2009 in the direction outlined
00:30:01.820 | and proposed by Murray.
00:30:03.580 | The good news is, there has come a lot of progress in the last couple of years, and
00:30:10.340 | I'm optimistic that the next decade will mark some of those changes called for so long
00:30:17.100 | ago by Murray.
00:30:18.300 | Are you ready to make your next pro basketball, football, hockey, concert, or live event unforgettable?
00:30:23.860 | Let Sweet Hop take your game to the next level.
00:30:26.620 | Sweet Hop is an online marketplace curating the best premium tickets at stadiums, arenas,
00:30:31.420 | and amphitheaters nationwide.
00:30:33.540 | Sweet Hop's online marketplace makes it easy to browse and book the best seats with
00:30:37.700 | no hidden fees and a 100% purchase guarantee.
00:30:40.820 | You can feel confident when you book your premium LA tickets with Sweet Hop.
00:30:44.660 | Visit SUITEHOP.COM today.